7 ms·
What is most interesting about this whole adblocking war: we're winning. If we weren't youtube/Google wouldn't be making such a fuss. So keep it up. I can also
by jacquesm 3y ago
What is most interesting about this whole adblocking war: we're winning. If we weren't youtube/Google wouldn't be making such a fuss. So keep it up.
I can also heartily recommend the 'unhook' browser extension, it takes care of all of those upsells and feeds.
- Timshel 3y agoNot sure that's the case, recent discussion on Firefox was not inspiring: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38531104 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38531104. Maybe they are making such a fuss because it works and people end up switching to chrome / removing ad block :(. Would be nice to see recent download graph of firefox or ublock origin so see if there is any impact.
- jacquesm 3y agoFor me the opposite: chrome was making an entrance on account of supporting WebMIDI and I gave them the benefit of the doubt for a bit but this is the bit that did it for me and besides some compatibility testing FF all the way for me. Google is already receiving plenty of money, if they promoted youtube as a commons they should maintain it as a commons. This bait-and-switch crap has gone more than far enough. Remember, not all that long ago their mantra was 'we don't care about ad blockers because it is only such a small percentage'. Look now.
- Timshel 3y agoI hope so :). I just see it, in the current context of layoff, as them wanting/needing more money and hoping blocker either leave (and stop costing them bandwidth) or switch to YT Premium. I do believe that the worsening experience on YT could be a win by making platform I want to support such as nebula more attractive. Or that it could backfire with a global adblock adoption making the current ad economy less viable. I'm just unsure if chrome/YT is not already too entrenched and that people won't use ad blocker or switch.
- jacquesm 3y agoGoogle has plenty of money, but it's never enough and so you get this kind of ridiculously hostile activity. I can't even watch my own videos without being bombarded by ads. That wasn't the case when I uploaded it so in my opinion that's bait-and-switch. They can pull these stunts on newly uploaded works with new T&C but to retroactively claim editorial control over the page where the videos appear is just abuse of power. If they were about to go out of business on account of how youtube is such a terrible loss leader it might garner some sympathy but as it is it is just a Google power play and a money grab to me.
- M3L0NM4N 3y agoAnecdotally, I just made the switch to FF from Chrome. And my only complaint is that Google Earth is practically unusable. Other than that, I love the customization and have no difference from Chrome. Extension support is just as good.
- DeathArrow 3y ago>What is most interesting about this whole adblocking war: we're winning. Until Google changes how the web works and all other browsers will align. And they can do that, since they almost own the web trough Chrome.
- fifteen1506 3y agoYup. Webbundles and the other thingie.
- isaacremuant 3y agoThen use Firefox and/or non chromium based browsers. Don't play the game. It's not a new game. Remember when Linux was "evil commie software"?
- discordance 3y agoI like Firefox, but isn't Firefox funded by Google?
- swiftcoder 3y agoIn the sense that Google pays for search engine placement, yes. They also pay Apple for the same thing - I'd hesitate to say that gives them much influence over either Firefox or Safari.
- Algent 3y agoTwitch "permanently" won by injecting ads directly on the feed, right now best you can do is sneak swap the small resolution version that stay on the side until they also removed this.
- fifteen1506 3y agoIf we annoy Google enough they'll have 3 different adblock detectors available and 2 of them won't ever be loaded on the filterlist maintainers computers :)
- CubsFan1060 3y agoWhat does winning mean in this context? If we take this to an extreme, doesn't content just not get made? Do you think Google is going to go to a model where things are freely accessible without ads? Feels like even when a company provides a way to get rid of ads, many people still won't pay. They _say_ they will, but I find often people will want to substitute their own terms (Well, youtube premium is $x, but I think it's only worth $y, so I'm going to just block ads completely).
- jacquesm 3y ago> If we take this to an extreme, doesn't content just not get made? I can't speak for anybody else but my content will still get made. > Do you think Google is going to go to a model where things are freely accessible without ads? Maybe, maybe not, whose to say what Google will do. Maybe they will value the influence or the goodwill more than the lack of income. Maybe some of the content will be free and other bits will be walled off (effectively this is already the case with youtube music). Maybe there will be less MFY content and that's perfectly ok with me, 99.99% of it is crap anyway. Youtuber isn't a profession I recognize. > Feels like even when a company provides a way to get rid of ads, many people still won't pay. And that's ok. > They _say_ they will, but I find often people will want to substitute their own terms (Well, youtube premium is $x, but I think it's only worth $y, so I'm going to just block ads completely). Yes, or you pay and you still get ads...
- CubsFan1060 3y ago> I can't speak for anybody else but my content will still get made. How will your content get served? If you say you'll just pay to serve it, I think that's a fine answer.
- EA-3167 3y agoUnless you're a VERY large and successful YT channel, you aren't making bank on YT itself, it's merch and sponsorships, Patreon and so on that make the money. Monetized Twitch-like feeds are another winner, and again not dependent on YT monetization.