6 ms·
Dave Ramsey: "Why We Don't Take Credit Cards"
- chris11 18y agoI don't know much about Dave Ramsey, and he seems somewhat legitimate so far, but I'm pretty nervous about spending money with a debit card instead of a credit card. I want something with more fraud protection than a credit card.
- wyclif 18y agoYes, even though Ramsey apparently advises debit card users to opt for "credit" rather than "debit", his hardline stance might create a problem if you're accustomed to using credit cards for major purchases.
- patio11 18y agoI bank at a small Japanese bank in the middle of nowhere. One day, I visited a small hospital, also in the middle of nowhere. As it happened, I did not have cash on me to pay the fee. I told the nurse to please wait for a moment while I went next door to use the ATM. Next door is a gambling establishment, with an ATM outside of it. I tried getting cash and the ATM refused my card. So I ended up walking three blocks (small town, luckily) and found myself a bank branch, which took my card. I returned to the hospital, paid the bill, and went on with my day. Some time later I mentioned to my bank manager "By the way, I think my card is bugged -- it got rejected by a reader the other day." And I told him the circumstances. "Sir, do you remember when we gave you your credit card that you promised not to gamble with it?" "Yes, of course. I don't gamble, ever." "We appreciate that, sir. Neither does the bank. Nor will we permit our customers to hurt themselves by gambling. Accordingly, we do not site any of our ATMs by gambling establishments." "Oh, I can respect that. Of course, your competitors do, and that makes them money." "Our real competitors do not. We have an understanding with them on this issue: no honorable bank in $SMALL_TOWN_JAPAN will countenance our customers losing their livelihoods while our eyes are still white. [Japanese idiom, means "while we still draw breath"]" "But there really is an ATM in front of it?" "It is from a Tokyo bank, and a disreputable Tokyo bank at that. And let them put an ATM there. They have no branch in this town, nor will they ever." "But they don't need a branch, do they?" "No. Bank A, Bank B, Bank C, and ourselves have enough branches to have 98% share of deposit accounts in this town. A, B, and C share our understanding of the importance of protecting this community." "Wait, so NOBODY can use that ATM?" "Maybe they can soak some tourists. wry smile Its a free market, you know." I've got to say, the capitalist in me thinks "Oh crikey, cartelization". The rest of me really, really likes my bank. [Edit: I just looked in my dictionary and it says that the actual idiom is "While my eyes are still black". I guess that means my memory is faulty. Wouldn't be the first time. Take note, students of the language.]
- unalone 18y agoI think you could argue that part of capitalism is guaranteeing quality service, and that cartelization in this case is an effort to treat you with more respect. That's a fascinating story.
- delackner 18y agoIt may be fascinating, but it is also entirely anecdotal and says nothing about the country as a whole. In the middle of Kyoto, and in downtown Tokyo I have repeatedly seen branches of major japanese banks that have lottery ticket vending booths built into their exterior walls. Talk about "disreputable"!
- patio11 18y agoI agree. In fact, this is a point that many people forget about Japan: Just like the US is big enough to accommodate both a sub-prime crisis and Dave Ramsey, Japan is big enough to both accommodate cosmopolitan financial centers like Tokyo and small farming towns where "a bank from Tokyo" is understood as an insult.
- Herring 18y agoWhat other understandings do they have? Gamblers can also walk 3 blocks, this attitude might end up doing more harm than good. I've heard a few things about Japan.
- jasonlbaptiste 18y agoSeriously? This is going to get voted up? Don't even try passing that- he should "practice what he preaches" crap on me to justify why he should do this. For the record, I'm personally against credit cards too. I only keep an AMEX, for emergency use, which has a zero balance every month. We're all usability fanatics here, and adding friction like this is asinine. If anything, give people a discount for not using a credit card or use this as an opportunity to preach to them. I'd also be able to at least empathize with this nutjob if he said it was because of the fees. These fees are why some small businesses are still cash only or credit card above a certain amount.
- sachinag 18y agoOK, I get the "debt is bad" angle here. But just so you know - the $50 limit on fraud that you're protected by if someone steals your credit card? It's not there if you use a check card. If you want to shop online, use a real credit card. If you want to shop offline, use a regular ATM card + PIN identification. http://www.pirg.org/consumer/banks/debit/fact.htm http://www.pirg.org/consumer/banks/debit/fact.htm
- tptacek 18y agoYeah, so, I think this might have been true in 1997, when this article was written. And it may technically still be true based on the law --- I haven't checked. But it's certainly not true in practice: every major bank guarantees accounts against fraud with $0 liability, a service I have availed myself of repeatedly with Bank of America. If they suddenly decided not to honor that pledge, they'd be civilly liable. I'm calling "urban myth" on this debit card liability thing, and eagerly await my comeuppance.
- gojomo 18y agoIf you've been victim of debit card fraud, how long did it take you to notice, and how quickly did BofA return cash to your account? I know debit card loss limits at major banks have become similar to credit card loss limits (as a competitive matter), but there are still practical differences. Debit fraud means your bank account is empty right now -- and until you discover the fraud -- meaning payments of other expenses may fail unexpectedly. The worst that can happen with credit card fraud is that one card gets denied. You are never short of cash unless you pay the bill without reviewing/disputing it, weeks later. Your liquidity is under your control, not the thief's or the bank's.
- tptacek 18y agoThat's all true, but it's not the argument the original comment made.
- run4yourlives 18y agoYou know, those of us who travel internationally find it much more convenient to carry a CC then a debit card. Also, putting business expenses on a CC is just plain common sense, especially if you work for someone else. Why should I lose interest waiting for reimbursement?
- einarvollset 18y agoIf you travel internationally, or spend money in places you don't trust 100%, or want 1-5% cashback, or in any way want the protection that comes from calling your credit card company and saying the magic words "That is a fraudulent charge" and not spending 6 weeks proving it, then you're an idiot for using a debit card.
- hbien 18y agoI'm confused, can I use my debit card as credit? Whenever I try to use it, people ask "debit or credit" and it'll work as credit.
- rms 18y agoYeah, that works, but oftentimes the protection isn't as good. For example, with many credit cards at this point you are liable for $0 worth of fraud, but with the debit as credit you are liable for the first $50.
- ig1 18y agoMaybe it's different in your country, but in the UK if you pay on credit card and the supplier fails to deliver your credit card company has to refund you, it's then upto the credit card company to get their money back from the supplier. In the case of debit cards you don't have any of that protection, so if you want to get your money back you have to get it back from the supplier (which if they've gone bankrupt/disappeared is near impossible for an individual).
- dougp 18y agoRetailers get charged about 20 cents per 100$ for debit transactions and $1.48 per 100$ for credit. If you say credit with your debit card you are giving your bank that larger cut and getting none of the protections associated with a credit card. Except you probably don't have to enter your pin number which may be important to you. http://redtape.msnbc.com/2007/09/paper-or-plasti.html http://redtape.msnbc.com/2007/09/paper-or-plasti.html
- 18y ago
- newt0311 18y agoGAAAHHHH!!! Enough with this credit cards are bad BS. Cons with CCs: If you don't manage your funds well, you git hit with a 20%+ interest rate and will never likely climb out of that hole. Solution: learn to manage debt. Seriously, most CC companies now allow direct account transfers. If you are that scared, whenever you make a purchase, go home, log in to your bank's website (every major bank has one, if yours doesn't, open an account with one that does), and pay off the card immediately. Its not rocket science, just basic financial management. Pros with CCs: Fraud protection. Easily one of the biggest plus points of CCs. Concerned that there is a charge on you statement that you didn't approve? Just call the company and tell them that it is a fraudulent charge and then its their problem. If nothing else, this easily makes credit cards worth the time it takes to manage them. After this, we have the easy record of all transactions, cash back, convenience, safety from the fact that you don't have a giant wad of cash with you, and last but not least, a credit history which can be used to reduce interest rates on long term loans. Seriously, this anti-debt attitude is in general ridiculous. Is excessive and badly-managed debt bad? Absolutely, its one of the worst situations to be in but there is a simple way to avoid it: manage your finances. Swearing off all debt is foolish and inefficient.
- trickjarrett 18y agoIt's ridiculous for those who are good at managing your money and debt, of which this site's audience probably has a decent percentage who can. As Entrepreneur's it's a necessary skill. But the fact is that we're a minority and the majority of people are bad at managing money. And so long as you're anything less than good at managing your money, a credit card represents risk. And so for those who don't pay off the debt, the risk grows. I like Ramsey, he goes balls to the wall and is over the top, as the site mentions he can get repetitive painful at times. And the NO-Debt approach, as you are noting, is a bit crazy but for those who have proven they can't be trusted with debt, then this is the safe choice. Your response is fine, but I think you're approaching it from a normal, well balanced and money conscious individual. There are people who call into his show with literally $250,000+ in debt between their house, car, boat, property lots, and they've got a sliver of that as income. These are the people he's marketing towards. Not you.
- swilliams 18y ago
- tjmc 18y agoA better approach would be to teach people how to use a credit card properly. I've setup my credit card to be paid off in full on the due date each month so I pay no interest. My savings account is offset against my mortgage, so it's generally better to pay by credit card as that defers savings account withdrawals (thus saving mortgage interest) by up to 45 days. The card fee is paid by reward points on the card and there's enough extra points per year for between $200 & $400 in store vouchers. So combining the mortgage interest savings, the rewards payouts and the fact I pay no interest or annual fees, I'd guess the card saves me ~$1000 a year. As a debit card is just as easy to use as a credit card, the argument that I'm likely to spend more with a credit card is bogus as well. I suspect the fees Dave Ramsey would have to pay on credit card transactions may be higher than on debit cards though...
- neilk 18y agoAs a debit card is just as easy to use as a credit card, the argument that I'm likely to spend more with a credit card is bogus as well. Except for the credit card continuing to work even if you don't have the funds right now?
- Psyonic 18y agoUnfortunately, so will be the debit card (til all the charges go through, at least). Then you get the wonderful luxury of paying multiple $35 overdraft fees on top of your bills, which is exactly what you need when you're hurting. Cash only is probably the best policy for these people.
- kqr2 18y agoDoes Dave Ramsey's company pay all of its suppliers with cash, debit card or equivalent? That would really be practicing what you preach.
- BigZaphod 18y agoYes he does. He doesn't use any credit at all. Ever.
- dannyv 18y agoIf you can't manage your own spending habits, use a debit card. If you treat your credit card spending like you would a debit card and pay off the balance in full, there are slew of benefits. Here's a great credit card offer I recently found: http://www.schwab.com/public/schwab/banking_lending/credit_card?cmsid=P-990780&lvl1=banking_lending&lvl2=credit_card http://www.schwab.com/public/schwab/banking_lending/credit_c... 2% CASH BACK ON EVERY PURCHASE, automatically deposited into an interest bearing account at the end of the month, which has an optional checking option providing free checks and full ATM reimbursements, no fees. If instead you used a lousy BOA debit card, you'd have no cash back, a bunch of fees, and a hell of time fighting any illegitimate charges.
- markessien 18y agoYou think that the point of that offer is to make YOU money? No, it's to make the bank money by convincing enough people to use credit cards. If everyone would follow your system, that offer would not exist. So these 'benefits' you tout are just marketing.
- dannyv 18y agoThe point of the offer is for the bank to signup new customers. I make money from cashback and save money on ATM fees. The bank won't make much if any money on me, but I'm not the average customer. Many of the new customers will carry a balance, transfer a balance, and/or invest & trade with them. This makes the bank money. Now if everyone paid their balance in full, this offer wouldn't exist, but of course this doesn't happen.
- Tichy 18y agoI think that is just patronizing. Thank you, I can decide for myself whether I want to use credit cards or not.
- danielh 18y agoI don't know Dave Ramsey, but he apparently puts his money where his mouth is. And this should be honored. Whether you agree with his opinion on credit cards is another story.
- Angostura 18y agoActually, he's asking you to put your money where his mouth is - and without any credit card protection. A cynic would also point out that that by not accepting credit cards he also avoids losing the cutr of the transaction that they charge and so makes more money. I'm not a cynic of course. Personally, my credit card is paid of automatically each month in full.
- neilk 18y agoWell, processing fees are there for both - I'm not sure he's making a big win there. But chargebacks are very common in online retailing. I don't think you can chargeback a debit transaction, can you? Also, if his business is dealing with people who are at the end of their rope, defaults and chargebacks may be more common.
- danielh 18y agoIt's not like anybody is forced to buy anything from him. You are free to look (and pay) for advice somewhere else. Without any statistics to prove it, I would reckon that Ramsey looses more money buy alienating potential customers than he saves on transaction fees. I also think that CCs have their benefits, if used in a responsible way. But if Ramsey is strictly against CCs, not accepting them shows integrity. At least, it creates massive buzz if the tubes pick up the story ;)
- jimbokun 18y ago"Actually, he's asking you to put your money where his mouth is..." Uh, yes. That is his entire business proposition, telling people how to manage their finances.
- neilk 18y agoI'm a bit disappointed in all this "bah humbug, I can manage my credit cards" attitude. That site is specifically for people who are struggling to manage their finances. I'm not really sold that their reasons for not accepting credit cards make sense (lack of fraud protection is the biggest problem). But it makes some psychological sense. You don't see a lot of AA meetings held in bars. Also, complaining that the average yokel can't manage their credit is like complaining that users can't deal with a command-line interface. Sure the discipline to learn it would pay off, but most people aren't wired that way. Furthermore the credit system as we have it now is designed, by very talented professionals, to prey on common flaws in the human mammal's ability to assess risk and future obligation. Everybody has something that they're irrational about. Don't make me ask you how much time you've spent on WoW this month. Lastly, those of us on this board are probably lucky to have relatively high-paying jobs, even if we were less-than-perfect students or tried startup life for a while. The demand is just that great. But software is a huge anomaly in the North American economy. Wages for most people have been flat, relative to inflation, for decades. And furthermore, the risk of sudden and prolonged drops in income has been much higher since 1970 or so. For hackers that means okay, okay, I'll take the stupid J2EE job. For the average North American worker, it might mean accepting some stupid low wage service job. Anyway, the point is, most families have been making up the difference with credit cards. They're not living extravagantly and still they're falling behind. See this lecture by Elizabeth Warren, "The Coming Collapse of the Middle Class". (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=akVL7QY0S8A http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=akVL7QY0S8A) that punctures some of the myths with hard stats.
- Tichy 18y ago"Also, complaining that the average yokel can't manage their credit is like complaining that users can't deal with a command-line interface. Sure the discipline to learn it would pay off, but most people aren't wired that way." That is a very, very scary statement. Basically it implies that most people are doomed to live a live in dependency and slavery, because they will always depend on the goodwill of other people to not screw them over. Maybe it even implies that in the long run communism is the only workable system. I can't imagine that the majority of people is THAT bad at maths :-/ I mean it is just basic addition and substraction. Even if you can only count to 5, you could get a rough idea of the state of your credit (number on bank account has less digits than number on credit card debt == bad).
- nanijoe 18y agoThere's just no way I'm entering my debit card details online. If a crook gets a hold of those details somehow, they'll be spending directly from your bank account.
- tdavis 18y agoFunny, because I pay for every possible purchase with a CC and have no debt. And the one time I paid for something with my Debit card, I was overcharged and essentially had no recourse. When someone got a hold of my CC number somehow and started making charges, I called AMEX, gave them nothing beyond the amounts of the charges and they charged everyone back for me. Oh, and I have over 40,000 Points on that card right now which means, since I've never paid any interest, AMEX is paying me to use their card. This guy is right, CCs are the Devil. When I die, they'll take that money out of my soul I suppose.
- mynameishere 18y agoTwice I've had fraudulent charges on credit cards. Needless to say, I lost exactly zero dollars in the process--in most cases, the merchant sinks the cost to keep Mastercard happy. That, and the fees, are probably the real reasons why this person doesn't want credit cards.
- BigZaphod 18y agoHere's his full policy as stated on his website: http://www.daveramsey.com/etc/cms/debit_card_policy_32.htmlc http://www.daveramsey.com/etc/cms/debit_card_policy_32.htmlc Note the bit at the bottom about not actually being able to tell a debit card from a credit card. This is really just a philosophical position. He can't enforce it online due to how the card processors work. I believe he tries to enforce it at his live shows, though, by simply not taking any cards that appear to obviously be credit-only.
- KirinDave 18y ago"Never mind that credit cards are basically the only safe way to spend money on the internet! Give us your debit card so we can really inconvenience you when our database is stolen!" Credit cards are terrible if you abuse them, and the whole credit system is mucked up. But they are otherwise very pro-consumer, because you have no liability when you are defrauded.
- zmimon 18y agoWhy does an article entitled "Why We Don't Take Credit Cards" not explain why the person concerned does not take credit cards? What is it that makes it so hard for people to come up with a headline that vaguely resembles what they have written about?
- RobertL 18y agoAnyone who doesn't take credit cards is "nuts". This is total nonsense.