7 ms·
Thermoelectric heating stands at the brink of commercialization
- grecy 3y agoSomething I've always thought about. Northern Canada we run our wood stoves for ~8 months a year. Temp on the surface of the stove is 200C to 300C. Outside is -20C to -40C. Let's say an average of 200C temp delta across the TEC. Throw a radiator on the outside of the cabin, use coolant with a tiny pump to circulate. How much power am I going to generate with a square foot (or two) of TECs strapped to the wood stove, using the coolant loop to cool the other side? It feels like we have such a huge temperature delta we should be able to do something with.
- Loughla 3y agoWouldn't that effectively just suck the heat from your home? I feel like that's not a great use of your stove?
- UI_at_80x24 3y agoHeating with a wood stove doesn't really have a 'medium' setting. You get 100% while it's roaring away, and that slowly diminishes as the fuel burns down. (Yes you can adjust dampers, and air-flow valves to "slow it down"; but that doesn't really work/happen.) I've lived in a home heated by a wood stove for 10 years. You would build-up the stove so it blasts away, goto bed, and by morning there would be enough coals left to start it up again but quite chilly in the house. There is nothing like it. I love it. I don't have the same access my father did to family farms, wood lots, and trees. Today I would look into rocket mass heaters. Spread that heat out and allow it to more slowly heat a house.
- petermcneeley 3y agoThis sounds all very "homesteading". If you automate various components including wood feed you could get a better experience.
- thsksbd 3y agoOr you do what slavs did for century and build a massive mud oven to trap the heat in.
- at_a_remove 3y agoBetter yet, bring back Feolite for ridiculous heat capacity in Calories per gram.
- Loughla 3y agoYes I'm aware. I grew up with a wood stove as a primary source of heat, and hated it. But that doesn't really address my issue. For an ambient wood stove, the heat is pushed through the house from one central spot (the stove). If you use a system to use that heat for power or something else, aren't you just going to cool your home?
- serpix 3y agoThe solution to this is and has been for centuries is to add mass to the stove.
- Retric 3y agoDoing that pumps energy outside your house without heating your house. A better option is to use the temperature differential between the stove and your house. You get less electrical power, however waste energy from both the stove and the device still heats your house effectively making a system over 100% efficient. Ie convert 1% of the stoves energy into electricity which you then use to power a fan. The fan‘s waste heat also heats the room thus you get to use both the utility of the fan (1%) + waste heat from stove (99%) + waste heat from fan (1%) = 101%.
- waterheater 3y agoYou're not going to achieve an over-unity system. Assuming no other losses, you'll be using 100% of heat energy from the stove. The equation is missing a -1% term somewhere.
- Retric 3y agoYou’re allowed to make use of the same energy at different points in time. The 1% used by the fan is the same 1% that’s heating your room. A computer converts 99.9% of the electricity to heat a room just like a space heater. However, you can play video games on the PC while it’s heating your room.
- pishpash 3y agoThat's why all electric heating should be devices that do work or compute. Do not waste the Gibbs free energy of the universe.
- andbberger 3y agothis was the only sane argument for blockchain mining but it was never competitive with heat pumps
- Scoundreller 3y agoDepends how cold it is outside, but yes, heat pumps usually win.
- skyfaller 3y agoTo steelman your proposal, I should mention that Low-Tech Magazine thinks you're on to something, although they suggest putting the panels on the stove inside the cabin: https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2020/05/thermoelectric-stoves-ditch-the-solar-panels/ https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2020/05/thermoelectric-sto... I disagree with that article for the simple reason that I do not consider burning wood to be sustainable, or healthy for anything with lungs. Wood should be used for long-lasting construction or left alone / carefully nurtured to aid our forests in rebuilding biodiversity. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/09/07/world/europe/eu-logging-wood-pellets.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/09/07/world/europe/... https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/dec/27/wood-burning-stove-environment-home-toxins https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/dec/27/wood-b... But if you're going to burn wood anyhow, perhaps thermoelectric stoves aren't a terrible way to generate electricity for yourself.
- antisthenes 3y agoMost burned wood is wood unsuitable for construction. No one goes into the woods and cuts down a 200-year oak to burn in their stove. Short lengths, widths, knots, imperfections, wood waste pressed into pellets, etc. Although you do have a point about it being bad for air quality. Especially old stove installations.
- jfoutz 3y agoI thought pellet stoves got hot enough to be pretty clean. Co2, yes, but not much else?
- jonstewart 3y agoIf you run it properly. A good wood stove will run cleanly as well. It’s all about the secondary combustion. An open fireplace will not get hot enough for secondary and be dirty.
- ericbarrett 3y agoResidential pellet stoves sound great but in practice they are not reliable (moving mechanical parts that operate at high temps, electronics poorly shielded from said temps—the manufacturers are pretty shady in my experience), and the cost of fuel varies quite a bit and can be very high. Compare to a wood stove that needs no electricity and can burn just about any combustible solid. Modern wood stoves are pretty efficient, too.
- petermcneeley 3y agoYes there is a massive potential for power generation. Stirling engine would give you the maximum efficiency but maybe not the max power output. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stirling_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stirling_engine https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ge3cerSVEI0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ge3cerSVEI0
- grecy 3y agoWhen it's -40 often, and you live off grid, no moving parts trumps complexity every time
- thsksbd 3y agoFor the PD to deliver work it would have to transport heat outside. Heat you're burning wood to have inside. Better to store the heat somehow, and have it be slowly released.
- grecy 3y agoHeat we have a massive, massive, massive excess of. It's electricity I want, in the winter, when the sun is only on the solar panels for ~3 hours a day.
- thsksbd 3y agoya, but not enough to overcome PD's limitations. You're better off buying a little steam turbine and generating electricity directly off of the stove. On top of the electricity, you get to keep the heat. Or, better yet, buy a propane tank and a suitably large generac. Then pipe the cooling water into radiators in the house.
- bilsbie 3y agoI’d pay a premium for a solid state AC or heat pump. It’s absurd how much they cost to install. And I don’t get why replacing one is an all day job for three people. There should be standard connections they just plug into. Like a dishwasher.
- antisthenes 3y agoWhat in the world are you talking about? The hardest part of installing AC is the ductwork. Swapping out the outside + inside heat exchanger unit is a 1-person 3-4-hour job. Sorry if some HVAC company scammed you, but it's definitely not a 3 person job, unless we're talking some commercial building 5+ ton units.
- bilsbie 3y agoJust residential. One guy working in the outside part and one on the inside and one helper. Seemed like a lot of wiring and charging things. I didn’t think it should take that long either. Their price was in line with other quotes. I wasn’t paying by the hour or anything.
- ChatGTP 3y agoIf you're system is hooked up to "floor heating", hydraulic stuff that runs under your floor it's still a one man job but can be a little bit harder to do.
- aurizon 3y agoThere are a few zero pipe mini-splits. They hang across the window frame and use 1 inch of height with an inside bidirectional radiator and an external one, SCrewed down to the window jamb and connected to 120/240 volts internally. They resemble a window A/C, but the rads are below the window level and are wider and less deep. I am getting a few next year. This is one of many. https://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/article/startup-promises-window-mounted-heat-pump-by-next-year https://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/article/startup-promise...
- magicalhippo 3y agoWe got a Mitsubishi Kaiteki[1], which is a mini-split from what I can gather. We just call them "air to air heat pumps" here in Norway. Anyway, the install itself was about $400, took one guy a few hours like you said. Another $200 for the electrician which had to hook up a dedicated circuit for it as per regulations, though he did it as part of a larger job so would have been $300 as a stand-alone deal. Total it was $2200. This is considered a premium unit over here, we could have gotten something cheaper but alas looks matter. Thing is supposedly guaranteed to provide COP of 2 down to -25C. We've had such low temps here a several times (in fact past week has been around -15 to -17C with a harsh 85% humidity, biting!) and we've never had to turn on the backup floor heating so far. Though you can definitely hear it working harder when it's that cold. [1]: https://mee.no/privat/produktkategori/luft-luft-varmepumper/kaiteki/ https://mee.no/privat/produktkategori/luft-luft-varmepumper/...
- frankus 3y agoI've been doing a bit of research into air-to-water heat pumps (using a conventional vapor compression cycle) as I'll be installing one soon (Bear with me—I promise I'll get to thermoelectric devices by the end). They're currently able to replace a boiler for a heating system designed around relatively low-temperature (120°F/50°C) emitters, with lower temperatures leading to better performance (so a large radiant panel in a floor or ceiling is a good choice). One of the underutilized capabilities they have is to do radiant cooling. The tricky part is that any part of the system that drops below the dewpoint (in whatever space it's located in) will condense moisture out of the air, likely damaging itself or things around it over time. You can address this to some degree by either modulating the heat pump or mixing/recirculating water to keep the emitters a few degrees above the dewpoint, but that limits the amount of sensible heat that you can remove from the space and doesn't do anything for latent heat (i.e. humidity). One solution is to use an emitter (e.g. fan coil, either central or in a little wall unit like a mini-split) that has a drip tray that drains the condensate away to where it can't do damage, but the pipes leading to the emitters still need to be insulated and vapor-sealed. This isn't terribly expensive to add to a new system but could be quite expensive to retrofit into a system where the pipes are already buried into the walls. Another approach is to keep the fluid above the dewpoint and use a separate dehumidifier that condenses moisture out of the air and releases the resulting heat into the space. This isn't ideal because you're adding an additional heat source into the space that you're trying to cool. As I understand it, the strength of thermoelectric devices is that they're silent and relatively small, but their weakness is they're not terribly efficient, especially for cooling, and have a steeper drop-off of efficiency with increasing temperature difference between the cold and hot side. But for dehumidification, the temperature difference is likely small (from a few degrees above the dewpoint to a few degrees below it), and also the latent cooling load tends to be a fraction of the sensible cooling load. So the idea would be to build a device that is plumbed inline with the emitter in each room (or possibly just e.g. a bathroom or kitchen) that uses a thermoelectric device to cool a heatsink below the dewpoint (with a fan) and collects the condensate for disposal, but rejects the heat into the return pipe to the heat pump. The advantage over a conventional fan coil-based system is that the in-wall plumbing (and indeed all of the hydronic plumbing) remains above the dewpoint, so the indoor hydronic piping doesn't need insulating or vapor sealing. I could see this being especially useful in buildings converting from a condensing boiler to a heat pump and want to add cooling without tearing open all the walls.
- 10u152 3y agoWhat an article of fluff. Doesn’t give any real technical/engineering information. It’s completely useless unless you show us the COP of the system at varying ambient temps. Heat pumps can get to around 4.0 that’s the number to beat.
- drtgh 3y agoA whole article for to say that researchers found a ZT of 3.1 for certain temperatures. This is what since several years ago many researchers are obtaining (those ZT=3.1, that is 20% of efficiency? for eventual temperatures) with a mean of ZT=2 as much. Peltier effect cells remain inefficient, they are electricity guzzlers. I don't understand then the article's purpose.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoIEEE Spectrum's writing and editorial quality does seem to have gone down over the last decade. Though I'm not even sure what the target audience is anymore.
- nirolo 3y agoCame for this comment. Why is there no COP/SCOP mentioned at all... If you want to get into the market you should be competitive. And the COP of 4.0 you mention is actually the lower end. I'm heating with an AC as air-to-air heatpump now for the second winter and I chose the most efficient that I could get with a SCOP of over 6. And for the first winter I also could reach these numbers.
- davidw 3y agoWe recently got a heatpump and... it feels like witchcraft. It chugs away even at 20F blowing hot air into our house.
- Kye 3y agoAt 20F that's probably the backup heat kicking in. Heat pumps start losing their efficiency advantage around 40. edit: apparently I was misinformed, but it doesn't seem like something worthy of being downvoted into oblivion.
- davidw 3y agoNo, because the installer set it up right at 20. We do have a gas furnace that kicks in below that. It'd be amazing if someone put together some kind of dynamic calculator that could take electricity and natural gas prices and examine inside temperatures based on a smart thermostat system and rejig the cutoff temperature based on all of it.
- patmorgan23 3y agoBet you could do this in home assistant
- davidw 3y agoYeah, if I could figure out the calculations to use and source all the data...
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoThere are hybrid heat pumps that do exactly this.
- pjc50 3y agoMy Vaillant system claims to do that, but it doesn't have dynamic input of pricing so you have to type it in on the head unit. I'm not sure it's even possible to get an API for dynamic pricing of UK energy prices.
- ctechbob 3y agoDupont will see that this never sees the light of day. Just like how we don't use butane/propane/CO2 as refrigerants which are just as safe as most of the flourocarbons but have the downside of being too cheap to make any money off of.
- thsksbd 3y agoWell they're also inflammable and not as good as CFCs. Kinda how we don't use toxic ammonia as a refrigerant. For what it's worth, my mini fridge and my chest freezer use some hydrocarbon refrigerant. They're littered with warning signs not to puncture them.
- ctechbob 3y agoMost of the FC's are highly toxic when exposed to fire. R-1234yf is not only (slightly) flammable but also releases hydrogen fluoride and carbonyl fluoride when exposed to fire, but this is what is in almost all new cars. I've run a propane/butane mix in an R12 car before and the fact that it was flammable didn't bother me a bit. The 14 gallons of gas would worry me more than 12oz of propane going up.
- quickthrowman 3y ago> Kinda how we don't use toxic ammonia as a refrigerant. Ammonia is definitely still used as a refrigerant, just not in consumer equipment. It’s commonly used for ice rink chillers, at least in the US and Canada. Not sure about Europe.
- thsksbd 3y ago"just not in consumer equipment." that's key isn't it? Ammonia is corrosive and consumers are often not too bright.
- com2kid 3y agoIsobutane is one of the most common refrigerants in use today... Chemical companies do plenty of actual evil things, there is no need to spread false claims!
- gcanyon 3y ago> Researchers use a dimensionless quantity called ZT to describe the strength of the thermoelectric effect in any combination of materials. Two decades ago, combinations such as lead and tellurium yielded ZT values of around 1. After ten years, the search for new, more complex, and more effective materials had yielded ZT values of 2. These sentences are useless. Going from 1 to 2 probably means doubling the efficiency, if the base value is 0. But even if that's true (which it's not guaranteed to be) is a real-world usable value 3? or 478? Much later in the article: "Vining predicted in 2009 that a ZT of 4 would be the required threshold for commercialization." There it is. But even with that, the information given tells us very little about the underlying property, or the technology.
- elil17 3y agoAs someone who works in this industry - no, thermoelectric heating does not stand at the brink of commercialization. The fundamental issue with thermoelectric heating is that you need a material with high electrical conductivity but very low thermal conductivity. zT is a metric that measures this ratio. Conducting electricity but not heat is a weird property for a material to have and no one even knows if zT can be raised much from where it is today. Even if it could, it would probably be expensive, so you'd probably want to use thermoelectric cooling for things like on-chip computer cooling, not to cool your whole house.
- Workaccount2 3y agoI don't understand why they would even consider it for heating? An electric heater is already 99.99% efficient.
- amluto 3y agoBy that standard, a heat pump is something like 400% efficient (it depends on a lot of factors), and replacing an electric heater with a heat pump pays for itself quite quickly if you’re using it to heat an entire house or even a poorly insulated room.
- lmpdev 3y agoTangental: Are there thermoelectric modules less prone to failure than Peltier modules? They have an awfully high failure rate in every project I’ve tried to integrate them into