6 ms·
And yet it's one of the crowning achievements of the entire Internet, and a contender for one of the most important written works of the last century. This is a
by tptacek 3y ago
And yet it's one of the crowning achievements of the entire Internet, and a contender for one of the most important written works of the last century. This is always the challenge trying to dismiss Wikipedia: something they're doing is working, not just well, but well on a level that is virtually unprecedented.
- harimau777 3y agoGive it time. As Wikipedia has become more and more obsessed with being "encyclopedic", I've noticed that they are increasingly ending up with articles that are stripped of any useful information.
- _a_a_a_ 3y ago[flagged]
- djmips 3y ago^ toxic comment. - "People like you" - "always" - "You" "calling them a failure" - all hostile. Should have stopped after first sentence.
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoMaybe I should have stopped after the first sentence, but there's always, every bloody time, someone there to drag you down with negativity. How wiki is shit, stackoverflow is shit, the web is shit, society is shit – they never offer evidence, it's just shit and they can't see good in anything. I'm tired of these people dragging me down. What is their fucking agenda other than to wallow in failure?
- drekipus 3y agoPeople having an opinion on something doesn't affect you. Just relax. Swearing at them, calling them out, "people like you" etc, affects them. I have to have this exact same discussion with my 60yo bipolar neighbour who terrorizes a whole ecovillage, because someone planted carrots and "don't they know the seasonal pattern!!" - just relax, focus on your lane
- dang 3y agoPlease don't cross into personal attack when posting to HN. You can make your substantive points without that. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoIndeed. So let's be consistent "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something". How did the comment I responded to say anything useful, constructive or usefully critical? Negative but vacuous dismissals like theirs seem ok. I hate that aspect of HN; the nihilism allowed to flower.
- the_only_law 3y agoHN rules are fickle at best. Only way to get a good idea of how they’re enforced is to observe for some time.
- dang 3y agoTwo answers: (1) it's not possible to be consistent because there are far too many posts for us to read; we can only moderate what we see. If you see a post that ought to have been moderated but hasn't been, the likeliest explanation is that we didn't see it. You can help by flagging it or emailing us at hn@ycombinator.com; and (2) shallow as the GP's criticism may have been, your comment was far worse. Responding to a bad comment (or one you feel is bad) by breaking the site guidelines yourself, let alone with a nasty personal attack, is exactly the opposite of what you should be doing here—it's driving the wrong way down a one-way street.
- _a_a_a_ 3y ago1) fair enough. Should the negative empty comment I was referring to have been flagged for your attention? I appreciate the answer may very well be "no, you're wasting our time with the little stuff", and I'd agree. 2) I honestly don't know how to respond to people like this. Their purpose is to negate, even purposefully destroy. I've sat down with people I've worked with who are apathetic and hopeless and slowly taught them that they can make a difference but I can't do that over the Internet. And it fills me with despair watching them trash what good things we do have. (BTW thank you for replying, I appreciate it)
- rockskon 3y agoWikipedia is also very poor when it comes to contentious political topics that the bulk of contributors are extremely passionate about.
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoI once pointed out on a music theory page that a long name for a scale could be shortened to "Dorian b2". The edit was rejected because the chief whatever wanted a source. If you knew what Dorian means and what the second degree of a scale means you'd know immediately that what I was saying was true. I've hardly suggested an edit since.
- t0bia_s 3y agoIdea of centralized and universal interpenetration of information soon or later bump into boundaries. By definition, it's impossible approach. Interpretation vary with knowledge, culture and is shaped by politics, religion, regime, etc.
- whatshisface 3y agoThat's why you don't interpret it, just list it: encyclopedically.
- moate 3y agoThat’s literally impossible. You’re consciousness trapped in meat, everything you experience is an interpretation of your environment and entirely subject to that meat. “The Republican Party exists” is an interpretation of each word, and is controversial on some axis. “2” is a concept, it literally does not exist outside of the mind. This is to say: your desire for objectivity has failed, the best we can ever get are “well defined and explained rationalizations that many people agree with”.
- whatshisface 3y agoAn objective, encyclopediac approach to philosophy would be listing the views on whether or not the word exists applied to a political party.
- t0bia_s 3y agoUntil someone called it toxic, disinformation, hoax, etc.
- t0bia_s 3y agoHistory is written by winners. If you agree, then there is a lot of unlisted informations. If you don't agree, then you are on the winners side.
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- juliusdavies 3y agoI consider Wikipedia to be the last standing wonder of the WWW (world wide web). - Google search results get worse every year. - Stackoverflow lies in ruins (albeit the ruins are still useful). - ICQ/Gtalk/AIM completely dead and all in silos now (Slack). - Twitter is dead. - Facebook is too annoying now. Google Maps is still amazing, but I consider that more a miracle of the internet as opposed to a miracle of the WWW, since the data is essentially sourced commercially (satellites and maps), whereas with the examples above the data was sourced communally. And so I think it's inevitable Wikipedia will die within my lifetime. Probably within the decade. I suspect my children will never get to enjoy the miraculous shockingly glorious human affirming paradox of Wikipedia. Their (public school) teachers senselessly already tell them to avoid it. :-( I don't think Wikipedia will die for any specific technical or political reason. I just think it will die because everything else that was wonderful from 2009 or before already has, so why not Wikipedia?
- switchbak 3y agoThe surprising rebirth of podcasts is the only standout in that list. It's as if blogs became popular again. Though the days of simple RSS feeds with a high signal to noise ratio are probably long behind us. (I know some are still around, but I mean popular in the way podcasts are now).
- 0xDEAFBEAD 3y ago>I just think it will die because everything else that was wonderful from 2009 or before already has Assuming this is true, what are the leading hypotheses? Regression to the mean? Eternal September? I know everyone likes to talk about "enshittification", but what is the actual mechanism? Since this is HN, someone's going to say "capitalism", but "capitalism" doesn't explain why Google search results get worse or Facebook is too annoying.
- Whoppertime 3y agoOh that's easy. Dotcom Boom and Bust ended one era of the web right around 9/11, and you get a weird era between 2001 and the release of the iPhone where there's a lot of content posted on Newgrounds or flash game portals like Miniclip. An era where people still got information from Magazines and got demo discs, and people were discouraged from sharing their real name or personal information online instead of being required to provide it in order to create an account. Steve Jobs refused to put Flash support in the iPhone justifying it through security reasons but the real reason being it undermined the walled garden and iPhone app marketplace, and Android didn't think it would be worth it either, leading to even Adobe dropping support in 2011 ending that chapter of the internet entirely. When 100% of your users access a website through a desktop computer you are going to design it one way. When half your users are mobile and half are desktop it's going to be designed a different way.
- Manuel_D 3y agoWikipedia's flaws are more subtle. Pages sometimes present controversial, or even wrong claims as unambiguously true. Note, this is not actually that bad on pages that are clearly covering controversial topics (namely historical & political topics). The issue is more prevalent on niche topics where the average reader wouldn't recognize the controversy being claimed. I've sometimes encountered citations where the cited material directly contradicts the claim made on the page. I highly suggest reading the talk page of wikipedia articles. Not just the talk page, but read through the history of the talk page too. E.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Ada_Lovelace&oldid=1165660551 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Ada_Lovelace...
- resolutebat 3y agoGenuine Q: what do you find "wrong" about Ada Lovelace's article as it stands today? To me it looks scrupulously fair about her contributions and the amount of disagreement on what exactly she did "first", which seems to account for 99% of the talk page wrangling. Lovelace's notes are important in the early history of computers, especially since the seventh one contained what many consider to be the first computer program—that is, an algorithm designed to be carried out by a machine. Other historians reject this perspective and point out that Babbage's personal notes from the years 1836/1837 contain the first programs for the engine.[6][better source needed] She also developed a vision of the capability of computers to go beyond mere calculating or number-crunching, while many others, including Babbage himself, focused only on those capabilities.
- Manuel_D 3y agoI don't have any issues with the article as it stands today. But earlier revisions had uncritically claimed that she had written the first computer programs. Hence the massive Talk thread.
- jorvi 3y agoSee the article about who created the internet. Packet switching was invented in the UK by Donald Davies, yet somehow it’s always the Americans that get sole credit for the internet. :)
- lmm 3y agoI don't think anything they're doing today is working. They had something great in, like, 2008, and have been at best coasting since then.
- GauntletWizard 3y agoWikipedia was one of the crowning achievements of the internet before said culture took over, and significantly such culture formed as a sort of symbiote and parasite to it's success. What made Wikipedia successful was that it was free in a time that people were more used to paying for that kind of information, and that it was open in the sense that anyone could contribute when many places were significantly gatekept. It has now evolved it's own form of said gatekeeping, not because such is necessary for Wikipedia to be successful, but to harvest the residual success of that open system for the benefit of the parasites.