18 ms·
Toxic comments are associated with reduced volunteer activity on Wikipedia
- EnigmaFlare 3y agoWith all these horror stories, I have the opposite. I made an article for my tiny company to help promote it. Sounds bad but I followed the Wikipedia rules to the letter. I ensured that every single piece of information was cited to independent reputable sources only, even though some of it was actually false. I declared my conflict of interest on the first edit and my user talk page. I was prepared for it to get instantly deleted but instead some bots fixed a bit of formatting and now it's the 2nd result on Google after my own website when searching for the company name.
- Vicinity9635 3y agoFun fact: if you check the Talk page of controversial pages you can frequently see all the public interest information the extremely biased editors are trying to suppress. Recent example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:2023_Nashville_school_shooting#Manifesto https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:2023_Nashville_school_sho...
- Grimblewald 3y agoOne take might be that it is indeed rambling and not targeted. I say that because the statements, while appearing political, display a profound ignorance on the topic. It is entirely possible this was a disturbed individual who wished to do harm and saw this as a 'acceptable to some' way of perpetrating those crimes. It's like someone claiming to be vegan to help them veil their eating disorder. Just because they say they are vegan, and do things a vegan might, does not mean that they share the behavioral traits or values of a vegan.
- WalterBright 3y agoI've decided to hang on to my old paper encyclopedia from the 1990s.
- calamari4065 3y agoMany years ago I got called an idiot for suggesting an extremely specific and extremely irrelevant article get deleted. I haven't bothered to contribute since. Clearly Wikipedia is full of very stable geniuses and don't need contributions from the common folk.
- nilslindemann 3y agoI regularly edit things on Wikipedia. My principle is: If someone is toxic, reverts my edits with mean words, fuck it, leave the lemma. Usually after a while these people get banned and then I come back and happily improve.
- nilslindemann 3y agoI hear a lot of comments here about the decline of Wikipedia. That's nonsense. One can be very productive on Wikipedia if they have viewer rights. Sites like Stack Overflow are much worse.
- kurtreed 3y agoThe real shocker is that there are two dozen sexual harassment scandals against women on Wikipedia, involving editors, admins and even high-up stewards and sysops. https://rdrama.net/post/215764/there-are-two-dozen-sexual-harassment https://rdrama.net/post/215764/there-are-two-dozen-sexual-ha...
- esbranson 3y agoIndeed. I have made numerous toxic comments (described by others as vitriolic at times) over my two decades of editing, almost entirely towards the admin corps and the other imps who are disruptive. I do appreciate their work as a whole. I am a top-5000 editor of all time on the English WP. Mostly politics but some tech. My toxic comments are few and far, but can be intense. And not to mistake them with passively-hostile, terse disagreement. I have never seen the 0.99 level comments on WP. The 0.83 and below is common, not just on Wikipedia but walking around large cities. 0.99 is part of the wonderful experience in SF and DC. But all the reports of decline are overstated, these places aren't going to decline much more, it's steady state at this point.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoWell there's a surprise!
- lupusreal 3y agoWho leaves the toxic comments? Rando readers some of the time I'm sure, but most probably come from other editors. Other editors are the ones who are well accustomed and most inclined to track down other editors associated with some article and give them a piece of their mind. Most of the public seems to be range-banned when not using an account anyway.
- bawolff 3y agoThis seems a bit to be a - water is wet article. I think the more interesting question is what is the impact of these volunteers leaving. Are the toxic comments directed at people who tend to get in the middle of flamewars, or are they innocents? Do these people do good work? Or are they just annoying people until someone snaps at them in a fit of toxity?
- bdhcuidbebe 3y ago> I think the more interesting question is what is the impact of these volunteers leaving. Then you might be interested in reading the publication you are commenting on, especially under the heading ”Results”.
- kemayo 3y agoThat just says "there's less activity", and doesn't address bawolff's question of quality in any way.
- chefandy 3y agoSure-- where you're driving is usually more interesting than the highway that will take you there, but this isn't an off-the-cuff editorial-- it's presenting a quantitative analysis. Trying to study the qualitative impact without data like this means merely assuming the fundamental size and shape of the problem, which at best reduces it's utility. At worse it points you in the completely wrong direction.
- intended 3y agoThere are very few water is wet articles in T&S research. It’s pretty dang hard to get any good scientific information. It’s only in the past few years that I have got an idea of churn and impact of toxicity behavior online on communities. I’ve been looking into this from before the term trust and safety existed. It’s THAT bad. Most of our data is behind platform walls. That water is wet is state of the art.
- Semaphor 3y agoedit: Misunderstood TFA. Leaving the original comment. ~~On the other hand, the only toxic comments I experienced on Wikipedia were from an editor.~~
- rewmie 3y ago> On the other hand, the only toxic comments I experienced on Wikipedia were from an editor. Isn't everyone an editor on Wikipedia? By definition, you need to be an editor in order to leave comments. Who other than editors would leave toxic comments?
- itishappy 3y agoAm I a marathon runner because I'm theoretically capable of it, or do I need to actually run one first?
- Thorrez 3y agoLeaving a comment on Wikipedia involves editing the talk page. So commenting is performing an edit, thus making the commenter also an editor. Also, anyone who is knowledgeable enough to edit a talk page most likely has edited regular articles in the past as well.
- itishappy 3y agoSure, but do you really think that's the intent of the article, or are we arguing semantics? Your second point is a great one.
- rewmie 3y ago> Sure, but do you really think that's the intent of the article, or are we arguing semantics? It's not semantics. Accusing Wikipedia editors of doing something in an attempt at portraying Wikipedia in a negative light has the same meaning as blaming wikipedia for accepting changes from everyone in the world who stumbles upon a page. By definition, an editor is anyone who edits anything at all on Wikipedia. In wikipedia, you don't even need to be logged in to edit articles or leave comments.
- Hitton 3y ago>For instance, the level of conflict on discussion pages, as assessed by raters, has been shown to negatively correlate with the quality of the corresponding Wikipedia articles. An alternative explanation is that "toxic comments" protect wikipedia from low quality content, acting as defense mechanism against bad editors. So without better study which tries to analyze if the critique (regardless of toxicity) is justified, it's absolutely useless to make any conclusions from the article.
- shagie 3y agoI wrote about this a couple of years ago as a post titled "Rudeness – the moderation tool of last resort" Part of that... > One of those things that comes up time and time again in virtual communites is that of “everyone here is mean.” There is some truth to that. > Try as we might with “be nice” policies and censoring rude comments that have the possibility of driving newcomers away, rudeness still thrives. While one component of this is John Gabriel’s theory ( https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/19/green-blackboards-and-other-anomalies https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/19/green-blackboa... ) and that people are more likely to act out when protected by some veneer of anonymity, it doesn’t handle that on usenet of old and many professional leaning forums where the link between online and real world identity is more tightly coupled for many users. > Clay Shirky touched on this in A Group Is Its Own Worst Enemy where he talks about a community oriented BBS (it was the 70s with all the ideals that implies) that was overrun by kids and the community there lacked the tools to be able to moderate or censor them (these tools were never built because it ran counter to those ideals). > This brings us to Usenet in the 80s and 90s. Usenet was much larger than the BBSs of old and it had some moderation tools with it. There were moderated news groups that restricted posting to only approved posts – this didn’t scale well. There were also cancel messages as part of the control protocls that were part of cancelbot wars against spam. At the personal level, there were was really only one tool available – kill files which caused specific posts, threads, or users to be ignored by you and only you. The reprocussion of this was that in order to have someone get disinvited from a news group, one had to drive them away with social tools. Rudeness. > Today’s sites are much larger than those BBSs of the 70s and the largest of those contest the volume of data of a full usenet feed at its height. The community moderation tools have simillarly grown in capability as the moderated usnet groups would not scale to thousands of posts per day (Reddit has on the order of 200k posts per day, Quora and Stack Overflow/Exchange have on the order of 10k posts per day). > The problem of rudeness arises as people run out of the ability to moderate using the tools provided in software. Votes, the ability to push a post into the workflow of “make it dissapear for everyone” and the ability to completely hide a post or person from ever showing up on one’s feed again – when those tools run out or aren’t provided the “social” moderation tools are the ones that remain. > Thus rudeness and the attempt to drive an individual away because other moderation tools have run out or are ineffective. Rudeness is the moderation tool of last resort. When one sees the umteenth “how do I draw a pyramid with *” in the first week of classes on a programming site – how does one make it go away when the moderation tools have been fully exhausted? Be rude and hope that the next person seeing it won’t post the umteenth+1 one.
- hoseja 3y agoHey I have a better title: "Toxic" comments easy to track and quantify for researchers.
- ProllyInfamous 3y ago"You're [not your idea] stupid." "Why can't you do what I asked, Stupid?!" "WHERE HAVE ALL OUR USERS GONE?!?" ---- My main wikihandle is two decades old. It still shocks me when a fewyearsaccount un-edits my contributions (I know how this rodeo works, folks). Even more shocking is when ChatGPT cites one of my trivial contributions (e.g. transistor density updates when M2Pro chipset was released).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vasco 3y ago"Toxic" would not be the thing I'd start with. I'd start with "being told no for the first time", which might or not have an overlap with toxicity. But I think it's much more likely that someone will start making edits, only get uninterested comments or bot engagements, keep editing, then at some point someone reverts the edits - tells them no, and so they stop. Potentially this scenario even catches situations like: 1. User registers 2. User adds a bunch of promotional edits to multiple pages 3. At some point someone discovers this, reverts something, tells them to go away 4. User was "caught" so abandons the account and re-registers If #3 is classified as toxic, this paper would find the same results I think.
- snoopsnopp 3y agoI find this happens with a lot of forums. The most critically minded users eventually get exasperated and become toxic after repeated bans to “kamikaze” accounts.
- notahacker 3y agoI suspect the system for scoring "toxic" comments is less likely to flag the bureaucratic "I have reverted your edit for a second time because it does not meet WP:NPOV or WP:NOR. Please be aware of WP:3RR and be prepared to discuss any further changes on the talk page" comments about reversion and more likely to flag the sort of very angry and personal comments that come up when the page being edited is related to the culture war or actual longstanding war. Whether the recipient of the angry messages was previously a constructive contributor to that topic is an open question, of course.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoThe system almost certainly doesn't address the primary problem, which is that a small group of people consider a page or topic to be their personal fiefdom and they're experts at snowballing people with the most obscure wikipedia policies. A shining example of this would be the page for Alcoholics Anonymous, which has a small legion of accounts 'defending' it. The accounts espouse, vocally, a victimhood complex - that AA is targeted by people "harassing" and "discrediting" the program. The page is brutally censored of any negative information - such as their problems with predation ('thirteenth stepping') and sexual assault, the fact that the program has no basis in science and is repeatedly demonstrated to be amongst the worst options for addiction treatment. The result is a page which is wildly not NPOV - it contains only material positive about the founder, program and organization. Someone tried to add mention of a documentary and the prick editor claimed the film did not meet notability guidelines because it hadn't been screened in the right kind of film festivals and thus its existence could not be mentioned.
- paulnpace 3y agoGave up looking for a clear definition of what a "toxic comment" is. All I found is a statement that they use some score from some tool and link to the tool developer's site so I'm required to sift through the developer's site to understand what the core part of the paper is, or I've missed some other part of the paper because they include so many dense paragraphs of nothing useful informations (as well as a nice promotion for the tool developers).
- Ensorceled 3y agoA good way to begin to understand about toxic comments is to look for the "dead" comments on HN. Dead comments fall into a few categories: trolling, advertisements, conspiracy/culture war and toxic. It's pretty easy to figure out which is which.
- lolc 3y agoNo the question is how the authors decided which comments were toxic for their evaluation. If they say "gut feeling" then replication will be greatly hampered.
- Ensorceled 3y agoThe article explains their methodology for identifying and tracking toxic comments.
- lolc 3y agoThe original comment said "All I found is a statement that they use some score from some tool and link to the tool developer's site". So if that's all there is regarding classification, their methodology is not nailed down very well in my view. But maybe there's more and we haven't found it?
- Ensorceled 3y agoThere is an entire section dedicated this at the end of the article. They are using at established tool for this domain and there are links explaining how it works and definitions.
- acadapter 3y agoIt's all just a matter of expectations. Today's Wikipedia has a quite difficult learning curve for making proper and lasting contributions. The "Visual Editor" should be confined to the Talk: pages, so that the difficulty of editing can be higher, to match the difficulty of dealing with Wikipedia's internal bureaucracy.
- squigz 3y agoAs an occasional Wikipedia editor... I would hate this so much.
- reddalo 3y agoI agree. The Visual Editor has simplified editing Wikipedia pages from a technical standpoint, but at the same time lowering the bar to edit pages also lowered the quality of many of those edits, making moderation even more difficult. It's a vicious circle.
- tamarlikesdata 3y agoAdd community notes
- collyw 3y agoThe talk tab generally has more interesting stuff than the main article these days.
- bivvic 3y agoI've left acerbic comments in replies to editors before, but only when they were being rude, obstructive, dismissive or sarcastic themselves. I do hope it changed their behavior, like the article suggests. Some of these people get so full of themselves and treat the pages they are interested in like their own little fiefdoms that no-one else is allowed to touch.
- kranke155 3y agoThe Portuguese Wikipedia has been completely taken over by a toxic mega group that’s bent the rules to get what they want. They constantly harass you, and they invent rules if needed to get articles down that they don’t like.
- jowea 3y agoPeople complain about that in the English Wikipedia but I guess it can be even worse in the smaller ones? Weren't a few of them basically captured by the local far-right propagandists? Is this group you're talking about political or just the "I/we own this and will do this my way" of English Wikipedia?
- kranke155 3y agoIt is far worse being a smaller Wikipedia. It’s both. There are political accounts that remove corruption scandals from local politicians and others who just harass you in general. I made a page about a major scandal in Portugal and they used the Brazilian admins by telling them the scandal was too small to be in Wikipedia. It was in a major TV show in Portugal but the Brazilian admins almost deleted the page (which then blocks you from remaking it).
- whstl 3y agoI remember it depending on the article. There are "turfs", and the rules aren't consistent between them. Some guy goes nuts on the movies and television articles and nobody can get anything through, it gets reverted with a "this is not necessary". On science and engineering pages I remember there being a lot of unsourced material that felt more like a school paper than an encyclopedia. The quality was really bad, but it was still hard to change.
- sonicanatidae 3y agoHave they met...humans?
- boomlinde 3y agoI'd rather have some uncouth editor berate me in a discussion than my personal editing experience of sometimes having simple and obvious, even clerical changes to non-contentious topics immediately reverted with no comment. It's not that I take it personally, because I realize that no one cared to review the edits before reversion. It's just that "be bold" in the sense that it's applied by me in combination with how it's applied by overprotective bots (maybe?) or at worst diligent but careless editors is a massive waste of time and energy. So I've stopped contributing altogether.
- donatj 3y agoI have been making small contributions for fifteen or so years. I don’t much feel like doing it anymore after a spurt of bad interactions. About a year ago I created a Wikipedia page for a TV personality and author I enjoy. Spent literal hours on it collecting citations and what have you. Within a couple hours the page was deleted for not being noteworthy. He had his own TV show, has multiple published books and a popular podcast. Seems noteworthy enough to me, but what do I know. A couple months ago I tried to create a page on a local tractor company that used to be really important to my hometowns economy. There was an existing section about the company on one of their specific tractors pages. I used that with its citations as the basis for the new page. I did scan the citations and they seemed fine. I even fixed one that was broken with a wayback machine link. What I didn’t do was read them word for word. Well turns out multiple sections of the text I had moved from the tractors page were straight up lifted from their sources. Within 5 minutes of posting the page, someone else did read my citations word for word, and it was marked for “rapid deletion for copyright infringement”. No chance to explain. No chance to reword. Just gone completely and I didn’t have a local copy of the article. It was particularly frustrating because the moved text only accounted for about 20% of the page by the time I was done. Beyond that the history of my author page is now marked with a copyright infringement warning that if I do it again I’ll be banned. I don’t think I want to play in their sandbox anymore.
- networkchad 3y ago[dead]
- rqtwteye 3y agoReminds me of my experience with Stackoverflow. I tried to solve a very specific problem with Windows installers. I only got some responses from oldtimers that basically said “why would you do such a thing?”and similar. It felt extremely unwelcoming. It’s ok to not answer but why be so dismissive? I guess the only questions they like are things like “how do I calculate 2+2 in python?”. Anything more complicated is not acceptable.
- julianeon 3y agoI think StackOverflow is a good example of a site where cultural norms have become a life-threatening issue. The site has experienced a sharp drop in search traffic and yet people still say it's unfriendly all the time. Fixing that perception should be a top priority.
- josefritz 3y agoI gave up contributing to Wikipedia when I looked back and found how much had been deleted. The deletionists have won the war.
- tptacek 3y agoThat being the literal premise of the project, it's the outcome you'd have expected.
- im3w1l 3y agoAre you saying people aren't allowed to be upset with an action if you announce it beforehand?
- tptacek 3y agoQuestions like these always make me think of Dwight Schrute speeding towards a sales call that Andy Bernard is closing out from under him, screaming into his phone "are you saying you INVENTED PAPER?". I'm not saying I invented paper. You can be upset with anything you like. I'm not the upset police. But if the thing you're upset about (20 years later!) is the premise of the what is probably the single most successful project on the Internet, it's going to be hard to take the concern too seriously.
- Ensorceled 3y agoThere are a LOT of people putting quotes around "toxic" in this thread and a lot of people claiming to not know what a toxic comment is at all. Really hard not to assume bad faith here.
- Levitz 3y agoHard disagree. Toxic itself is a term used precisely because it's nebulous enough. Note it's not "obscene", or "insulting" or "offensive". "Toxic" here serves as a synonym to "bad", which meaning is entirely subjective. This comment of mine might be considered toxic, your comment might too, there is no way to argue otherwise since it entirely depends on the beholder.
- Ensorceled 3y agoToxic in this context means rude, disrespectful and unreasonable. Insulting and offensive are just as subjective as rude or disrespectful. We just have a culture of "sticks and stones" and people who leave toxic conversations are called "snowflakes" and told to "grow thicker skin".
- epgui 3y agoI can say assuredly that toxicity and politicization (IRL, not just on wiki) also makes the vast majority (>99%) of science experts refrain from trying to engage with the public. The experts that do engage tend to be outliers, which sometimes exacerbates the public’s distorted impressions of science questions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tivert 3y agoHere's how they define toxicity (only clearly described in their "Supplementary material"): https://oup.silverchair-cdn.com/oup/backfile/Content_public/Journal/pnasnexus/2/12/10.1093_pnasnexus_pgad385/2/pgad385_supplementary_data.pdf?Expires=1704812853&Signature=UCc7IEiyv61Q1DQkrPch80gTx1udZDflv1XAo3SHNhZ1TBtMuLYKV2JYQgkopGxc6GcFyJ-IQawfGCuGQQfQEl7TMhtr81KHhBxfUN~8Z4PcBl0ZDKHnImUH9NGBV1oxpc6UXHpkwFCtvVRqsI2EtjhFo0rRUmCqHQLCVJuC~YAQuv3nyKB4pHlaKN7YTY85~aUa6K-vT~8JKsrkukcUPyM~Jj0NkbGFelT0tXkDM0mYDYau8i7ar1-mzp8GbVXZqV3z8J2jCuwGzQ0GsuWJ3eQnhPi3l7hYs8ps40mPh8AcsQXMaxt2aoDwJmRS2U6~c5F9nCcngMcwG1-F24d42g__&Key-Pair-Id=APKAIE5G5CRDK6RD3PGA https://oup.silverchair-cdn.com/oup/backfile/Content_public/... Honestly, that's probably the most "measurable" kind of toxicity, but Wikipedia has a much bigger problem with toxicity than that. The whole place is infused with passive-aggression (by policy) and toxic double-standards. IMHO, you have to be deeply weird to be a frequent contributor.
- nomilk 3y ago> Toxicity: A rude, disrespectful, or unreasonable comment that is likely to make people leave a discussion Rude and disrespectful are subjective. As a layperson learning biology for fun (e.g. Bob Sapolsky lectures) I often chuckle at how rude or shocking nature can be! I grimace at how nature videos (e.g. a pride of lions hunting a baby elephant) will garner comments like "you're sick for filming this!" or "do something to help!". Ignaz Semmelweis discovered that microscopic particles (what we now know as bacteria) on the hands and body were causing women and babies to become infected during birth. He was considered a misinformation-spreading pariah for a quarter century until links were made between germs and diseases. But for the 25 years it took the ideas to mature and reach mainstream, he was "toxic".
- projektfu 3y agoI think looking at the examples and their rating of toxicity, there's a difference between a Semmelweis who says, "I think you're killing people with established practice" and a theoretical one who says, "You [expletive] [ethnic slur] ... should be shot like a dog in the street."
- 3y ago
- WesolyKubeczek 3y agoWhen I see this war between petty editors and insolent demanding contributors, I can’t help but sorta cheer to both teams. They are all so right and simultaneously so wrong, and you can see the exact same thing happening on all large online spaces where content is supposed to be curated, that I can’t help but wonder: how is it that the phenomenon hasn’t been researched with hundreds of non-shoddy papers and a dozen of books written? And how come we haven’t moved on from screaming at one another about what the cure should be — “more censorship” or “more empathy”? How far can you dial both before realizing it just plain doesn’t work?
- grammers 3y agoThis is the new cancel culture: Comment away with hate speech (bots) to stop a true and honest discussion. It's too bad the internet is not yet ready for this form of misinformation and destroying real conversations. Now with AI (bots) coming up, it will get even more difficult...
- dv_dt 3y agoI have to think there is a lot of crossover between Wikipedia edit review interactions and code review interactions in terms of what actually brings out better quality outcomes and what make for discouragement of efforts.
- whamlastxmas 3y agoI tried to be an editor for a couple months. I found the experience to be extremely unpleasant because even the best intentioned feedback came across as callous and annoyed and unkind. Softness is not a strong skill amongst Wikipedia editors. That and the shitty bias evident everywhere due to using corporate news as the primary source for anything not involving STEM. Corporate news is wildly biased and it bleeds heavily into Wikipedia. It’s unfortunate that billionaires who own news organizations are literally writing history
- melenaboija 3y agoWikipedia is definitely used in politicized way by the editors. A clear example of my knowledge is how the referendum celebrated in Catalunya (Spain) in 2017 is described in the Catalan and Spanish versions, for some topics they seem to be talking about different events. Anyone can use an english translator and check it out. Just in the first three lines the Spanish version uses the word "ilegal" and the Catalan does not, it might seem subtle but this subtlety has had huge implications in Spnish politics: https://ca.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refer%C3%A8ndum_sobre_la_independ%C3%A8ncia_de_Catalunya_de_2017 https://ca.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refer%C3%A8ndum_sobre_la_indep... https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refer%C3%A9ndum_de_independencia_de_Catalu%C3%B1a_de_2017 https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refer%C3%A9ndum_de_independenc...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sproketboy 3y ago[dead]
- dom96 3y agoWow, this is a great study and I bet it extends to other volunteer-based activities. In particular: open source software projects. It seems obvious that toxicity needs to be rooted out of open source communities, and any projects that don't do so or ignore the issue will fail to keep their contributors. But it's nice to have some real studies on this with some objective results (even if not strictly for open source software project contributions).
- Kevin09210 3y agoYou need to get rid of codebase ownership and find something else to replace the trust it brings. - Fine granularity forkability. Fork functions, not just projects - Curators/Reviewers who endorse the validity/security aspects of those forks.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>Fork functions, not just projects I'm not dismissing your idea, but I'm not finding the value in this compared to copy-pasting that function.It'd also be beholden to all kinds of dependency checking to be practical unless it was a tiny function. But i can see the benefits of granular ownership. You don't necessarily want to fork off a whole new repo just to have a contributor be responsible for a module but not the entire project.
- ceving 3y agoThere is too much politically motivated agitation on Wikipedia. This is particularly a problem because Wikipedia's power apparatus is completely undemocratic and anonymous. Wikipedia's organizational structure corresponds to a medieval feudal system.
- Scea91 3y agoFeudal system? I didn’t know my oldest son will inherit my Wikipedia pages and live from the rent paid by the editors.
- t0bia_s 3y agoIt's impossible to have centralized "democratic" interpretation of information. You need vote system and constant revision of text. Even though I think it's not possible to have universal interpretation of information. Point of view vary with many aspects including politics, religion, regime, actual available knowledge...
- iamthirsty 3y agoI think since the paper is littered with the term "toxic", it clearly has its own point of view — that is, not as objective as one would like in this kind of study.
- csours 3y agoYou're being sprayed with weed killer (metaphorically). The problem is, you have step into a conflict area without realizing it. The moderators spray the whole area with weed killer because there really are weeds. It's too much work to pull the weeds individually, so it all gets hosed down.
- youcantcook 3y ago[dead]
- alboaie 3y agoAfter an editor, who has edited millions of pages and seems to be a jack-of-all-trades, unjustifiably rejects your contribution on a topic where you have dozens of scientific articles published, the only conclusion is that the system is flawed. There's a need for a fundamental change in approach, probably to a system where censorship exists only in cases of clearly illegal content, and various opinions are allowed to be expressed. On the other hand, to filter out the noise, there's a need for a trust propagation system among editors and viewers, so that each time, you get the most probable form of a page based on the trust given to direct contacts and indirectly to recursive contacts. Maybe AI could also help a bit. Who dare to start a new Wikipedia ;) ?
- pndy 3y ago> the only conclusion is that the system is flawed. There's a need for a fundamental change in approach There are attempts of creating more "professional" electronic encyclopedia like Citizendium [1] and Scholarpedia [2] but it seems that such tasks are rather hard since Wikipedia solidified its position already, despite flaws [1] - https://en.citizendium.org/ https://en.citizendium.org/ [2] - http://www.scholarpedia.org/ http://www.scholarpedia.org/
- alexey-salmin 3y ago> Who dare to start a new Wikipedia ;) That literally happened hundreds of times and every single one of them is dead. Whatever is it what Wikipedia is doing, it seems to be working far better then alternatives.
- cooper_ganglia 3y ago[flagged]
- adastra22 3y agoFYI community notes predates Elon.
- tptacek 3y agoFrom bitter experience: if you have well established subject matter expertise on a topic, you should almost certainly not be writing Wikipedia articles about it. In Wikipedia's framing, you are a generator of primary and secondary sources. Wikipedia is a tertiary source: it is exclusively a roadmap to other, more authoritative sources. Instead of writing Wikipedia articles, write the articles Wikipedia will end up drawing from. It's quite painful to directly edit Wikipedia articles on your own areas of expertise. You have context lay readers don't have, and you'll often leave things implicit or skip steps, because you know that laying those steps out and citing every detail of them isn't helpful for learning & understanding. But the encyclopedia doesn't work that way: the community there can't tell the difference between sensible elisions done in the spirit of efficient explanation, and original research that simply takes an opinion you hold idiosyncratically or fractiously and mints an encyclopedia article out of them. It's also going to be deeply suspicious, for very good reasons that don't apply to you but do apply to like 70% of all other cases, any time you write something and cite yourself. It is also just the case that not everyone should commit themselves to writing whole Wikipedia articles. I found the process pretty unhealthy; it sucked me in, to be sure, but it also filled my time with rules lawyering and squabbles. It'd be easy to criticize Wikipedia for having that culture, except that the project is so spectacularly successful.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eterevsky 3y agoAn obvious alternative explanation would be that pages on controversial topics both attract toxic comments and are more difficult to edit. I am not sure whether this paper controlled for this.
- intended 3y agoSince the discussions seems to be focusing entirely on the headline “Toxicyity” They are using Perspective, you can find more here: https://github.com/conversationai/perspectiveapi https://github.com/conversationai/perspectiveapi
- miroljub 3y agoWikipedia has grown to be a PR outlet. It's overwhelmed by different interest groups pushing their own agenda or doing PR. Especially smaller Wikipedias, like for example German, are known for defamation campaigns against “unpopular” authors and topics. And before someone cries "citation needed" I'll add just one link to satisfy the requirements: https://swprs.org/wikipedia-and-propaganda/ https://swprs.org/wikipedia-and-propaganda/ Though the source, although worth reading and providing a valid criticism, may not be good enough, since Wikipedia, the main source of truth on Internets, marks it as a misinformation website.
- hanniabu 3y agoThis is the same reason i've stopped answering and asking questions on stack overview, except the toxic culture is coming from the moderators.
- commandlinefan 3y ago> the toxic culture is coming from the moderators And the moderators are given free reign to behave that way _because_ of so-called "toxic behavior" from the users.
- skymast 3y ago[dead]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoSemi-tangent: With Wikipedia being one of the last great resources (imo), it's interesting to see the amount of hate and negativity sent their way.
- exo-pla-net 3y ago[flagged]
- mikeyouse 3y agoWhat is it about this topic that drives people absolutely crazy? Far less than 1% of people ID as trans yet it's just the most important cultural shibboleth and just mentioned / argued about constantly... why do you care at all how Wikipedia phrases the opening paragraph on their page about Trans women?
- fffs 3y agoIt's because this is a fundamental redefinition of the difference between women and men, one which seriously disadvantages women. When this ideological stance of "trans women are women" is enacted into law and imposed as policy, it has the effect of eradicating female-only spaces, forcing women to accept any man who purports to be a woman in these spaces. This is good enough reason to oppose it.
- anoxor 3y agoThere were women's spaces (bathrooms / changing rooms) for example that kept women safe from predatory men. Who should be allowed in those? Is it defined by the clothes? If a predatory man / bad actor decides to put on those clothes to abuse the system, then what? What if the predatory man / bad actor decides to hang just below the bar of illegality, and creep on women long term?
- mikeyouse 3y agoIs this something that you spent a lot of time worrying about prior to this bizarre trans panic? All of the existing laws that prevent predatory men from creeping on women in those spaces also apply to trans people..
- anoxor 3y agoTrans panic? Totally disagree, it’s now entirely legal in many places for a predatory man to say he identifies as a woman, and change in spaces previously created to keep women safe. And yes, thanks, I do like thinking about issues of justice, morality, and politics. https://www.economist.com/united-states/2021/01/30/putting-trans-women-in-female-prisons-sets-up-a-clash-of-rights https://www.economist.com/united-states/2021/01/30/putting-t... Excellent example. Is it possible for a convicted criminal to game compassion to be moved from a men’s to women’s prison. Would anyone lie in that situation? There is probably a whole lot more people to take advantage of if your a convicted predator in a woman’s prison.
- incomingpain 3y agoI would agree with the premise that there's reduced number of editors. I would agree wikipedia should try to figure out why. It's not immediately obvious to me, from OP, who are leaving but I have a pretty strong understanding who. It's also quite impossible to survey the people who left. When you survey those who remain, you're getting the complete incorrect cohort. >automated toxicity detection They never really define what is a toxic comment. Their sources seem to suggest the gender gap, task related disagreements, harassment survey from 2015, and something about arabic wikipedia. All the while there are clear rules against things like personal attacks. So you have to kind of find rather subjective examples and you somehow automated it? That seems frought with inaccuracy. Yet they seem to find some correlation? Oh wait they don't provide those numbers. I bet it's pretty bad for them to hide them. Perhaps it's my mistake and I failed to find them. >voluntary opt-in survey of the 3,845 Wikipedians conducted in 2015 All data prior to the actual problem occuring will be a red herring at best. Again, wrong cohort. This is like surveying non-cancer patients and making conclusions about cancer patients. >The automatic detection of offensive language in online communities has been an active area of research since at least 2010 Offensiveness is subjective and clearly 2010 is too early of data. What I see from this study, is cherry picked data from at least ~7 years ago. Why are they even doing this? Are they trying their best to find an explanation while being intentionally blind to the problem? I'll just throw down. How about the better explanation? Wikipedia became biased and can't really be trusted anymore? Why contribute to something because has become a political tool? I could point at John Stossel's work on showing wikipedia's bias. I could offer wikipedia cofounder Larry Sanger's blog on wikipedia's bias. There has even been countless live examples where influencers modify wikipedia for greater truth. Provable on live video that the facts were incorrect. They then edit wikipedia and then it's near instantly reversed. How about wikipedia's own curated 'reliable sources' which reads like a they only accept sources with only 1 type source; a particular establishment left wing viewpoint. https://www.wired.com/story/why-wikipedia-decided-to-stop-calling-fox-a-reliable-source/ https://www.wired.com/story/why-wikipedia-decided-to-stop-ca... Whether or not fox news is reliable, it's not, it was practically the only source from a differing viewpoint. They purged all the rest. Why is the reduced numbers of editors? People left wikipedia because it's not reliable and trustworthy anymore. People aren't leaving because someone on the internet hurt their feelings. Wikipedia is absolutely free to continue in this path, but they will be in decline for doing so.
- 6510 3y agoPersonally I have no problem working with toxic people. Toxic people talking nonsense I cant deal with. You do have to have a f**g point if you are going to be toxic and you need to demonstrate by example how you think things should be done.
- egberts1 3y agoYea, during the dark ages of toxic Wikipedia editors, I had ample of citations to split apart "Deaf" (ethnocentric label) from "Deafness" (culture) and "Hearing-Loss" (medical) not to mention the toxic ableism of "Hearing Impaired" (former medical), it was nothing but a browbeating, deletion of my Wiki drafts, and reversion of my hard and diligent efforts. About 20 years later, some 240 Deaf wikipedia editors finally led a revolt: first to fall is "hearing impaired" (ablist slang), of which many governments/civic/businesses are now moving away from. We are almost there.
- zlg_codes 3y agoI think everyone has the capacity to be toxic, but few things elevate my willingness to be toxic than having my well-reasoned contributions insulted or rejected. I've contributed a total of once, ever, on Wikipedia. It was a typo correction that was reverted, then remade under the mod's account so he got credit for it. If that's what I can expect by interacting with Wikipedia, I'll pass. You have to actually reward participation if you want it.