3 ms·
maybe conversational Japanese lets more go unspoken. From the little Japanese I speak I've found that this is indeed the case. Japanese speakers will happily
by Symmetry 15y ago
maybe conversational Japanese lets more go unspoken.
From the little Japanese I speak I've found that this is indeed the case. Japanese speakers will happily leave out subject, topic, or object of a sentence when it can be inferred from context.
- rollypolly 15y agoInferring from context.. like many programming languages. Is there a programming language you would say most resembles Japanese in spirit?
- Danieru 15y agoNo, its more like a unified diff.
- Locke1689 15y agoWhere did you get this idea? Programming languages infer almost nothing from context. Moreover, when they do that's often seen as bad because it usually creates ambiguous semantic or syntactic constructs. Good programming languages are often based off of a formal language[1]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formal_language http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formal_language
- corysama 15y agoBasic Japanese always struck me as having special purpose registers and a postfix notation. The basic sentence structure is "noun wa noun da verb." where wa is the "set the subject" operator and da is "set the direct object" operator then stating a verb sets the verb register to complete the statement. Once a register is set, you are able to omit it from later sentences until you want to change its value. "noun wa noun da verb. noun da verb." would indicate that the same subject is doing two different things to two different objects. More operators: http://fm1397.com/knowledge/chalkboard/chalkboard-session-5-wadakano-explained/ http://fm1397.com/knowledge/chalkboard/chalkboard-session-5-...
- evincarofautumn 15y agoIt’s not nearly that simple, formal, or programmatic. First, は wa is a topic marker, not a subject marker; the topic need not be the grammatical subject of a sentence, and indeed is often included for emphasis alone. There is a subject marker が ga, but it’s primarily used to introduce new information (“ペンがある。” pen ga aru “There is a pen.”) without changing the topic. だ da or the formal です desu is known as a copula, standing for an assumed verb. This is often is, but not always (“飲み物は?ソーダです。” nomimono wa? sooda desu “What would you like to drink? I’ll have a soda.”). だ is not a direct object marker—you might be thinking of を wo. Of course, it’s a perfectly reasonable idea to borrow topic-structured statements for a programming language. Just assume the topic wherever a required term is missing: = new Window .width = 640 .height = 480 w = = new Button .label = "Hello" .align = CENTER w.add() It comes with a host of problems, but it’s reasonable. And you might want to have a look at Forth-family languages if you’re into postfix notation and pointfree/tacit programming.
- gommm 15y agoExactly, the less formal the japanese is, the more unspoken words are left to be guessed by the context... Another interesting thing about japanese is that because of the lower number of different syllables it's easier to understand in situations when it's not possible hear clearly (like on mobile phones when the reception is not good). I've remarked on it when living there and had a researcher working in the field confirm me that it was the case (not to sure of the details but that was during a discussion on voice compression).
- Tipzntrix 15y agoMaybe this explains why Hatsune Miku can perform live shows for millions around the world while people still have trouble taking Microsoft Sam and Anna seriously.
- lmm 15y agoI suspect that's more about Japanese celebrity dynamics; consider Naomi Campbell's famous statement on her album sales.
- YmMot 15y ago> the lower number of different syllables I have a theory that this is why the Japanese are so (seemingly) fond of portmanteaus. It makes it easier to smoosh words together.
- mc32 15y agoSounds a bit like mafiosi conversations where it's mostly context with a few details in order to avoid being overt about what they're discussing. Albeit without the use of codeword substitutes.
- TazeTSchnitzel 15y agoYeah, since it isn't very reliant on word order for denoting function of words in a sentence and instead using markers, practically anything unnecessary can be omitted.