3 ms·
I can help track down distant family members who have committed crimes? Sounds like a plus. I think the angst about this comes from men who don't want their s
by pfdietz 3y ago
I can help track down distant family members who have committed crimes? Sounds like a plus.
I think the angst about this comes from men who don't want their status as fathers of illegitimate children (or, rapists when they were younger) unmasked.
- Majestic121 3y agoWhy do you make this issue gendered, and if you do why would it impact only men father of illegitimate children, and not cheating mothers ?
- pfdietz 3y agoThe mother will already be connected to the child. The father is what would be needing tracking down. I mean, wasn't that completely obvious?
- watwut 3y agoCause in the case of cheating mother, it is clear she is the mother. And to confirm fatherhood of husband or partner, no external registry is needed or helpful.
- mschuster91 3y ago> I can help track down distant family members who have committed crimes? Sounds like a plus. It's no longer so easy when the definition of "crime" gets expanded. Let's take this scenario: - you're a first generation Chinese immigrant in the US - a nephew of yours is in China and critical of the CCP - you decide to have your genome scanned into 23andme or whatever to determine if you are at risk of genetic illness - your nephew sprays an anti-CCP tag on a wall somewhere - the Chinese police gathers DNA evidence from a laxly discarded spray can, but doesn't have fingerprints so they can't immediately link the can to your nephew - the Chinese government, either via a legal subpoena or via espionage, gets its hands on your genetic profile from the genetic analytics company - the Chinese government finds your data, now knows that the sprayer must be related to you in some way, and forces everyone of your family to subject to a DNA test Sounds dystopic? Yes. But this is exactly where we will be headed. Police here in Germany already do DNA tests on petty vandalism [1]. [1] https://www.fuldaerzeitung.de/fulda/fulda-bahnhof-neuhof-dna-analyse-ueberfuehrt-taeter-polizei-strafverfahren-91257652.html https://www.fuldaerzeitung.de/fulda/fulda-bahnhof-neuhof-dna...
- pfdietz 3y agoIt's precious that you imagine not getting your DNA sequenced will provide any sort of shield against dystopian governments. This sort of thing looks more like a psychological crutch than an actual effective action.
- dylan604 3y agoThat’s not what the comment was driving at. At all. It’s about how data you think is innocent can be used in a manner you never thought about nor intended for dark purposes.
- pfdietz 3y agoFair. On the other hand, I'm a bit surprised that anti-immigrant forces in the US haven't made DNA sampling compulsory for new immigrants. The argument would be these would be harder to track down by these techniques, because the ancestry information is not as available, giving them an "unfair" advantage over white Americans.
- junofan 3y agoI don’t think that fits with how people on this side of the pond think about immigration.
- dylan604 3y agoIt fits with how some people think about immigration on either side of the pond. That some is close to 50% on the western side of the pond.
- kasey_junk 3y agoThe US does do DNA collection for anyone it detains whether they end up being granted legal status or not. They were processing so much DNA that they had to write a special rule allowing border agents to _not_ collect it if it would cause operational difficulties to do so. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/03/09/2020-04256/dna-sample-collection-from-immigration-detainees https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/03/09/2020-04...
- pavel_lishin 3y agoYour father submits his DNA to 23 and Me. One of your brothers committed a crime. The police, during an investigation, find your father's data and realize that one of his children is the criminal. Congratulations! You are now the target of an investigation, the purpose of which may not be to find the truth, but to successfully convict a suspect.
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago> You are now the target of an investigation All you have to do to clear your name for that crime is to turn over your DNA to the police to be in their records forever[1], and Bob's [2] your brother [3]. [1] - You might be able to get a court to order that your DNA records are destroyed after proving your innocence, but it's an ask to believe this would actually happen in every case. [2] - https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/bob https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/bob bob 3 of 7 verb (2) bobbed; bobbing transitive verb 1) obsolete : deceive, cheat 2) obsolete : to take by fraud : filch [3] - https://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/bobs-your-uncle.html https://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/bobs-your-uncle.html