3 ms·
>she has trouble controlling her own students because I believe they themselves have realized she's inconsistent and illogical, so anything goes. They do someth
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
>she has trouble controlling her own students because I believe they themselves have realized she's inconsistent and illogical, so anything goes. They do something, she says something they don't respect, they continue, she gives up
This really shouldn't be surprising to anyone. Even 2 year old children can understand authority, power dynamics, and contests of will. For that matter, a 6 month old puppy will understand the same.
I pretty strongly disagree with the rest of what you said about state curriculum.
- talldatethrow 3y agoWhat part? That it exists as stated? Or do you believe that every single teacher in California should be deciding how to teach what verbs are, or how dividing works, in their own way however they choose? Is that really better than finding the best explanation, worksheets, and using that? Because right now there's a classroom in California being taught the worst possible way how to divide, out of all the other classrooms in California. Why? Because why not, freedom!
- s1artibartfast 3y agoFirst, I object to the idea Every teacher gets to decide what they teach. There is a very prescriptive list of what the curriculum must contain, and it is assessed by standardize tests. Second, teachers aren't fungible robots. They are humans with personalities, interests, and passions. Education works best when teachers are engaged. I think you underestimate the value provided by flexibility. you might be able to reduce variation through standardization, but that doesnt mean you improve the mean. My very best teachers went off script, teaching more valuable information, like a 5th grade teacher that decided to teach business, html, and the scientific method. Last, it isn't exactly anarchy. Many subjects can be taught from texts, which are organized along standardized approaches.
- tick_tock_tick 3y ago3/4 of teacher believe in "learning styles" which we figured out was bunk science pretty much the instant it came out. It sucks that we'll probably crush the great teacher but forcing so much standardization but the simple fact is most teachers can't be trusted to actually make good decisions or teach well.
- hutzlibu 3y ago"the simple fact is most teachers can't be trusted to actually make good decisions or teach well" Another simple fact is, that despite all that effort and forced curriculum and years of attending - most people don't understand even basic science. So I question, that the current system is working efficiently at all.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThe question then is if you expect better outcomes from the same teachers you dont trust, who cant teach, and make bad decisions if you provide them a script they hate. Do you expect better outcomes if they quit and you replace them with training videos? Call me a skeptic, but I dont think standard lesson plans will move the needle for a shitty teacher that doesn't give a shit. They probably wont even engage with that standard lesson plan.
- tick_tock_tick 3y ago> The question then is if you expect better outcomes from the same teachers you dont trust, who cant teach, and make bad decisions if you provide them a script they hate. Yes > Do you expect better outcomes if they quit and you replace them with training videos? You still need someone to enforce the kids are actually doing what they've been instructed to but yes I'd expect an equal or better outcome.
- MikeTheGreat 3y agoIt's worth pointing out that different students are different people; each person has their unique background and knowledge when they first arrive in a classroom. If you've got a student who's struggling with < versus > they're going to have a real hard time with further math if you don't provide some support for them (and even then they'll still have a hard time, you'll just be helping them - it'll be similar to someone spotting you while you do bench presses near the limit of what you can handle). There is no "best explanation, best worksheet" any more than there's a "best shoe size, best cut/style of pants". Hire good teachers who care about their students, and let them figure out how to best address the needs of their students in that particular classroom.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- beaeglebeach 3y agoChildren are often hardest on their own caregivers though, so the more you look like a parent figure the more they rebel. Of course nowadays corporal punishment is 'child abuse' so the child is emboldened knowing they can do whatever they like, including violence, with absolute impunity from physical pain.
- dxbydt 3y ago> Children are often hardest on their own caregivers Hear hear! If your kids turn out good, they'll say you are lucky.If they don't, they'll say you messed up as a parent. Either way, the parent never gets any credit.
- bcrosby95 3y agoReality is a mixed bag. There's lots of things about a kid that is very difficult to change. We've done a lot in the past to try to discourage certain bad behaviors once they developed but what mostly happened was they eventually grew out of it thanks to no particular tactic we employed. So I mostly just try to model the behavior I want to see.
- jmcqk6 3y agocorporal punishment is child abuse. It does not mean children can do whatever they like. You might find it difficult to find alternatives, but better alternatives than violence exists. Save your children the costs of therapy as adults, and focus on real emotional health.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tiahura 3y agoIs there a mammal that doesn’t utilize corporal punishment to set boundaries? Does every dog / chimp / giraffe that got nipped by mom for being a brat need therapy?