9 ms·
A calculator that only shows the answer after you give a suitable estimate
- jdwhit2 15y agoThe tolerance - how far out one may be for the estimate to be accepted and the answer shown - must at all times appear reasonable ... The student should never feel that an estimate was unreasonably rejected, and on the other hand should not find an odd guess being accepted The inventor had considered this question for 14 years while developing this calculator.
- ColinWright 15y agoAnd now with linefeeds: The tolerance - how far out one may be for the estimate to be accepted and the answer shown - must at all times appear reasonable... The student should never feel that an estimate was unreasonably rejected, and on the other hand should not find an odd guess being accepted.
- sp332 15y agoOr with automatic line breaks: The tolerance - how far out one may be for the estimate to be accepted and the answer shown - must at all times appear reasonable ... The student should never feel that an estimate was unreasonably rejected, and on the other hand should not find an odd guess being accepted.
- unwind 15y agoI feel somewhat silly after seeing the landing page, and realizing it's about a new physical pocket calculator (a product category I didn't think received all that much attention), I still clicked the calculator in the image, thinking it might have a web simulator. Which it doesn't, and then I thought "meh". It's truly easy to be spoilt by this clicky-shiny web thing.
- jyothi 15y agoand they have a patent for this one http://www.google.com/patents/US6820800 http://www.google.com/patents/US6820800 An electronic calculator having means for enabling a user to input a calculation, characterized in that the calculator has a mode of operation in which the user is required to input additionally at least one estimate of the result of the calculation before the correct result of the calculation is displayed.
- bluecalm 15y agoHas it any chance of standing in court ? I mean it's as close to patent for idea as it gets. I hope there will be movement of not buying things manufactured by companies filling silly patents. I feel it's my duty to ignore this company after reading it.
- georgieporgie 15y agoThe patents I find offensive are the ones held by companies that aren't producing any products, much less a product similar to what's described in a given patent.
- MartinCron 15y agoI mean it's as close to patent for idea as it gets. Patents are intended to be for inventions, and this feels like it qualifies.
- chc 15y agoNo, this is pretty far from a patent for a general idea. I mean, how much more specifically do you think they could describe the method, and would it really add anything in your estimation?
- gaius 15y agoI feel it's my duty to ignore this company after reading it That's nice, but you haven't any understanding of what a patent actually is. It is not an idea, any more than the title of a book is a story. It is an implementation. In the case of Qama, the clever bit is scaling the estimation tolerance with the difficulty of the calculation. It seems that maths isn't the only area that needs education.
- sharjeel 15y agoTLDR: Requires guess before it answers ... Revolutionary ... US Patent 6820800
- tmh88j 15y agoDoes the patent cover the concept or the hardware/software?....or both?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mattsouth 15y agoI think this is an excellent idea. Calculators were just being brought into the school curriculum when I was 8 years old (to some controversy at the time!) and we were told always to use the the three E's: estimate, evaluate, evaluate. The idea being that first you guess roughly what the answer should be and then after calculating it, you check it again to make sure you havent made a keying mistake. I've always thought this a lesson well taught that I've applied to many automation tasks since.
- bostonvaulter2 15y agoI half expected this to be a kickstarter project. I wonder if they've done any studies on this calculator.
- gouranga 15y agoJust what you need - a smug, obstructive calculator.
- ColinWright 15y agoFor students who are learning, perhaps this is what they need. What they don't need to to be given answers to everything on a plate without having to work at all. We all know that skills unpractised are skills lost. You need to work continually and constantly on skills to keep them honed, and you need to work hard to gain new skills. Clearly this calculator isn't suitable for every context, but neither is Python, C++, Haskell or Lisp. (Well, except for Lisp. We all know that's useful in every context. 8-)
- StavrosK 15y ago> We all know that skills unpractised are skills lost. We also know that skills unused are skills unpractised. I don't know how useful keeping up with my handwriting is, for example, I haven't done it in about ten years.
- gus_massa 15y agoWould you want to use a computer language that only gives the answer (of a numeric integral or the number of registered users) after you give a suitable estimate? The problem is that this is a tool that an author designed for another people to use. There is an essay from pg that says that the good languages are designed by the authors for themselves, but I can't find the link. The same idea applies to the other tools. I'm teaching elementary calculus and linear algebra in the university, and I think that it is very important that the students get a general idea of what they are doing. (For example: The integral from 0 to 1 of e^-x is less than 1, because the area is inside a 1x1 square. If a linear equation system includes x+y+z=1000 and each variable is positive, then x=2117 is not a good answer) But an annoying tool is not the answer to this problem.
- ColinWright 15y agoThis may surprise you, but I never use the results of a computation without first estimating what the answer should be, estimating the errors in that estimation, and having some alternative ways of deciding how accurate the calculation is. Of course, I do work in safety critical application. But I also deal with students, and constantly, constantly struggle against their willingness to accept just any old number simply because it came from a calculator, a program, a newspaper, or wikipedia. Recently a colleague recounted how a student had been doing some work and had come up with a result. When asked "How accurate is this?" the student clearly just didn't understand the question, let alone have a clue how to answer it. There is no single solution, there is no single way to make the lazy work harder, there is no single tool that will solve all the problems that exist in education as a whole. But having a collection of tools, a collection of techniques, and a collection of approaches has to be a good thing.
- tzury 15y agoBTW, "Qama" in Hebrew means "How much" or "How many"
- pithon 15y agoI'd be there all day trying to estimate roots in my head, depending on the accuracy they'll accept for the estimate. I think this is a great idea, though - too many times I've caught an in put error simply because the answer was an order of magnitude or two off - or I had forgotten to convert units.
- nothis 15y ago>With QAMA as the student's regular calculator and used exclusively, calculations can no longer be performed without involving the head and the proper comprehension of the ingredients. As expected, its effects on performance and, more importantly - understanding, are phenomenal. Yea... fuck you.
- NeilCJames 15y agoReminds me of Louis Benezet's experimental elementary math education system (ca. 1930s), and Sanjoy Mahajan's Street Fighting Mathematics. What a clever idea.
- tagawa 15y agoJust wondering... If you had a software calculator such that after you typed in the question, the calculator returned, say, four possible answers, you chose one, and the calculator confirmed or corrected you, would that infringe on this patent? You're not actually inputting a calculation directly so I believe not, but I know nothing about law. Maybe I should just build one and wait for the knock.
- Udo 15y agoI can't believe someone was so proud of this idea they patented it. Then came the second WTF: it's actually a physical calculator (and an early-nineties model at that). If anything, this idea would have been neat as an app. And you shouldn't have to guess the "right-ish" answer by some margin, instead make it a social game where you get points for getting as close to the correct answer as possible. Enter your estimate, instantly get the correct solution and your points. That could be fun in classrooms.
- neonkiwi 15y agoThe physical calculator allows students to use this calculator in the classroom. If a student was using a smartphone on a test, how does the teacher know at cheating is not going on? That said, this calculator does allow a no-estimation-necessary mode, but entering that mode causes some LEDs along the top to blink. If the student thinks he or she can get away with it while the teacher is looking away, those LEDs actually keep flashing for a while after switching back to estimate-first mode. I think it's a good idea! The calculator's ease of use is stopping people from thinking about what a correct answer should look like.
- blahedo 15y agoI love the idea, although I think a lot of the comments here are missing the point---this is not about what you might be using, now, but rather what might be useful in a classroom situation. The giveaway is that if you turn off estimate mode, a flashing light comes on... so an instructor or test proctor would be able to see it. This is exactly the sort of practice a lot of students need. But then they lose me a bit when they say (on the scope/content page) that they don't accept rational-number estimates because there's no point. I'll tentatively agree (with reservations) for numbers greater than one, but decimal numbers are just a subset of fractions, and there are a lot of problems where an answer like "1/20" is a lot more natural than "0.05" or "5E-2".
- drostie 15y agoWell if it's not about what we are using now but what will teach a kid to know roughly how big some numbers are, we could always ban calculators in favor of slide rules. What I mean, I guess, is that calculators are by their nature supposed to eschew estimation for the sake of simplicity. Porting estimation back into them seems like a mistake.
- wildtype 15y agoIf we can get the estimation of answer, then we can answer it. Calculator are in math when i was on highschool.
- derleth 15y ago> decimal numbers are just a subset of fractions If you're talking about general decimal numbers, this is provably false. Pi, for example, cannot be written as a fraction. If you're talking about floating-point numbers on a piece of finite hardware, they can all be written as fractions, and, depending on whether you use multiple-precision math, you might be able to represent all the fractions your computer can work with as decimal numbers.
- jeffcutsinger 15y ago> Pi, for example, cannot be written as a fraction. Pi cannot be written as a decimal either. Decimals _are_ a subset of the rationals. Any rational whose denominator has a prime factor other than 2 or 5 cannot be written using decimals.
- ArekDymalski 15y agoLooks like MVP to me. But anyway funny concept.
- shock3naw 15y ago3rd year university student's opinion: The first problem to be solved is that most introductory math education is still about calculating and not about applying mathematical principles to real problems. I think that being able to estimate a solution is a valuable skill, but for many problems with a high degree of precision (lots of decimal places) or large numbers, this just becomes problematic. I'll definitely admit that at the end of a string of transformations of complex numbers, integrations, and other things, the last thing on my mind is guessing whether my solution is close. Understanding all the steps that lead up to that point is more crucial (and worth more marks!). The only thing I worry about is whether I typed the equation into the calculator correctly to get my final result. That being said, when students are first learning about a new 'operator', like when learning division, multiplication, logarithms, and exponents, this could be a useful tool for enhancing a student's intuition about how that operator works. But after that, I'll stick with a normal calculator.
- T_S_ 15y agoWhy won't it accept my prior distribution? Sheesh.
- fonzie 15y agoI actually think this is pretty great. I like the idea that I try things my head to at least figure out if I'm in the right ballpark and, as a physics major, in the correct order of magnitude and understand underlying concepts. I also see this being really useful at getting better at stuff like dimensional analysis.
- its_so_on 15y agoThis is hilarious. I can imagine a snarky scale from where you're exactly right, almost exactly right... "Hey, what do you need me for! That's the answer." "Glad I'm here. You're off by more than 10%" "This is not even the right order of magnitude" "You don't even have the sign right!" "um, what? This is...not even wrong..."
- twomills 15y agoPresumably, the intended usage scenario is when the student does not have access to the answer of the problem from a different source, like the back of the book. In that case, I would submit that being given the correct answer to a calculation helps the student FAR more than being forced to estimate it. Suppose you are studying math, and come upon a question to which you don't know the answer. Which better helps you to understand, starting from "I need to figure out how to do this" or "I need to figure out why the answer is 0.0001."? Further, this has little to no application in the real world classroom. For tests in which calculators would simply give the student the answer, students are simply not allowed to use calculators at all. I would argue that, in an exam environment, there is effectively no margin between "a normal calculator would be cheating so you have to use paper" and "this has multiple steps such that a simple calculator will not give you the right answer without understanding." In light of the existence of pen and paper, and simple 8-digit calculators, this product addresses a problem that simply doesn't exist.