4 ms·
> you supply it with the intentionally current-carrying wires and the ground Whether you connect both grounds to both themselves and Earth, or just connect bot
by marcosdumay 3y ago
> you supply it with the intentionally current-carrying wires and the ground
Whether you connect both grounds to both themselves and Earth, or just connect both grounds to Earth, or connect them to Earth once and connect them both depends on so many details, it's not funny.
What is certain is that you don't want something that doubles as a lightning rod protected on the same internal circuit as your house. So your rationale doesn't apply to the GP.
But anyway, every time somebody talks about electrical installations on the internet, somebody says some version of "If there is a fault from a hot wire to a grounded object, this (if done correctly) allows the upstream overcurrent protection to trip." Is it still a recommended practice on the US to rely on overcurrent protection to protect against current leakage? It's an horrible practice, as it requires several amperes of leakage before triggering.
- jacquesm 3y agoIndeed. We had proper ground fault protection breaks for that purpose, and it was really hard to get them. That + the use of metal tubing to carry electrical power as well as the incredibly flimsy construction of various sockets and such (as well as the high amperage) translates into lots of preventable fires each year in the USA and Canada. Point a FLIR at your average distribution panel and try not to be amazed at the number of hot spots. My biggest gripe: I don't mind inspectors, I just expect them to be really knowledgeable, not just theoretical. Grounding a structure is inherently different from grounding a circuit. He basically kept on insisting that the windmill is part of the circuit and should be bonded rather than that it had its own ground and that is just patent nonsense, more so because the windmill produced variable frequency AC that first had to be rectified, passed through a battery charger, a bunch of batteries and an inverter. The latter of course was bonded to the house ground.
- amluto 3y agoWhat’s wrong with metal tubing indoors? Outside is another matter. Those galvanized steel tubes don’t last very long underground, and the results are terrifying. And nothing in the code requires ground fault protection upstream of a 120V circuit running through a corroded steel tube underground.
- marcosdumay 3y agoThey conduct electricity. Thus if you have a leak from one conductor somewhere in your house (that without ground fault protection goes undetected almost every case) and gets a different one from a different wire, you now have a constant-on heater passing through God knows where, ready to start fires. A single leak also gives you a minor risk of electrocution. But the fire hazard is the important one.
- amluto 3y agoThis is possible with nonmetallic conduit, too, as well as with NM-B. At least metallic conduit has a decent chance of containing the resulting mess inside the conduit. The right solution is ground and arc fault protection, both of which are available, and one of which is increasingly required in the US.
- marcosdumay 3y agoYou seem to be thinking about short circuits. That's not what my post is about. (Anyway, plastic conduits are quite capable of containing the mess.) And yes, they are way less dangerous if you have ground fault protection. To the point that I'm not sure it's still important to ban them. But they don't have any upside either.
- amluto 3y agoI think metal conduits are most useful in more industrial-ish spaces where they're exposed -- they're quite resistant to getting banged up. Schedule 80 PVC works, too, but it's harder to work with than steel (at least for an electrician with the right tools).
- marcosdumay 3y agoIndeed, they are useful for exposed installations.
- amluto 3y ago> Is it still a recommended practice on the US to rely on overcurrent protection to protect against current leakage? It's an horrible practice, as it requires several amperes of leakage before triggering. Yes. I don’t agree with it, personally — I think that there should be standard ground fault trip curves that are functions of circuit breaker rating such that they coordinate properly, and that they should be used at least on all circuits that extend outside of a building and really on most circuits, period. This would add costs, and it would detect and thus prevent a lot of dubious wiring practices and outright errors. But you should still bond all your “ground wires” together so that even if these breakers fail to trip you have a degree of protection. (And breakers do fail.) Under current NEC (the US code), when you supply a building with a feeder (i.e. from another building or similar structure), you must provide it with all the current carrying wires and separate ground, and you must ground it to the Earth. In any case, if you live in a place where your utility supplies power above ground, and a utility pole or line is hit by lightning, its ground is most certainly solidly connected to your house. So you can’t really pretend that your house’s ground is connected only to the Earth near your house and that it won’t let lightning in. Hmm, I wonder if you can take the ground wire running between two buildings and carefully insulate it and give it a wrap or three around a piece of steel to add some inductance and reduce lightning currents that might otherwise go through it. I’m not saying this is wise…