10 ms·
Why do everyone's logo fonts look the same? (2020)
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoI love that I can't tell if the Adobe sponsored content a couple of paragraphs in is an exhibit, or just coincidence, because it's a perfect example of the phenomenon.
- taspeotis 3y ago[flagged]
- MaxBarraclough 3y agoPlease don't post only a link with no context or commentary. HackerNews reliably downvotes this.
- Unfrozen0688 3y agoThe before after on the luxury brands is baffeling. Serif the old looks much better
- Cockbrand 3y agoAnd often much more premium, IMHO.
- crazygringo 3y agoFunny, I'm the opposite. The old logos look fuddy-duddy, like stuff that my grandmother would have loved. The new logos make me think -- oh, maybe they're actually doing something cool and relevant today, and not stuck in outdated ideas of luxury that include full sets of china and silver and mink coats.
- Unfrozen0688 3y agoI'm talking about these. You serious? https://imgur.com/NyhbDFC https://imgur.com/NyhbDFC We truly are lost.
- furyofantares 3y agoI had the same reaction as you, but the point makes a lot of sense to me after some consideration. If I cover up the new ones, I can TOTALLY see how someone could associate the old ones with values and styles they find outdated. At an extreme, if I imagine asking my 16yo niece about the old logos, I wouldn't be at all surprised by a highly negative association with the old.
- crazygringo 3y agoYes exactly. They look like they're for grandma and will go with her pearls. And a Rolls-Royce. I don't see what's so "lost" about that. It's certainly not the type of luxury vibe that seems to speak to anything desirable today. The logos look like something out of a museum.
- Unfrozen0688 3y agoToday the height of status is the new iphone and a gucci shirt. How far we have fallen.
- crazygringo 3y agoHow is that any different than a new Rolex and a Brooks Brothers shirt? The more things change, the more they stay the same. (And at least an iPhone does a lot more than a Rolex, and is a heckuva lot cheaper too. So I see this as a major improvement, actually.)
- Unfrozen0688 3y ago>How is that any different than a new Rolex and a Brooks Brothers shirt? Also nevau rich shit
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dustedcodes 3y agoI've noticed this loss of creativity and personality before. It's very noticeably in building architecture. Now it's taken over web architecture. All websites and logos starting to look the same-ish.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mglz 3y ago> It's very noticeably in building architecture. My bad take: Modern architecture ugliness comes from architects using CAD with insufficient proficiency to create complex designs. Result: Mossty cubes and grids, with some advanced users adding fillets.
- taneq 3y agoJust wait til the next generation come in, who've grown up designing widgetes for 3D printing. Weird procedural geometry, swoopy curves and crazy patterns galore! :D
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoI for one am here for techoGaudi-ism.
- marklubi 3y agoBack in the 80's, my dad invested tons of money into a top of the line computer (a 386), plotter, software, and training, when CAD was first a thing. He did one project with it and roundfiled the whole thing because there was no art involved. He had become an architect specializing in high end custom homes because of the creativity involved. CAD killed that aspect.
- a1o 3y agoI don't think you are too wrong about it, the tools we use do shape the norm of we make with them
- 3y ago
- quirino 3y agoThere's this great blog for Logo changes: https://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/ https://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/ You have to subscribe to read the articles now, but just looking at the thumbnails is fun enough
- pzmarzly 3y agoWow, thanks for that. I had no idea that e.g. Deezer got rid of their iconic logo https://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/archives/new_logo_and_identity_for_deezer_by_koto.php https://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/archives/new_log...
- astrolx 3y agoYeah, very recently. I am still very confused trying to find the Deezer tab on my browser with the new logo as favicon!
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoMeanwhile Reddit gave their new icon a neckbeard! Talk about embracing community history!
- merelysounds 3y agoThanks for sharing. Browsing the before&after tag was especially enjoying: https://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/archives/category/type/before_after/ https://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/archives/categor... I found a nice counter example to the trend presented in the article: https://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/archives/new_logo_and_identity_for_madeformed_by_grapheine.php https://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/archives/new_log...
- nvoeiah 3y ago[flagged]
- Adverblessly 3y agoThe explanation I heard for the simplified logo fonts is that they want something that reads well on tiny phone screens.
- woodruffw 3y agoThe design cycle is especially obvious in the case of Airbnb et al.: they all went from having cursive logo fonts to sans-serif. In other words: the only thing that’s new with the current cycle is that it’s a minimal cycle, making a lot of designs converge. I’m sure we’ll see a larger variety of designs with the next cycle, underlying design philosophy permitting.
- taneq 3y agoI wonder if it's to do with fixed-width serif fonts looking "old" due to their association with old text printers? Now sans-serif looks 'new' by comparison. Couple that with the 'clean sleek minimalist' look that all the modern tech companies have popularized and everything's re-converged on another round of samey looks. We're ripe for another new wave any year now. What'll it be this time? Comic sans? sARcAsTiC?
- woodruffw 3y agoThat might be some of it, but I think there are even more quotidian answers: large companies often have fixed design budgets (by virtue of having a design staff sitting around, waiting for things to do) and are generally under pressure from investors, etc. to demonstrate market fit and relevance. In other words: "what are you paying all these designers for, if you aren't going to have them match the latest trends?"
- passwordoops 3y agoThere's been much virtual ink and video play time discussing the phenomenon. Just do a search "why are designs so boring?" My personal slant pins it on the cult of minimalism. I realized we were effed when Lufthansa went with their incredibly dull and depressing livery. Most people in the planespotting world disliked it (1), while designers were falling over themselves gushing about the elegance, clarity and simplicity of the brand (2). My UX designer even used them as an example to emulate (we disagreed on many things). Also, designers, like most people, are inherently uncreative. A new trend will start, and people will follow. Just look at how every AI project has been trying to shoehorn "Q" into their names these past couple of weeks. Or how everything "smart" had to have a lower-case "i" in front of the brand for a long while. I'm starting to see the backlash against minimalism more frequently, hopefully it'll hit design schools soon and the next home run brand will move away from extremist minimalism (1) https://thepointsguy.com/2018/02/lufthansa-new-livery-boring-frequent-flyers-agree/ https://thepointsguy.com/2018/02/lufthansa-new-livery-boring... (2) https://www.adelahaye.com/blog/2020/2/11/feeling-blue-lufthansa-rebranding https://www.adelahaye.com/blog/2020/2/11/feeling-blue-luftha...
- dun44 3y agoHopefully AI will make those uncreative designers redundant, freeing them to do something more aligned with their talents.
- passwordoops 3y agoThat's way too hopeful. AI is not creative, it's a tool that gives you what it calculates to be the best solution which is taken from the space of all pre-existing solutions. So if anything it will double down on the lack of creativity and keep showing whatever worked before referring us down a cycle of dull, but very machine-predictable mediocrity. AI is not the solution for making things more creative.
- ungamedplayer 3y agoI think that was what op was saying. They will make the boring samish logos.
- A_D_E_P_T 3y agoSee also what I think is an even more striking set of examples: https://www.creativebloq.com/news/logos-look-the-same https://www.creativebloq.com/news/logos-look-the-same It's definitely a trend.
- bad_username 3y agoAlso colors and shapes seem to converge. I find it increasingly hard to find programs by icon in my taskbar, they look the same.
- zo1 3y agoIcons inside programs too. Just this morning I got confused trying to un-mute myself inside Discord. Like at some point these braindead designers need to realize that an important part of "UX" is that users should easily be able to find what they're looking for and differentiate it from the next ugly white-on-grey icon that looks the same.
- 1over137 3y agoAges ago, the Apple HI group had a saying: a word is worth a thousand pictures. Alas those people are all gone.
- benj111 3y agoI just don't get why companies change their branding every 5 minutes. What do you gain? Did everyone suddenly start thinking Google was new and fresh after they spent however many millions on their rebrand? And then there's the inherent contradiction. Is a logo important, if not why are you changing it, if it is, why are you throwing out the current valuable logo, or are you implicitly accepting you somehow failed and tainted the old logo? All I see is a company bike shedding rather than spending the money and effort to improve their offering.
- nottorp 3y agoEasy. They have a chief marketing officer or even a specialized chief branding officer. Those need the fat bonuses for succesful... something too.
- mikhailfranco 3y agoI was employee No.3 in a start-up a long time ago. When the founders & senior management started spending time redesigning the (perfectly fine) logo, I knew it was the beginning of the end. I began to look for an escape route to another role. It took 3 months for the logo to launch. I was ready. I left. They cashed out my Angel options at the Series B price. It crashed and burned about 1 year later. I still believe I was the only person to make money from that startup
- crazygringo 3y agoWhy do people change their haircuts or buy new outfits? Part of branding is fashion. What is current fashion looks outdated and old and, well, out-of-fashion after a few years. So what you gain is that you continue to look modern and current and up-to-date, rather than looking old and fuddy-duddy and out-of-touch. > Is a logo important, if not why are you changing it Because it's important to keep it looking good, part of which is keeping it up-to-date. > why are you throwing out the current valuable logo Because it loses value over time as it starts to look old-fashioned > or are you implicitly accepting you somehow failed and tainted the old logo I don't know what that means. Logos go out of style not because of anything you did, there's no "tainting". It's just how fashions change
- tcldr 3y agoQ: Why do everyone’s logo fonts look the same? A: Because they need to be legible on a mobile device. It’s no coincidence this trend started in the 2010s with the arrival of the smartphone. Brands need a consistent look that work across mediums. With over 50% of e-commerce sales happening on mobile, and the dominance of social media in the marketing of, for example, high fashion, a brand mark must excel in these kinds of treatments. Perhaps we’ll find another design trick to facilitate legibility at smaller scales but until then, those marks that looked great in print, aren’t fit for purpose.
- ilumanty 3y agoSerifs improve legibility of small prints. With modern HiDPI screens, there is no reason not to use serif fonts across all media.
- tcldr 3y agoSure, a restricted subset of serifs and typically when you’re reading a run of text i.e body copy. But the typical neoclassical serifs used in high fashion (think the Vogue logo) with their hairline serifs will look awful scaled to the sizes needed on mobile – regardless of screen definition.
- dannyw 3y agoYou generally have to cater to the lowest common denominator, like that $150 prepaid Android phone with a non-HiDPI screen. Or someone on a 1336x720 Chromebook.
- a1o 3y agoI think we all used Times New Roman for writing in 800x600 desktop CRTs with 15" curved displays and could read just fine.
- marginalia_nu 3y ago15" CRTs were physically significantly larger than anything mobile today.
- davidgaleano 3y agoI think the recent rebranding of ILM was quite successful, it is less bland that the previous one. https://youtu.be/oEj-2qmtvrU?si=KvfZ5KzwvHgjPoYP https://youtu.be/oEj-2qmtvrU?si=KvfZ5KzwvHgjPoYP
- laurent123456 3y ago(2020)
- Log_out_ 3y ago[flagged]
- NotGMan 3y agoMight be a combination of attention span and readbility. Many logos use cursive or letters which one must "focus" in order to read. But if you use a "simple font" you asap read it without even knowing. If you want to get the most out of your ads you need the people to actually register the ad message instantly.
- Cockbrand 3y agoPlaying devil’s advocate here: the message itself could be written in an easily legible font (plus an image, potentially), and the company logo could still be cursive or whatever, making it much more distinct. Once the logo shape is learned, it should be easy to recognize.
- rereasonable 3y ago[dead]
- WesolyKubeczek 3y agoI can’t help but notice how history rhymes every 100 years or so Wasn’t it the 1920s when sans serif typefaces became a major fad?
- ranting-moth 3y agoI think the generic answer is trend and fashion, mixed with fear of failure. If you do it like/similar to everyone else, you won't get the blame. If the company/brand fails, everyone is going to put the blame on someone else. Yeah, the designer did this strange thing and it totally tanked the brand.
- 542458 3y agoAs a designer, I think this is correct. The boring sans-serif logo is the “nobody ever got fired for buying IBM” of logo design.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoForget the fonts. What's going on with Diane von Furstenburg rebranding to DIANE (invisible word) VON (linebreak) FURSTENBURG? The original logo correctly reflects that von is not capitalized, that von is part of "von Furstenburg", and that there is no hidden word between "Diane" and "von Furstenburg". The new logo does none of those things. Who puts a caesura in the middle of a word?
- mongol 3y agoIt's different. That it is less correct pales in comparison.
- 23B1 3y agoI'll tell you exactly why: because graphic design, which used to be about concept and humanity and risk-taking, has been transformed into a darkpattern-loving exploitative commodity in which no truly creative person wants to live. The most ironic thing of all is that the author of this article has built a platform – one of many – that has sucked all deliberation and concept and creativity out of the branding process. The Fiverrification of identity creation.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoDesign is a bit of a fashion industry. Lots of people imitating each other. I'm not a designer but I know a few good ones and appreciate good design. What I appreciate in good design is not only looking good but standing out from the crowd. The problem with imitating others is that you end up looking like everything else. It's not offensive. But also not remarkable or memorable. A lot of web design suffers from being bland and generic. A few years ago we had an app and our designer came up with an intense shade of red that was slightly pinkish. He then proceeded to use that for our app icon. Net result: it jumped out from all the other icons on the phones apps drawer. The whole app looked fantastic but that icon was awesome. You could not not notice it. Everybody else was using fashionable blues and greens that literally everybody uses.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoTrue. But this effect isn't limited to design. How many cookie cutter / copy-cat businesses (i.e., apps) do we see? The origin of lack of (brand) identity is rooted in the companies themselves and their leadership. The irony? Avoiding risk is itself a risk. The higher your chance of failure, the more significant this risk (from self-commodit-izing).
- 127361 3y agoAlso maybe a symptom of chasing a quick profit in the short term over other considerations, such as product quality. So better play it safe so the valuation rises by the time the manager/designer/marketer has moved on to another company?
- chiefalchemist 3y agoMaybe. But the designer only presents ideas / concepts. Final sign-off on generic comes from the founder(s) or someone higher up the tree.
- mrtksn 3y agoIMHO the imitation serves a function. Familiarity conveys a message associated with that familiarity, that is the nature of the brand(cheap or high quality, for young or for old etc) and the brands need to update their logos to convey the correct message as their customers churn(people grow up and then get old). For example, if you are an expensive brand for people of age over 30 but under 50, 20 years later your 30y/o customer will be 50 and will drop out. Now you need to convey to the newly coming of age humans that your brand is expensive high quality one but they associate different styles and symbols with high quality than the previous generations and therefore you will need to re-design your logo to mach the new taste. If the new people don't associate the British royal symbolism with the stuff your brand stands for, you drop them and embrace contemporary symbolism, for example. Therefore, the source of the imitation is not really imitation but an attempt of different brands to capture the new symbolism. In other words, If everyone drinks coffee in the morning it's not an imitation to serve coffee in the morning.
- gardenhedge 3y agoHaven't seen Reddit mentioned yet. Their new logo doesn't follow this pattern.
- bloopernova 3y agoThe new reddit font (and logo) looks terrible to me. https://www.redditinc.com/blog/evolving-the-reddit-brand-a-more-accessible-bespoke-typography-new-conversation-bubbles-and-colors-and-a-new-snoo-logo-now-with-opposable-thumbs https://www.redditinc.com/blog/evolving-the-reddit-brand-a-m...
- rightbyte 3y agoOh dear. My eyes literally hurt while looking at it. Its like the text moves away from me, straight into the screen. It's not an animation right? I got astigmatism. Funny how the excuse is "More Accessible" ... but I guess the picture is the problem, not the font or the devil eyes on the logo.
- layer8 3y agoPrevious related (217 comments): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32040506 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32040506
- captainmuon 3y agoThey write "Logo fonts are indeed beginning to converge" but I think the minimal sans-serif has been the style for some time. I wonder if you could get ahead of the curve and use fonts like Garamond in the old Apple ads. Maybe that would be considered avantgarde soon?
- ghaff 3y agoYou could. But the theory is that you'd be communicating that you're old but reliable. The style for decades is also that you use serifs mostly for blocks of body copy and the old text heavy David Ogilvy ads would mostly not fly today. I'm not sure 20th century typographic practice ever especially favored serifs for display (e.g. headline) use.
- lagt_t 3y ago40% of my screen was a sidebar that has no content halfway into the article. I was expecting more from a design site.
- unconed 3y ago...and then it popped up an obnoxious subscribe popup while scrolling down which is when I closed this article as garbage.
- jbverschoor 3y agoIt fits what happens with the companies. They all start to look alike. Same culture, products, pricing models The logo is just a result of that
- 127361 3y agoThe decline of the modern corporation in general, then? Just gets bogged down by bureaucracy and the marketing departments taking everything over? Or some similar malaise.
- Varqu 3y agoPaul Skallas notices this trend as well, and it applies to pretty much everything: - logos - cars - architecture - even personal appearance https://lindynewsletter.beehiiv.com/p/refinement-culture https://lindynewsletter.beehiiv.com/p/refinement-culture
- 127361 3y agoCould that be homogenization caused by the rise of social media in the ~2010 timeframe? Where individuality is being eliminated by the stifling conformity of being constantly visible and everyone knowing your stuff? Things which used to be private and personal. And people are playing it safe by conforming to avoid being rejected by their peers. Thus creating a hive-mind which has spread to every aspect of life, including design and aesthetics?
- cschmidt 3y agoThe fashion houses all ended up looking exactly the same. Burberry is the first to swing back the other way, returning to an updated serif logo. https://twitter.com/ucllc/status/1622979476899393536 https://twitter.com/ucllc/status/1622979476899393536 So, hopefully the identical logo trend has peaked.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- spacebacon 3y agoSanding away character isn’t limited to typefaces. As we all seek to fit into a well defined and streamlined “likes” driven society do we not also sand away parts of our own character?
- hcks 3y ago[flagged]
- d--b 3y agoI thought the trend in fashion could be traced back to the rise of non Western customers. Many Chinese and Middle Eastern people can read Latin characters well, but it’s still easier in a cleaner font.
- syngrog66 3y agopartly its because it just doesnt matter EXACTLY what font. you might give Elon's rebranding of Twitter to the Unicode X glyph as a most famous recent exemplar application of this perspective -- plus it saves money on custom font crafting or analysis work. two: there really are a certain set of traits an ideal font should have and only a subset of all possible fonts have them. so just pick one of them, dammit -- Janet! -- and move on.
- loughnane 3y agoThe one that bums me out the most is the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston. They went from an elegant serif font to a bland sans with a few funky tails. Before: https://mir-s3-cdn-cf.behance.net/project_modules/disp/6a35674196742.5601d8305f0ac.jpg https://mir-s3-cdn-cf.behance.net/project_modules/disp/6a356... After: https://creativereview.imgix.net/content/uploads/2022/09/MFA_OOH2_Seaport_Sarah_Hopp-1920x1075.jpg https://creativereview.imgix.net/content/uploads/2022/09/MFA... Their stated purpose was to make it more accessible. The reasoned that the neoclassical architecture and old-style font made the space intimidating to people who didn’t hold those things to be part of their culture and that it was out of tune with the increasing diversity of their collection and programs. I think that’s the real trend here: change. Sans is so tempting because it hardly means anything and so designers will tell you it’s a blank canvas you can imbue with whatever values you want. If those values change, you don’t have to tear down your whole identity. That’s deeply appealing for firms in the tech world considering the rapid change of pace. What’s disappointing to me is to see cultural institutions take the same defensive approach. A logo change is fine, but saying “we want to be accessible to everybody so we’ll strip out anything that ties us to a time, place, or tradition” is like trying to make a welcoming living room by replacing all the sofas, tables, and rugs with a milk crate and a metal foldout chair. It doesn’t have to be that way. A few miles away the Boston Athenaeum did a rebrand with the same usual rhetoric on accessibility and diversity, but came through with a font that fits their tradition Before: https://web.archive.org/web/20210126132351/https://bostonathenaeum.org/ https://web.archive.org/web/20210126132351/https://bostonath... After: https://bostonathenaeum.org/ https://bostonathenaeum.org/
- JCharante 3y agoWow I haven't been to the MFA in a while but have good memories there. The new logo is absolutely abhorrent.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> Their stated purpose was to make it more accessible. The reasoned that the neoclassical architecture and old-style font made the space intimidating to people who didn’t hold those things to be part of their culture and that it was out of tune with the increasing diversity of their collection and programs. Can put this under the dictionary definition of insanity. Or someone needed justification to get paid without doing any real work.
- starstripe 3y agoTo me, serif fonts convey a sense of the classic, and sans serif fonts convey moderness. So if the top people of a company says to designers "make the company more modern", it makes sense that one of the first things the designers will do is to change the serif logo to a sans serif one. It's not always a good decision though, some industries, like high fashion (as seen in the article) and literary (e.g. New Yorker, Littler Books) benefit from being "classy" and having a serif font.
- blueridge 3y agoPersonal experience: My portfolio site gets more views, engagement, comments, and interviews when it's in a sans-serif font. I've copied the same portfolio and designed it with serif fonts and it seems to be nowhere near as attractive as the sans-serif. All of the fonts were purchased from designer type foundries and are very readable and pleasing to the eye. I much prefer the serif with warm colors for various elements. But the people I might work with strongly prefer the sans-serif with white and black and bold and bright accent colors.
- crowcroft 3y agoDiscussion about fashion and trends aside, A lot of it driven by a desire to make the branding easy to reproduce across web formats. I wonder if that’s an indictment of the web…
- eyelidlessness 3y agoNot everything is an indictment of the web.
- pilgrim0 3y agoI’m in favor. More legible, easier and cheaper to reproduce, good rendering in small sizes. Brands need more differentiation when they’re new. Once they’re established, the name and the product stands for itself. I don’t get why people care so much about this. Do they also bother with people using t-shirts rather of suits? Simpler logos are more functional. Logos also don’t exist on a vacuum (like a JPEG in an article), they are accompanied with other elements of visual language. Hand picking some logos and putting them all together in order to make a statement about a perceived trend is artificial. There are much more fancy logos than simpler ones overall, so nowadays simpler stand out more. Also, there’s nuance in simple, it’s not just “sans serif”, there’s weight, spacing, contrast and proportion differences. A design must be evaluated in its own context and usage, unlike they do in these articles. I’ve lost count of these superficial attacks on “minimalism” which appear on the net. I bet not one of the designers responsible for such redesigns did that on basis of a trend, each project had a specific scope and rationale, but somehow people attack designers like they are all getting stupid, yeah, sure, random people on the internet must know better than designers evolving their craft and understanding for decades, working closely with clients to realize a comprehensive and carefully crafted vision.
- rapnie 3y agoAnyone throwing some examples that bring the fun back? I'll add the first 2cts with https://omg.lol https://omg.lol Minimalism plus serif combined in colorful design.
- zzzcsgo 3y ago[dead]
- renegade-otter 3y agoPapyrus. I KNOW WHAT YOU DID. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVhlJNJopOQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVhlJNJopOQ
- AlienRobot 3y agoI noticed this same risk-averse "generic" phenomenon about article bodies. I was trying to design a wordpress theme for my blog and I was googling some things and readings articles. I had multiple tabs open and while I was in the middle of an article I realized I couldn't even tell what website that article belonged to! Every website was white with black text on it. Web "design" seemed limited to picking which color should links be. When you notice this, you start seeing it everywhere. Every article just looks exactly the same. They were all forgettable and devoid of personality. It seemed as if branding didn't reach the content of the article and was just a crown worn on top of the content, literally, at the header.
- cxr 3y ago> It seemed as if branding didn't reach the content of the article Good. > They were all forgettable and devoid of personality Are you similarly upset that books are so "devoid of personality"? The work of a book designer differs essentially from that of a graphic artist. While the latter is constantly searching for new means of expression, driven at the very least by his desire for a "personal style", a book designer has to be the loyal and tactful servant of the written word. It is his job to create a manner of presentation whose form neither overshadows nor patronizes the content [... whereas] work of the graphic artist must correspond to the needs of the day and, other than in collections, seldom lives on for any length of time[...] The aim of the graphic artist is self-expression, while the responsible book designer, conscious of his obligation, divests himself of this ambition. Book design is no field for those who desire to mint the style of today or to create something. --Tschichold, on the form of the book We should be so lucky if web designers grew up and subordinated their impulses—of imparting their (eventually unfashionable) "personal styles"—to their duty to serve the page and the content the way that it is done with books.
- AlienRobot 3y agoNot at all. Because there are many books with colorful designs and unique visual language. Any textbook or magazine you pick will have more visually interesting articles than webpages.
- Sunspark 3y agoPart of the original impetus is because the nice-looking classical logos, etc. were too high-resolution for low-definition display devices. Then it became a game of pointy-headed middle-managers having meetings in the boardroom and micro-managing the creatives.. "our competitors wet their pants, so we have to as well in order to not appear behind the times.." That's an inherent problem with the system.. even if something works and is comfortable for people to use and they're happy with it, you still have some middle-manager screaming at subject matter experts that they need to innovate because the system is based on creating artificial value for "the shareholders". So you end up with dubious changes like Google Maps recently deciding that they would change their colour palette to a "cold tone". Why? Did anyone ask for more blue and green and gray, or is this just more artificed "innovation for the shareholders"?
- crtified 3y agoThe majority of designers use the same few software packages (a truism of most digital fields), with the same range of functions and parameters, the same trends, all reading the same internet articles, subscribed to the same creative influencers, and being churned out of the same college courses, where they all got taught out of the same text books. It's increased homogenisation at every level.
- crtified 3y agoI'll reply to my own [now un-editable] comment to add, by way of balance to that comments somewhat cynical take, that some of the ubiquitous tools and techniques I mentioned have enabled a great many people to participate in these activities, who might otherwise not. The pros and cons of that too are debatable, however I certainly think we can all see some positives in the principle of technology enabling people.
- wanda 3y agoNaivete back in the 20th. Before: let's commission a designer to make a cool logo / let's make a cool logo. Now: market research data indicates that 90% of sales went to people who used this font style in their logo so let's commission a designer to make us a logo that looks like everyone else's [1] [1] with no consideration of the fact that 99% of sellers use that font type in their logo and 85% sales went to market leader who definitely used that font type in their logo, to say nothing of the fact that the logo probably didn't secure the conversion in any cases
- sabon 3y agoI wrote an extensive article about this: https://www.velvetshark.com/why-do-brands-change-their-logos-and-look-like-everyone-else https://www.velvetshark.com/why-do-brands-change-their-logos... Since its publication it even got featured in a Spanish textbook, and I get tons of traffic to it all the time. The topic seems very much valid for the last few years, with no sign of change. The main reason seems to be to look good (or even readable) on mobile, but it seems that it's more of a bandwagon than a proven good strategy.