6 ms·
Google Maps now looks more like Apple Maps
- satellite2 3y agoIt seems there is no way to revert to the old scheme which is the real issue here.
- botanical 3y agoThe grey roads aren't good on the eyes, and it needs better contrast. They come out with design schemes but fail when they need to deliver it themselves. I don't even bother with Google Maps any more. It shows miles on many dialogues when my locale (South Africa) only uses kilometres. Also, I don't know what preference they give to nearby POIs, but it's mostly useless (or random). Install one of the OpenStreetMaps-based apps like Magic Earth or OSMAnd with offline maps and customisability, and it works well enough.
- parineum 3y agoGoogle has, in my opinion, a severe problem with change for the sake of change. I use a lot of Google software but it seems like something is always changing with new versions and not for the better but not always for the worse either, just different. It's fairly frustrating especially in apps I use infrequently. They just don't seem to value a long term and consistent user experience.
- cromka 3y agoI remember reading this is a side effect of their corporate ladder structure, where successful projects for “new stuff” are used to self-advocate for promotion. Not unlike any other corporations, to be fair.
- piva00 3y agoAgreed, I feel it's definitely Conway's law in effect, the org structure is being delivered: PMs need promotions so will change things for the sake of change, to have something to be delivered that is not only maintenance or steady small upgrades. To get a promotion it needs to be flashier, PMs chase "impact" (whatever that means) and not a "this is a nice and consistent user experience". To the detriment of us all, users... Unfortunately I don't have many examples of large orgs being able to escape Conway's law, every larger org I've worked at has this issue. After 2 decades in tech I definitely feel the incentives are all wrong, what organisations push for the ticking box process of getting promotions is quite disconnected from the needs of users. Given enough time, inevitably, it breaks.
- pmontra 3y agoHow about no incentives, just get the money at the end of the month?
- piva00 3y agoI'd be extremely glad for that, fucking tired of all the political games to keep churning projects a PM wanted for their promotion package, regardless how actually useful it was 2-5 years down the line, usually abandoning the team right after they jump up in their career... I haven't had a PM for longer than a year or so in a long time. Getting pretty exhausted by the endless cycles of: 1. new PM 2. weeks and weeks of product workshops to define vision/mission/goals 3. teaching the PM how the product works, who are the customers, why it works this way, all the weird business logic cruft 4. PM has a passing knowledge of the product 5. PM decides on a new questionable flashy project after 3-6 months 6. PM gets promotion (or a burnout) Rinse and repeat.
- pmontra 3y agoThat's a PM looking for a promotion and I'm afraid that it can't be helped. It's not the only way, somebody they get promoted without doing anything, only backstabbing other people. In a sane environment there should be user problems to solve, real problems and not invented ones, and teams that solve those problems. The PM of a team delivering the best solutions should have an advantage when looking for a promotion, that's fair. Unfortunately that means that they had a brilliant PM and they'll turn it into a maybe mediocre manager one level up and there is no way to climb down the ladder in the same company. Peter's Principle.
- simmerup 3y agoYeah this is a part of the reason I got an iPhone. Got tired of having to relearn google’s UI every year or so.
- izacus 3y agoYou can say that for a lot of things, but this maps change is a massive usability improvement despite change grumpiness. There's a reason why even Apple chose a similar color scheme.
- archerx 3y agoGoogle’s new UI refresh has been a step backwards. The biggest crime for me is the now in chrome when you right click you have to sometimes scroll to see the “inspect element” button, the most used thing in the context menu for me now hidden and requires more effort. I hope many bad and painful things happens to all the people who thought that was a good idea.
- skywal_l 3y agoRight click and press Q.
- hutzlibu 3y ago" the most used thing in the context menu for me now hidden" For me as well, but I think it is crazy, that it is usually still enabled by default for EVERYONE. I had to calm quite some people, that they did not break their internet accidently for opening dev tools. Now it surely would be nice, if the majority could make use of that button, but the majority ain't devs and so they should not have that option one click away from buttons they do care about, like copy and paste.
- tgv 3y agoSafari has a simple, application-wide setting "enable dev tools" (or something like that).
- bradley13 3y agoA bit off-topic, but I maintain three simple, static websites. Every few months, I get mail from Google, telling me of "new" reasons why these sites may not be ranked well in Google search. The reasons are nonsense, at least in my view. For example, suddenly the spacing between control elements is "too small" for mobile devices. It wasn't last month, but it is now. Or the font, or something else that hasn't changed in years. Other search engines (e.g., Bing) report no problems. More "change for the sake of change", but they want to force other people's stuff to change as well. Google hegemony can't end soon enough...
- jesterson 3y agoAs someone who has few high load dynamic ones, I am getting those by dozens. Likely google "improves" the algorithm by which those are decided and voila. The good thing is I never got to spot any correlation between SERP and those "reasons".
- chrismorgan 3y agoYep, seen all of these. Got a new one a couple of weeks back: some pages on my site http://www.example.com/ http://www.example.com/ aren’t being indexed because of “Page with redirect”. This is the http:// http:// → https:// https:// 301 redirect which has been in place since the day I created the site. But apparently Google forgot about it a week earlier, and then noticed it again and mentioned it. Some cases where I’ve seen “element too small” must indicate a bug in the browser or the measuring: no scripting, CSS failing to load wouldn’t make it any smaller, and the content is all after the meta viewport declaration (of course). So unless the entire thing is deliberately faked (which seems unlikely), it’s got to be a bug in the browser or measuring.
- threeseed 3y ago> but they want to force other people's stuff to change as well They aren't forcing you to do anything. They are simply informing you that they prioritise end user experience and that they will be promoting more usable sites ahead of yours. Because inadequate spacing between control elements is a fundamental user experience issue on mobile.
- 3y ago
- maxglute 3y agoRolled out for me. Looks more unpleasant but feels more usable.
- l33tman 3y agoThe worst thing with google maps the last years is that you can't see many venues until you zoom in to the absolute max zoom-in, even if there is PLENTY of room to show it at a lesser zoom-level without cluttering up the view. Sometimes it's even inconsequent, like you see something, zoom in to look at the streets, zoom out, it's gone... then you can't see it again until you zoom max..
- arlcode 3y agoWell you see SOME venues reliably, in particular those that chose to get (aka pay for) a logo etc. Maybe I'm just being cynical but my pet conspiracy is that in order to make the map space marketable it needs to get worse first so companies are "encouraged" to pay for the privilege. It would fit in with Googles business model.
- water-your-self 3y agoThis is frankly obvious, ever since google maps spoken directions began mentioning chain stores by name. "Turn left at the [national fast food chain] is too obvious.
- arlcode 3y agoAh that didn't yet arrive in Germany I think
- linker3000 3y agoIt's the 'Supermarket bacon' method of enshittification. The normal product heads towards lower quality until the vendor can then sell one that's closer to the original, but call it a premium item, and charge more for it.
- rwmj 3y agoThe difference is that you are the supermarket's customer. For Maps the customer isn't you.
- 3y ago
- TrianguloY 3y agoI personally only use the satellite view, I can see what is a park, a street, a river, and in full details without any doubt. The standard map view is useless now for me, I can't find anything there :/
- jonplackett 3y agoI wish they’d give me some options. About 5 years ago Google totally fucked up the colours of smaller roads here in the UK. Now basically everything except really big roads are white on slightly off white background. It’s just the worst colour combination ever if you don’t have brilliant vision and can’t be that great anyway.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bitcharmer 3y agoI bet there were bonuses and promotions so it's fine. Who cares about the users.
- pmontra 3y ago> why would you fix something that wasn't broken? Because if you're not pretending to do something useful somebody might think that the company doesn't need you anymore. So you have to invent something to do and breaking working stuff just happens. I also noticed that Google Maps looks like a watercolor now with more white margins around.
- benrapscallion 3y agoAlso: to continue to show people more and more ads and in places where they have built muscle memory for expecting other information.
- jonathanlydall 3y agoMore and more I'm seeing headlines suffixed similar to the above "...and a lot of people aren't happy" or "...and people are upset" and it just seems to me like shoddy work by article authors. These kinds of headlines make me assume the article is not going to bother to give a balanced or researched analysis, but instead just talk about how people are feeling about things, without necessarily quantifying anything. It's okay to have feelings or opinions, but that's generally pretty useless to other people without some rationalization or justification as to why you have them. I would have been far more inclined to read an article with a headline like "Google updates its Maps to look more like Apple's at the expense of ease of use".
- eur0pa 3y agoNot everything needs to be a peer-reviewed research paper
- jonathanlydall 3y agoNo one said anything about peer review. If I went to my boss and I said “people are upset with our product”, he will bemoan me for providing un-actionable information. If I went to my boss and said “this is why people are unhappy with our product”, then I’m bringing him something potentially useful. My point is that I have no desire to read an article which from the headline seems to merely tell me “people are upset with something” as just about anything will upset someone. If your headline indicates you’ll at least attempt to tell me why people are upset with something, that might actually be interesting.
- hnlmorg 3y agoA lot of time I see those kinds of titles, it’s just a low quality article aimed at driving page impressions for minimal effort: - talk about the change in a way thats easy to casually observe - then link a few Tweets … - Profit This article might be better but I’m training myself not to open articles with such titles anymore.
- ghusbands 3y agoThe previous google maps coloring was terrible, too [1] (linked from [2]). At least you can now _see_ the minor roads on the map. It's impressive Google Maps has had terrible coloring for so long, but hopefully this is a step in fixing that. [1] https://i.xkqr.org/gmapsvsosm.png https://i.xkqr.org/gmapsvsosm.png [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31245700 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31245700
- Timshel 3y agoDon't know at the zoom level it looks like a feature to me when searching for a path, I don't want to cross residential area. Edit: Looking at Paris with the updated version on a tablet vs previous one my phone, main axes dot not pop as much. Guess it's not optimized to navigate without gps now ...
- dan-robertson 3y agoIs there anything where someone has taken the effort to measure quantitatively how contrasting the colours are now compared to how they were before? It feels to me like people will be biased towards what they are used to, regardless of which is better. I don’t have good pictures of the maps before but just comparing to Apple Maps by eye: - at high zooms, AM public transport has lower contrast between roads and the rest than GM which is lower contrast than other AM views - zoomed out a bit and the contrast is similar. AM shows fewer small streets but more main streets are shown thicker than in GM. AM shows more of certain POIs like stations or landmarks - zoomed out a bit more and GM shows major roads with higher contrast than AM which doesn’t pick them out so much but shows side streets with hairlines. The green is greener in AM. - public transport view at this level is so much better in AM. It’s less cluttered (lines are thinner, when trains run along the same route the lines are rendered right next to each other where GM has an ugly amount of space. Both views are omitting useful information at this zoom level (eg stations and interchanges aren’t all marked; it’s reasonable not to name them but AM used to be better I think). AM does a better job of mimicking signage/designs you see on the network (eg if the letter for a line is a coloured circle on a certain background) - zoomed out a lot and it’s a bit hard for me to describe the difference. AM seems to have a bit more contrast of roads against backgrounds. Roads are grey in both (I vaguely recall AM used to mimic road atlases). AM shows a greater variation of road thicknesses/darkness for more major roads. AM labels roads closer to how they appear on road signs and shows more road labels in ‘driving’ view - zooming out further and major roads fade to thin blue lines in AM and grey-blue on grey-green in GM. There is more variation in roughness (different terrain) for the green parts in AM.
- SushiHippie 3y agoSome comparison was done here, by someone who helped design Google Maps 15 years ago IIUC https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38398751 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38398751
- parineum 3y ago> It feels to me like people will be biased towards what they are used to Using this as an argument _for_ change is user hostile.
- nvoeiah 3y agoThen there's a lot of people like me who don't care at all because it works as well... they just changed the colours.
- jinushaun 3y agoBut the colors don’t work well. The various map providers are now all about the same level of quality and I chose Google Maps because I preferred the color scheme. With this change, Google Maps lost that advantage.
- dan-robertson 3y agoVarious comparisons from Justin O’beirne: https://www.justinobeirne.com/google-maps-testing-new-apple-maps-inspired-map-style https://www.justinobeirne.com/google-maps-testing-new-apple-... Note the current style is described in the November 2023 update part-way down.
- kmarc 3y agoThis is a correct and better article than OP. I think it was featured in an OSMweekly post at the time too. BTW I'm the only one who still likes the 2013 version the best...?
- rabbits_2002 3y agoThe difference however is that Apple Maps actually works
- gumballindie 3y agoGoogle needs to have a serious review of their product management hiring practices. There are regressions in quality across the board.
- vijucat 3y agoI suspect a larger theme at play, whether it be the universally disliked flat UI design that permeates all platforms or how company logo fonts are all converging to a bland sans serif [1], is that UX designers are not only disconnected from the U in UX, the Users, but are encouraged to have a self-image as being superior in sensibilities and thus, free from having to deign to listen to the inferior User. How else can one explain how the Windows UX team supposedly uses Apple Macs, lol? I would fire that bunch and replace them with a more grounded set that actually uses the product they design ("eat your own dog food"). Stop the starving artist impersonation while sipping on $7 lattes and listen to the actual user, IMHO. 1. https://justcreative.com/why-do-everyones-logo-fonts-look-the-same/ https://justcreative.com/why-do-everyones-logo-fonts-look-th...?
- disgruntledphd2 3y agoThis is the real problem. Certainly when I was at Facebook, basically zero employees used Android so the product was much worse there. I suspect the same is true at Google which is both darkly hilarious and very sad.
- kmlx 3y agoone company i worked for mandated underpowered laptops for frontend engineers and split their wifi so that everyone in that group had poor internet when trying to see/test their own work (the rest of the internet was fast). everyone complained. except for the users. the website (a very complex web app full of graphs, images, videos etc) was super fast and tiny. there are other ways of doing this, but i found this approach interesting.
- Maxion 3y agoYep, same when handing out reference devices for developing. Don't give out the Samsung galaxy excalibur 10+ super pro, or the Apple iPhone Pro Master 10+ extreme. Go to walmart and get the budget android on sale. Go get a used and beat up iPhone SE. If you get your stuff to run on those, it'll run fantastically* on the big devices * Barring device specific bugs.
- qwertox 3y agoI just opened a tab with Google Maps to see "Berlin-Bezirk Neukölln", as I was reading an article on a news site about it. My first thought was "I can't see shit with this new map" [0]. I also created a comparison between OSM, old map, new map of that section [1]. I wonder if this is Google trying to transfer less vector data per view. [0] https://www.google.com/maps/place/Berlin-Bezirk+Neuk%C3%B6lln/@52.445912,13.4617911,12z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m6!3m5 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Berlin-Bezirk+Neuk%C3%B6ll... [1] https://imgur.com/eiU4HGH https://imgur.com/eiU4HGH
- pmontra 3y agoThe one on the left is the best one by far. However it lacks POIs and they could be useful. I'm unsure which one is better between the middle and the right one. They are probably at the same level. The middle one has some more POIs. The big difference is that all roads have the same color in the map at the right (the new Google Map) so you have to rely only on thickness/thinness of the line to assess the importance of a road and maybe on its label.
- sys_64738 3y agoOne of the design flaws with Apple Maps is that it unintelligently rotates the map outside your control. It's utter chaotic and makes it useless for me. I hope GOOG Maps doesn't do the same.
- xnx 3y agoThe base map needed to be changed to have less contrast and less information to make more attention space for paid ads.
- purplepatrick 3y agoI just want any map provider to make the compass feature work reliably and easily visible. That’s all I want. But for whatever reason both Google and Apple seem incapable of doing this. I’m puzzled…
- oglop 3y agoBoth products ended up becoming caught up in a race to the bottom. I have no insights how it happened. But I am fascinated that over time apps that work are “improved” and inevitably devolve based on this premise. Except Hacker News. Go figure.
- felurx 3y agoI really like using OpenStreetMaps, the maps are so much more readable than GMaps. And the map material itself is quite good too. I only wish the search in OsmAnd was a lot better than it is.