5 ms·
COP28: Countries launch declaration to triple nuclear energy by 2050
- Equiet 3y agoBut not Germany.
- mplewis9z 3y agoTechnically, Germany has already met their share of the requirements, well ahead of schedule.
- whatisyour 3y agohttps://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/w/ddn-20230130-1 https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/w/d... Germany is prety high up there.
- mplewis9z 3y ago(You missed the joke that they’ve already managed to triple their current nuclear capacity… i.e. 0 x 3 = 0)
- butler14 3y agoMy immediate reaction too — zero surprise of course but it’s ridiculous given recent events
- _Microft 3y agoThe dependency on Russian gas was bad but Russia is also controlling 40% of the worlds uranium conversion capacities. https://www.rferl.org/a/russia-nuclear-power-industry-graphics/32014247.html https://www.rferl.org/a/russia-nuclear-power-industry-graphi...
- rciorba 3y agoCANDU reactors use un-enriched Uranium. Technology exists, and has been in use for half a century.
- jansan 3y agoBut the German government has stopped ALL research in nuclear power usage. Even if there was a safe and cheap solition that would not make us dependent from Russia, Germany would not find it because they decided to not even try. It is an absolute disgrace.
- _Microft 3y agoThe German federal government is funding Wendelstein 7-X, a large, experimental fusion reactor of the stellerator type, to a high degree (9/10 of 80% = 72% as it seems?), so this statement cannot be true in general (maybe you are thinking only of nuclear fission research?).
- pfdietz 3y agoStellarators (like tokamaks) have terrible volumetric power density, so it's really doubtful they can ever be made economically competitive, even with fission as it currently exists.
- pfdietz 3y agoThe modern Advanced CANDU reactor in fact does use moderately enriched uranium. The cost of enrichment has fallen greatly since the original designs, so the benefit of using natural uranium has mostly dissipated, and enrichment provides some operational benefits.
- hommelix 3y ago40 % is not bad. That leaves 60 % other suppliers.
- ChemSpider 3y agoGermany bets its future on solar, wind and H2. That will be interesting experiment. Who will have the lower cost/kWh in the end?
- dgellow 3y agoDefinitely not nuclear, it’s a great source of energy but really expensive, susceptible to temperature changes, requires well trained technicians. But Germany doesn’t really have a coherent plan. The country will continue to depend on nuclear from neighboring countries.
- jansan 3y agoH2 is a pie in the sky. Betting your future on this is pure insanity.
- pfdietz 3y agoGreen H2 is projected to get cheap enough that a combined cycle plant running as a base load source on green hydrogen would be economically superior to a new construction nuclear power plant. Of course, a 100% RE grid needn't operate any hydrogen plant in base load mode, only to fill in gaps not covered by direct use of solar, wind, and batteries. Very little H2 is actually needed to cover dunkelflauten; somewhat more might be useful for seasonal leveling.
- the_third_wave 3y agoAs it stands now it will be a disastrous experiment which will (and already has) affect(ed) the rest of north-western Europe due to the interconnected nature of the electricity network. Electricity prices in the lower half of Sweden have risen dramatically due to this and also due to the fact that our own 'progressive/green' politicos took down half the nuclear generation capacity based on ideological reasoning. This poses a number of questions: - will these ideologically driven apparatchiks ever be held accountable in some way or will they just glide through the promotion circus and end up in cushy positions as ambassador in some warm country, in some UN organisation or as head of some NGO or (like Schroeder [1]) in the board of Gazprom or some similar organisation? - if Germany continues to de-industrialise due to a shortage of affordable power it will only be harder to reach that pie in the sky called the H₂-based economy - can this downward spiral be halted in some way? - how does a country's responsibility to help stabilise the European grid interact with another country's irresponsible experimentation with that stability? While the climate-apostles have boarded their private jets for yet another posh gathering the temperature has steadily dropped, the land is white and frozen and electricity prices have risen up to tenfold. Gas prices are still low but that does not help for those who listened to the apostles and replaced their gas-burning central heating for an electric heat pump. Solar does not help either when snow covers the panels which look out over a steely-gray snow-laden sky (source: I just looked out of the window) nor does wind (source: same the before). [1] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/gerhard-schroeder-ukraine-gazprom-vladimir-putin-olaf-scholz-b2007898.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/gerhard-schr...
- myspy 3y agoGermany has no newly educated technical personal, has no place to store the used fuel, and a majority of the public doesn‘t want it due to the risks in this densely populated country. We have build a lot of solar and wind though. And more is coming after years of right leaning parties blocking wind. As far as I know it‘s cheaper to build than nuclear, isn‘t it?
- jansan 3y agoOh come on. Germans have developed a completely irrational fear of nuclear energy, and everything is just a result of this. Driving cost of nuclear power plants up as much as possible was a political decision. Not finding a permanent storage was a political decision. Not having any personell was a poltical decision. What do you expect if you shut down modern and perfectly working power plants, and stop research in nuclear power? Alternative energy is more expensive, as you can see on your energy bill. I am paying 45€ per khW. How come electricity is so much cheaper in France?
- mpreda 3y agoAccording to official statistics [1], in 2022 Germany produced 33% of its electricy from coal (up from 30% coal in 2021). Of this coal, one third is brown coal. Judging from these numbers, the situation in Germany is a catastrophy from an ecological standpoint. Any german green that acted agains nuclear in Germany should feel deeply ashamed for what was achieved in the country. A green catastrophy in a country that could have been a leader! A national shame, I say. [1] https://www.destatis.de/EN/Press/Graphics/Energy/2023/_Interactive/20230309-electricity-fed.html https://www.destatis.de/EN/Press/Graphics/Energy/2023/_Inter...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- matsemann 3y agoWhile I'm for nuclear, I hope that it's not used as a cop-out to do nothing now. Which is what it often feels like locally. "I'm against these new windmills being built, we should instead build nuclear" is quite common to hear. Especially from climate deniers, so it's often more of a stalling technique to undermine green energy. We need the power now. Not in 15+ years. Of course, the best time to start would then have been yesterday. But we don't have nuclear in my country (Norway), I don't believe we could be efficient in building it. I'd rather our neighbors do it, that already has it (Sweden), and then we build what we're good at, and then we share the grid (ala ACER). A report from this week (in Norwegian) by Rystad Energy concluded that they don't believe it would be beneficial for Norway to look into nuclear at the moment. https://www.nho.no/tema/energi-miljo-og-klima/artikler/kjernekraftrapport/ https://www.nho.no/tema/energi-miljo-og-klima/artikler/kjern...
- ChemSpider 3y agoFor Europe (the continent and the EU) it totally makes sense to have a common grid - as it has already now. Nuclear in France, solar in Spain,... this diversity has served Europe well in the last decades. But you are right. Those who are against windmills always mention nuclear as alternatives, but you can bet 100% they would be even more against a nuclear reactor in their neighborhood.
- otherme123 3y agoAt least in Spain, the municipality that holds de radioactive waste or the reactors are very eager to have them because they get a lot of money either from the government or the electric utility. The biggest complainers are the nearby municipalities, that receive nothing but have to deal with nuclear being around. And then you have things like Chooz plant (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chooz_Nuclear_Power_Plant#/map/0 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chooz_Nuclear_Power_Plant#/map...), that is technically in France but is more in Belgic than France. Plants in the border like Gravelines, Cattenom, Fessenheim, or as far as possible from big cities like Flamanville, Paluei, Penly, Brennilis. In fact, Flamanville (one of the biggest planned plant in France) or Gravelines are closer to London than to Paris. Cattenom closer (and upwind) to Frankfurt or Luxemburg than to Paris. Fessenheim would be in Germany if it was build 1 mile/km to the east. They also built a lot of reactors in the highly seismic area of west Alps, but if something happened to any of them, the winds would carry the spicy cloud to Switzerland, Italy or Germany.
- legulere 3y agoTripling nuclear until 2050 is too little and too late to stop CO2-emissions in the energy sector. And looking at the issues western countries have even just replacing old reactors with new ones, it is also a highly unrealistic goal.
- ben_w 3y agoBased on current exponential growth curves, we get 100% of current electricity demand (even after allowing for capacity factor) just from just PV some time around 2032, and 100% of all current primary energy demand 3.5 years after that. And that's without counting any contribution from wind, geothermal, tidal, etc. Practically this means some combination of the exponential turning sigmoid or energy use going up; but even so, CO2 from energy is no longer something I'm worried about. All the other CO2 sources (steel, aluminium, concrete), all the other non-renewable resources (phosphate), all the other environmental problems (biodiversity loss)? Those are still things to be solved (solutions are known for many and possibly all, but now they must be proven economically). CO2 though, especially from energy, that problem I think we're going to resolve.
- Erratic6576 3y agoFrom an economic point of view, this is a catastrophe. Solar panels will become more and more efficient, making nuclear power an utterly expensive alternative. Private investors are building plants everywhere in my region. Not only solar panels, but windmills as well Why can’t we apply liberal market forces to nuclear energy? If it was worth it, heaps of corporations would be investing in it.
- dehrmann 3y agoUnless everyone starts building them tomorrow, I wouldn't worry too much. Commitments from these events are mostly empty promises, so if wind and solar are looking that much cheaper in five years, I'm sure they'd switch.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoPart of the game will be to get other countries to sign contracts with the supplier before that realisation hits. They'll have decades of construction and further decades of expensive power to regret their decision by which time the sales team will have long retired. That kind of corruption is common even when the person selling the dream is getting money from their own country's people. It steps up a gear when you are selling the dream to other nations.
- moritz 3y agoNuclear already is the expensive alternative. Just in the beginning of Nov, NuScale Power terminated its much hyped SMR projects in Utah [1]. Target price for these was $89 per megawatt hour. Wind and solar are what, ~$25/MWh currently? [1] https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/nuscale-power-uamps-agree-terminate-nuclear-project-2023-11-08/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/nuscale-power-uamps-...
- pfdietz 3y agoNote that the target price (which probably wasn't going to be achieved) also involved about $30/MWh of federal subsidies, and the target assumed 40-50 reactor modules being built (it was not the price for those first six modules for CFPP). It was clear what was going to happen after they announced the price increase late in 2022/early 2023. NuScale carefully stopped making positive statements that could get them personally sued and the executives started unloading their stock.