11 ms·
Purists will always hate the idea of computational photography, but I love how well my iPhone captures handheld nighttime, low-light, and motion images. I’ve ca
by Aurornis 3y ago
Purists will always hate the idea of computational photography, but I love how well my iPhone captures handheld nighttime, low-light, and motion images. I’ve captured some photos at night that I never would have thought possible from a physically small sensor due to the laws of physics.
Is it 100% pixel perfect to what was happening at the time? No, but I also don’t care.
I’ve used HDR exposure stacking in the past. I’ve used focus stacking in the past for shallow depth of field. I’ve even played with taking multiple photos of a crowded space and stitching them together to make an image of the space without any people or cars. None of them are pixel perfect representations of what I saw, but I don’t care. I was after an image that captured the subject and combining multiple exposures gets the job done.
- tonmoy 3y agoI just want to be able to turn it off when I want to
- HumblyTossed 3y agoAgreed. But since the 13 (12 was the last), there's no way to remove even the HDR processing.
- afavour 3y agoI have no objection with what we have today either but it does feel slippery slope-y, especially in the AI era. Before we know it our cameras won’t just be picking the best frame for each person, it’ll be picking the best eye, tweaking their symmetry, making the skin tone as aesthetically pleasing as possible, etc etc etc. It was always this way to an extent but now that we’ve given up the pretence of photos being “real” it feels inevitable to me. I’m reminded of that scene in WALL-E where it shows the captain portraits as people get fatter and fatter. It’s clearly inaccurate: over time the photos should show ever more attractive, chisled captains. They’d still be obese in real life though.
- simias 3y agoWhile I don't use TikTok I often see videos from there and it's really spooky to me how aggressive and omnipresent filtering seems to have become in that community. Even mundane non-fashion non-influencer "vlog" style content is often heavily filtered and, even more scary IMO, I often don't notice immediately and only catch it if there's a small glitch in the algorithm for instance when the person moves something in front of their face. And sometimes you can tell that the difference from their real appearance is very significant. I really wonder what's that doing to insecure teenagers with body issues.
- _kb 3y agoThat already happens, in realtime. FaceTime uses eye gaze correction, Cisco is all in on AI codecs for image and audio compression, and other vendors are on similar tracks too. When you talk to a client, a colleague or a loved one we’re on the verge of you conversing with a model that mostly represents their image and voice (you hope). The affordances of that abstraction layer will only continue to deepen from here too.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bigallen 3y ago> When you talk to a client, a colleague or a loved one we’re on the verge of you conversing with a model that mostly represents their image and voice (you hope) Wow, this threw me for a loop. There’s not much difference between talking to a heavily filtered image of a person and texting with them. Both the image and the words are merely representations of the person. Even eye-to-skin perceiving someone is a representation of their “person” to a degree. The important part is that “how” and “how much” the representation differs from reality is known to the observer
- karlshea 3y agoThis is nothing new. Very old examples are the xerox machines that accidentally changed numbers on scanned documents, and speech coding for low bit rate digital audio over radio, phone, and then VoIP.
- autoexec 3y ago> Is it 100% pixel perfect to what was happening at the time? No, but I also don’t care. No photographer thinks images the they get on film are perfect reflections of reality. The lens itself introduces flaws/changes as does film and developing. You don't have to be a purist to want the ability to decide what gets captured or to have control over how it looks though. Those kinds of choices are part of what make photography an art. In the end, this tech just takes control from you. If you're fine with Apple deciding what the subject of pictures should be and how they should look that's fine, but I expect a lot of people wont be.
- willseth 3y agoTry to photograph a toddler without this feature. Good luck. Does the fact that the iPhone allows me to do this pretty reliably without any fuss mean I have more or less control?
- leephillips 3y agoOdd. I have hundreds of great shots of my toddlers, none taken with these “features”.
- willseth 3y agoI know you’re pretending to be dense on purpose, but taking a dozen pictures at once and automatically picking the best one can obviously save a lot of shots. Same with combining exposures.
- autoexec 3y agoThe camera in this case wasn't taking many shots and selecting one. It wasn't just combining exposures either. It did a bunch of shitty cut/paste operations to produce an altered composite image which showed something that never happened. Some automatic features are wonderful. People have been able to take pictures of fast moving toddlers and pets for ages because of them. The camera "features" that secretly alter images to create lies and don't give you a photograph of what you asked them to capture are a problem.
- crotho 3y agoThere's a big difference between looking at reality through a bad filter and looking at a completely different constructed reality.
- dkarras 3y agowhen you think about it, with rolling shutter, no row (or column?) of pixels are from the same moment in a given picture unless you are shooting with a global shutter camera - which is rare for consumer type devices.
- stevage 3y agoI think purists are fine with it as long as you can turn it off.
- rmaccloy 3y agoIt's honestly better than this on all fronts, since you can get ProRAW out of recent iPhones even in the default camera app and get RAW without DeepFusion out of different alternative camera apps. I think I had to spend ~$1k to get my first DSLR with RAW support back in the 2000s. Adjusted for inflation, Halide + a recent iPhone feels like a pretty good deal.
- hibikir 3y agoMy issue with this has nothing to do with purism, but with how often the results are just no good, for reasons that have nothing to do with the sensor, but the choices of whatever model they run. Does it take a picture at night? Yes, but it's often unrecognizable compared to what my own sensor, my eyes, sees. It's not a matter of a slightly better reality, but the camera making choices about how light should go that have nothing to do with the composition in front of it. You might remember an article about how there are many situations where the iphone just takes bad portraits, because its idea of what good lightning is breaks down. 5 year old phones often take pictures I like more than one of the latest phones, and not because the hardware was better, but because the tuning is just bad. Fun things also happen when you take pictures of things that are not often in the model: Crawlspaces, pipes, or, say, dentistry closeups. I've had results that were downright useless outside of raw mode, because computational photography step really had no idea of what it was doing. It's not that the sensors are limited, but that the things that the iphone does sometimes make the picture far worse than in the past, when it took fewer liberties.
- adamredwoods 3y agoWhy not both? I am more in the purist camp, because when people take iOS photo, I remind them that someone else made that decision on how the photo should look. Additionally, we are in an era of not trusting anything on the internet or in a photo anymore. Do we want photojournalism to go that same path? I don't. So I enjoy being closer to "reality" than the computational photos, but for average entertainment photos, I don't mind.
- kazinator 3y ago> Purists will always hate the idea of computational photography A non-purist will hate it too, as soon as the technology re-imagines the positions of his hands such that they are around someone's throat.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoexactly, this tech eull send innocent people to prison
- TeMPOraL 3y agoOr moves the hill a little to the left, and the forest a little to the front, and the tanks a little to the side, and next thing you know, artillery is raining down on a nearby village.
- unethical_ban 3y agoThat last example is where I draw the line. It's one thing to enhance an image, or to alter the contrast across multiple frames to capture a more vibrant photo and a challenging lighting. But for our photography apps to be instantly altering the actual reality of what is occurring in a photo, such as whether someone is smiling or has their hands in a certain pose, or whether they're in a crowd or all alone next to a landmark, is not a feature that I think should be lauded.
- alentred 3y agoAs a layman in photography, I agree with you. But it is easy to understand the artists. It is said that in art everyone needs to master the technique first, the tool of the trade, but true works of art are the expressions that are created with these various techniques. At this point, a tool - computational photography in this case - may get in a way. So, it is not about purism. Quite the contrary, it is about being able to use the tools and bend the reality the way an artist wants. Having said that, I would think anyone would normally use *all* the tools available at their disposal, and the truth is that iPhone camera among else is a great one anyway.
- saiya-jin 3y agoYou are overblowing things, 99% of the photographers out there and 99% of the professionals out of those don't have this sentiment, since its primitive emotional one and detrimental to any actual work. Maybe few loud people desperate for attention make different impression on you about the state of affairs, but these days for any topic internet discussions can easily twist perception of reality and give very wrong impression. You simply have to be practical, use the best took for the job you need. If you ever actually listened to photo artists talking among their peers about their art (ie Saudek), they practically never talk about technical details of cameras or lenses, its just a tool. If they go for analog photography its because they want to achieve something thats easier for them like that maybe due to previous decades of experience, not some elitist Luddites mindset. Lightning of the scene, composition, following the rules and then breaking them cleverly, capturing/creating the mood etc are what interests them.
- makeitdouble 3y agoHow many "purists" are there in the wild ? I'd only see police and insurance agents needing pixel perfect depiction of reality as it's out of the sensor. Photography as an art was never about purity, and I think most of us want photos that reflect what we see and how we see it, and will take the technical steps to get that rendered. If the moon is beautiful and gently lights the landscape, I want a photo with both the bright moon and shadowy background, and will probably need a lot of computation for that. But the doppelganger brides, or the over-hdred photos, or the landscapes with birds and pilars removed aren't what someone is seeing. They can be nice pictures, but IMO we're entering a different art than photography.
- netsharc 3y agoI think the police/insurance topic will be a big deal soon. I still remember the first building inspectors walking around with digital cameras, and of course when smartphones with "good enough" cameras came they started using these... Now if society (including the courts) learn that the photos might not reflect reality, photo "evidence" could face issues being accepted by courts...
- makeitdouble 3y agoThere's been dedicated camera apps with tempering protection baked in (still won't help if you trick the physical camera, but at least they make an effort on the data handling side) I assume road assistance apps could also have that kind of feature. It's definitely becoming a thing.
- octacat 3y agooh, there are a lot of people who like control though. Journalists/competition photography probably also would go into purists.
- cesaref 3y agoIt's best to just think of it as a different art form. B&W film photography + darkroom printing is an art form, as is digital photography + photoshop. These modern AI assisted digital photography methods are another art form, one with less control left to the photographer, but there's nothing inherently wrong with that. I wouldn't want to say which is better, it's not really an axis that you can use to compare art is it? At the end of the day, do you generate an image which communicates something that the photographer had in mind at the time? If so, success!
- TeMPOraL 3y agoThe mistake is in thinking photography is only, or even primarily, art. It's also measurement. A recorded observation of reality. People use their cameras - especially phone cameras - for both these purposes, and often which one is needed is determined after the fact. So e.g. I might appreciate the camera touching up my selfie for the Instagram post today, but if tomorrow I discover a rash on my face and I want to figure out how long it was developing, discovering that all my recent selfies have been automatically beautified would really annoy me. Or, you know, just try being a normal person and make a photo of your kid's rash to mail/MMS to a doctor, because it's a middle of a fucking pandemic, your pediatrician is only available over the phone, and now the camera plain refuses to make a clear picture of the skin condition, because it knows better. I'm also reminiscing about that Xerox fiasco, with copy machines that altered numbers on copied documents due some over-eager post-processing. I guess we'll need to repeat that with photos of utility meters, device serial numbers, and even scans of documents (which everyone does with their phone camera today) having their numbers computationally altered to "look better". EDIT: Between this and e.g. Apple's over-eager, globally-enabled autocorrect at some point auto-incorrecting drug names in medical documents written by doctors, people are going to get killed by this bullshit, before we get clear indication and control over those "magic" features.
- pasabagi 3y agoI figure that digital photography is by its very nature 'computational', both in the obvious sense, and in the sense that the camera from hardware up imposes a set of signal-forming decisions on what is essentially just structured noise. The problem is more one of what controls the camera exposes to the user. If you can just take one kind of picture: whatever picture the engineers decided was 'good', then it limits your expressive options.
- _glass 3y agoI think the future will have digital mirrors with filters, so we don't have to mess with reality anymore, and our own imperfections. The raw image/reflection of oneself will be a societal taboo.
- rereasonable 3y ago[dead]
- underlipton 3y ago>Is it 100% pixel perfect to what was happening at the time? No, but I also don’t care. I do. Photos can be material to court cases where people's money, time, even freedom are at stake. They can sway public opinion, with far-reaching consequences. They can change our memories. At the very least, there should be a common understanding of exactly how camera software can silently manipulate photos that they present as accurate representations of reality.
- philistine 3y agoApple's obsession with hiding the magic trick is hurting them badly here. Just like Live pictures show you a video from before and after your pressed the shutter, every single picture should include an unprocessed, probably way too dark picture without any computational photography. That way regular users could truly grasp at what their phone is doing.
- fennecbutt 3y agoWell actual photographers will use phone computational photography the same as anybody else "the best camera is the one you have with you" but they'll also laugh if anyone tries to say that computational photo is still "taking a photo". It's not. There's the right tool for every job, an actual camera with a nice lens is the tool for the job when you want to "take a photo", situation permitting.