4 ms·
Trying to change the rate at which avocados ripen is way beyond anything I would ever worry about. Because I can't even tell when they're ripe! The article is s
by crazygringo 3y ago
Trying to change the rate at which avocados ripen is way beyond anything I would ever worry about. Because I can't even tell when they're ripe! The article is spot-on when it says (emphasis mine):
> "The window of time in which they are absolutely perfect—soft and tender with no brown spots or streaks—is notoriously short."
But then it claims:
> "...gauge ripeness by touch: Using your fingers, very gently press on the avocado near the stem end (that's where the avocado was once attached to the tree). You want to feel a slight tenderness and give. If the avocado is very firm, it's not ready; if it feels soft and mushy, it's gone too far."
I have gotten this wrong so many times that it seems like useless advice. The skin of the avocado is so stiff and wrinkly by the stem end, you simply cannot tell. By the time you apply enough force to feel through the skin, you're going to explode the avocado.
But if you try pressing against the side, where you can sometimes feel the level of hardness/softness more accurately (if it is a particularly thin-skinned one), you bruise it.
I'm an expert in the kitchen at basically everything else, but trying to figure out if an avocado is ripe or not just absolutely defeats me. I've routinely cut into an avocado I thought was underripe, only to discover it's so over-ripe it's inedible, because the skin all over is so darn tough that the whole thing simply felt rock-hard all over. It's like fossilized reptile skin.
How does anyone do it? I'm talking about regular Hass avocados bought in the northeast US shipped from Mexico.
At the end of the day, I just buy a few, wait 3 days, cut into one, and if it's ripe I try to eat the rest quickly. If not, I throw it out, wait another couple days, and repeat. Ugh.
- civilitty 3y agoYou must be consistently getting the world's worst avocados - do you always buy them from the same store? Though it might just be a variety designed for distant shipping that sucks in general. None of what you described sounds accurate to me but I'm spoiled in the Southwest. Ripe avocados are definitely soft and when I find the rare one that isn't, it's usually a bad avocado altogether (most of the flesh is very tough despite being overripe).
- crazygringo 3y agoThe avocados I buy look like this: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/c9/Avocado_Hass_-_single_and_halved.jpg/640px-Avocado_Hass_-_single_and_halved.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/c9/Av... See how the outside is super bumpy, and there's a thick rigid brown layer before you get to the green flesh? Rock-hard skin even if the flesh is soft. A serrated knife helps to cut through it without smushing the flesh. While I see other photos that look like this: https://daily.jstor.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/avocado_1050x700.jpg https://daily.jstor.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/avocado_1... Where the skin is visibly much thinner and smoother and there's no brown layer, and I can only imagine that's the type of avocado where people can judge its ripeness. But those don't seem to be available in NYC at my local store or Whole Foods or anywhere...
- rashkov 3y agoThere's an avocado delivery service in NYC that claims to deliver perfect avocados every time. There's some good press coverage around it: https://davocadoguy.net/ https://davocadoguy.net/
- squidsoup 3y agoI use a similar service in New Zealand, and no longer have avocados ruined by overzealous squeezers in the supermarket. I don't know who these people are, but they exist! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=38m-wnbHPLA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=38m-wnbHPLA
- civilitty 3y ago> Where the skin is visibly much thinner and smoother and there's no brown layer, and I can only imagine that's the type of avocado where people can judge its ripeness. But those don't seem to be available in NYC at my local store or Whole Foods or anywhere... I get both of those here in SoCal, or at least a varieties that look similar to those photos - the bumpier variety is noticeable when I come across it (it's definitely tougher). I never paid attention to the thickness of the skin or kept track of how quality correlates to the bumpiness, though. I'll keep an eye out from now on. I wonder if there's a single vendor/broker supplying the stores in your area. Have you tried buying them from outside the boroughs?
- locallost 3y agoNot really sure why it's giving you so much grief. I gently press on the bottom larger side and if I feel it's soft and not hard or bouncy it's good. I press on the larger sider because in my experience it takes longer to ripen.
- dekhn 3y agoI press against the side and it mushes in slightly. this tells you the avocado is ripe or past ripe. When you cut it open, then if it's already browning, it's gone past ripe. I agree it's a bit difficult but I used to make a few pounds of guacamole a day and it always worked great.
- bowmessage 3y ago> if it's ripe I try to eat the rest quickly If it's ripe, put the rest in the fridge, and you'll have a week or two to eat them at your leisure.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ars 3y agoSqueeze the side of the avocado, and if it gives AT ALL it's ready to eat. If it's soft it's way way overripened. Take a piece of cardboard between you fingers and squeeze - that's the firmness level that indicates the avocado is ready. Actually even more firm than the cardboard and the avocado is still ready. > where you can sometimes feel the level of hardness/softness more accurately (if it is a particularly thin-skinned one), you bruise it You are squeezing way too hard.
- gooseball92 3y agoI think you’re underestimating the variability in hand strength between people.
- lobocinza 3y agoSelf-calibrating over time.
- leobg 3y agoYou know that Hass is German for “hate”? I always find it funny that I didn’t bother to change the name here.
- labster 3y agoSF didn’t change the name of Haight Street either. People are pretty comfortable with homophones in general.
- JonChesterfield 3y agoThere's a stem of sorts at one end. Prod at it from the side - if it falls off easily, it's ripe or too far gone. If it stays attached, not ripe yet. More usefully, you can buy pre-mashed avocado in the same style as pre-made guacamole. If the use case involves (or could be made to involve) mashed avocado this option has a serious shelf life (presumably it's irradiated or similar) and lives in the fridge until use time.
- hobofan 3y agoIf you want to go for a over-the-top techy solution you could do non-destructive testing with a near-infrared handheld spectrometer. It's a pretty neat technique that can determine ripeness of a lot of fruits (and properties of other materials) if that can be detected via abundance of certain molecules. It looks though that Consumer Physics stopped selling their SCiO device that was ~$250 to consumers, and I don't know if there is any equivalent current alternative.
- crazygringo 3y agoThat would be the best. I already can't imagine going back to life before my infrared thermometer -- for food, for liquid temp, for pan temperature, for pan hotspots... And similarly you can pry my sous vide circulator away from my cold dead hands. If there was seriously something guaranteed to tell you ripeness, that would be golden. (Pineapples, mangoes, and melons like canteloupes, are sometimes tricky too -- I'm usually pretty good at figuring them out, but sometimes they surprise you.)
- gorgoiler 3y agoLots of consumer cameras have near infrared sensitivity, mostly 750nm but with a long exposure I can get photographs through a 900nm filter in my Fuji X-Pro. You lose at least four stops. Could the photography technique work to determine ripeness? Assuming the fruit is fairly motionless of course.
- hobofan 3y agoI have to admit I'm not the biggest expert on it. I mainly know about it because my brother wrote his PhD thesis about using portable Vis/NIR spectrometers as food checkers (verifying that they perform on par with expensive desktop spectrometers). He showed me the SCiO in person a few times, and IIRC always had to make direct contact with the solid probe, so I'd be surprised if a NIR photograph would be a suitable substitute. I think it also mainly measures the area of the fruit where you make contact, so to get an optimal picture about the ripeness of a single fruit it's good to take multiple measurements. That also usually makes fruits with tick skins/shells (e.g. melons) hard to measure. There seems to be a startup[0] aiming to bring suitable sensors to smartphones so that anyone has access to it - something that the food checker research literature has been hinting at for some time. [0]: https://mantispectra.com https://mantispectra.com
- robocat 3y agoApply some sciencey thinking. Test a variety of ideas (perhaps start with what is given here) until you find something that works for you. Challenge yourself: either practice someone else's technique, or invent your own. Outcome: satisfaction for the rest of your life every time you use your technique and get a perfect avo!
- dunham 3y agoI'm following Rick Bayless' directions to check the _bottom_ of the avocado and use it or put it in the refrigerator (for 3-7 days) when it gives slightly. https://www.rickbayless.com/ingredient/avocado-1/ https://www.rickbayless.com/ingredient/avocado-1/ I've mostly had good luck, but sometimes they're just bad to start with, bad because they're bruised from mishandling, or have been exposed to too much heat. I don't see a lot of the tough leathery ones, but I have seen a few. (Seattle, so I'm not in the southwest.) I wonder if they are a different varietal or just dried out.
- dzolob 3y agoYou just need to press it gently with all your fingers around the principal axis, not on the poles (as if your hand were a spider). If it feels hard, is not ready; if it feels soft, but not too soft, is ready. Also the color and the texture of the skin. Green means green, black and clear/bright + soft means ripe, black and opaque/wrinkled + too soft means overripe. Source: I’m from Mexico.
- makingstuffs 3y agoI usually put the tip of my thumb and pinky together and then press the palm flesh beneath my thumb first to get a sort of muscle memory as to what I am looking for. Then I press the avocado around the centre and compare. If it is around the same I open and eat. Seems to work most of the time — with the super thick skinned ones I generally press higher up on the avocado (closer to the stem)
- QuantumGood 3y agoThe period of time they taste appropriate is longer than the period of optimal softness. I eat 4/day (lowest carb source of potassium), and it was initially surprising how soon they tasted good. Also, the longer and thinner the point at the tip of the avocado, the less random the brown spots are. I rely HEAVILY on this to avoid loss, since I buy them 24 at a time when I go to Costco.