5 ms·
The University of California has all but dropped carbon offsets
- jeffbee 3y agoUC Berkeley is deeply unserious about actually cutting its emissions, which it could very easily do by replacing its cogeneration plant with something else. Yes, it will be less efficient to generate steam from renewable electricity, but it will also be carbon-neutral. The cogen plant releases 100x more CO2 than the vehicle fleet but everyone wants to talk about a handful of EVs while whistling past the power plant.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- barney54 3y agoNo. UC Berkeley is already in the process of replacing its cogen plant: https://sustainability.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/final-cec-phase-1-04.05.23.pdf https://sustainability.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/fina...
- moate 3y agoThat sounds deeply serious to me (specific plan with < 5 years towards projected completion). I award you victory and all the points.
- exabrial 3y agoWhat we need is a fantasy football league, but for carbon offsets. Then maybe, people would probably understand the vast majority of them are made up or stuff that we were "doing anyway" and aren't actually incremental.
- gosub100 3y agoWhy don't the big accounting firms (KPMG) start doing auditing of CO2 along with finance? Either audit the corporations that emit CO2, or audit the "carbon credits" to make sure they're legit? they have decades of experience specifically in sniffing out accounting bullshit, it wouldn't be much of a leap to hire a scientist or two and start auditing molecules?
- labster 3y agoBecause the average carbon credit is prima facie less legit than the average crypto token. You don’t need a deep investigation when almost the entire industry looks like junk when put under the slightest scrutiny.
- gosub100 3y ago"They shouldn't be audited because they're obviously not legit"? That doesn't make sense. If KPMG steps up and says "hey CC buyers, show me your operations and books", either 1) they refuse, and KPMG says "Green-n-Co refuses to be audited", and demand for CC (by your presumption, bullshit) goes down. 2) they get audited, KPMG reports "Green-n-Co is bullshit", and demand for BS goes down. or... 3) audited, report says "Green-n-Co met 93% of their stated goals, we found X areas for improvement", and (presumably) GnC only gets better, and demand for working CC services increase. So you're either against (reduced demand for bullshit), or against reducing CO2? Help me understand.
- e63f67dd-065b 3y agoOr 4) they switch to E&Y/PwC/Deloitte for their next audit, and all of KPMG's customers do the same in fear of the same thing happening to them
- sickofparadox 3y agoHow about a carbon offset credit where companies pool money into a big pot and start building nuclear powerplants? And then we 'offset' their carbon emissions by them buying electricity from the plant. Instead of people lying about planting trees or other opaque nonsense. We built our way into this problem, it makes sense to build our way out.
- Teever 3y agoWhy nuclear plants and not solar, wind or geothermal?
- xnx 3y agoSolar and wind are already being built almost as fast as they can (grid permitting).
- cronix 3y agoIt works 24/7
- Teever 3y agoExcept it doesn't work for the 20 years that it takes to build a nuclear power plant.
- sickofparadox 3y agoSkill issue - overcome after we build a few and streamline the onerous permitting process.
- Teever 3y agoThat will still take at least 20 years.
- sickofparadox 3y ago
- ahelwer 3y agoIf you're still committed to technocratic market-driven solutions to climate change there's the interesting idea of Carbon Quantitative Easing, essentially directly paying people to not emit carbon (read: pay oil companies to not pump out the oil they're going to pump out) or to sequester carbon with various methods. It's thought of as a carrot along with the stick of carbon taxes adding a cost to emissions. First learned about this in the excellent sci-fi novel The Ministry for the Future. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_quantitative_easing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_quantitative_easing
- Ryoung27 3y agoI'll never not upvote The Ministry for the Future. It was such an interesting book once I could get my mind in the space of what it was doing.
- sokoloff 3y agoThat’s never sat right with me. I don’t pump any oil out the ground personally now, but I’m thinking about starting. What area of the country would be best for me to decide to not pump oil and cash in on this program? Should I not pump oil from both Alaska and the Gulf, in order to diversify my non-operations? Or maybe start smaller and just not pump in the Gulf to get started, and only later expand to also not pumping in Alaska? It seems far better to pay carbon dividends to people (only humans, not fictional people) and then charge for carbon emissions (not the extraction of fossil fuels; you’re welcome to pull it out and put it in a tank paying only the emissions of your extraction equipment, but when someone buys it to consume, they pay the carbon cost.) Tweak the dividends and carbon costs as needed to achieve the balance of policy goals.
- ahelwer 3y agoGo ahead and buy the land & oil rights to a large oil reservoir if you want to cash in on this hypothetical program. Paying off the oil companies in this way means the end of the oil companies. They get a one-time cash infusion but that's it, no recurring revenue. Then no more oil companies to lobby against climate change. It's the only non-revolutionary route left, probably. Oil companies aren't just going to stop pumping oil and stop throwing the government around.
- I_Am_Nous 3y agoCarbon offsets seem like a great comparison to the way recycling ended up working out for us. Instead of actually doing anything helpful, companies began trying to make money doing everything but actually recycling the stuff. The recyclable plastic became a product to buy and sell until it got far enough removed from the people initially tasked with recycling it that it was cheaper to dump it in the Ganges River or some other place companies don't care about. Good on them for following up to try to do something that actually works or at least attempts to solve the issue rather than "We bought carbon tax credits and now it's someone else's problem to figure out how to offset that much carbon."
- turadg 3y agoA recent article chronicling the rise and disillusionment of carbon offset trading: https://web.archive.org/web/20231129175703/https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2023/10/23/the-great-cash-for-carbon-hustle https://web.archive.org/web/20231129175703/https://www.newyo...