5 ms·
Remember the UK doesn't have a constitution and hence it's not clear what it can't do. One common theory is "Parliament can pass a law on anything that's not ph
by rmc 15y ago
Remember the UK doesn't have a constitution and hence it's not clear what it can't do. One common theory is "Parliament can pass a law on anything that's not physically impossible". Kinda makes a change from "only regulat interstate commerce"
- rwmj 15y agoWhile it's not always good, it does allow government to move quickly and avoids the kind of weird deadlocks (eg. over healthcare, the budget) that one sees in the US. There are also limits: MPs individually vote, and on something that was hugely controversial they would defy the whips. It's not "the Government" but a collection of individuals. And in the end we can vote them out and overturn absolutely any legislation in the next Parliament.
- noarchy 15y agoAllowing government to move quickly and without restriction is not something that many would see as a good thing. Government deadlocks are not always a bad thing, either, particularly when the issue is controversial. I'd argue that it is far better to have an issue debated and for compromises to occur, than to have one party's solution shoved quickly into place. This includes so-called emergencies, which are often excuses to go after civil liberties.
- EvilTerran 15y agoUnfortunately, the recent US budget fiasco shows that governance rules intended to discourage excess speed and encourage debate can backfire.
- mjwalshe 15y agoAnd the lack or party disaplin means that you have to make lots of dubious deals to dole out pork or to pander to fringe extremists. Oh and in most places adding unrealted riders to bills for pork is banned. Germany has the same problem caused by PR Andrea Merkal needs 1 green vote to stay in power so buy buy Nuclear power I am sure Rep or Dem whips visiting the HOC must be jelous of the power that their counterparts have.
- epscylonb 15y agoRushed legislation is usually bad legislation. As a UK citizen I agree with you, the real problem is the apathetic electorate though, we get the politicians we deserve.
- arethuza 15y agoOf course the UK has a constitution, what we don't have is a single "core document" that codifies the constitution: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_United_Kingdom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_United_King...
- taejo 15y agoSaid constitution can also be changed by any act of Parliament, so I'm not sure. Parliamentary supremacy was supposedly part of the UK constitution until parliament gave up some of its sovereignty to the EU.
- untog 15y agoForgive my political ignorance, but can the US government not also create constitutional amendments?
- ceejayoz 15y agoYes, but with an extremely high threshold. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_Five_of_the_United_States_Constitution http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_Five_of_the_United_Stat... It essentially requires 2/3 of both the House and Senate to agree on it, and then 3/4 of the States have to ratify it. These days, meeting such a threshold is probably effectively impossible.
- jessriedel 15y ago> These days, meeting such a threshold is probably effectively impossible. At first I was inclined to agree with you, but consider this: there were six amendements to the constitution in each half of the 20th century but just four in the entire 19 century. (The Bill of Rights and the 11th Amendment were all passed before 1800.) Now, it's true that when you throw out the 27th Amendment (whose multi-century ratification time makes its 1992 passage deceiving), it has been 41 years since the last amendment was passed. But there was 60 years between the 12th and 13th Amendments and 43 years between the 15th and 16th. Neither of those two lulls were signs that the Constitution had become effectively un-amendable. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_amendments_to_the_United_States_Constitution http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_amendments_to_the_Unite...
- whyleyc 15y agoIt would be more precise to say that the UK doesn't have a written constitution.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoI remember long and fruitless, yet highly enjoyable, arguments with a friend on this one: if we have a constitution but it's not written down anywhere how do we know what it says? If we do know what it says then it can be written down. If it can't be written down how could it enter as a factor in any legal proceedings? Worth the paper it's not written on IMO. A: "You can't do that it flouts the UK constitution" B: "Oh right, what's the constitution say?" A: "Well, I can't tell you that ..."
- excuse-me 15y agoIt is written down, in 800 years of case law and legal decisions. It's just a little more complicated than a few cliches about "all men being equal" written by slave owners
- briandear 15y agoSorry but that's from the Declaration of Independence. By the way, those clichés were not clichés when they were written -- that's why they were so revolutionary at the time. England certainly didn't recognize individual rights at the time. Dismissing the Constitution and the Declaration as a few clichés is to reveal an ignorance of the historical context of those documents. Additionally, The British had slavery until 1833 -- slavery wasn't an American invention. Disparaging the paradox of slave owners writing all men were created equal is also revealing as to a lack of understanding of history and the context in which those documents were created as well as the political realities at the time. Stick to code, your historical snark makes you look foolish.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoSo English (UK?) constitution === stare decisis with common law? That of course makes the constitution unknowable because the supreme court, the House of Lords, can ignore precedent. So that still leaves us with no way to know the constitution the best we could hope for is to form a quorum of Lords and check that something is legally OK with them; even then they could changed their minds. I still think that without a clearly defined and codified set of basic principles a nation doesn't have what I would call a constitution.