5 ms·
EVs have more reliability problems than gas cars, says Consumer Reports
- jimbob45 3y agoLooks like they're mixing the definition of EV and hybrid. I feel like those are two separate things, particularly when we're comparing the reliability of a gas-powered vehicle versus an electric vehicle. Who's to say that the unreliability isn't coming from the gas-powered component?
- javitury 3y ago"But simpler not-plug-in hybrids bucked this trend, with 26 percent fewer reliability problems than conventionally powered vehicles." I think it makes a clear distinction between EV, plug-in hybrids and non-plug-in hybrids
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 8bitben 3y agoThe whole point of the article is basically: > EVs are still in their relative infancy as mainstream vehicles, so it’s really not surprising that manufacturers, by and large, are still working out the kinks. That said, we are seeing signs of movement in the right direction. The teething problems we are seeing with EVs are because they are new, not because they are EVs
- joezydeco 3y agoThere are some manufacturers that have historically always had lousy electrical systems in their cars. Making an entire car out of electrical systems is inviting trouble. Looking specifically at you, VAG.
- prometheus76 3y agoI don't think we have a long enough timeline of data to make that declaration yet. The problems could be intrinsic to the complexity of an EV system.
- MrMan 3y ago[dead]
- 29athrowaway 3y agoWhat kind of power grid can supply electricity to a country full of EVs?
- adrianN 3y agoThe existing power grid basically with maybe some local improvements. An ev the charges while parked averages to less power than an electric kettle.
- boatsie 3y agoA charging EV can draw 30-50 amps @220V, much more than a kettle…
- dzhiurgis 3y agoKeyword - averages. 50km a day is about 7kwh which is about 500w on average. That said my basic calculation for New Zealand is additional 50% is needed. Probably easy peasy if we get over lobby given how much existing hydro we have and capacity for sun and wind. Using Chinese offshore wind turbine costs my estimate was 1/3rd of some major railway project cost we are considering…
- acdha 3y agoHence the word “averages”: most people are going to do that every week or two overnight, when demand is well below peak. If you want a harder problem, it’s electric building heat in cold climates.
- huijzer 3y agoToday's power grid with some upgrades. The 1910s power grid also wouldn't be able to handle today's load.
- nathanaldensr 3y ago> with some upgrades You are vastly, vastly underestimating the amount of investment required. It's in the trillions of dollars.
- binarymax 3y agoUnsurprising - ICE car makers have learned hard lessons over the past 100 years. Many of those lessons translate, but not all. Add to that fact that software and electronics for the physical world are super hard to get right, so we've got alot of problems to deal with. Hybrid is weird - you need the complexities of both ICE and electric, so more complexity leads to more potential areas to fail. By the time the majority of people are driving electric, there will have been lots more iteration and the reliability will hopefully be much better.
- calvinmorrison 3y agonothing simpler than an old 1 barrel carburetor
- xnx 3y agoConsumer Reports article: https://www.consumerreports.org/cars/car-reliability-owner-satisfaction/electric-vehicles-are-less-reliable-than-conventional-cars-a1047214174/ https://www.consumerreports.org/cars/car-reliability-owner-s...
- daft_pink 3y agoI would really like deeper information about where the reliability issues are. Consumer reports did a report showing Tesla had so many more recalls, but most of the recalls were just software updates that fixed driving software. I'm much more concerned with not having my car breakdown, than random issues like not getting the charging range I expected or needing a software update, etc. I don't find the brand by brand reliability ranking very useful when comparing vehicles that have a very different profile from the other's. I need more meaningful data to make a judgment on buying vs not buying.
- EA-3167 3y agoIt gets worse, they appear to have included EV's going back 20 years. The sheer gulf in function and reliability between a 2003 EV and a 2023 EV strikes me as so immense that it must skew the chart to an extent. > CR is known for buying cars for its own test fleet, but for its annual auto reliability survey, the organization cast a wider net. Specifically, it gathered data from 330,000 owners of vehicles from model year 2000 onwards, and it uses that survey data to generate reliability scores for each vehicle and model year. Sorry, 23 years.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoAlso, forgive my ignorance, it is my understanding that EVs have way less moving parts than gas, and that is the reason why there is less maintenance needed. How's the title true?
- iamawacko 3y agoNot really all that surprising, its a new design with a lot of changes. My real problem with EV's lies in the fact that they only address a small portion of cars environmental impact. Tire bits remain dreadful. Bikes and public transport remain the better options.
- r00fus 3y agoI have long since stopped relying on consumer reports - they seem to take quixotic positions on specific vendors to try to editorialize their findings for "balance" (audience capture?) when in some years, there are clear best options. As an EV owner (and someone who owned a Prius when hybrids were new), I find a lot of the supposed issues they raised seemed trumped up and not at all something I found anecdotally as well as from friends/family or forum users online. I used to really like them but even outside of automotive, a lot of their recommendations simply didn't pan out well.
- bhandziuk 3y agoI'll scroll through my Google News app and it's riddled with articles describing the approval cost of charging vehicles, of they reliability and cost. I've been driving a Nissan Leaf for almost 2 years now. Charging is annoying but still dirt cheap, both at home and in the road. I know I've had this car for less than 2 years but it works fine. It's been great so far and it's probably the worst full EV you can buy in the US. I find it strange that there are so many alarmist articles saying how EVs aren't the panacea they're cracked up to be. But that was never how they were advertised.
- freedom-fries 3y ago> It's been great so far and it's probably the worst full EV you can buy in the US. You are right and so are the articles. Boring EVs like Nissan built are supremely reliable and cheap to run and inexpensive to repair when they do have issues, but unfortunately that's not the case for everyone else. EV market is unfortunately dominated by "fancy EV" manufacturers who have loaded the cars with fancy structure and LCD screens everywhere. Teslas and Rivians cost upwards of 10K to repair (Rivian R1T requires 20K+ for repairs for low-speed rear-end) with months long parts backlog for things like rear quarter panels. Rivian recently accidentally bricked 10% of cars on road with a new OTA firmware update while Tesla is involved in several lawsuits over its Autopilot. The story is same with other manufacturers. We don't yet have a "Toyota" of EV makers who would make a range (Sedan, SUV and a Truck) of great, reliable cars that look nice, are nearly boring to drive and inexpensive to repair.
- bhandziuk 3y agoI guess I didn't think about it like that. That my bottom of the line car is more serviceable because it doesn't have all the bells and whistles. Personally I think it still has very good cruise control (adjusts speed based on traffic and can come to a complete stop, makes an attempt to stay in the lane, maintains a safe following distance) and errors on the more conservative side (will turn off the lane maintenance feature if the lines become too difficult to see). None of that is "self driving" I guess but I find it impressive and useful still.
- 3y ago
- thegrim33 3y agoI gave up a long time ago on anything coming from Consumer Reports because by and large, as the name truly indicates, the data comes from .. consumer reports. Not actual data, but surveys of people's thoughts. If, for instance, I wanted to judge how reliable a brand of car is, I would want the data: how often they have major failures, how many miles they can go between major service issues, how many are still on the road etc., the actual data about reliability. However, the only data that consumer reports usually uses is what random polled people THINK about the reliability of the brand. Even worse, it's a self-fulfilling prophecy. They publish reports saying, for example, brand X is the most reliable brand of truck. People read those articles, and it influences their belief of which brand of truck is most reliable. Then Consumer Reports ask them next year what brand of truck they think is most reliable, and now they're more likely to say brand X, and so it's published that brand X is still the most reliable. Its an ouroboros with no actual data underneath it all.
- teachrdan 3y agoYour thinking here seems to be a bit confused. You said, "the data comes from .. consumer reports. Not actual data, but surveys of people's thoughts." But that is incorrect. It's not a survey of people's "thoughts." Survey participants: "are asked to identify problems that they considered serious (because of cost, failure, safety, or downtime). We ask them to include problems covered by warranty, but not the ones resulting from accident damage or due solely to recall. Respondents check off problems from a list of trouble areas, ranging from the engine and transmission to climate system, brakes, electrical system, and electrical accessories..."[0] Can you explain how this is "not actual data"? If it isn't, what would you expect instead -- that Consumer Reports buy a statistically significant number of all cars by all manufacturers every year and drive every single one thousands of miles and then calculate the reliability of each one? 0. https://www.consumerreports.org/cars/car-reliability-owner-satisfaction/consumer-reports-car-reliability-faq-a1099917197/ https://www.consumerreports.org/cars/car-reliability-owner-s...
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoThat's not surprising when EVs are today made by companies who were making kitchen appliances and mobile phones yesterday.