3 ms·
Why would you ever allow people to work 12-hour days on something so important? Grad student labour is cheap, surely trying to have one person do the work of tw
by lmm 3y ago
Why would you ever allow people to work 12-hour days on something so important? Grad student labour is cheap, surely trying to have one person do the work of two is a false economy.
- stickfigure 3y agoOn your next hospital visit for life-saving care, I'm sure you will be comforted to know that nurses (in the US) typically work 12 hour shifts and they're on their feet the whole time.
- darrylb42 3y agoAnd doctors doing 24h shifts. At least in the NICU my kids were in.
- ajmurmann 3y agoThis is true, but IMO doesn't refute the point, it just makes me concerned about care quality. Were there any studies that showed that the long, grueling shifts are actually better or is it simply this way because it's always been that way and change would be hard and expensive, and because "my grandma walked up hill to school both ways, so young people can too"?
- flashback2199 3y agoWho said it's gruelling? In the case of the rover, it's not year round, it's when they are preparing for a launch. Also, you're on HN, so surely you have heard of flow.
- Aurornis 3y agoNurses work 3x12 shifts to reduce the number of times patient care is handed off. If everyone worked 8 hour shifts you’d have 3 handoffs per day and a minimum of 3 different people caring for the patient. With 12 hour shifts you have only 2 handoffs per day and can have 2 people trade off on patients if their schedules line up. I’m sure it varies by location, but my nurse friends only work 3x12, giving them 4 days off per week. Working 12 hour shifts is much more acceptable when you have more days off than days spent working. They’re virtually unavailable on days they work, but then they’re off traveling or having fun for 4 days, some times more if they combine their days off back to back. My close nurse friend routinely takes week long vacations without actually taking any time off at all.
- lmm 3y agoOne of the many reasons I'd never live there. I'll stick to places with better labour laws thanks.
- elteto 3y agoSo the work is too important to work 12 hour shifts on it, yet your solution is throwing “cheap” grad students at it?
- TeMPOraL 3y agoWait until I tell you who's doing work in hospitals and how much they're being paid for it.
- dgunay 3y agoAnother relevant bit of info from hospital accidents: hand-offs between shifts are known to increase the risk of a mistake in care and are part of the reason nurses and doctors work such long hours.
- elteto 3y agoI avoid, if possible of course, going to the hospital right before a shift change for this very reason.
- noSyncCloud 3y agoI'm not questioning your logic here, but how do you keep intimate knowledge of the seasonal vagaries of shift changes at every department of your local hospital?
- TeMPOraL 3y agoYou can probably make a good guess, but at this point I wouldn't be surprised to find websites or Facebook groups dedicated to tracking this information for hospitals in any given area.
- elteto 3y agoIf you’ve been to that hospital you can easily take note. And most places have a shift change between 5-7am. This one is almost universal, as far as I have observed, even in different countries.
- flashback2199 3y ago> Grad student labour is cheap Sir, this is NASA not Kerbal space program ;)
- schmichael 3y agoI have bad news for you about health care professionals.
- foobarian 3y agoI have worse news for you about grad students.
- 542458 3y agoHealth care professionals is a weird one, because while long shifts are dangerous, patient handover is also dangerous and there may be an argument that longer shifts means fewer handovers which could result in better patient outcomes.
- 0xbadcafebee 3y agoWould we accept this if they were dealing with nukes, rather than people? Yeah we let people who haven't had sleep in 36 hours handle the nukes because having the people involved talk to each other between shifts is hard.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- anon-3988 3y agoThat just means that doctors need to handle fewer patients.
- Eisenstein 3y agoFewer patients doesn't necessarily get the patients they are handling out the door faster.
- vlovich123 3y agoThey do know roughly how long it takes to take care of a patient & should be set up with overlapping shifts and to be winding down towards a normal shift (i.e. no new patients) so that there's no handoff of a single patient but no one is working long hours. Some patients might take longer than a single shift, but handoff is inevitable at some point. You can improve your handoff processes but you can't improve the decision making of someone working a 12 hour shift.
- ahepp 3y agoOne of the hardest problems in a workplace is coordinating the workers. There's also a substantial overhead cost for every employee. I'm sure workers are less efficient at the end of a 12 hour shift, but shift changes also cost a lot and introduce lots of opportunities for errors.
- idlewords 3y agoThey definitely should have used a grad student to complete the circuit, freeing up that multimeter.
- jwrallie 3y agoI am guessing from my personal experience, but for the most part people tend to ask more repetitive technical jobs (like testing motors) to people lower in the ladder, so (relatively) less experienced people are going to touch the parts more. Then such people are doing the "actual work" and overloaded with tasks, working overtime is a rule rather than the exception. The justification for this is that he was "getting experience" for trying to move up in his career. So all good. Most people are going to remember that he messed up, rather than that he was working overtime to meet expectations, maybe except for the guy that pat him in his shoulder, he saw enough to understand it.