3 ms·
How would it even be economical for a developer to build new rent controlled housing? Or is the base set to when the apartments are constructed? If not, you don
by seanmcdirmid 3y ago
How would it even be economical for a developer to build new rent controlled housing? Or is the base set to when the apartments are constructed? If not, you don’t need to be economic illiterate to think something fishy will happen if the math doesn’t work out.
If I had a rent controlled SF apartment, why would I ever want to give it up? That’s like winning the lottery. I can see where these people are coming from.
- xenadu02 3y agoNo the idea is they can replace a 4 unit 2 story rent controlled building with a 4 story 8 unit building that now has 4 rent controlled and 4 market rate units. This is due to another Byzantine quirk of SF zoning where the neighborhood is zoned 40X (~40ft or 4 stories) but if you try to build a 4 story building you have to notify all your neighbors and they get the chance to demand discretionary review, forcing your project to go before the planning commission for a vote. People also pull this crap for simple additions to existing houses. At any rate the state is demanding reduced setbacks, elimination of neighbor notification and DR, etc. This would apply to other normal projects too, turning a lot more stuff into "by-right" approval: if you meet the set standards you can get a rubber stamp at the permit desk and no one can block you.
- mint2 3y agoThe neighbor notification and design review are nice ideas in theory but in practice they turn building into a nightmare. I wish new builds weren’t so bland and ugly, but that’s by far the lesser of the evils at this point. I hope the crazy tall outer sunset tower gets built so it’s a kick in the pants to cut the red tape and at least allow mid rise without any of the BS that even a single family home construction is face with at present. Actually if anything, single family houses should be banned in the core city including parts of the sunset and Richmond.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoRent control means base rent is set when the tenant moves in, not when the building is built. Its therefore reset with new tenants. It also doesn’t lock you into this rate, but simply to a rate better pegged to wage growth. E.g. outside covid extreme measures rent control could mean rent can be raised 4-5% a year sometimes. Rent control really just prevents huge price gouging more than anything.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThey are limited to 60% of CPI growth, so over ten years that adds up to much cheaper rents than market. It still turns into a huge benefit that no one would want to give up, you have winners (who have rent control apartments) who don’t want to give them up to allow for more density.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoHow they are structured depends on municipality. Right now in SF its apparently set at 3.6%. Imo CPI is hardly relevant here, what is relevant is wage growth and typically thats always lagged behind. SF interestingly has stated going forward minimum wages will be based on some cpi calculation. Realistically if you applied rent control over the entire bay area any concerns regarding its ability to disadvantage building is moot at that point. The true limiting factor is probably a combination of zoning as well as onerous permitting and review processes. People in rent control units do get developed upon, they often readily accept buy out offers for example that are a rounding error for multimilliondollar apartment development projects. I believe redevelopment or renovation would count as just cause to evict but ianal.
- yonran 3y ago> you don’t need to be economic illiterate to think something fishy will happen It’s not the city’s job to make good things illegal because they are too good to pencil out. But by “economic illiteracy”, I was referring to tenant groups’ reasons for opposing unsubsidized housing. Excuses such as that San Francisco had increased vacancies during the pandemic and thus not need any more housing. Or that San Francisco already met its RHNA housing quota for 2014-2022 (which was way too low since it was calculated based on outdated population growth trends rather than rents). Or denial that housing construction has any affect on rent. These are not fringe positions; these are the canon of the self-proclaimed “progressive” faction in San Francisco (see Supervisor Peskin’s statements in https://sfgov.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=6412806&GUID=4DEFDA6D-09E3-48E1-8E57-283310D51F54 https://sfgov.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=6412806... and https://twitter.com/_fruchtose/status/1729280621313511602 https://twitter.com/_fruchtose/status/1729280621313511602 and basically any article on 48hills.org). The set of policies they support are basically to reduce for-profit apartment development by increasing neighbor veto points, ask for increased funding for favored nonprofits, increase tenant protections, and watch as rents rise.