3 ms·
Honestly I kind of assumed that was the future direction, especially with their work on rootful xwayland - I'm surprised that they didn't emphasize that path fo
by yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago
Honestly I kind of assumed that was the future direction, especially with their work on rootful xwayland - I'm surprised that they didn't emphasize that path forward.
Edit: Though I do feel obligated to say that
> Today, Wayland has been recognized as the de-facto windowing and display infrastructure solution.
Is... optimistic. It has been called that, usually by people busy explaining why your use case isn't valid and shut up already about Wayland's shortcomings, but that's not quite the same as it being true.
- dathinab 3y ago> Is... optimistic. RHES is looking at their (potential) paying customers, not Linux in general. And a lot of that are in a context where there are many further restrictions to what can be run and how thinks can be setup. For example software whitelists and/or multi device administration where you are not admin on you desktop system. This for example means that for them most windows managers which are not GNOME/KDE did never matter for them at all (and just to be clear most means most, there are some exceptions). And XWayland is also still around in RHEL10 which mean the only problem are applications which 1. for their customers matter, 2. do not work correctly with XWayland, 3. can not be ported to a newer version of their GUI framework which supports Wayland. Which let's be honest aren't that many to begin with and mainly was stuff like e.g. missing HDR support for certain VFX use cases and similar, whist has been fixed by now. So for RHEL this isn't "optimistic" but very realistic and based on facts derived from studies done with their customers, not some "busy people".
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoI really struggle to read "the de-facto windowing and display infrastructure solution" as "for our super narrow usecases" rather than a very general claim. Though yes, if that's the meaning then it's much easier to defend; if RH knows that none of their customers need an actual raw Xorg server without xwayland, then it's really easy for them to say that they can drop Xorg proper.
- dathinab 3y agoI personally would not call it super narrow or even narrow. Sure it's non end user, but non end user desktop Linux is not as narrow as it might seem. Through it's not well represented on HN I think. Most important both GNOME and KDE have embraced Wayland as the de-facto standard with their latest/upcoming versions and when it comes to commercial Linux desktop usage outside of some special cases only GNOME and KDE matter (and all the special cases I currently can come up with also use Wayland, but that might be due to my limited knowledge about special cases). Other DE are nice and fun but in relevant amounts I'm only seeing them on privately managed (but not necessary privately owned and used) desktops.
- MBCook 3y ago>> Today, Wayland has been recognized as the de-facto windowing and display infrastructure solution. > Is... optimistic. Is it? Wayland is largely developed by the old X developers. They’re the ones who say Wayland is the future and there is nothing else. Xorg hasn’t been under real active development for a very long time. The people in the best place to decide decided. They’ve been fixing the remaining issues. There is no path forward for Xorg. It won’t get better. Only Wayland has a future.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago> There is no path forward for Xorg. It won’t get better. Only Wayland has a future. Well nobody tell the folks shipping new features[0]; I'd hate for them to realize. That said, as an active user, I don't really need X to get better, I just need it to keep working until either Wayland actually catches up, or everyone moves on to the next thing and that manages feature parity. [0] https://www.phoronix.com/news/Modesetting-TearFree-Merged https://www.phoronix.com/news/Modesetting-TearFree-Merged , https://www.phoronix.com/news/X.Org-Server-21.1 https://www.phoronix.com/news/X.Org-Server-21.1
- arp242 3y ago> Wayland is largely developed by the old X developers. They’re the ones who say Wayland That doesn't mean it's any good. Or that they're right. "The people in the best place to decide decided" is a hugely fallacious argument. You can say that about any controversial change to anything and dismiss any argument out of hand with that.
- MBCook 3y agoI’m going to assume they know better than random people do. Simply because they have the experience. But thats not all I was really trying to get. Also: that there are no major Xorg developers left. All the ones that knew that weird massive codebase moved over to Wayland. If a whole bunch of developers wanted to pick up Xorg and fix its issues and move it forward (no one has yet) they have a very very deep hole to dig himself out of it just understanding how everything that’s there works and how fragile it is.