3 ms·
For all three, it's a problem of demand exceeding supply, because supply is artificially constrained (and inefficiently allocated). 1. Housing. Increase supply
by ethbr1 3y ago
For all three, it's a problem of demand exceeding supply, because supply is artificially constrained (and inefficiently allocated).
1. Housing. Increase supply of affordable housing. Which means upzoning existing land for denser redevelopment. Which means more public transit. (And outlaw the realtor / commission system for transactions)
2. Health care. Increase supply of GPs and allow mid-level providers more independence (within bounds) to take less complex work off their plates. (There's also the inefficiencies created by the ridiculous number of middle layers. To which, single payer)
3. Tuition. Make highly-automated online degrees the new base normal to increase scalability of the system. (And use the stick of government tuition assistance to bludgeon any university that disagrees or exceeds set administration cost caps)
- api 3y agoFor tuition I don’t think you even need the tech approach. Just cut university administrative and construction overhead. Both of those areas have bloated massively, fueled by lots of easy student loan money. Student aid and subsidized loans should require that the admin to teacher ratio not exceed a certain value. That would help a lot. For the others you nailed it. Housing is tough though, because the existing policy is a massive success for older homeowners who bought before the prices rose and property speculators.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> Just cut university administrative and construction overhead. Both of those areas have bloated massively, fueled by lots of easy student loan money. Hence the solution is cutting off the student loan money spigot. Everything else will automatically fall into place.
- bluGill 3y agoAutomatically, after 30 years of pain. There is no easy answer. I'm about the last person ever to pay full tuition while working, no loans or other help. In 30 years we can make that normal, but it will take that long to figure out how, and I pity any youngster stuck in the middle while we work on it.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIf the money stops flowing tomorrow, then universities start cutting costs tomorrow. And tuition prices are much lower the day after tomorrow.
- lotsoweiners 3y agoSo they start cramming even more students into classrooms and creating other new, innovative ways of getting money and giving the students less for it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 3y agoWithout access to unlimited taxpayer underwritten loans, students will not have money to give to schools. And one can safely assume schools are already cramming students as much as they can to maximize budget for other expenses that benefit administration. In any case, the number of students should be declining for a very long time, so they will have to figure out how to compete for the students’ business.
- bluGill 3y agoIt isn't that fast. Even if the money stops tomorrow (which it won't - there are a lot of laws in place that need to be found and undone), universities will take a long time to adjust. They have contracts they need to pay. They are in debt to pay for those buildings and that needs to be paid. Which is why I said 30 years - that is a much more realistic timeline.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoBankruptcy protocols would be utilized. There is no mandate for US federal taxpayers to keep subsidizing universities’ largesse. If they are in debt for fancy athletic facilities and don’t have the cash flow to service the debt, that is between them and the lender. Congress can surely do pass a law removing access to taxpayer backed student plans starting whenever they want.
- acdha 3y agoFor tuition, I’d also be okay with funding it as an investment. Prior to the late 1970s, tuition at the UC system was nominal – where the “part time summer job paid for college” beliefs came from – and it worked out well for California having so many graduates paying taxes for decades to come. The idea that education should be paid by the student is just tragically shortsighted (and dovetailed with nastier things: a lot of the late-70s “taxpayer revolt” stuff was also older white people deciding they didn’t want to pay for things their own kids no longer needed because the current beneficiaries didn’t look like them).
- WalterBright 3y agoHousing, health care, and tuition were all far less expensive before the government got involved in them. More government interference will not improve matters.
- arp242 3y agoAnd all this things are vastly cheaper almost anywhere else in the world. And almost everywhere government is hugely more involved than the U.S. And I don't mean just "Europe": also South-America and Asia. But maybe the U.S. is a super-special case and whatever works for the rest of the world doesn't work for the US shrug.
- WalterBright 3y agoWhen I attended Caltech, I paid for junior and senior year tuition, room and board with a job that paid $5/hr. No loans, no scholarship, no subsidy. Single family home ownership rates were the highest in the world. Healthcare cost a tiny fraction of what it does now.
- ethbr1 3y agoWas the government less involved? My general sense was that the government was equally (or more) monetarily involved, in terms of total funding sums. But less involved with regulating. Then, inevitably, fraud and scandal happened, which begat additional regulation, which begat regulatory capture by industry. And then the government stopped directly buying/doing most things, which introduced a new layer of intermediaries, which in turn required additional regulation to police. The older I get, the more I think paying the graft tax for direct government production but getting a simpler, more manageable/agile system might be a preferable outcome. But I just went through Springfield Armory last week... which managed to supply 1/2 a Civil War, most of 2 World Wars, and innumerable minor wars from a government enterprise (while innovating). So maybe government successes are readily at hand in my mind.
- WalterBright 3y ago> Was the government less involved? Yes. A lot less. The US government was fairly small until WW2. > So maybe government successes are readily at hand in my mind. You have to look at the cost before determining if it is a success. Not simply the volume of production.