4 ms·
People shouldn't bother you about wearing a mask, or bother storekeepers who request patrons mask, but a reason to push back on state-mandated masking isn't tha
by tptacek 3y ago
People shouldn't bother you about wearing a mask, or bother storekeepers who request patrons mask, but a reason to push back on state-mandated masking isn't that COVID isn't serious (it clearly is), but rather that the empirical evidence for masking, especially vs. the new strains, is quite weak
- graeme 3y ago>the empirical evidence for masking, especially vs. the new strains, is quite weak If you're wearing an N95 or KN95 the filtration efficacy is quite high. Most of the mask studies looked at whether mask policies lowered covid. If you wear a mask in class but then take it off in the cafeteria or outside of school, the mask no longer has an effect. If, however, you wear a mask with high filtration efficacy while outside of the house, that's a different story. To my knowledge we have no challenge trial of people wearing such a mask when exposed to an infectious agent. It is folly to ignore the physical mechanism of such masks when reasoning about them, and defaulting to only considering the studies we have, which simply cannot measure efficacy when the mask is worn. This study on parachutes is a good analogue: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC300808/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC300808/
- tptacek 3y agoN95 vs. KN95 seems like an instructive example: people equate the two based on the effectiveness of the filtering media, but the salient difference is in the attachment mechanism --- most KN95s are ear-loops, and don't achieve especially tight coverings (similarly: the reuse concerns about N95s are less that the filter media can't be "recharged" or whatever, but rather that the elastic gives out). At any rate: masks as worn in the real world seem pretty performative, for a variety of reasons. If you're wearing them carefully, that's great, and I appreciate it. Nobody should be messing with you regardless. You can look epidemiologically at this stuff and see that states with laxer regulations fared pretty well in the early COVID years, and appear to have fallen off only with the introduction of vaccines, which really seem like the high-order bit of COVID control.
- jeffbee 3y agoI don't know what's "performative" about it. The respirator has a clear mechanism of action. They filter out almost all airborne viruses and are even better at filtering bacteria (which are larger). They also have the side benefit of making the wearer not want to eat airline "food" which I've noticed leaves me feeling better when I arrive. They are designed to be worn effectively even by illiterate manual laborers, so it's not as if you need to be a PhD to get one on your face.
- Scoundreller 3y agoWhat I like about wearing a mask on a plane is that I rebreathe some exhaled moisture. Though I did a flight in mid 2020 and I'd inhale, move mask, take bite/sip, exhale while putting mask back, and then breathe normally through mask. Was probably a bit unnecessary when the flights were basically empty, but reduced-risk eating/drinking is possible.
- jeffbee 3y agoI noticed something similar: no nosebleeds. I have only taken a few flights in the last several years though and I can't rule out that maybe the 737 MAX has a more humid interior atmosphere or something like that. But before I started wearing masks on airplanes I used to shoot saline spray up my nostrils every hour to keep the nosebleeds away.
- Krssst 3y agoAlso: I find that the air feels warmer in winter when breathing through a mask.
- Scoundreller 3y agoYeah, it’s up there with water is wet. Ever wonder why your shoulders don’t get dry in winter but your face does?
- graeme 3y agoCompletely agree that an ear loop is less effective than a headstrap. The question is: by how much? This beard length mask study is a good source of data. They actually measured fitted filtration efficacy at different beard lengths, including zero beard. N95 was near 100%. KN95 was between 80-90% (surprisingly, higher with a small bit of beard, around 0.5-1mm). Now, you could certainly argue that 80-90% filtration is performative, but on what evidence? We know from hepa filtration studies that lowering the concentration of virus in the air lowers infection amongst those in a room. So from physical mechanisms we would expect that reducing inhaled virus by 80-90% should likewise reduce risk of infection. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34006963/#&gid=article-figures&pid=fig-2-uid-1 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34006963/#&gid=article-figur...
- vlovich123 3y agoYes they are effective, but don’t forget that they’re not perfect - your eyes and ears remain as access ports for the virus even when wearing a mask. Probably eyes is the biggest after respiratory because glasses have been shown to decrease infections if I recall correctly.
- Sakos 3y agoIt doesn't need to be perfect in order to be effective. What's your point?
- Scoundreller 3y agoPersonally, I think the ocular route has been under-investigated in transmission.
- vlovich123 3y agoJust that the sequence of events is "I'm told masks prevent COVID" => "I was wearing a mask and got COVID" => "masks don't stop COVID" (or it happens to a friend or a friend of a friend etc). You have to explain that masks help prevent it but aren't perfect because your eyes & ears remain open (my hunch is that it's likely the eyes as the next major transmission vector so glasses or full goggles would be almost fully effective).
- mrb 3y agoThere is a lot of empirical evidence supporting the effectiveness of masks against COVID-19, and I would not call it weak. In my own quest for actual research instead of single data points ("I never mask and have never gotten COVID"), I found that out of 27 peer-reviewed studies, 22 of them show masks are effective: https://github.com/mbevand/masking-effectiveness https://github.com/mbevand/masking-effectiveness
- Krssst 3y agoI am a developer, not a doctor, so I just rely.on health authorities as imperfect as they are: https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7106e1.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7106e1.htm .
- tptacek 3y agoPublic health authorities didn't exactly cover themselves in glory from 2020-2022. Scientists did! But there's a world of difference between a public health practitioner and a microbiologist or physical chemist or chemical engineer.
- greyface- 3y agoAre you suggesting that microbiologists, physical chemists, and chemical engineers now claim that properly fitted N95 masks are ineffective in reducing the transmission of current strains of COVID?
- amatecha 3y agoWell, first off I'm going to say "citation needed", but secondly, I haven't had a single transmissible illness since I started wearing KN95 whenever I'm around people indoors. This includes going to crowded markets, trans-continental flights, a recent concert... Of course, wearing some flimsy loose thing that barely even covers your face (like those "surgical" masks that are typically handed out) is certainly going to be of limited usefulness. A decently-fitting N95/KN95 , well.. it works.
- Aaronstotle 3y agoI have only gotten sick once in the last 2 years and I haven't worn any type of mask since restrictions lifted.
- naasking 3y ago> I haven't had a single transmissible illness since I started wearing KN95 whenever I'm around people indoors You mean you haven't gotten ill since you started being hyperparanoid about getting ill? Sure, that's not really surprising. Tying the result specifically to the masking itself is still speculative though, as would be generalizing your specific case to the whole population, eg. as you say, "decently fitting N95" is probably key, but how many are going to be that vigilant?
- vlovich123 3y agoThis really gives off to me the same vibes as when doctors were up in arms that washing hands before surgery couldn’t possibly have an effect on the outcome. We know that such viruses have to enter your body through eyes, ears, nose or throat or there’s no way to get an infection. Why do you think it’s so surprising that blocking access to your respiratory system by a filter that is small enough to exclude the virus (whether cold, flu or COVID) prevents you from getting sick? Furthermore, if I recall correctly there’s studies showing efficacy of having even a basic cloth covering helps because the thickness of the material means that even if the virus is small enough to get through, the probability of crossing all the layers through the cloth is harder. Picking up illness from contact with a surface -> touching your face is a much more difficult infection vector than the direct access port available through the communication ports on your head.
- vik0 3y ago>but rather that the empirical evidence for masking, especially vs. the new strains, is quite weak https://medium.com/incerto/the-masks-masquerade-7de897b517b7 https://medium.com/incerto/the-masks-masquerade-7de897b517b7
- doctorhandshake 3y agoI’d be curious to read more on that - any citations?