3 ms·
Thoughty2 on youtube has said the name 'dead internet theory' is a misnomer. Dead internet prophecy is a better term for it. It's kind of like being in the midd
by pixl97 3y ago
Thoughty2 on youtube has said the name 'dead internet theory' is a misnomer. Dead internet prophecy is a better term for it. It's kind of like being in the middle of an extinction, yea there are still some animals left, but everything is looking unhealthy and the outlook isn't promising.
- gumballindie 3y agoIn a world where everything is procedurally generated and people’s property stolen there is no benefit of using the internet for anything else but e-commerce or porn. Perhaps a few communities here and there populated by sane people otherwise it will be filled with dubious content.
- generalizations 3y agoSo we build AI tooling to parse the internet on our behalf and find us the content we want. News will still be available, and users, to some level of verification or another, will still be communicating - we're not all going to just stop using the internet...even with massive amounts of noise it's still better than nothing. We'll just build better and better tools for sifting through the chaos. Probably, we'll end up with a new paradigm for web browsers that involves a lot of filtering on top of the morass of raw internet. Dunno exactly what it'll look like, but it'll probably involve multiple LLMs and some kind of abstraction on top of 'web pages'.
- hotpotamus 3y agoIs it old and curmudgeonly of me to say that sounds terrible and I want no part of it? As though our filter bubbles aren't already driving us into our own realities already.
- JohnFen 3y agoI agree. The very notion seems unacceptably dystopian and likely to make a lot of the bad things about the web even worse.
- foobarian 3y agoMaybe the web of trust will finally become a useful tool.
- gumballindie 3y agoProblem is that building these tools at the expense of genuine content creators will alienate said content creators. The end result with be a south park type of human centipede that few sane people will want to be a part of. I expect communities to become more segregated - as in real life where small communities isolate away from criminals - and more closed. It makes sense considering rampant theft, misinformation and ever increasing dubiousness that plagues the internet as a medium - in no small part thanks to procedural content generators that are schizoidly compared to human intelligence.
- JohnFen 3y agoIf we need to use AI in order to make the web even moderately useful, then the web is truly dead. > even with massive amounts of noise it's still better than nothing Nothing isn't the alternative. If the web literally vanished tomorrow, we still have other existing ways of communicating, researching, and recreating.
- pixl97 3y agoYou're assuming some place that's not the internet will exist. At least in the US with our worse than lax privacy laws, devices that turn IRL occurrences into digital data will multiply until there is simply no where left unconnected. Is your friend running a phone app that's identifying the people around them and the topics they are interested in, all while earning a few dollars? Where are you getting news from that's not just the firehose of falsehood? Do you really trust the people sending it to you, or are they profiting off of shoveling bullshit in to the feed?
- kjkjadksj 3y agoThe silver lining might be its hardly worse than how its already been. People complain we are entering an era of a firehose of falsehood. Its been that way since propaganda was rebranded as public relations after the first world war, probably longer even. You never are exposed to the full truth, the facts, the contexts. The incentives to shift opinions are too high to ever simply faithfully educate the populace. Control of the common narrative of “truth” is highly profitable, and these reins of power will never not be controlled by some entity.
- JohnFen 3y ago> there is no benefit of using the internet for anything else but e-commerce or porn. For me, this is already about 80% true. The web is largely a vast wasteland at this point.
- SleepilyLimping 3y agoI've regularly thought "what's the point of creating, taking photographs or putting effort into [artistic endeavour] if it means that it's just going to be stolen and reposted on Instagram, Reddit, TikTok ad nauseum?" Obviously there ARE points to doing so, but it feels ultra-shitty that you're consigning yourself to having your work stolen if you're good enough.
- mattgreenrocks 3y agoCombine dead internet prophecy with the idea that most people commenting on the Internet are slightly crazy and the statistics look even worse.
- geph2021 3y agoeven here on HN, the percentage of AI generated comments has to be increasing day by day. I have to assume that some have created HN commenter bots, even just as a hobby/learning project.
- mjr00 3y agoDo you have any examples of comments you believe were generated by AI? In my experience, ChatGPT has a very distinctive writing style that's easy to identify, even if you "prompt engineer" to get something a little less generic. It also tends to not write anything of substance. The very few GPT-generated comments I've seen tend to get downvoted into oblivion.
- geph2021 3y agoI do not have anything specific. I have read threads where someone, usually with snark, responds with a comment of the sort "are you a bot?", or "you sound like chatGPT". That's probably only been a couple times over a few months, and I'm on HN reading threads multiple times a day, so it's not very frequent. But it does make me wonder... That distinctive ChatGPT style will become less recognizable. IMHO, bot content in the HN comments should be fairly low, but non-zero. I don't think there's much, if any, incentive to invest much in an HN comment bot, but with all these hackers/coders some would do it just out of curiosity/challenge.
- yoyohello13 3y agoI've come across some comments that just feel a bit off, you know? Like they're trying a bit too hard to be informative without really getting to the point. It's like they're dancing around the conversation.
- JohnFen 3y agoEven if there are no AI generated comments, the very fact that there could be means that every comment will be judged for whether or not they're real. This will certainly some cause real comments to be disregarded. That's already degrading the quality of all online discussions all by itself.
- soupfordummies 3y agoI use reddit a good bit still (as I'm sure most of you do as well) and I'm starting to notice more and more comments (and accounts, by extension) that are blatantly and clearly "ChatGPT" responses. Like, it's obvious just by skimming the content because it's clearly just "ChatGPT-style".