7 ms·
Tata Consultancy Services ordered to cough up $210M in code theft trial
- achow 3y agoAt the end of article.. However, the champagne corks won't be popping at CSC just yet. If the Epic experience is anything to go by – the decision was appealed – there will likely be legal twists and turns aplenty before payments are made and the case is closed. 6 days ago: TCS will be making a balance provision of $125 million in the December quarter of FY24, after the US Supreme Court rejected the company's plea in a matter pertaining to EPIC Systems Corporation. https://www.fortuneindia.com/enterprise/tcs-to-make-125-mn-balance-provision-in-q3-after-us-court-rejects-plea-in-epic-systems-case/114807 https://www.fortuneindia.com/enterprise/tcs-to-make-125-mn-b...
- xNeil 3y agoI'm surprised the US Supreme Court is hearing cases filed against or by TCS.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoTCS conducts business in the US, so it is subject to US courts.
- wging 3y agoThey didn’t hear it, and therefore the lower court’s decision remains in place. That’s what this means: > the United States Supreme Court on November 20, 2023 rejected the Company’s petition to file an appeal against the orders passed by the US Court of Appeals, 7th Circuit
- spaceman_2020 3y agoHow soon - if ever - will AI tools be able to replace or at least reduce the demand for these offshoring companies? I've seen the code some of them put out. Even chatGPT 3.5 can be better than them.
- pjmlp 3y agoBeware of one wishes for, it starts with offshoring companies, juniors will follow and eventually only the AI druids will code.
- thejackgoode 3y agoprompt shamans, yes
- HenryBemis 3y agoNope it cannot. I have been using 3.5 to write code. I wrote a 'simple' app (200-300 lines) that although 'simple' it took A LOT of back and forth with the 3.5. In the end I had to spend a couple of days combing through it to add some key features (i.e. set values to zero so you don't see old data, etc.). Basically crude (but smart?) coding (I am not a professional developer). When I finished the code and the app was performing EXACTLY as I wanted (v1.0), I thought to start planning for the v1.1 and when I pasted my code to the 3.5 and asked it to 'work on it on the new features' it was a shitstorm :) Perhaps it was me feeding the requirements 'wrongly', but it was like pulling teeth 'guiding' it to correct even the simplest mistakes.
- lacrimacida 3y agoGPT can sew snippets of code and see patterns but it has no understanding of coding and such. But even without this ability it could work amazingly well if you know what to ask for and accept its limitations.
- IggleSniggle 3y agoThis is also how it is with offshoring.
- BoorishBears 3y agoSomeone who's not a professional developer was able to take the weakest model OpenAI offers today and get exactly what they wanted for a V1. Have you actually worked with a consultancy? Have you priced out what the back and forth you had with 3.5 would have cost with a real human with a similar level of depth? _ I personally don't think AI's effect on offshoring will be so cut and dry, since it's not like offshore developers can't level up with it too, but your example is showing how badly people are underestimating the impact AI will have on programming.
- srvmshr 3y agoWithout sounding controversial and having peers in Infosys/TCS since college days, I can attest that leaking design & implementation decisions between projects is very common in consultancies. I have personally privy to one such story where choices made in one healthcare giant's systems were "modified/adapted" to another. IP issues galore, these should be red flags but sneak under the radar being a consultancy
- neuronic 3y agoTo contextualize this, in my experience this doesn't happen as a result of some malicious conspiracy but rather as a natural outcome of working with various projects and exchanging with colleagues in various projects. For the consultancy it boils down to not reinventing the wheel, learning from others and sharing knowledge about what works and what doesn't. Typically, what is shared are anonymized generic design or cases and not actual code or design files though. Of course what is knowledge sharing and efficiency for consultants might simply boil down to IP theft for the affected companies. My question is rather how much of it is natural human social interaction and collaboration if you put dozens of people from dozens of projects into one room talking about a similar problem.
- firebirdn99 3y agoIt's not necessarily consultants in these companies that are malicious. I find working with many to be honest, and deeply caring about their work. It's that some of the management in these companies are incentivized to engage in duplicitous behavior to gain clients one way or another. Working for a tech consultancy before, they do have clear lines to distinguish for legal reasons and make you take courses. For e.g., you can't give or receive gifts of any monetary value, etc. But management find other ways, to gain client's trust and affection. One way is to overwork the consultants, and other is to share information that is privy sometimes.
- iamshs 3y agoMy Indian Engineering college had no course on ethics and nor were ethics mentioned even once. While Ethics was a mandatory course in my Masters abroad. Indian engineering colleges really need to start cleaning up the detritus, it is time to provide healthy base for the young ones. Once a culture builds up, the managers at consultancy will feel ashamed to cut loose on ethics even under pressure. Or not, but a start has to be made in this aspect.
- HenryBemis 3y ago> These former employees had access to its code and documents, and forwarded them on to the Tata BaNCS development team And these (ladies and gentlemen) is why you need smart IT auditors in your corporations. Also robust DLP systems with alerts when emails are sent to 'some' specific domains.
- IG_Semmelweiss 3y ago"Copied on the wrong email" may cost them 210M Company CFO and CIOs need to do better dilligence of their vendors. Two simple contract clauses: priced soliciting to price staff pouching, and treble-5x damages for IP theft. Develop a heuristic - any consultancies brought on from 3rd party contracts must sign enhanced protection clauses. Cite publicly available info to support your position. All it takes is a quick google and a few boilerplate clauses
- monero-xmr 3y agoTrick of the trade - either keep a former employee’s email active or just forward all emails to their address to something searchable. Especially if they are an older exec that was terminated, because they will fuck stuff up all the time with their boomer butter fingers. You will get CCs on all sorts of email chains which will help you in future litigation and termination issues.
- fipar 3y agoYou could have given the same advice (which is very good, I do the same) without the age reference because if you've only seen boomers fuck up with butter fingers, you've been very lucky! (Preemptive disclaimer that I'm not a boomer. I'm not from the US, but if I were, I'd be gen X).
- eddtries 3y agoYou’re actually gen X outside of the US too, unfortunately!
- rithikjainNd01 3y agoThat’s not true! Google “Indian Generations” to understand where the difference lies. I believe it’s divided like so: 1947-65: Invested in National Success and self determination. Do more with less is key. Govt Jobs are the best jobs. 65-80: First Gen to start moving abroad, more private opportunities, care about making money and enterprise. 81-00: First exposure to the West, TV, entertainment. More holistic in their wants and desires, such as love. Witnessed the westernization. 00-16: Grew up with Western ideas and tech right beside them. More online, more diverse etc.
- doubt_me 3y ago[flagged]
- RunSet 3y agoOn this week's episode of "CEO or LLM?": > "In any given quarter, there will always be some amount of de-growth. What's happening now is that de-growth is not being compensated fully because clients are optimising and there is some deferral happening," said K Krithivasan, MD & CEO, TCS. > "If the existing projects get paused or optimised more than the incoming revenue, it results in muted or moderated revenue growth," Krithivasan added. > According to Krithivasan, once things settle down, this optimisation will be compensated by new projects.
- usrusr 3y ago“Nice LLM you have there. Would be a shame if someone added CEO gibberish to the training set"
- kibwen 3y agoNo, that's a feature. Replacing your gormless CEO with a machine is one of the highest-impact ways to leverage an LLM. Frankly, it's a shame that OpenAI is too afraid to eat their own dogfood.
- londons_explore 3y ago"optimization" means "our clients are spending less money with us".
- deathtrader666 3y agoProfessionals in the software service industry have mastered the art of saying "shit has hit the roof" without any shit. This, combined with "never saying no" and "never give bad news", has twisted simple communication behaviours.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThis is the first time I have read shit has hit the roof. It is usually shit hits the fan.
- ActionHank 3y ago
- lawlessone 3y agoI remember some TATA people visited my college. It was supposed some event about signing up for intern roles with them. Instead they had some activity that people had to do and it was more like a mini competition. The example activity was they had acquired some company and the objective of the task was giving ways to tear the acquired company apart to extract value (layoffs, spinoffs, IP etc). I left during the break. It's a bottom to top evil company.
- mikelovenotwar 3y ago>It's a bottom to top evil company. Worked there for a while, can confirm
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- neilv 3y agoThat sounds like a refreshingly upfront recruiting first impression. And the winning kid to join the Wonka consultancy was the one who not only chopped up the hypothetical company, like all the other kids did... but then also loaded what remained with debt, while self-dealing (or whatever it is they do)?
- dingi 3y agoOne of our clients had a consultancy agreement with TCS. As one of their software vendors, we had to work with some TCS guys. It looked like their job was to make other people's work harder. They were full of work politics, bad mouthing other people, and shit like that. They didn't seem to be good at their job either.
- mavelikara 3y agoMany of these business domains - insurance, healthcare etc - have complex state-specific business rules evolved over decades. I’d even suspect that the software implementations in some big players, like Epic, would be the default interpretation of some regulations (like, say, CRuby acts as the specification for Ruby language). It seems TCS might have tried to plagiarize those rule implementations.
- GabeIsko 3y agoNo, it's probably implementation specific. They probably refered to some documents regarding the ongoing implementation of a DXC app. Remember that with the enterprise deals it is pretty custom how these things are deployed. CSC probably set something up for Transamerica, and then info about it leaked to TCS. Probably through one of the 2000 Transamerica employees they poached. I doubt there is any internal platform documentation that got leaked, or that CSC even has access to from its vendors that TCS doesn't. Who knows what kind of vendors are under the hood of this thing.
- GabeIsko 3y agoMan, it sucks that the law makes this situation. Texas would rather punish TCS than have stuff work well. But I guess you can't go around sharing confidential information - it's a big no no in these contracts. TCS should know better.
- mikelovenotwar 3y ago>Texas would rather punish TCS than have stuff work Why would it have to be one, and not both?
- GabeIsko 3y agoLet's say that I hire you as a software engineer. I tell you to implement several new features in the product you are assigned to. But, you aren't allowed to read any documentation or source code of the project you are working on. It exists, but by law you aren't allowed to read it. That's the situation TCS contractors are in. Now, laws are laws, and we have to follow them. There is always plenty of money to do things by the book. I thought this was a gov. project, not insurance, but the principle is the same. Transamerica is getting worse service because the contractor that they prefer wanted to look at documentation for a system they payed for. This is why enterprise IT is a legally mandated mess.
- mikelovenotwar 3y ago> That's the situation TCS contractors are in. Now, laws are laws, and we have to follow them. There is always plenty of money to do things by the book. I thought this was a gov. project, not insurance, but the principle is the same. Transamerica is getting worse service because the contractor that they prefer wanted to look at documentation for a system they payed for. This is why enterprise IT is a legally mandated mess. This is not the case. Regardless you state that there is a single choice to be made, getting something that works OR having it done legally.
- AlotOfReading 3y agoIt sucks that they wrote a contract where they didn't have legal access to redistribute documentation to the contractors they hired, but them's the breaks when you write shitty contracts. Any insurance company has armies of lawyers available, so it's hard to feel bad for them.
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoMakes me wonder if they did the same for a large system we built for a state agency. I was lead developer on that project, so I'm pretty familiar with most aspects of it. The first few years after delivery, the agency had us come back a couple of times for change requests and to train their in-house developer when there was turnover in that role. At some point after I left that consultancy, the agency switched to using TCS. A few years later, several other states had very similar systems built for them by TCS. While I can't see any of the internal management portions, based on URLs, the public facing portals all use similar somewhat obsolete tech stacks. The workflow is also the same. But I have no way of knowing what happened behind the scenes. Perhaps the state agency gave TCS a license to use the code we developed (the agency, not our consultancy, retained ownership of the code). Or maybe some of the TCS people who worked on maintaining the code for the agency later went on to build a new system from scratch inspired heavily by our system. There's no way to really know from my vantage point, but given this story, it sure makes me wonder.
- thunkshift1 3y agoDidn’t Nvidia also get pulled up by courts recently for stealing code? I am not condoning either action, but this seems to be a tech culture issue of which almost every company seems to be guilty of rather than just everyone’s fav punching bag tcs.
- 8BitArmour 3y agoThis HN post w.r.t TCS has aged like wine: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2628318 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2628318
- Obscurity4340 3y agoTata!