6 ms·
When will global greenhouse gas emissions peak?
- eigenspace 3y agoI moved to Germany this year from Canada, and I've been incredibly impressed with the speed and aggressiveness with which Germany has been pursuing renewable energy sources[1]. This is great news because it's happening despite the fact that Germany is really not an ideally situated country for any of the major renewable energy sources, so these advances are applicable to other countries in ways that e.g. the experiences in Denmark or South Australia might not. The buildout of renewable energy sources in Germany has been so widespread and so successful that they're no longer the interesting part of the problem. Now that the electrical grid here is averaging 60-70% renewable electricity in any month of the year, the limiting factors now are energy storage, and long-distance flexible transmission of electricity. Transmission lines are a not-so-sexy, but totally vital part of running a grid with so much intermittent electricity production that's only accurately forcastable a few days in advance. There's been a lot of HVDC lines build connecting Germany to the UK and various scandinavian countries, but one of the biggest things we're still waiting on is a new link from the north of the country to the south. The south has more solar resources, and the north has more wind resources, so there needs to be way more capacity to share. Storage is going to be a very hard problem to tackle and has a less clear path forward. Batteries are going to play an important role, but in the near term they're likely only to be valuable for smoothing out supply and demand over a two to three day window. Something that doesn't get discussed very much though is how much bio-gas Germany generates. German farmer collective, landfill operators, and wastewater operators actually make quite a bit of money by using specialized bacteria to compost organic material and generate methane. Bio-gas is responsible for around 8-9% of German electricity generation. It's currently used in a very consistent way, with the same amount being burned nearly every hour of every day, but eventually when wind, solar, battery, and HVDC electricity sources are able to take over most day-to-day electricity needs, this bio-gas could instead be stored and used as a backup power source, as well as being sold to industry for hard-to-electrify industrial processes. Afterall, if all that gas were stored instead of used up immediately, it'd only take 11-12 days of storage to store enough gas to power the whole grid for a day. This is really important, because the amount of solar and wind energy being produced can vary huge amounts from week-to-week. --------------------- [1] Yes, I know, Germany made a gigantic mistake decomissioning their nuclear reactors early. I strongly disagree with that choice, and I think there's a deeply rooted misunderstanding and fear of nuclear power in this country which is a big shame. Despite this, good progress is being made however.
- firebot 3y agoNuclear isn't profitable. Renewables have plummeted in cost making nuclear cost prohibitive, and let's face it, if they're ever built it'll probably be too little too late.
- eigenspace 3y agoFirst of all, nuclear is very expensive, but most of that cost is in the original construction, of the reactor. In the wake of Fukushima, Germany decomissioned many already built, mature reactors that could have continued to safely and cheaply operate for decades. Shutting down pre-existing reactors and justifying it with "well, building new reactors is expensive" is at best stupid. Second of all, renewables are incredibly cheap when they're a minority of the grid. The problem is that if there's a shortfall of electricity, things get real expensive real fast. To make realistic grid-scale comparisons between renewables and nuclear power, you need to compare the cost of renewables-plus-storage against the cost of nuclear, and at that point things get a lot more nuanced and hard to compare. For instance, solar PV is the cheapest electricity you can get, but in places with a lot of preexisting solar installation it's also some of the lowest value electricity. During the middle of a sunny summer day in Germany, electricity spot prices can go negative because so much solar is being produced, but then that same night, prices shoot up because suddenly all those PVs stop producing any electricity at all. It's a bit of a race to the bottom if you don't have storage to offset those swings. ____________________________ All that said, I'm of course a big fan of renewables and I'm glad Germany is investing in them, and I think there's a bright future ahead with them. But using the low cost of solar modules and wind turbines as an argument against keeping nuclear power stations online is silly -- especially when there's still coal plants operating in Germany.
- hollowturtle 3y agoI agree nuclear initial investment is high but it’s cheaper to maintain in the long run than renewables. The making of solar panels, wind turbines and hydroelectric power stations release more carbon in the athmosphere than nuclear sites. Making of this stuff, especially batteries for stocking, produce more poisonous material than any nuclear site will, and must be stocked underground with high risks. Exaust fission materials produced by humanity so far is so little that stocking isn’t a problem and in some kind of reactors can even be recycled! Renewables don’t guarantee power continuity, nuclear fission does. I can go on the whole day, renewables alone can’t power the ever increasing world need. A mix of nuclear reactors, even small, and renewables could
- HPsquared 3y agoIt just takes a quick look at the graph to say "around now".
- kakaz 3y agoYou miss the point. It will never drop
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoThis report is really confident that peak is basically now, regardless of the future course we take regarding fossil fuels and renewables. Sure...
- isodev 3y agoThe report says that me must make the peak happen now (by 2025) or else we’re in more trouble than we can manage.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> regardless of the future course we take regarding fossil fuels and renewables How do you read a report modelling future emissions and conclude this?
- eigenspace 3y ago"read" is a very generous description.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoBy matching the descriptions of their hypothetical scenarios from BAU to turbo-renewables with the emissions graphs in which all the lines go down. Which is still to say that I don't buy it. https://www.unep.org/resources/emissions-gap-report-2023 https://www.unep.org/resources/emissions-gap-report-2023
- shrubble 3y agoDepends on China's coal fired power plants, doesn't it?
- ViewTrick1002 3y agoChina's coal boom is ending being replaced with renewables. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/nov/13/chinas-carbon-emissions-set-for-structural-decline-from-next-year https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/nov/13/chinas-carb...
- rr808 3y agoStill building 2 a week. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/aug/29/china-coal-plants-climate-goals-carbon https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/aug/29/china-coal-pla...
- timbit42 3y agoChina has also built entire cities and never used them.
- epistasis 3y agoBuilding them isn't so bad. Using them is where it causes problems. What's the trend there?
- rr808 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_China#/media/File:China-electricity-prod-source-stacked.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_China#/m...
- eigenspace 3y agoGod that's a depressing graph.
- gmuslera 3y agoThat it will peak means that we are still adding, each year, even more greeenhouse gases than in the previous ones. That is not directly what causes the warming. In simplified terms, we have excess of greenhouse gases, we keep more heat of what we receive from the sun than what we lose, and that is one of the forces behind global warming, hitting the 1.5ºC and so on. And CO2 remains in the atmosphere for 100-200 years after emitted. So, this "peak", if achieved, means that we are still accelerating the problem. after we peak, we will keep adding roughly as much carbon as we did in previous years (that will keep be adding to the excess). We are not sensibly lowering the amount of extra greenhouse gases, we will still be growing what is up there for the foreseeable future. And as the planet warmed up, several feedback loops have been triggered that are adding their own quota of even more greenhouse gases, like permafrost thawing. And the extra fossil carbon that we kept adding to the system all this time will now keep circulating in the new carbon cycle, is not like after 200 years it will just vanish. This is not "things are getting better", but at best "we will keep worsening things, but not so fast, maybe in a future"
- TheCleric 3y agoWhile this is true, it’s still a positive point. If you’re hurtling towards a wall in your car, you have to take your foot off the gas and hit the brakes. So at least we’ll be taking our foot off the gas.
- eigenspace 3y agoYes, emissions peaking is just one step on the journey, but it's a very necessary and important near term target along the way.
- jesperlang 3y agoExactly! Peak gives a sense of relief.. Better is of course relative, should we be happy that we are no longer stepping further down on the gas pedal, but still going at dangerously high speed? When where we should really be is at least in full stop, preferable going in reverse..
- fbergen 3y agoTrue, it doesn't mean that the problem is solved, but it's a big milestone on the way. I fwiw something I thought was way further in the future
- halfeatenpie 3y agoI'm a little concerned about using IEA model analysis to address the question of timing, as these models do try to hit timing but in reality are still very uncertain that any analysis based on the timing is fun to talk about but holds no real value and, from the publications I've read, shouldn't be interpreted as such. This isn't to discount policies or decisions based on the energy transition scenarios used here, I mean we need more and more effort to curb our GHG emissions, but I would advise against interpreting this dataset in this manner.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rr808 3y agoWorld population is till going up. Economic growth is still going up. Oil and Coal production is still going up. No sign of a peak to me.
- epistasis 3y agoWhat the peak means is that economic growth will now decrease emissions. There's a bunch of downright wrong thinking that we can somehow stop climate change with asceticism. But we can't. It's not a solution. It can at best do a marginal decrease in emissions, we need to eliminate and then start massive amounts of carbon removal, on the order of 5 gigatons per year. We need to massively increase economic growth in order to save the environment, because the newer cleaner techs will create cheaper energy and massive economic growth as they massively reduce our environmental impact. There's some sort of weird religious belief that economic growth is tied to environmental destruction, but it is not based in fact, merely faith. And it's a very harmful belief to actually improving the environment.
- rr808 3y agoThe growth I was talking about was more about the few billion people that have been dragged out of poverty and can now afford cars, AC, flying. I think that will out-emit anything the developed world does in going green.
- epistasis 3y agoI'm not so sure, because the question is how they will get their energy. Will it be from a big grid with natural gas powering it? Most likely not, because in developing areas it's going to be far far far cheaper to power a mini-split with a few cheap solar panels and a small battery than it will be to deploy a massive grid and all the maintenance, etc. The cheapest new energy is carbon free, meaning that new load will be coming from zero carbon sources. As the cost curves change more, this trend will get even more extreme. Right now in developed countries, there's enough entrenched interests, political propaganda, and an older set of decision makers in industry that we don't fully yet see how the technology landscape has changed. But in developing areas of the world, they won't be burdened by our same baggage.