7 ms·
Grimoire: Open-Source bookmark manager with extra features
- ApolloRising 3y agoIs there any bookmark manager that will auto reorganize your bookmarks by following a few logical rules?
- kevinsschmidt 3y agoCan you give an example?
- ApolloRising 3y agoSure, All python related bookmarks go into a folder marked Python, or the system looks at your folder structure and then puts the correct bookmarks in the right folder by learning from some type of training.
- optimusPrimal 3y ago[flagged]
- hschne 3y agoI love products with a bit of personality. There's tons of bookmark managers out there, but how many of those take the magical-mystical angle? I don't have a use for Grimoire - not willing to change my bookmark workflow at this point - but you can be sure I'll remember it just based on that.
- paxcoder 3y ago[dead]
- talkingtab 3y agoIt would be helpful to have an overview of how to use this. I understand that I run a docker image, but what does it do? Do I have a bookmarklet? Can I import and reorg my saved bookmarks? Does it tie in with Chrome or Firefox saved bookmarks? Etc? Thanks!
- devsda 3y agoDocumentation is still WIP and incomplete. As per https://grimoire.pro/docs/roadmap https://grimoire.pro/docs/roadmap sharing, import, export, bookmarklet and browser extension are on the roadmap. Offtopic: I've heard the word Grimoire only from the Black Clover anime and expected the author to be a fan of the series. Didn't know that it's such a common word, so TIL.
- hprotagonist 3y agosusan cooper and d&d, for me.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoTouhou Project for me.
- stavros 3y agoDerived from the word "grammar" for me.
- asdffdasasdf 3y ago(for now?) it's just a sample webapp. Like those TO-DO lists exercises. It have a dozen random metrics dashboards about how many bookmarks you add per day etc but not a single use case is done yet.
- 9dev 3y agoAside. I completely stopped using book marks. Everything relevant to me will be an open tab, and closed once read or no longer useful; everything not immediately relevant enough to warrant an open tab will probably not be read anyway, or the link broken once I get back to it. This has made my digital life a lot less burdensome to manage, and it also felt freeing to drop all that unorganised baggage. To all those bookmark junkies out there - do you really actually read all that stuff, or is it just data hoarding? (And I don’t mean this in spite, I’ve hoarded lots of data at one point or another myself :-))
- mkotowski 3y agoYes, but now you can run into risk of becoming 1000-tabs-open junkie like me :-) Off-topic, but given how people try to apply LLMs to everything right now, I am surprised there is no extension or something similar to help manage bookmarked and open tabs.
- hendler 3y agoI use quicktabs https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/quick-tabs/jnjfeinjfmenlddahdjdmgpbokiacbbb?pli=1 https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/quick-tabs/jnjfeinj...
- buro9 3y agoI bookmark things in pinboard that I may wish to find again, at some other point in time... I am helping my future self, and I appreciate that by paying pinboard to ensure a backup of the page is saved. I search the bookmarks every week or two, and I frequently search back years to "I recall a passage, but now want to read the full article again or share it with someone"... this works even when the site has long-ceased to exist because of the backup scraped at the time. I have bookmarks going back to the mid-1990s, and I do periodically (every year or two) look at which still work and which have fallen by the wayside for which I have no saved page — and I delete those. Additionally I have this page https://david.kitchen/bookmarks/ https://david.kitchen/bookmarks/ which is my browser home page in all browsers, and is another form of a bookmark collection, and this is how I mostly interact... where pinboard is long-term storage of bookmarks, anything I interact with regularly enough is on this page. I update this whenever I find myself returning to the same thing for more than a few weeks. I don't feel like I carry any baggage, the opposite in fact... I feel like this clears the mind of the responsibility to remember as this is mostly long-term memory and short-term convenience. I also keep my browsers in permanent incognito mode with NoScript... so tab-city is not a thing I've ever done, every session is a blank session. I view bookmarks like data on a computer... it should be extremely portable across devices and OSs, and so bookmarks should transcend the device, a specific browser, and be available everywhere.
- hendler 3y agoWhile humans are still browsing (instead of agents), there is definitely a need to manage our collections better. I worked on something in 2007 for bookmarking, too. https://vimeo.com/60251128 https://vimeo.com/60251128
- KetoManx64 3y agoThanks for sharing! watching your video gave me some ideas about how my bookmarking workflow can be improved that i've never considered. I'm going to be doing some scripting this week.
- hendler 3y agoMaybe will no one will read my reply here, but getting downvoted for sharing stuff like this is lame. The community is awesome, the algorithm generally works, but I'm looking forward to something better when we need community.
- kristjank 3y agoI went from firefox to shaarli back to firefox now that sync is fairly reliable, tagged and optimized, better search is the reason I might check this out.
- skilled 3y agoWhy did browsers fail when it comes to bookmark management? I mean seriously, it is arguably one of the most important features for organising your digital life and the best that a browser vendor can do is “folders”? This has always baffled me. Who enjoys opening their bookmarks and seeing 500 links in an unordered list? Metadata has been a thing for how long now, and yet no browser that I know of has gone ahead and implemented a proper bookmark management workflow.
- oulipo 3y agobecause it's contrary to their business model? Google wants you to search for all your queries, so it knows in real time what matters to you
- skilled 3y agoI don’t think that argument makes any sense. Do people who use external bookmark managers suddenly stop using search? Also, this isn’t just about Chrome.
- devsda 3y agoFor many people, Google is sort of their bookmark manager. Want to open Facebook? Search 'Facebook' and click on the link. Want to open your bank site ? Again google bank name and click on the link. I've see even tech people do this. The only bookmarks I've seen my colleagues use are for internal reference wikis and links which are not readily searchable. I don't know whether this is a search or UX or people problem but the whole workflow can be improved for sure.
- crossroadsguy 3y agoAfter delicious and pinboard I am done with bookmarks. You know why? Because I never access them ever again and if I do, and that is ridiculously rare, finding them elsewhere in is actually easier and faster. I am all for cute little services and one app for one need, but bookmarks for me are not a need at all. Whatever little need it has are squarely served by the browser’s bookmark service and I think all of them have one these days. They’re not the easiest but it’s fine.
- dewey 3y agoFully agree, I used to be the same but if I can’t find it again through a search engine it was probably not important enough. So far I was able to track down everything I wanted.
- asdffdasasdf 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- manojlds 3y agoThe person who created the Custom GPT with same name will be pissed
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- b1476 3y agoThis looks great and I’ll definitely give it a spin when I get a chance. What I’d really like though is the ability to save the pages locally, I often revisit bookmarks from years ago only to find that the page no longer exists.
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoI used a Bash script for a long time that would take my new bookmarks each month and download a copy of the page. It came from an idea presented on HN, I would ack-grep it for search. Stores using it because I use several computers and two OS now, and the utility of it is pretty low for me. You could make a donation to Archive.org and just a script to check for an "archive-this" tag in your bookmarks, then pass those pages to archive.org??
- dotancohen 3y agoDo you still have the script perchance?
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoI'll have a look, you might find the one I based it off if you search here?
- sundarurfriend 3y agoZotero has been mentioned in this thread a few times, and it has this feature. The browser extension has both "with a snapshot" and "without" options (the snapshot being your local copy), and you can choose the default and also choose for each page if you want to. (It does have some idiosyncrasies since it's supposed to be a citation manager originally, but once you get used to the workflow it gets out of the way and works really well.)
- ankit70 3y agoBrowser bookmarks were always ignored. Now I just save them to Pocket (getpocket.com).
- paxcoder 3y ago[dead]
- renegat0x0 3y agoI don't like any service that requires account, and is managed by a corporation. I use self hosted solutions whenever possibile. For bookmarks I wrote a special program for myself for that, as no other program, service fully ticks all the right requirements.
- DLion 3y agoI use https://www.gettoby.com/ https://www.gettoby.com/ to organise and save my bookmarks
- s1291 3y agoZotero can save webpage snapshots. IMO, It's a good bookmark manager choice.
- hruzgar 3y agoI use raindrop https://raindrop.io/ https://raindrop.io/ to manage my bookmarks but would switch if this actually gets browser extensions and stuff
- thenbe 3y agoI'm in the same boat, currently using Raindrop and looking to switch. I'm currently eyeing Linkwarden as the alternative, but I'm not sure how painless the migration will be. https://github.com/linkwarden/linkwarden https://github.com/linkwarden/linkwarden
- adhamsalama 3y agoSame. I love Raindrop, but I don't feel well about keeping my digital brain in a closed source SAAS.
- sundarurfriend 3y agoHaving a first-class UI for bookmarks really does make a difference. I used to agree with some of the sentiments expressed in comments here - that bookmarking is a write-only activity, that just feels satisfying without actually being useful. Then I started using Zotero for my bookmarks, organizing them into collections, tagging them, adding descriptions ("Abstract"), etc., and I find that I actually go back to them a lot more, and find it really useful. The UI browsers provide for bookmarks is pretty atrocious, and seems to have been the main reason I didn't go back to use them much - which I didn't realize until I had the idea to use Zotero as a bookmark manager. It has a lot of the features that Grimoire lists, including separate "user accounts" - I have a separate Work profile, for which I've created a desktop shortcut the same I do for Firefox [1], with its own collections and tags. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37953035 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37953035
- LunarAurora 3y agoIf you overlook some idiosyncrasies due to its main purpose (references), Zotero really shines as a bookmark manager. It is mature and has a lot of advanced features. The last one I discovered is enabling hierarchical tags with an addon. [1] I still welcome any new well-built alternatives like Grimoire, and I agree with you that a first-class UI is important. [1] https://github.com/windingwind/zotero-actions-tags https://github.com/windingwind/zotero-actions-tags
- actuallyalys 3y agoI’ve been really liking Zotero, but I don’t use it for webpage bookmarks outside of topics I’m researching. Maybe I should rethink that.
- dr_kiszonka 3y agoAre there any good apps that allow you to add bookmarks to zotero from a phone? For example, I would like to easily bookmark websites that I come across in a HN app. I found Zoo for Zotero but it is pretty clunky in this respect.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Ringz 3y agoMy perfect bookmark manager is Markdownload https://github.com/deathau/markdownload https://github.com/deathau/markdownload Just save the complete page, only selected text or only the link to a markdown file or Obsidian. With downloaded, linked or without pictures. My OS and Obsidian can search those files, they have more (automatically added) metadata. I can even edit them in the browser: add your thoughts, tags or change the name of the file before they are saved. I can (automatically) do with them what ever I need. They can be used to (automatically) generate an always up to date start page or a data vault on GitHub. My local AI assistant can parse them. Local, versatile, permanent, flexible, cost effective, future save. No need for a bookmark manager.
- s5ma6n 3y agoThis sounds like the solution I could benefit a lot as well since I am using Obsidian for almost everything. Could you elaborate more on the "local AI assistant parsing" part please?
- Ringz 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36933452 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36933452 https://khoj.dev/ https://khoj.dev/
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- poisonborz 3y agoFor users like me, finding a server like this is the easy part, it's just a glorified CRUD for links. Well-working, up to date extensions and mobile app are all that matter and where most such projects (like wallabag) fail. I just want a selfhosted Pocket with a similar quality UX.
- ode 3y agoI haven't tried Grimoire yet but I've recently started using Shiori - https://github.com/go-shiori/shiori https://github.com/go-shiori/shiori A big plus is that is a single Golang binary so very easy to set up. It also has a browser extension.
- Tomte 3y agoUnfortunately, you can only import bookmarks from a Netscape HTML file once. There is no update. That mens I cannot periodically import my Raindrop bookmarks to shiori. After I've done the import I can either add new bookmarks to both immediately and by hand. Or I do a total re-import in shiori, which re-archives everything (and if a page isn't retrievable anymore, that's bad luck).
- jrm4 3y agoIt's VERY nice (and this is absolutely about to be a question in the form of a comment), the one thing that is perhaps a deal-killer for me that I'm actually unable to get a clear read on: It appears to be impossible to have a "public" page? How it does everything else is perfect for my style, but I'd like to be able to share my link page to my students without login?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bigfishrunning 3y agoI feel like "docker as the preferred installation method" is a dealbreaker for me. This means that either the dependency situation is out of control, or the author just doesn't want to think about it, but either way it's a no from me...
- plagiarist 3y agoI didn't realize this was a perspective. Yeah, that's true, the dependencies may be whack. I kinda prefer docker installations because I don't need to guess what implicit "works on my machine" dependencies someone had, and the whole thing can be mostly stateless or the extra state is made pretty obvious.
- Someguy1098 3y agoWhat don't you like about a project needing dependencies?
- evanjrowley 3y agoThere is a belief that risk of vulnerabilities introduced by insecure package ecosystems goes up with the number of dependencies. For example, a study on this was recently conducted for PyPI. https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11021 https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.11021
- Someguy1098 3y agoBut it's inside the Docker container so even if a dependency was compromised it's in a separate userspace and chrooted so unless theres a docker zero day it should be pretty secure still it seems like. An updated Docker environment is pretty secure I think.
- DandyDev 3y agoI think Docker is a great installation method. - People who use Docker (Compose) can easily get up and running with a project in minutes - People who dislike/don’t use Docker can at least use the Dockerfile and Docker Compose file as a reference to learn how to install the dependencies and the service itself.
- paulyy_y 3y agoGotta love the generic LLM generated description
- simlan 3y agoYep:" casual and dial up the puns" It is funny though ;)
- lucb1e 3y agoScreenshots: https://grimoire.pro/screenshots https://grimoire.pro/screenshots
- caymanjim 3y agoThis is a total nonstarter without a browser extension. I know it's in the roadmap, but I'm not willing to even look at this without the extension as the starting point. It's also the part you need to get right before anything else matters. Right now I use xbrowsersync. It's got major problems, like sometimes (always?) breaking the ability to add bookmarks at all when sync isn't working, having to authenticate with a long-ass sync ID that you can't possibly remember, and not remembering recently-used bookmark folder order. But it works on the browsers I use and can be self-hosted. I'd love an alternative with a better UI that fully integrates with the browser (in my case ungoogled Chromium).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- andrethegiant 3y agoWill give this a try. I had given up on bookmarking and now rely on Raycast to search through my browser history, which works pretty well. But I miss the browsability, and screenshots for each page entry. What would be awesome is if I could wget all the assets locally, and then use a local LLM to search its contents.
- aledalgrande 3y agonowadays I save everything in Logseq I gave up on bookmarks
- ri0t 3y agoIn another note: The docker-compose file builds the frontend live on the docker container. I've built similar technology a few years ago and am totally trying to get rid of this kind-of "on-premises" build process, as imho it is WAY to fault-prone. Interesting to see this project pull it through anyway. They also begin with updating a lot of deb-dependencies. I imagine this to be hellishly difficult to maintain. Props for even trying!
- breadchris 3y agoI used to use Pocket extensively until I realized it wasn't going anywhere with features. I have since moved to Omnivore [1] and I couldn't be happier. The devs are also ex-Pocket users and have worked hard to get feature parity and then some. There are mobile apps too for reading on the go (and work offline) which I use extensively when I am on flights. There is a graphql API and webhooks you can use for extending its functionality. Search could be a little better, but I use the labeling system which works well. I also use the logseq integration to keep a persistent log of articles I read on any given day. [1] https://github.com/omnivore-app/omnivore https://github.com/omnivore-app/omnivore
- millermk 3y agoI hate to be that guy but you sound like you know your bookmarking/readlater/knowledgebase apps: What made you choose logseq over obsidian? Did you try both, or switch over at a certain point? Is starting an Obsidian knowledgebase not a thing you would to suggest to people today if they are just starting? Thanks for any input
- pbnjeh 3y agoOver 20 years ago, a small software company named Kaylon made a bookmark manager called PowerMarks. Cross browser, handled thousands of bookmarks lightning fast, pretty damned good automated indexing that could be manually supplemented or overridden just by typing in space-separated terms. Lightning fast search; the indexing very quickly got you to what you wanted. And, local -- thank goodness. Web apps weren't really even a thing, yet. This also meant a compact, information-rich GUI, as opposed to all the low-density web crap we're forced to put up with, these days. It's EOL. IIRC, in part browsers closing themselves off to third party application access did them in. Anyway, if anyone's serious about making a good personal bookmark manager, take a look at PowerMarks, if you can somehow. No one else I've seen has come close to what they had.
- nylonstrung 3y agoWhat bookmark manager options will catalog the bookmarks I add via Chrome's native functionality?
- KetoManx64 3y agoNone that i've seen, i built myself a script that read's firefox's sqlite bookmarks database and imports new items into linkding through the API. Surprises this is not a bigger request by people, especially when it comes to importing pre existing bookmarks
- ndom91 3y agoAuthor of [briefkasten](https://briefkastenhq.com https://briefkastenhq.com) (https://github.com/ndom91/briefkasten https://github.com/ndom91/briefkasten) here - a veryy similar opensource/self-hostable bookmark manager based on Next.js. Just wanted to congratulate you on this, looks great! Especially the bookmark cards and user profile page / infos. Will probably be copying some of that down the line :wink:
- goniszewski 3y agoHello there! I'm Robert, the creator of Grimoire. I'm very flattered by such good observations and the warm welcome for this project. I won't be able to respond to every comment from you guys, but you bet I will read them all and take notes! For now, Grimoire is at 1/10 of its potential, and I will work hard to make it worthy of being a good contender for your default bookmark manager. Definitely, it's missing many features, like a dedicated browser extension, import/export capabilities, and better documentation, and I'm well aware of that. Was the launch rushed? Maybe, but I thought it would be great to hear your opinions and perhaps even appeal to some potential contributors (wink wink). For now, I want to address the most common issues that prevent some of you from even running and testing it (clearly an oversight on my side). Then I will write a blog post on https://grimoire.pro https://grimoire.pro to answer some of your questions and doubts, so (if not now, but maybe in the not-too-distant future), give it a chance. Thank you again, and big kudos to user hunderbong for mentioning Grimoire on HN!