8 ms·
Autonomous excavator constructs a six-metre-high dry-stone wall
- nuc1e0n 3y agoShow it still standing in a year and I'll be more impressed.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/scirobotics.abp9758 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/scirobotics.abp9758 https://youtu.be/P7wmotyKgXc https://youtu.be/P7wmotyKgXc
- soperj 3y agoConsidering it scans all the rocks, you'd think it would be able to fit the rocks together better. I don't expect a Incan wall, but I think it would be able to construct a tighter fitting wall if it were programmed to care.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoIt could perhaps if it had all rocks available up front to scan and plan the entire wall with. But it retrieves one rock at a time and can only place on the top row somewhere. Given the geometries are random I wouldn’t expect it to reliably have tight fits given how it’s sampling and placing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ano-ther 3y agoIt scans 20-30 (a truckload) before building a section of the wall with them.
- mlhpdx 3y agoExactly as I do as a human when I build such walls (several of them in my life). It’s a very difficult spatial problem to fit the stones into a pretty, stable structure. No doubt something large memories and detailed spatial search on a computer could help with. That doesn’t seem to have happened in this example, though. That wall is horrendously ugly.
- highstep 3y agoNot only ugly, but unstable and sketchy. I wouldn't go near that wall.
- foota 3y agoI'm getting some light towers of hanoi vibes
- ur-whale 3y agoIn other words, it's using a greedy algorithm
- soperj 3y agoEven then, if you make one long row, you have hundreds of available spots to place it, with at least 6 sides to decide on which orientation to place the stone. If there are no good spots currently, it could place the stone down next to the pile and go collect another stone until a better spot materialized.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoNo, I was wrong. It has a collection of 30 or so rocks per section and optimizes their placement in the entire section. I’ll still posit the randomness of the geometry requires more rocks than that to find a smooth fitting, and I imagine human wall makers select rocks up front with similar geometries before even beginning out of thousands of rocks then optimizes their placement during construction in a similar but less preside way than the machine. If you watch the video closer than I did you will see it plans each stone for optimal stability and placement.
- defrost 3y agoAn Incan wall is much "easier" (airqoted qualifier). There's much effort required to square up stone and shape faces, a lot of drilling, wedges, and precision chisel finishing. However, once it comes to the stacking it's been reduced to a bricklaying exercise (already solved for robots and posted to HN). Traditional drywall evolved from field clearing, stacking rocks to get them out of the way and to reduce wind across exposed otherwise rocky potential fields. Stacking and balancing "as they come" or with relative minimal look ahead | reshuffle queuing is a tougher proposition; this is impressive work.
- soperj 3y agoI'm not saying that it's not impressive. I'm just saying that I feel like considering that it doesn't have the human limitations of it being hard to remember every facet of the rocks, that it could do better job still!
- Qwertious 3y agoSome Incan walls are regular bricks, but others are just slightly-dressed boulders used for drywall polygonal masonry. They're an interesting compromise - some dressing for flexibility, but not so much that you have to throw half the boulder away.
- progne 3y agoI was once on a mountain top composed almost entirely of rocks like these. I'd like to give a sand castle artist this excavator and ask them to turn it into a fairy tale.
- mkoubaa 3y agoAnyone under the age of 20 is a Minecraft artist already
- beachy 3y agoThis seems like game changing technology. There are a heap of such walls around here, some built long ago by Dalmation immigrants (and some allegedly by German POWs). It's quite labour intensive and highly skilled to create them. We have some on our property, used to retain the hillside after land slips. They were built with an excavator by a gnarly old guy who was unbelievably skilled. One thing I wonder is whether these are safe. These things terrify the shit out of me, as one toppling rock of that size could instantly kill a child. Walls built by human operators of sufficient skill are safe (I know, I went around and tried to wobble every single rock to make sure). But are these built to the same level?
- toomuchtodo 3y agoYou could potentially shotcrete (spray it with concrete to reinforce) the wall after the robotic excavator is done if you’re concerned about stability. I can’t speak to whether you can highly automate this as well, but it seems possible with current state robotics with human operators. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shotcrete https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shotcrete https://www.geostabilization.com/technology/shotcrete-robot/ https://www.geostabilization.com/technology/shotcrete-robot/ https://dawinvehicles.en.made-in-china.com/product/jBMnaOKdLgrL/China-Robotic-Shotcrete-Arm-Concrete-Spraying-Machine-30m3-Per-Hour-Output.html https://dawinvehicles.en.made-in-china.com/product/jBMnaOKdL...
- myegorov 3y agoThe ability of a dry stack retaining wall to shift and breathe is a feature, not a bug. For stone walls that require added reinforcement against lateral loads, look into tiebacks or geogrid reinforcement.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoAppreciate this. Where can we read more on this engineering? All citations are welcome, I am fascinated by this engineering domain.
- 3y ago
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- yk 3y agoFirst they are coming for the medival castle builders, then they come for the renaissance painters. In all seriousness though, that's a pretty nice feat of robotics. The excavator has to work with stones that are not standardized and has to understand how they interact, my intuition is that that is a lot harder than building a regular brick wall.
- Oarch 3y agoThe Fabricate conference has always been great for research like this
- ExMachina73 3y agoPerhaps in hundreds of years they'll be able to deploy AI robots to poorer regions of the world to build basic utilities, mine resources, and even whole cities from nothing. Or have them depoloyed to current cities constantly repairing and optimizing infrastructure.
- HPsquared 3y agoFactorio style.
- dublinben 3y agoIf there's one thing that lower income countries have an excess of, it's people to perform labor. There's a reason why you don't see countries (e.g. China) introducing more automation until they rise to a certain income level.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoGenerally you're right, but also a) You may not have skilled labor easily available for a niche like constructing a dry stone wall out of giant rocks, and b) sometimes employing that labor via local firms can result in corruption issues.
- trebligdivad 3y agoDamn, that must have been fun to debug and test!
- fernly 3y agoETH Zurich[1, 2] is fairly famous as an engineering school. Somehow in my mind it is linked with computer scientist Edsger Dijkstra[3], but according to the Wiki he was never based there. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETH_Zurich https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETH_Zurich [2] https://ethz.ch/en.html https://ethz.ch/en.html [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edsger_W._Dijkstra https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edsger_W._Dijkstra
- hollerith 3y agoDijkstra was close to Niklaus Wirth, who was based there.
- ur-whale 3y agoETHZ is quite famous indeed. Einstein, among others, studied there [1] [1] https://ethz.ch/en/the-eth-zurich/global/events/digitaler-einstein.html https://ethz.ch/en/the-eth-zurich/global/events/digitaler-ei...
- mahkeiro 3y agoIndeed, 22 Nobel Prizes have been awarded to researchers who have or had a connection with ETHZ.
- dryrocks 3y ago[dead]
- Animats 3y agoNice. Heavy equipment with many degrees of freedom is hard for humans to control. Some operators are really good, but not all of them. A backhoe hooked up to a virtual reality input arm with force feedback was built several decades ago. The operator could feel obstructions, and dig out the dirt around a pipe by feel. Never became a product, though. Probably too early.
- h2odragon 3y agoThe force feedback would be yet another layer of tetchy stuff to keep running in a really harsh environment. I've know backhoe operators who strongly preferred older equipment, when its too new the pins are too tight and they have no "slop" to work with. That slop is what they're using for sensory input, if you watch them. With attention and experience that's real time feedback. The whole machine is the force feedback mechanism. You're not just sitting there in a comfy chair pulling levers, you're on top of a collection of systems all singing their own song in response to the varying loads placed on them.
- londons_explore 3y ago> The force feedback would be yet another layer of tetchy stuff to keep running in a really harsh environment. Luckily, hydraulics offer a very easy way to do force feedback: Just measure the post-valve cylinder pressure. That means you can have all your wiring and sensors in the cab far away from the dirt and rain. Makes force feedback pretty easy and cheap.
- zyxin 3y agoDo operators currently need to manually control every movement of the arm? I always assumed that such heavy equipment uses inverse kinematics to help the operator.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoIt is usually one lever per hydraulic cylinder. The human brain already automates the kinematics. There isn't much upside to automation and a lot of downside because of the diverse instructions required.
- gfodor 3y agoThis is the kind of thing computer science academics dream about
- ur-whale 3y agoMinecraft IRL
- WhitneyLand 3y ago- Wouldn’t this type of wall normally be built using heavy machinery without laborers lifting and placing heavy rocks? - A heavy machinery operator would no longer be needed, but wouldn’t you need 1 or more people to operate and manage the robot as well as verify the solution? It’s a really cool direction for construction but I wonder what the net/net cost savings would really be in the near future anyway.
- maxglute 3y agoThere's probably a lot of savings to be had by lifting safety rules. Cram more machines to do more work on site and finish faster.
- beachy 3y agoI think this is great tech, but maybe not for those reasons. On any safe site, people are already very cautious and working well back from the excavator. Some teams have a protocol where you have to make eye contact with the digger driver before you can go anywhere within the sweep of its arm.
- maxglute 3y agoBut without the excavator operator, can you not cram more autonomous excavators to get more work done? Seems like sufficiently good sensors would allow them to work in each others safety zones for parallel work.
- bluGill 3y agoProbably not as the soil they ig needs to go someplace. That means dump trucks will still be the majority of the site.
- logtempo 3y agoI don't like wars, but being able to build a wall out of some broken concrete blocks without it being man handled is a good feature I believe. Also being able to build during a long period of time (during the night for example) make the job less exhausting. Also one could think of it as an assistant: put some augmented reality display, and let the machine showing to the operator where to put the rock. Or help for building records: you keep the operator part, but you record the scans and position and weights during construction phase, so you can eventually run simulation later to know how the wall will change over time etc.
- Eumenes 3y agoGraham Hancock BTFO
- vondur 3y agoThe Romans could have used this to keep those pesky Germans out!
- Daub 3y agoHaving made a few dry stone walls I can attest to the merit of this achievement. Judging where rocks are to be placed, and in what orientation is a zen art. Anecdotally... I once tried to get wild flowers to grow on a stone wall. Every year we would seed the wall, only for the seeds to fall out or be eaten by birds. On inspiration, my boss filled a few shotgun cartridges up with seeds and fired them at the wall. Perfect result! The following year it was covered in flowers.
- 93po 3y agoNow this is gardening I can get behind
- chaboud 3y agoWell please don’t stand in front of it…
- schiffern 3y agoNot only is this a technical marvel, but it has potential construction physics implications. In simple terms, currently we expend energy to fragment rock, and then we expend additional energy (as concrete) to glue it back together. We do all this to re-arrange rocks into a shape (and strength) we want, and most importantly to do it cheap. Suddenly, an alternative just got a lot cheaper. Clearly this isn't fully baked yet (and it's hardly a drop-in replacement for reinforced/pretensioned/cantilevered/etc) but for things like heavy infrastructure and civil engineering this might offer a way to achieve fundamental thermodynamic improvements. Excited to see where this technology goes.
- samtho 3y agoThe problem with dry stone construction is that you cannot determine the performance characteristics required for, say, a building foundation. Not all boulders are created equal, but a professional concrete pour, mixed and installed to the manufacturer’s specification is going to have a guaranteed maximum strength- something random boulders will not have. What we can do is create our own concrete mix using Portland cement (the “glue”) and locally sourced materials to bulk it up such as gravel, aggregates, sand, etc.
- nopinsight 3y agoNice achievement! With upcoming multimodal foundation models, there will be many more robots with increasing capabilities soon. The world of robotics will look very different just in the next 5 years. Some announcements: China’s plan: “…China aims to be ready to mass-produce humanoids by 2025.” https://www.therobotreport.com/china-plans-to-mass-produce-humanoids-by-2025/ https://www.therobotreport.com/china-plans-to-mass-produce-h... Tesla Robot: “…it would be low cost and available to the public sometime between 2025 and 2027. ” https://builtin.com/robotics/tesla-robot https://builtin.com/robotics/tesla-robot
- tsimionescu 3y agoYou should take both of those announcements with a huge dollop of salt. Even the article you shared is extremely skeptical of the actual progress of Tesla's robot. And Chinese press releases should really not be read into too much - they are often much more for internal signalling then information. Either way, there are companies which are much farther along than those - Boston Dynamics has a series of extremely impressive robots. They are still very far away from being a consumer technology. The kinds of physical power required to achieve the movements makes them extremely dangerous to be around on any malfunction or glitch, and they are very heavy machinery. Even animals and other humans, which are far more advanced in terms of their ability to control their movements, sometimes accidentally hurt others (stepping on your toes, turning around and hitting you when they didn't know you're there, etc.). Imagine a several hundred kilo machine stepping on your toes with its full weight just because it mis-estimated your movements.
- nopinsight 3y ago> Imagine a several hundred kilo machine stepping on your toes with its full weight just because it mis-estimated your movements. "Specifications. Tesla Bot is planned to measure 5 ft 8 in (173 cm) tall and weigh 125 lb (57 kg)." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optimus_(robot) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optimus_(robot) I'm aware that Tesla tends to be over-optimistic in its timeline regarding AI and robotics. I do not endorse the estimates without question and yes, some other companies might have made more progress than they did. The citations were meant as examples of the development in the domain. (And Boston Dynamics doesn't seem to plan a consumer launch of a humanoid robot any time soon, so I didn't cite them.) What made me more optimistic these days are recent progress in multimodal large foundation models which allow robots to perform much better, esp on manual manipulation. See demo from Sep 2023 here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D2vj0WcvH5c&t=18s&ab_channel=Tesla https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D2vj0WcvH5c&t=18s&ab_channel...
- 082349872349872 3y agoFor those both unfamiliar with Menzi Muck walking excavators and having a little boy's love of construction equipment, there are plenty of videos online of non-autonomous skilled operators with fancy moves...
- BobaFloutist 3y agoI wonder how many decades before someone hooks this up to a webcam and lets people play minecraft in real life.
- digitalsushi 3y agoAs someone who works in insurance, I advise you not to wait
- amelgares 3y agoThis is the kind of equipment that you do not want a rogue AI getting in control of.
- nextworddev 3y agoMost likely these come with periodic OS updates… which is an attack vector
- rendaw 3y agoI'm surprised centimeter precision is sufficient. I'd have thought millimeter precision or so would be required. It feels like 1cm could accumulate to a gap or could spell the difference between stable points contacting and not.
- RichieAHB 3y agoIIUC cm precision should be fine if the algorithms looking for stable placement accounts for that cm (and reality id imagine it’d account for less precision than that). If a placement needs sub cm precision the algorithm would just discard that option. Additionally there shouldn’t be any accumulation in a specific direction. Any accumulated gaps would be accounted for when placing the next rock and rectified to within a cm.
- hliyan 3y agoWith this type of advancement, we may finally be ready to tackle the biggest challenge for domestic robots since domestic robot were envisioned: ironing and folding clothes.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoYou have forgotten the first task of the day: buttering fresh toast.
- downboots 3y agoSimilarly, envision a solar sintering bot operating in the desert
- 1-6 3y agoI wish there were more companies in the US that can look at problem and solve it to a great deal of technical complexity. It seems like we’re too focused on large and shiny objects.
- lnsru 3y agoRobotics is expensive. One needs a team of software developer, electronics engineer and mechanical engineer to develop something. 3 people over 3 years with expensive hardware and couple millions $ for MVP needed. How many google ads for an app could one buy for this sum?
- sschueller 3y agoThat is what public funded universities and research is for. Many claim projects like CERN is a waste of money but this is where many new ideas and tech comes from as a side effect of trying to solve problems that arise while trying to build a bigger and more powerful accelerator.
- lnsru 3y agoI have a problem with public funded universities and research in Germany. I really don’t like how professors own companies where everything comes from PhD students’ work. Basically they transfer state/grant money into personal pockets via paid work hours. Though I don’t know how this works in Switzerland. Another day I saw a long list of CERN technologies that I can license from them and they were not for free.
- wg0 3y agoJaw dropping. There's too much engineering work involved. Interfacing with vehicle and tons of sensors. Software. Would be best if some entity quickly moves towards commercialization/packaging of this solution.
- unglaublich 3y agoThese folks have a spin-off called 'Gravis Robotics', pretty interesting stuff going on. Their promotional video contains technical details as well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yiTIXAAulzI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yiTIXAAulzI https://gravisrobotics.com/ https://gravisrobotics.com/
- aristophenes 3y agoThe photo of the wall in the article is obviously digitally altered, just to the left of the person walking. The rocks change into uniform smooth grey, and it doesn’t match the reflection in the water. Is it supposed to be the digital plan of the wall vs the real thing?
- rkangel 3y agoIt absolutely matches the reflection in the water - you can see the hard hat of the person and the colour transition. The change in colour will be the result of a change in source of boulder. The whole point is that they are "recycling".
- evilaubergine 3y agowhere were the wireframe mesh rocks sourced from?
- dryrocks 3y agoThe excavator creates a mesh of each stone by scanning it "in hand", and updates the settled positions of them as it builds. The left side of the image is the 3D digital twin model that is maintained by the system, captured from the same perspective to show how it matches the real wall.
- TomWhitwell 3y agoYes, I think it's an artistic interpretation of a digital model of the stones - how the autonomous system sees them.
- 7734128 3y agoIf you zoom in you can see that it's a polygon like mesh. It's certainly supposed to be how the rocks are represented in the system.
- jvidalv 3y agoJust wanted to share that in my country (Spain) and more concretely in my area (rural part of Catalonia) we have a building technique called “Pedra Seca” literal translation is “Dry Stone”. It basically involves building stuff with just rocks, nothing more. It’s still in use mostly in agricultural fields. Here are a few examples: https://dd9de8c7b7.cbaul-cdnwnd.com/b5fbcf0e77b7b72ef95acd629fde517c/200000077-a34bfa4463/pedraseca.jpg https://dd9de8c7b7.cbaul-cdnwnd.com/b5fbcf0e77b7b72ef95acd62... https://static1.ara.cat/clip/98e3619e-8dd2-4c0b-828c-254a62ed40bd_16-9-aspect-ratio_default_0.jpg https://static1.ara.cat/clip/98e3619e-8dd2-4c0b-828c-254a62e... The google search: https://www.google.com/search?client=safari&sca_esv=584083287&hl=en-es&q=pedra+seca&tbm=isch&source=lnms&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwisk-Gy9d6CAxVEQ6QEHeE1B64Q0pQJegQICxAB&biw=393&bih=659&dpr=3 https://www.google.com/search?client=safari&sca_esv=58408328...
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoDry stone walling is also very common in the UK. It's a complex and now expensive skill, but a properly-built (this bit is key) wall will stay put for well over a hundred years because the rocks can shift a little rather then cracking the structure as temperatures change and water drains right out of them. It's also very locally distinctive because the shape of the stones and therefore the wall layout and texture depends on the stones you naturally have nearby. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dry_stone#/media/File%3ADry_stone_fences_in_the_Yorkshire_Dales%2C_England.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dry_stone#/media/File%3ADry_st...
- fullspectrumdev 3y agoVery common in rural Ireland, and having such a wall repaired or made is either going to cost you nothing or a LOT of money.
- HPsquared 3y agoAs with many of the best things in life, they are either free or very expensive.
- protomolecule 3y agoLooks safe.
- buro9 3y agoThis is incredible because the vast majority of what it takes to build roads, rail tracks, docks, and such infrastructure is all in the clearing and relandscaping of land. It doesn't have to be perfect in terms of aesthetics or seals, but it has to be very stable and able to take the thin layer of road surface, rails, concrete on top and the weight that they'd carry. To be able to automate the landscaping is to massively reduce the cost of infrastructure projects in terms of labour and materials, but also likely the time to deliver them too.
- dryrocks 3y agoFor those looking for a more technical overview of the process, the overview video of the research paper is available here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TxpE5yryCTU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TxpE5yryCTU
- Obscurity4340 3y agoStonewaller-3000
- rob 3y agoFarmers in New England would have loved this. Miles and miles of stone walls just hidden in forests/woods.
- daedlanth 3y ago[dead]
- gnarlouse 3y agoImagine if the Spartans had this at the battle of Thermopylae
- hardlianotion 3y agoThis will revolutionise Yorkshire.
- moffkalast 3y agoOne might call it a... Deus Ex Cavator.
- bufferout 3y agoFor comparison, a 15th generation Japanese stonemason master doing it by eye: https://youtu.be/f9wGOXXoCuY https://youtu.be/f9wGOXXoCuY
- crtified 3y agoI assume (but don't know) that this method of construction would be less viable in more seismically-active parts of the world.
- elendee 3y agonow the rocks are more rational rocks