5 ms·
My First PCB (2019)
- demondemidi 3y agoYour second assembled board: what happened? Why the long leads??
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoIt's components plugged into sockets as opposed to soldered into the board.
- sweetjuly 3y ago>Designing a PCB and sending it off to fab is surprisingly accessible and feels like a super power Relatedly, reflow for assembly makes this feel like a super^2 power. I had always struggled with SMD components with an iron, but once I finally took the plunge and tried reflow I realized I could never go back. Not only is it considerably easier and cleaner (you place the parts, bake it, and do minor touchup with a braid and a hot plate--it just works!) but you can just build so much denser, more technologically advanced devices!
- bruckie 3y agoAre you talking about toaster oven-style reflow, or something fancier?
- kiwih 3y agoFirstly, well done on making your first PCB - and it looks like you've done a pretty good job besides! > I passionately hate Digikey’s search interface. It is shockingly bad at having the right metadata for filtering to be effective. I disagree wholeheartedly. Digikey has amongst the best interface for parts searching that I have ever used. What exactly about the interface do you dislike?
- fake-name 3y ago100% this. I shop almost exclusively on digikey at work when I can because their search is *so much* better then everyone else's. It's certainly not great, but it's definitely the best of any electronics component vendor by a large margin. Mouser's filtering facilities are dramatically worse.
- doubloon 3y agoi had no idea how to use digikey until I watched Lady Ada do it on an Adafruit video tutorial. compared to a lot of other web interfaces, its not exactly intuitive but once i got the hang of it its nice.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoIt's probably the best there is, but still leaves a lot to be desired. For example, let's say you want to choose, say, a power MOSFET to handle certain large current. In your design you could use one, or you could use multiple in parallel. Naturally, in this case you want to sort parts by amps per dollar, but you can't sort or filter by mathematical functions of combinations of parameters. So first you have to assume you'll use one mosfet, and find the best one; then repeat assuming you're paralleling two, and so on... Same if you're looking for capacitors and so on. You can rank by dollars, you can rank by Farads, but you can't rank by Farads/dollar, or stored energy (farad-volts-squared) per dollar etc. You could perhaps export to excel and do the search yourself, but sometimes that's not easy. You can specify value (6 mH) and tolerance (+-10%), but not joint values-and-tolerances. So if you really need at least 6 mH minimum, you technically want to search >6.7 mH +-10% and >6.3 mH +-5%, etc, but that's extra work. Sometimes the parameter you care about simply isn't available in Digikey's filter, because it's a little obscure like... high-frequency CMRR, or something. So you have to dig into each part datasheet one at a time. That's not really Digikey's fault though; they've tried their best to guess the parameters that are most important, and nobody else has done better. Where it does get very frustrating is when you need to search through ranges of ranges of values. Like, if your application has a supply voltage that could be between 3.3V and 5V, then you want to filter out parts that require an input voltage higher than 3.3V, or are damaged by an input voltage below 5V. But there's rarely an easy way to do this; often Digikey has one column containing value ranges like "1 - 4V", "1 - 4.1V", "1 - 4.2V"... "1.1 - 4V", "1.1 - 4.1V", and so on. Some of their filters have gotten smarter, but many are still like this, and it takes a long time to go through and select all possible acceptable parts and reject all inadmissible ones. So to save time you end up just guessing at a few likely ranges of values, but then later you discover that there's one really good part that's perfect and cheap but it can tolerate voltages all the way up to 25V for some reason, and you just filtered it out early on because it would have taken too long to scroll that far down. Searching for connectors can be very frustrating, because there's usually no easy way to look through related parts in a connector family, like to find matching male and female crimp pins and their respective housings. A lot of frustrations like that are very common, especially when approaching a design from a blank slate.
- BMc2020 3y agoA little dated, but kicad has only gotten better. Sadly Autodesk is actively depricating Eagle and I can't recommend F360 for new users. Digikey Dkred is a heckuva deal, about $1.50 a square inch. Start designing some simple 1x1 inch pcbs, get some for $20. The learning experience alone is worth it. A BOM? what's that?
- _fizz_buzz_ 3y agoWe actually switched from altium to kicad at work. For the stuff that we build, kicad does everything we need and it's honestly a bit smoother experience than altium imo. I am sure there is stuff where you absolutely need altium (RF stuff?), but I encourage people to look into it.
- baz00 3y agoRF stuff is fine without Altium. You can use QUCS for synthesis and just tape out in Kicad. Basically this without the manual steps and better impedance control! https://youtu.be/drwGvATLNaw https://youtu.be/drwGvATLNaw
- BMc2020 3y agoon github openscopeproject there is an interactive BOM for kicad. Opens up a graphical representation of your pcb in chrome and you can highlight all the components you can see how it works on the KiCad Interactive HTML BOM Plugin Demos Joe Bob says check it out (for anyone that remembers Joe Bob Briggs)
- AdamH12113 3y agoOSH Park is great for small-batch PCBs. A great feature (especially for newbies) is the previews of the board it shows when you upload the Gerber files. I tend to use the OSH Park preview even if I’m getting the actual board made somewhere else (e.g. with a high-frequency substrate) just because it’s such an easy way to do a final check on my Gerbers.
- rgoulter 3y agoI use https://tracespace.io/ https://tracespace.io/ for gerber viewing.
- baz00 3y agoOSHpark boards aren’t that great from experience. Had a couple with mask registration issues and the silk screen and edge cuts are terrible. They’re also slow and expensive. I’ve switched entirely to JLCPCB now which seems to have none of those issues. I’ve done ~20 runs through them including complex multi layer boards for ref.
- mrb 3y agoIsn't JLCPCB's turnaround time even slower than OSH Park, for shipping to the US? I know JLCPCB advertises "24h build time" but that's just physical manufacturing. The shipping is at least 4-5 days(!), as per the last time I got a quote. I occasionally make PCBs, as a hobby, and I would love to find a manufacturer with a next-day delivery guarantee to the US (California) for simple 2-layer PCBs. I would pay $50 just for shipping for that service, even for just 2-3 small PCBs that fit in an envelope. But to my knowledge this isn't possible. I hate designing a project, and having to wait a whole week to get my PCB. This truly hampers my creative flow... sigh
- baz00 3y agoDHL takes 2 days to UK. I usually get PCBs snail mail though. I don't mind waiting because I'm a cheap ass. I've got to the point I don't screw up the PCBs now anyway (every time you screw up write something on a checklist and don't do it again!) As for next day, you can pay to get anything like that. Years ago I worked for a large company that had an in house PCB fab because it was cheaper than subcontracting out prototypes and production builds to third parties. They were quoting 500-800 GBP a board and much much more for Rogers for the same week production. We are truly in magical times now for how cheap this stuff has got.
- axegon_ 3y agoMaking PCB's truly is an awesome experience. But I have to disagree with one of the statements(though it is a regional thing): > Designing a PCB and sending it off to fab is surprisingly accessible and feels like a super power. That may very well be the case if you live in the US, Germany, France or the UK. Go anywhere else and it's a different story. To give you a bit of context, there is a shop that makes them 15 minutes walk from my place. The prices are ridiculous. If you ever need to go through 3 prototypes to fix some mistakes, you are looking at 3-400 bucks for a total of 9 pcb's. And while you can order from abroad easily, shipping costs+the additional time you need to wait makes the price tags identical. Meaning it's cheaper to get a laser cutter/engraver or an sla 3d printer and make them at home. Sure, they turn our a bit sloppy, no matter how much effort you put into them but it's worth it at the end of the day. Kind of a shame that laser cutter, sla printers, CNC's have become dirt cheap. I would have imagined that some sort of democratization of pcb manufacturing would have happened by now but here we are...
- danhor 3y agoI think most people the US and europe have switched over to chinese manufacturers like jlcpcb or similar for small batch-size PCBs, since they're cheaper and more user friendly. I would've expected them to ship to most of the world, is that not the case?
- axegon_ 3y agoThey claim to do but shipping from China has always been a hellish experience for me. 6 month delays have pretty much been the standard. And if that's not bad enough, filling up paperwork for the customs is just as shitty of an experience. Sadly hacking pcbs together in my basement/attic/on the roof is the least painful experience. The annoying bit is really the time I spend doing it. But living on the last floor and being the only one with a direct access to the roof is definitely a privilege: ferric chloride truly smells like ass.
- Beijinger 3y agoIf Laura does a multivibrator, I would have expected something else.
- selcuka 3y agoSlightly tangential, but when I read something like "my first PCB" I immediately think of drawing the circuit on a PCB with a permanent marker, letting it bath in FeCl3 solution, then drilling the holes with a mini drill. Apparently those times are over now, but I still think that it would be faster (and subjectively more fun) for such a simple circuit.
- dekhn 3y agoYou can still do that- or even just mill away copper clad- but dealing with solvents is messy, and the process is fairly time-consuming, labor intensive, and is useful mainly for fairly simple designs (this board qualifies).
- max_ 3y agoI really love the idea of Recurse Centre. It seems like a non coercive type of education, where people follow their curiosity and at the end finnish up with something tangible. I honestly think if education is to change for the better, it should turn into something like many Recurse Centers, for Music, Technology, Medicine, Pharmacy, Art etc. And the kinds of stories, like the one linked always make me think that I am right. I like listening to them. My dream is to one day make enough money and build something like Recurse Center in my country.
- scsteps 3y agoWow, building physical tech feels so much more approachable because of stuff like this
- mips_r4300i 3y agoBack in 2007 when I did my first board, the only option I could afford was a US fab that had a "33 each" special. You got a 2layer board with HASL finish and had to order 3 of them. So it cost $100. If you were academic they'd let you order just 1. That's what I did. I remember being at school eating lunch when my brand new flip phone rings, and it's a sales rep from Advanced Circuits asking me about my estimated annual volume, while my friends where throwing pizza slices at the lunch table.