9 ms·
Zoom Fatigue Is Real, According to Brain Scans
- blueridge 3y agoHere's a great article by Michael Sacasas about Zoom fatigue: https://theconvivialsociety.substack.com/p/a-theory-of-zoom-fatigue https://theconvivialsociety.substack.com/p/a-theory-of-zoom-...
- eikenberry 3y agoReading the article it sounds a bit like he is describing zoom/video-conf as sort of the uncanny valley of in person communications. We want to make sense of it in the usual way as it is close but the differences stress the process and tire the individual. I'm also curios if this will at all be relatable to how introverts find in person communication tiring. Maybe that same stress is at work there but from the start, without the need for the differences introduce by zoom. It will be interesting to see how the research on this plays out.
- hedgehog 3y agoI spend a lot of time on calls of different sorts and I've found that I really prefer voice only and I think it allows for slightly higher quality discussion. Informal video where everyone is free to drift in and out of frame works really well too.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mthomasmw 3y agohttps://twin-cities.umn.edu/news-events/do-images-brain-make-us-more-likely-believe-what-we-read https://twin-cities.umn.edu/news-events/do-images-brain-make...
- marginalia_nu 3y agoIt's a weird notion that experiences only are real when they show up in brain scans.
- gipp 3y agoThank you, what a rubbish headline
- garbanz0 3y agoIt's more true that brain scans are only real when they show up in our experience. :)
- johnfn 3y agoEh, it's somewhat forgivable. How on earth are you going to get a headline like "Zoom Fatigue Is Real, According to My Experience" to work? If I posted that onto HN, I'd get 100 people telling me that actually, remote is fine and just as good as in-person, if not better.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- contravariant 3y agoI suppose it's good to investigate what exactly is happening, but surely we didn't need to do a scientific study to check if it exists? Have we now advanced empiricism so far that experiencing something yourself is not enough any more? Anyway, just to make sure I suppose we'd better gather some volunteers to make sure running long distances makes people tired.
- serial_dev 3y agoA: I hate being in zoom meetings all day. B: Do you have a peer reviewed study about it?
- hotnfresh 3y agoWe got accustomed to it, but it never stopped feeling super weird, I think, somewhere deep in our heads. A wall of faces staring at your neck is not what any real in-person thing feels like. A wall of facings looking in your eyes isn’t, either, for that matter, but the constantly-averted-gazes do add even more to the weirdness. You don’t feel so constantly watched in person, unless you’re doing a presentation. I did a little work with one of the Big 3 management consulting firms about… oh, four or five years back, well after everyone cool and most non-cool had adopted Zoom or some other video chat for work calls. They favored actual dial-in conference calls. At first I thought they were dinosaurs, but the more I considered it the more I thought they had the right idea. Nothing to download or permissions to allow. Doesn’t tie up your laptop. Don’t need a laptop out at all, in fact. Phone number and code digits are all you need, can record that on a napkin. Mass video chat’s so weird that I’m not sure the video’s adding value anyway, if you’re not screen sharing.
- Gigachad 3y agoI absolutely hate calls. WFH works well when you just need to grind out something solo, but it’s awful to communicate. Personally I go in the office 1-2 days a week. If you want to talk to me, do it in person those days. If you add me to some 10 person video call. I’m just going to zone out.
- colechristensen 3y agoI find meetings I shouldn’t have been invited to a great time to do the dishes. Likewise big status update meetings with low information content.
- selykg 3y agoWish that was easy for me. The people I work with seem to insist on having video on.
- Gigachad 3y agoBecause video off meetings are entirely pointless and just shouldn't be run. Not to say that turning video on magically makes the meetings have point, but if you are muted, video off, and doing the dishes, you just shouldn't be in that call. Requiring video on probably makes people push back against being invited to useless meetings rather than seeing it as an hour to clean the house.
- kstenerud 3y agoSounds like my regular in-person communication experience. I wonder if this is why I don't notice any difference between zoom and in-person? A big thing that I like about zoom vs in-person is the knowledge that I can turn the camera and microphone off, and that as soon as I end the call I'll be instantly, blissfully alone.
- gardenhedge 3y agoThe problem is most companies seem allergic to working asynchronously. During covid, they moved to Zoom calls but didn't bother changing how they work.
- fullshark 3y agoThe truth is a modern office is based on hacking fundamental components of humans and their desire for tribal membership and signals + rewards there of. The tricks don't work as well over a zoom call.
- teaearlgraycold 3y agoToo bad most of us need to work to live. Might as well take the lesser of two evils.
- Kuinox 3y agoThere is something that I noticed quickly: The fatigue depend of the quality of the call. If someone in the call have a lot of background noise, have noisy environement, or a bad microphone, it takes a lot of mental energy to process what they say.
- jakeinspace 3y agoI just sat through a 3 hour french class that got moved onto teams last minute since the instructor is sick. 20 people who can barely communicate in french, unprepared, with crappy laptop microphones... I wanted to jump out the window then entire time.
- atleastoptimal 3y agometaverse will solve this
- eropple 3y agoThe biggest thing that leads to this, I think, is bad audio. Listening to shitty scratchy laptop microphones -- or even the comparatively-excellent Apple array microphones -- is deeply fatiguing. I notice a distinct difference in energy expended when I'm on a call with people who have low/zero background noise and decent-quality microphones, and others have noted that about me (as I'm also an audio engineer in my spare time and tend to have pretty good audio and video in teleconferences).
- gryfft 3y agoThrowing in probabilistic latency and some occasional distortion and I think the fact that it almost works well enough some or most of the time makes it _worse_: instead of just getting used to a certain base rate of distortion like one might with a walkie-talkie or lossy landline, you end up constantly on edge, uncertain if you're going to fall out of sync and start talking over someone else, asking people to repeat things again and again-- it's punishments on a randomized reward schedule, a slot machine that deals out miscommunication that the communicating parties can't control or mitigate by changing their behavior. I'm going to lose control and smash my macbook one of these days.
- tayo42 3y agoI don't understand why companies don't invest in this. It doesn't seem that expensive to provide headsets, I'm already getting an expensive MacBook.
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoNo one should be using built in audio IO on their laptops. A proper headset, with a relatively nice attached mic should be considered minimum viable equipment for VoIP calls, and companies should as such supply them, just like they do laptops.
- whiddershins 3y agoWhat’s sad is that the relatively expensive and high end apple Bluetooth headsets also sound awful. Blame Bluetooth blame whatever, but AirPods Pro and AirPods Max should sound incredible at their price point. And they just don’t. They sound obviously filtered and robotic. And also the latency they add is a problem.
- sesm 3y agoWhat can a person do to make Zoom calls less exhausting for themselves? I would be happy to hear any tips.
- cpeterso 3y agoI keep my camera on, but turn off my own self view. I read this recommendation on HN here just a couple weeks ago and I now do it all the time. It's less distracting and I feel less self-conscious. It also frees up more of my screen real estate for other faces. Just make sure your camera setup is good at the start of each call before turning off self view!
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoCameras should rarely be used. They don't help, they just drastically add to the fatigue. Sound quality needs be kept as high as possible, which means everyone involved needs decent equipment. Comfortable, over-the-ear headsets, with either good built-in microphone arms, or standalone mics. Don't use VoIP providers that can't figure out basic noise reduction or over-compress the audio, and you'll be in a much more tolerable spot.
- nunez 3y ago- Take a long break during the day - Take short breaks throughout the day, like getting coffee/water, etc. - Turn off self view! - If you code, try to cluster your meetings together to reduce context switching. Block focus time on your calendar to avoid drive-by meetings that break up these clusters. - Invest in good headphones and a good mic. Others might have bad sound quality but you definitely won't. Also, it will be easier to hear others even if they have bad sq
- deprecative 3y ago> - Take a long break during the day Your status goes yellow and you're fired. >- If you code, try to cluster your meetings together to reduce context switching. Block focus time on your calendar to avoid drive-by meetings that break up these clusters. If you code, you don't have enough authority to do this.
- zmmmmm 3y agoMy guess is our brains are basically incapable of ignoring faces. It's hard coded at such a deep level. So what happens when you are confronted with an ENTIRE WALL of faces? Your circuitry goes crazy trying to map, constantly monitory, interpret them all. This is not how in person meetings work - you look at one person at a time even if you are in a room of 15 people. Its one reason why I think there could actually be a usefulness to meeting in VR if that ever does become high enough quality and low enough burden for people to want to do it.
- dtjb 3y agoI like that Teams added the option to hide your self-view. Even if you don't focus on it, just having a slightly delayed mirror copy of yourself in the corner of the screen is mildly distracting. It feels more natural talking to a group of people that doesn't include yourself.
- gumballindie 3y agoStop using zoom and stop holding endless meetings.
- booleandilemma 3y agoUnfortunately my present manager loves meetings. The worst part is after we get through the agenda he starts rambling about whatever topic is on his mind, like one of those old people you see at the supermarket who talk to the cashier and who are in obvious need of social interaction. The man doesn't know how to end a meeting.
- gumballindie 3y agoI know that feeling. When I was managing remote engineers I made a point out of not holding meetings unless strictly necessary. Anything urgent could be raised on chat, and if devs felt the need for a meeting they’d hold it and optionally involve me as well. At some point even dailys were reduced to a morning message about the previous day and the current day. Until a “scrum master” was brought in and the shit show started. However that role was quickly made redundant and things got back to normal - including productivity which stuttered for a while due to the aforementioned adventure. In terms of tech we used whatever we felt was relevant. The client was a top 100 corpo, worldwide. I find it slightly amusing when people confidently think that the only way to produce anything of value is by endless talking and hair splitting. I find that a sign of inexperience - which is fine if it doesnt become a virtue - or worse, i think in some that’s a sign or ladder climbing bullshit. I know for a fact that if you trust the people you hired for being trustworthy and suitable for the role you will get couple of times more value from their work. And letting them work also tends to get more work done.
- dankwizard 3y agoThats why I use google meet : - )
- digitalabyss 3y agoZoom was great when everybody was working from home. Audio quality was never a problem. Everybody on my team are on high end macbook pros and in some cases had personal higher end podcast/streamer equipment. Your not squinting at a TV on the wall 15 feet away when someone is sharing their screen. Everybody was far more prompt for meetings since they where not physically changing locations or waiting for the people who had the conference room before them to vacate. Its the hybrid mix that I can't stand. I remained a remote employee when everyone else was forced back into the office. Now I have no idea who is talking or who is in the room half the time. The AV setups in the conference rooms pick up any background conversations and amplify them. The cameras randomly are zooming in and out at the wrong person. Nobody is ever on time to the meetings anymore because they have to move between physical locations. There tends to be a conversation in progress when the conference room finally joins the call.
- binary132 3y agoThis brought to you by the same geniuses behind "the sky is blue sometimes" and "water confirmed wet"
- methou 3y agoWhile attending longer video conferences where I don't have to speak I just put my headset on and do something housework, like vacuuming the floors and some food prepping. For those I have/want to talk, I feel that most difficult part is that it's hard to get into the conversation if it's hybrid, people attenuating in a meeting can easily use facial expression and/or body languages to indicate they want to interrupt or add something in it, while for us on the big screen, some of the people couldn't read the cue, unless someone virtually "raised a hand" with a binging sound. My best experience with the meetings are the smaller ones that everyone has the camera on, speak in turn, giving feedback by using "raise a hand" button in a row, and don't take details offline. (around 60% of hour meetings are in this way - weekly). One upside about larger video calls is that you can read participants expression without them realizing.
- atlgator 3y agoSo you spend all afternoon in Zoom meetings, let's say back to back for 4 hours? How does that differ from in-person meetings? You're exhausted in either scenario.
- ehnto 3y agoFor me personally it's information deficit and context dissonance that fatigues me. When I am in a meeting room I see all the faces, I can tell what everyone is looking at and read their emotions from their movements etc. It's all subconscious though so I am not distracted by this process. I also know when I am not being looked at, and can relax some of my own social cues. In an online meeting, I get none of that so I am working a bit harder to piece everyones contributions to the meeting together. I also have the dissonance of context, I am in a meeting here but also on my computer and in my house. You get good at it but you are fighting off distractions regardless. Meetings are a pain regardless but I do find them less tiring in person.
- nunez 3y agoYou're basically talking to yourself for four hours That sucks
- randyrand 3y agoi think the latency is the biggest fatigue. it’s constantly making our brains annoyed.
- lbourdages 3y agoIt's so difficult to intervene at just the right time. When you're in person, you can just immediately start talking after whoever was talking stops. There are rarely conflicts about two people starting talking at the same time. The nonverbal cues also help everyone see who'll be responding. In Zoom, you start as soon as your audio and video feed tells you to, but by then someone else has started talking, which leads to the infamous "sorry, go ahead" ritual. It's annoying. The more people there are, the worse it is.
- steveBK123 3y agoI dunno, my baseline is I've worked on global teams for 90% of my career going back nearly 2 decades at this point. Zoom is better than phone, and I was never going to be in the same office as these people anyway..
- pllbnk 3y agoSo is live meeting fatigue. Recently I had to spend a few days in the office (I work remotely, so thankfully it's at most 10 days a year) and I must say I never felt so tired while working from home or having even long calls over Zoom. What I am trying to say is that probably fatigue comes from getting disengaged. If you're participating and you find meaning in what you're doing, it doesn't really matter over what medium it's done. But sure, if you have to stare at your screen while knowing that you're being broadcast to your colleagues and the call is irrelevant to you, of course you will feel tired. In the office meeting room you can at least pretend you are doing some important stuff while scrolling at your laptop or phone. Organizations should embrace asynchronous communication and whatever meetings need to be done, it should be ensured that only relevant parties are participating.
- Threeve303 3y agoRemember when everyone called it video conferencing?
- ochronus 3y agoYes, it is! I've written about the contributing factors (and some remedies): https://leadership.garden/zoom-fatigue/ https://leadership.garden/zoom-fatigue/
- tommiegannert 3y agohttp://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-45374-y http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-45374-y Based on ECG and EEG. n=35. I wonder if eye strain doesn't blend into it too. Focusing on a screen is exhausting, and a clear difference from in-person meetings across a table. If you're a computer worker, having regular in-person meetings might be good for this reason too.
- thefz 3y agoRoom fatigue is real as well. Try working in a noisy environment concentrating while other people talk and make general noise. I'll take Zoom fatigue any day.
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y agoZoom Fatigue? Why not call it "Video Conference Fatigue"? It sounds like FUD
- lamontcg 3y agoAre scientists discovering anyone who is immune to zoom fatigue? Because I went full-time WFH in 2015 or so and never experienced it and have never understood what people are talking about. I hate IRL meetings much more when you want to hide behind your laptop and yet want to act like you're paying attention and yet you're bored to death. With zoom if someone starts pinging you something important over slack you can just mute and hide your video and respond and let yourself be distracted while keeping a bit of your attention on what is going on in the meeting. In IRL, you're stuck trying to sort out the urgency of responding to the issue in slack vs. the urgency of appearing to pay attention to the meeting you're stuck in. And I haven't even had "zoom fatigue" when I've been the presenter in 2 hour long recorded training sessions with junior devs, even though I'm an introvert. I get a bit exhausted after doing that, but talking at people for 2 hours just exhausts the shit out of me any time. That last bit kind of makes me wonder if extroverts experience "zoom fatigue" due to actually experiencing self-reflection in conversations for the first time or something like that.
- hikarikuen 3y agoWhile I'm sure most of us have relevant anecdotes for both in-person and videoconferencing, I'm not sure how relevant the circumstances in the study (watching a videoconference lecture) are to typical workplace experiences (participating in a videoconference conversation).