4 ms·
The devs of Windmill seem to have taken the winning advice of "do one thing and do it well" and done the exact opposite. Going over windmill.dev I have no idea
by paxys 3y ago
The devs of Windmill seem to have taken the winning advice of "do one thing and do it well" and done the exact opposite. Going over windmill.dev I have no idea what specifically the software should be used for. Is it a competitor to Retool? Airflow? Temporal? Apparently there's a no-code workflow builder? A drag and drop UI builder? An online IDE? Dozens of integrations? What on earth is going on??
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- debarshri 3y agoDoing one thing well is not a winning advice. You can do multiple things, it really depends on the execution and other factors. They are doing one that is workflows and doing it well.
- sisve 3y agoAlso they are using postgres for everything. I think that is a good example of picking one thing that you know very well and using that to the limits. But i do agree that windmill is doing so many things that the elevator pitch need some work. But a lot of companies are trying to do the same. So i do not think people will think of workflow engine + online ide + app builder as a natural grouping in 5 years
- MuffinFlavored 3y agoI don't really understand what a "workflow" is / what it means. Like GitHub Actions is a workflow, but it's a convoluted YAML wrapper around shell scripts. Is a workflow shell scripts? I'm going to guess no. I'm going to guess it's "code". So... why is a workflow code but code isn't a workflow? Windmill is a "workflow (code?)" orchestrator?
- jagtstronaut 3y agoYeah I assumed this was a camunda competitor (a bpmn workflow product), but it seems like it is not that.
- uoaei 3y agoOne task is the elementary unit of business operations, and one workflow is one DAG of tasks.
- Bonapara 3y agoLooks like a workflow engine to me
- rubenfiszel 3y agoThe critics is more than fair and our positioning is not very clear. We are doing a developer platform for enterprise to build internal software, including apis, workflows, background jobs, and UIs using code, but only where it matters. We happen to be quite decent in all aspects, with a focus on performance, and we have an active community of users and customers that are mostly developers and hence have plethora of feedback and feature requests, so we're happy to oblige. By being at the right level and trying to expose the code as much as possible, we can be great generalists without sacrificing on the quality. Python, Typescripts, Go, Bash and all the query languages are where all the complexity is and capabilities come from. They are well developed languages with great ecosystem. We merely provide a way to run those language in a system fit for production at enterprise scale.
- MuffinFlavored 3y ago> We are doing a developer platform for enterprise to build internal software > for enterprise I mentioned this product to my enterprise boss and his enterprise answer was "we can't easily get this approved by tech-selection committee for no good reason" (and that would have just been to have an off-to-the-side proof-of-concept instance or two running in our sandbox k8s cluster let alone actually bringing it onboard as a paid service) How do enterprise users not already have the functionality you are offering covered one way or another and why would they migrate off of what they have to what you are offering? What kind of business today doesn't have something like ActiveBatch, AWS/Azure functionality with massive cloud support contracts, etc. already?
- rubenfiszel 3y agoYou can't win every contracts but the market we're after is immense and so even a small percentage of enterprises being more daring is sufficient. But the argument is true for any enterprise software, you cannot be small and sell to enterprise (or you must have amazing product market fit), that's where open-source comes in. We have overlap with many existing products, but we are the only one to provide such product, with emphasis on DX and excellent performance and scalability, and to be open-source. We do currently have a few big enterprise customers and many enterprise open-source users. It's a lot easier to get approval since they get it for free and it's fully self-hostable and air-grappable. Once they have tried it on a few non-essential workflow and see the benefits, then they are more motivated to make a case internally. Wide net, some catches until it becomes ubiquitous. I happen to be a really strong believer in open-source so it's not just an adoption strategy but I think it happens to be also fortunately the best strategy for such infra level software.
- MuffinFlavored 3y ago> Is it a competitor to Retool? Airflow? Temporal? If it makes you feel any better, I'm pretty sure I personally couldn't tell you specifically what any of those specifically do in terms of "the one thing they do well" / why anybody would ever use one instead of the other / not need to use all 3 to accomplish the same thing slightly different ways
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- knowsuchagency 3y agoI had the same thought when it popped up on my radar a year ago. Now that I’ve been using it for a few weeks, it’s difficult to go back to the exact tools you’re naming. I didn’t realize how large of an impediment it is to move back and forth all of them. Windmill is the thing I never knew I needed. It’s changed how I think about delivering data products/solutions.
- Kiro 3y agoWhat are you using it for? I don't understand the purpose of any of these tools.
- j45 3y agoThe intersection of all those areas listed is often an inordinate amount of work and integration and maintenance. In that way as people want an easily grokable description, windmill seems to be a super-platform that leverages enough of the important bits that come up. I am going to try it out!
- halostatue 3y agoFor our purposes it looks like Windmill might take the place of MWAA (Airflow) that we were planning for our ELT pipelines and could take the place of Rundeck as well. I'll need to look at it and play with it (especially from the ELT pipeline perspective for running transformers), but I suspect that we will be able to be up and running both faster and cheaper with either self-hosted Windmill or cloud.
- zo1 3y agoI'm also very confused about the pricing. Its "open-source" but with SSO user-limits? Paid version comes with Prometheus metrics, so does that mean the open-source free tier doesn't? So many questions.
- anonzzzies 3y agoMany others have done the same thing (I mean, something like airtable is now 'everything' as well, as are many others). It's hard to do positioning though like this I must admit; for new users it's almost impossible to say what exactly it is. The 'what can I do with it?' -> 'everything' type of thing.