5 ms·
"Iowa Governor Terry Branstad, whose state is home to a BPI plant, is seeking a congressional investigation of what he calls a “smear campaign” against BPI." L
by joezydeco 15y ago
"Iowa Governor Terry Branstad, whose state is home to a BPI plant, is seeking a congressional investigation of what he calls a “smear campaign” against BPI."
Look, it's a lot simpler than that. It had nothing to do with the idea of mechanically separated meat (wait until they learn about McNuggets!)
A lot of parents quickly got exposed to the concept of beef being treated with ammonia. All the science reports in the world can prove it's effective and safe, but you can't erase that mental image in their heads that (food + poison) = bad. The mindset of a parent is just different from that of a food processing executive.
- bmj 15y agoThe issue is that people really don't want to know how their food is produced (remember the ol' adage about sausages and laws?). As soon as they learn what industrial-scale food production looks like, they begin to turn their noses. Did these parents really think that the hamburger a school was serving its kids was composed of anything more than the scraps from the proverbial butcher's floor? As far as science proving things "safe and effective," this is a sliding scale, no? There have been plenty of things once declared safe and effective that ultimately were discovered to be not so safe and effective (particularly when the science comes from someone sympathetic to the cause).
- wpietri 15y agoThat's not quite it. People pretty clearly do want to know. And they would like to believe their food is produced in a way that seems wholesome to them. So yes, I think parents did think that school hamburgers were of roughly the same quality that they'd get if they decided to make it at home. Hoewver, I think that people a) like things to be cheap, and b) are too lazy to look into things in detail. That worked to the advantage of the meat producers for a while. But this country has a history of panics around food, and there's been a trend for decades in the direction of less processing. So I'm not going to shed many tears for these folks. What they did may have been innovative when they started, but they shouldn't have expected it to continue happily forever.
- bmj 15y agoWell, people wanting to know is a fairly new thing, and I think quite a few people still prefer not to know. I reckon that most people who truly care how their food is produced don't allow their kids to eat school lunches. That said, I agree--I'm not shedding any tears either. Personally, I care quite about how my food is produced, and as a result, essentially all of the meat my family consumes is sourced from producers with a great deal of transparency.
- grannyg00se 15y agoI believe people actually prefer not to know. I can recall several instances where a friend would say "I'd rather not hear about that" when I point out how their poultry is injected, processed, killed, packed and shipped. If people really did want to know they would realize that it's actually difficult to find out first hand, and then laws would have to be changed. And people might eat a lot less meat. I do agree that people would like to believe their food is produced in a way that seems wholesome to them. The way they do that is by not asking questions. Even something as simple as orange juice isn't produced in the way that most people would expect and accept.
- zdean 15y ago"I think parents did think that school hamburgers were of roughly the same quality that they'd get if they decided to make it at home." If the beef they were buying for their home burgers was from Walmart (or any one of the many retailers selling pink slime beef), then the parents were correct to think the quality was the same.
- jballanc 15y agoHeh...just wait until the world learns what gives Brie it's distinctive flavor.
- ramy_d 15y agoHah, just read it. Same deal, no one cares until kids start eating it I guess.
- cracell 15y agoLooking at the wikipedia article on Brie and I'm confused as to what you are referring to. You just mean the mold?
- jballanc 15y agoThe mold used produces ammonia as a side product. Too much ammonia means overripe cheese, which is no good, but a little touch of ammonia is an important component of the overall flavor.
- joshuahedlund 15y agoI thought I read somewhere that the ammonia made the meat smell bad, so they tried using less, which wasn't enough to kill the E. coli or salmonella or whatever and led to some outbreaks. There's a lot of hyperbole going both ways, but I don't blame people for not wanting to be caught between the tradeoffs of smelly ammonia and sickening E. coli. (Unless of course I've got something inaccurate.)
- joezydeco 15y agoRemember that the processors also tried sterilization via gamma radiation to prevent E. coli and botulism and other nasties. That was met with just as much resistance due to image-vs-science. The meat wouldn't be any more radioactive than the food coming out of your microwave, but just saying "radiation" did it in.
- stan_rogers 15y agoDid nobody else here grow up with ammonia cookies[1]? (Almost everything I can find online now is about the peppermint variety, which I didn't much care for. I loved the lemon sort as a kid.) [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ammonia_cookie http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ammonia_cookie
- freiheit 15y agoI remember an old german anise cookie recipe my grandmother used to make, but had to stop when she couldn't find hartshorn (ammonium carbonate) anymore. I don't recall much ammonia smell or taste in the final cookie.
- protomyth 15y agoWell, these parents should avoid ice cream also. // ice cream plants are not the safest work site