6 ms·
Not surprised. That said, Panun did also threaten to blow up an Air India flight by Nov 19th (clearly didn't happen). That said, there won't be blowback betwe
by alephnerd 3y ago
Not surprised.
That said, Panun did also threaten to blow up an Air India flight by Nov 19th (clearly didn't happen).
That said, there won't be blowback between India and US relations as a whole. The US is too important to India and India is too important to the US.
The Indian method also sucks from an OpSec standpoint - Indian agencies transfer Senior Police from state level to RAW or IB and those state police departments might brag about it on their websites. This is a big issue with Punjab Police (who tend to manage the Khalistan issue)
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Panun did also threaten to blow up an Air India flight by Nov 19th Source? The article says “Pannun angered Indian officials this month by issuing a video in which he warned Sikhs not to fly on Air India because it would be ‘life threatening’ and that “he told the FT he was not making a violent threat against the airline. Given the context of Sikhs being murdered overseas by New Delhi, that statement seems to have multiple reasonable interpretations.
- alephnerd 3y agoI'm trying to find a way to share the video from Instagram to HN. I'm not sure how to generate a share link.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> the video from Instagram If this is the best source available, we’re probably best without it.
- alephnerd 3y agoHis organization - Sikhs for Justice - only posts on Instagram and FB
- ra7 3y agoAn Air India flight was blown up in 1985 by Canadian Sikh terrorists killing 329 people. With that context, it’s easy to see how this would be considered a threat. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_India_Flight_182 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_India_Flight_182
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> With that context, it’s easy to see how this would be considered a threat Not really? Threats require specificity and credibility. Using simply ethnicity or even cause as the sole qualifier for credibility isn’t something most people do.
- ra7 3y agoIt’s not quite the same thing though, is it? This is a person with a history of provocations making an indirect threat. I’m not saying he deserves punishment, but I can see why the Indian government would take his threat very seriously.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> a person with a history of provocations making an indirect threat It’s sort of like an Iranian student group saying American Airlines isn’t safe to fly anymore. Like, okay? Not nice. But not quite a threat. (Certainly not a credible one.)
- natureGood14 3y agoThe issue is that this statement of Panun will be used against innocent Sikhs and will cause undue burden on them, in the worst case leading to human rights violations. India has no qualms with using draconian laws like UAPA, NSA, and sedition and ruin the livelihoods of people and their families.
- shri_krishna 3y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> literally put out a direct threat warning Sikhs not to board Air India flights and that Indira Gandhi Airport will be attacked on November 19th Is there a credible translation? The parts in English are indistinguishable from a call for boycott. (Not disagreeing.)
- OJFord 3y agoI don't know how credible I am (fwiw white British, Christened but agnostic, no particular bias except perhaps 'hey guys can't you resolve this peacefully somehow') and it's difficult for me to understand much, but I think he's not being that direct about it, but kind of alluding to it, talking a bit euphemistically. In the beginning after saying 'we are urging Sikhs not to fly Air India' in English, which sounds like boycott, he switches to Hindi[0] and says similar with 'on the 19th November' (unnis navambar ko) - why would a boycott be so specific; then he says same date 'Indira Gandhi airport [Delhi international, i.e. North India but not Punjab] will be closed' (band rahega). Later he says something about 'khalistani airport' which I would guess is his way of referring to Amritsar or Chandigarh (the two international airports in Punjab afaict, perhaps the former because it's cleanly Punjab vs. the latter seems to be the capital city of both Punjab and Haryana states, kind of an interesting quirk) but it's difficult for me to understand much more. Edit: actually it's Chandigarh, I just realised the sentence is 'Shaheed Bhagat Singh [name of Chandigarh airport] will be the khalistani airport' (khalistani airport hoega). Again you could say it's a boycott: take your money to Punjab's airports, not Delhi's - but why's the latter 'closed', why 19 November specifically. As an economic boycott, that being done by the subset of Sikhs who follow him on a single day would have trivial impact, it'd be completely inconsequential. I realise that's not much, maybe it helps a bit, I was mainly interested for myself as a learning exercise really! (My vocabulary's quite limited, but more than that I struggle just with listening/speaking fast enough, so trying to practice more in ways other than reading.) [0] or maybe Punjabi, I'd have thought it would be, and they're similar enough spoken that I'd pick bits up anyway, but seems more familiar (i.e. Hindi) word endings/conjugations to me (even where I don't know the actual word) than there would be if it was Punjabi (which I might recognise from '-da's and '-di's for example)
- local_crmdgeon 3y agoThat the US and India aren't each other's closest ally confuses me. It's the 2 biggest democracies, both are on uneasy terms with China, there's an enormous Desi diaspora here. Both are heavy into high-tech with struggling manufacturing bases. Both have a history of trouble with Islamic terrorism, both ardent allies of Israel. Each is the largest country in their region. Hell, we speak the same language (kinda, I know it's a lingua franca etc)! So why are we allies with Pakistan, a country that openly hates us, instead of India?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> the US and India aren't each other's closest ally confuses me We increasingly are. > why are we allies with Pakistan, a country that openly hates us, instead of India? India openly allied with the Soviets, so we took the other side. Also, India was an immature democracy through the 70s, when it flirted with outright authoritarianism. It isn’t until recently that it has become a middle-income democracy with a high-income upper-middle class and cosmopolitan elite.
- ra7 3y ago> India openly allied with the Soviets, so we took the other side. I’m afraid you have it backwards. India and the Soviet Union signed a treaty only after the US sent its seventh fleet towards India during the 1971 India-Pakistan conflict. US supported Pakistan in the war and India had no choice but to align with the Soviets to deter them.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> India and the Soviet Union signed a treaty only after the US sent its seventh fleet towards India during the 1971 India-Pakistan conflict New Delhi and Moscow were transferring technology in “steel, defense, railways, construction equipment, metal & mining [and] petrochemicals” by the time “Khrushchev announced that the Soviet Union supported India's stance on the Kashmir conflict against Pakistan and over Portuguese coastal enclaves such as Goa” in 1955 [1]. The MiG-21 was co-produced in India in the 1960s. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/India–Soviet_Union_relations#History https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/India–Soviet_Union_relations...
- natureGood14 3y agoMany Sikhs (including myself) believe Panun is a professional provocateur. This recent statement of his is downright insane.
- alephnerd 3y agoMa vi veere.
- jakderrida 3y agoHe does seem very un-Sikh. In my experience, quickest way to disarm a Kirpan is to just tell the assailant I'm not a Sikh. I don't understand the theology behind it. As far as I can guess, everyone outside the Khalsa are functionally children, limiting Sikh violence to just other Sikhs. I've observed multiple bizarre Sikh tendencies like that and observe them nowhere else. Another is the tendency for Sikh cab drivers being stabbed or shot after refusing to deny they are muslim, the rate of which far exceeding actual muslims, which means that muslims have less qualms denying they are muslim than sikhs.
- catlover76 3y ago[flagged]