5 ms·
it's not cool for companies to try to shut down academic freedom of inquiry in scholarly publishing in order to improve their public image her independence fro
by kragen 3y ago
it's not cool for companies to try to shut down academic freedom of inquiry in scholarly publishing in order to improve their public image
her independence from openai was the nominal reason she was asked to supervise it in the first place, wasn't it
- foota 3y agoI'm not sure you should get to have your cake and eat it too.
- 15457345234 3y agoYou seem to be fundamentally misunderstanding the role of non-executive board members. In many cases they're industry experts / academics and in many cases those academics continue to publish papers that look objectively at the actions of all companies in their sphere of influence, including the one they're on the board of. It's _expected_ for them to publish this type of material. It's literally their job. Cheerleading is for the C-suite.
- foota 3y agoThey've admitted that they think it would be better to destroy open AI than to continue on its path, but how can an organization uphold its goals if it doesn't exist? Imo you have to commit to working within an organization if you're on its board, you can't burn it down from within. I think it's less of an issue to try to remove the CEO if you don't agree with the direction they're taking, but this was obviously done in a sloppy manner in this case, and their willingness to destroy it makes me distrust them (not that my opinion matters per se).
- 15457345234 3y ago> but this was obviously done in a sloppy manner I don't think it was done in a sloppy manner, I think there's a huge amount of spin and froth being generated to make it _look_ like it was done in a sloppy manner, but the reality is that the board took an executive action, released a discreet and concisely worded press release and then fell silent, which is 100% professional behaviour. To me it's the other side that are acting sloppily, they're thrashing around like maniacs, they're obviously calling in favours behind the scenes as supportive articles are popping up all over the place, apparently employees were calling other employees in the middle of the night urging them to sign the 'I'll quit unless' letter, employees have been fed a misleading narrative (two of them, actually) about why the action was taken in the first place which riled them up... I have to assume here that the board - as they're the ones acting professionally - similarly acted professionally before the firing and discussed the matter at great length and only resorted to this last minute firing because of exigent circumstances. The fact that a fired employee was able to cajole/bluff/whatever his way back into the office to prove some sort of point suggests that the board's action may have been necessary. What exactly was done during that time in the office, one might ask? Were systems accessed? Surely it was an unauthorised entry and a major security violation. You do see that that action (re-entering the office after being fired) gives off lunatic vibes, don't you? Maybe it really did come down to 'yeah you're technically my boss but I'm gonna do whatever the hell I want and there's nothing you can do about it because everyone loves me' to which the board's only possible course of action is to fire immediately.
- foota 3y agoI don't think Sam cajoled their way and talked to the employees, as I understand it Ilya talked with the staff and revealed what they claimed were the reasons for the firing.
- 15457345234 3y agoIn your opinion, was a crime committed when that person returned to the office? Either by himself or by the person that permitted him access knowing beyond any reasonable doubt that they were not authorized to be there? If systems were accessed, was another crime committed? If a person facilitated that access, has the boundary for 'conspiracy to commit...' been reached?
- foota 3y agoWhat? It's my understanding Sam Altman was invited back to talk to the board, and Ilya is still employed there.
- 15457345234 3y agoWere the board members in the office on that day? I just find the whole thing weird. I just think it seems unlikely that a board would decide something then about-face so rapidly as to have a meeting at the office the next day. It would be conventional for further meetings to take place at the offices of lawyers, for example. It would also be normal for the non-fired members of staff to be instructed to have no further contact with the fired person without legal counsel present. Sometimes it seems very much like everyone here is really playing to the cameras in a big way.
- kragen 3y agothat does seem to be what altman was attempting: he wanted to have the cake of independent board members, but eat it by having them never express any opinions contrary to his own
- jxi 3y agoHe wasn't shutting down her academic freedom. However, if you're going to diss what your own company is doing and praise competitors, you probably shouldn't be on the board. >During the call, Jason Kwon, OpenAI’s chief strategy officer, said the board was endangering the future of the company by pushing out Mr. Altman. This, he said, violated the members’ responsibilities. >Ms. Toner disagreed. The board’s mission is to ensure that the company creates artificial intelligence that “benefits all of humanity,” and if the company was destroyed, she said, that could be consistent with its mission. This person is too far gone. Life isn't a movie.
- sudosysgen 3y agoThis is a non-profit, not a for profit company. Nominally, she's on the board precisely to criticize.
- random_cynic 3y ago[flagged]
- comp_throw7 3y ago> A board member cannot sabotage their own company. Criticism (especially valid criticism) is not sabotage, and in any case the board's responsibility is to advance the charter, not to support the (non-profit) company regardless of what it's doing.
- kragen 3y agothat would be true for a for-profit company where her fiduciary duty was to shareholders, but in this case, given the charter in question, not publicly criticizing the company would be more likely to be a breach of her fiduciary duty
- jibal 3y ago> This person is too far gone. Life isn't a movie. This comment is a credibility killer. "This person", as a member of the board of a non-profit, has a duty to keep the non-profit on mission, and even to call for its dissolution if that isn't possible.
- ecshafer 3y agoThere is a difference between independent from an organization, and someone that takes a public stand against a company. Reading that paper, which I am not really impressed with, they are taking a stance that openai's current trajectory is not as good as a competitor. I bet that if a Microsoft board member wrote a paper how Google search is better than Bing / AWS Better than Azure / OSX better than Windows they would be reprimanded also.
- ralfd 3y agoBut I bet if a Greenpeace-like-organization board member would write a paper how a different environmental group is greener, they would be praised.
- abracadaniel 3y agoA comparison to another nonprofit would make more sense. A board member of the Komen Foundation being reprimanded for pointing out that other nonprofits are far more effective at helping cancer research would be a better comparison.
- jibal 3y agoNon-profits and for-profits aren't comparable. The latter have a duty to make money. The former has a duty to its mission.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]