5 ms·
X has been placing ads for Apple, Bravo, IBM, Oracle next to pro-Nazi content
- op00to 3y agoThe mental gymnastics people are making to somehow kowtow to Elon really amaze me. “Who cares if my ad runs over Nazi twitter!” Really? That’s what you’re going with?
- wenderen 3y agoI'm seeing multiple examples of it in this thread at the time of writing! It's baffling. Do they not know how humans brain generally work or are they just being willfully dishonest?
- spiderice 3y agoIt's just human nature to be biased toward the thing that supports your view. It's actually more blatant in you than most people in this thread. Your 3 comments: > I'm no adtech expert but <insert something you want to be true to validate your opinion, despite not knowing if it's true> > Were ads being placed... at the same rate Again, you have no idea what the answer is here. But you clearly think it supports what you believe. > Do they not know how humans brain generally work.. A lot of assumptions baked in here that, what do you know, support your own biases. Your a self-admitted non-expert in adtech, but in the course of 3 comments it's suddenly so baffling that people can't see what is so obvious In other words, HN is full of humans, just like you.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoI really don't understand the problem. Don't nazis buy phones? Or is the real complaint that nazi content is being placed next to ads for typically non-nazi twitter users?
- op00to 3y agoNo advertiser wants to be associated with hateful content.
- isthispermanent 3y agoDidn't the AG of Texas just open an investigation into Media Matters for this, citing fraud? And X sued them on Monday.
- chimerasaurus 3y agoAlso relevant for context on that. https://www.cnn.com/2023/11/21/tech/elon-musk-texas-lawsuit-media-matters/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2023/11/21/tech/elon-musk-texas-lawsuit-...
- isthispermanent 3y agoCNN is not relevant for anything
- smoldesu 3y agoSome fun background on that particular AG: > He has sued president Joe Biden's administration nearly 50 times. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ken_Paxton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ken_Paxton
- isthispermanent 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smoldesu 3y agoNormally I don't stoop to ad-hominem, but we are talking about an indicted felon who was impeached by his own party. Without context you might mistake it for a serious lawsuit.
- isthispermanent 3y agoBetter but still not quite right. Paxton was acquitted of all counts in the Texas Senate and remains in his post. The suing of a presidential admin by a state AG says very little about the merits of the lawsuit. Pointing it out as a reason to dismiss the legitimacy of a suit stains your reply with obvious bias against conservative policy. There are plenty of reasons to not like Paxton. Suing POTUS is not high on the list.
- crest 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- agbrrw 3y ago[flagged]
- Justsignedup 3y agoSure. But do you want to be known as the guy who hangs out a bunch of pedophiles? Man that'd really make you popular at kid's parties with all the parents right? But just hanging out where the pedos are doesn't mean an endorsement. Point is. It's not how humans think.
- eusto 3y agoIs it how humans think? Or is it just media trying to create drama out of nothing? Most of the people who get exposed to extremist content without looking for it will surely not even register the ads around that content. An IBM ad cannot possibly be as noticeable as that. And, of course, the real problem is the presence of said content, not it's placement among ads. Manufactured drama like the one we're looking at here only detracts us from taking about what is really important.
- Justsignedup 3y agoLITERALLY marketing is all about creating associations and perception. That is basically marketing's entire purpose for existing. So to say "well its only media that creates an association because of XXXXXX" sure! Because that is marketing. Thus marketing in a nazi filled content site makes your marketing associate you witrh nazis! Every movie of a dystopian society shows some ads in bloody places, you don't think "man, I wonder if that company really just meant to sell workout equipment, and in no way related to the purge happening below the billboard in that area all the time". Again, its just not how we work. There's a vast difference between saying "I live in a neighborhood that has a nazi in it" and "i actively go and spend my money at a bar that is known for making it easier for nazis to hang out there and harass customers"
- DrThunder 3y ago[dead]
- skymast 3y ago[dead]
- coldtea 3y agoYeah, so? Would the ads be contaminated by being in close promitity to unrelated to them ads? This charade is used since the dawn of internet to police media and social media outlets using advertising boycotts.
- wenderen 3y agoI'm no adtech expert but I suspect that potential customers would form mental associations between two things that often show up together, like pro-Nazi content and the ads I'm sponsoring, and I wouldn't want that.
- coldtea 3y agoYeah, right, they see Apple's ads 24/7 in all kinds of mediums, and alonside 100000 tweets of all persuassions, but it's the 100 tweets most wont even ever see, unless they follow those people, that they'll make associations with the brand...
- ryandrake 3y agoCome on. No mainstream brand wants to be even remotely associated with this content. Merely appearing on the same screen as content that “touts Adolf Hitler and the Nazi Party” is enough of an association to tarnish a brand. If you don’t believe this, start and invest in a wholesome brand and then advertise on Stormfront. This is Marketing 101. > During all of this Musk-induced chaos, corporate advertisements have also been appearing on pro-Hitler, Holocaust denial, white nationalist, pro-violence, and neo-Nazi accounts. Yaccarino has attempted to placate companies by claiming that “brands are now ‘protected from the risk of being next to’ potentially toxic content.” It seems the company knows that this stuff is on there and is paying lip service to protecting brands from it.
- jstarfish 3y agoI'm surprised Stormfront haven't leveraged their own notoriety to do the opposite-- conspicuously support and endorse companies like Apple. Apple's wholesome lineup of all-white products is right in line with Nazi ideology.
- aeternum 3y agoInteresting that Media Matter is trying to double-down on this. Seems non-profits might be even more corrupt than for-profit companies. It's clearly a weak argument, and why are they focusing on X only when they could expand their criticism to the many other social media news feeds. The pants are sagging and the bias is showing.
- Zetobal 3y agoI am not exactly following what is the weak argument?
- chronotis 3y agoNot doubling down, this is just the original article that started the controversy.
- appplication 3y agoIn light this fact, the GP comment reads a lot like disinformation.
- faeriechangling 3y agoI don’t see anything particularly corrupt about mediamatters. Just the normal baseline level of corruption one sees in US politics where corruption has been legalized. It’s just a blatantly partisan operation mostly dedicated to criticism of conservative media with close ties to the Democratic Party and the Clintons. If anything I’m more critical of the SLAPP free speech advocate Elon issued against Media Matters, and Ken Paxton using his power to direct government resources towards a partisan investigation of Media Matters in response to this drama. These BOTH strike me as more corrupt than Media Matters pointing out what posts are appearing by what ads to put pressure on advertisers to cut their ties with Twitter. If anything Musk and Paxton are helping media matters look squeaky clean by contrast.
- smitty1e 3y agoPossibly I am a bit of a right-wing reactionary here, but I have nothing nice to say about Media Matters. My hope is that the case establishes on the record all of the skullduggery that MM peddles. One must support and defend MM's 1A right to be complete pieces work within legal limits. Reasonable persons should also reject their nonsense. In fact, let me go subscribe to X right now. This is a move I have resisted, but the cause of fighting the nitwits merits support.
- tomlockwood 3y agoSeeing a lot of comments here already that don't know what "brand safety" is. We've lived in a time where many media platforms were burning VC money and that brand safety wasn't as important. Now we're seeing everything converge back to middle-of-the-road, inoffensive content due to the reliance on advertising.
- charcircuit 3y agoArticles like this is how you get things like YouTube where even a single swear word in the middle of your video gets it demonitized. I wish brands would be less conservative about potential edge cases of where they show up and I wish journalists would stop painting these edge cases as being what is happening 100% of the time.
- racketcon2089 3y agoI think the complaint is worth reading, not because everything in it has already been proven true, but it's important to understand the claims being made: https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/3428af84caea0c21b620498b06a7414e/X%20lawsuit%20media%20matters.pdf https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/3428af84caea0c21... It's also useful to understand the origin of Media Matters and know a little about its founder, David Brock. He's a lifetime "dirty tricks" political agent who by his own admission in his 2002 memoir has knowingly and repeatedly put not just misleading statements but outright lies in print before. Elon Musk also has a record making misleading statements and in some cases outright lies, but what's under discussion is the observable behavior of the platform which leaves behind a wealth of empirical evidence; logs, humans in the loop, third party caching and scraping, etc. If the outcome of this case becomes available to a prediction market, I would bet 10:1 against Media Matters prevailing absent a full retraction and apology which leads to the suit being dropped.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> I think the complaint is worth reading, not because everything in it has already been proven true, I think its worth reading, because it claims things are false and then describes how they are literally true, if perhaps incomplete. If you know even a little of the applicable law, its also worth reading for entertainment value because its shockingly bad even beyond directly undermining its own falsity claims. There's a lot to go into about how bad, but the crowning bit of absolute failure is that it names two defendants—Media Matters and Eric Hanonoki—but then fails to even mention any allegations against Hanonoki in any of its causes of action (he is mentioned only in footnotes past the “Jurisdiction and Venue” section.)
- racketcon2089 3y agoIs this your opinion as an attorney who is licensed to practice in Texas and has tried cases in this district before or are you speaking as a layperson? As a layperson I might agree with you, but in these sorts of cases the judges tend to play a pivotal role, as do both the economic power of the plaintiff and the existing reputation of the defendants. Many any engineer has been run aground by privileging the predictive power of their own literal interpretation over the case law and disposition of the actual judges.
- jeegsy 3y agoTell that to the judge I say
- ImJamal 3y agoWhy didn't these companies care when their ads were placed next to pro-Nazi and other unsavory content a few years ago?
- wenderen 3y ago(genuine question) Were their ads being placed next to pro-Nazi content at the same rate a few years ago?
- ImJamal 3y agoThe article doesn't say the issue is the rate is higher, just that they are shown next to a pro-Nazi post. I've seen pro-Nazi and similarly gross posts pre-Musk so either the companies didn't care back then or the article is lacking on the real reason.
- DrThunder 3y ago[dead]