7 ms·
No evidence screen time is negative for child cognitive development, well-being
- pixxel 3y agoWho funded this research, or indirectly the institution/s behind the research. I wish this declaration was labelled under the heading for all research. I’m jaded though.
- jari_mustonen 3y agoThe title is misleading. This is not about child cognitive development, merely just some brain imaging. In short, the MRI method can not see the effects of screen time. This is of course a good thing but does mean nothing about cognitive development. From the abstract of the article [1]: We studied a [...] sample of young people [...] (ages 9–12 years) to investigate the relations between self-reported use of various digital screen media activity (SMA) and functional brain organization. [...] Of principal interest were two hypotheses: First, that functional brain organization (assessed through resting state functional connectivity MRI; rs-fcMRI) is related to digital screen engagement; and second, that children with higher rates of engagement will have functional brain organization profiles related to maladaptive functioning. Results did not support either of these predictions for SMA. 1. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001094522300237X?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001094522...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- civilitty 3y agoHopefully it wasn’t the children themselves self reporting their screen time
- SkyBelow 3y agohttps://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001094522300237X?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001094522... >Self-report estimates provided by participants were our predictor variables. Participants used a 7-point scale to estimate the amount of time they spent on each of a series of six digital activities on both “typical” weekday and weekend days; Sounds like it was.
- mrpopo 3y agoSo, this begs the question: what cognitive functions can be diagnosed from an MRI?
- astrea 3y agoI think “merely” brain images is a bit dismissive if by your own quote they’re using functional MRI and comparing the profiles to known maladaptive functioning. Or are you saying that fMRIs can’t possibly capture complex social behaviors?
- chadbr 3y ago“Safe and effective”
- it_citizen 3y agoI forgot where I read that but I remember a neuroscientist studying the impact of TV on learning abilities saying that it is much better to leave a child in a silent room with no stimulation and a dumb toy than putting them in front of a TV program with a lot of cuts and making loud noises. It interrupts their thought process every time there is an abrupt visual or audio change and the baby thinking is reset.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- justrealist 3y agoPeople stop trusting science when they are asked to believe "research" findings which are obviously not true.
- kspacewalk2 3y agoObviously not true, or does not fit your biased priors?
- justrealist 3y agoIt's actually reasonable for people to build theories about the world around them by carefully observing the environment around them.
- kspacewalk2 3y agoCasual observation, always careful in the mind of the observer, is a piss poor substitute for scientific data collection. Are you, as we speak, conducting a double blind, properly controlled and sampled study of juvenile cognitive development and device exposure?
- justrealist 3y ago> Are you, as we speak, conducting a double blind, properly controlled and sampled study of juvenile cognitive development and device exposure The study you are defending is not blinded, controlled, or randomly sampled. Use your brain for a second instead of reacting instinctively. Do you really think this oneoff paper was the result of a 10-year longitudinal study? In fact, the hypothetical study you are describing would cost millions of dollars, never pass an IRB or be consented by parents. Please try to update your priors.
- vidarh 3y agoThere's a great deal of irony of this criticism coming from someone claiming to know better than this study while providing nothing to back up your dismissal.
- pvg 3y agoRecently https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38313840 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38313840
- mhartz 3y agoAbsence of evidence != Evidence of Absence
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sickofparadox 3y agoScience reporting does itself a massive disservice publishing headlines like this, especially when the real takeaway is just "MRIs cannot see the damage done to children's brains with screens". Even other children know that the "ipad kids" are different and damaged in some way, my young cousin and his friends call them bots.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vidarh 3y agoMaybe. Or maybe the causal relationship doesn't go in the direction you assume without evidence, and maybe your cousin is just intolerant.
- sickofparadox 3y agoI can completely believe that whatever damage is being done to children by screens does not show up on an MRI scan. Having never even seen one in person, I have no assumptions about what that would look like, if the damage even manifested physically. What is plainly obvious and would take much more than a self-reported survey to disabuse me of, is the idea that excessive electronic usage screws up kids' brains, making them highly prone to anti-social behavior and likely some form of screentime addiction.
- vidarh 3y agoWhy is it "plainly obvious"? You criticize a self reported study, but offer up a self reported second hand anecdotal claim as the only alternative, without even stopping for a moment to consider other potential reasons, such as e.g. whether the causal link may go the other direction, or whether kids who get to have more screen time have less involved parents. I don't know whether this study is right. What I do know is that my observation of the people who insist it is not in this thread suggests I can't trust their reasoning about what they claim to have observed, because it fairly consistently involves illogical leaps and unsuported assumptions of causality.
- ohduran 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ProjectArcturis 3y agoThat is false, off-topic, and the article you linked doesn't even say that.
- bitshiftfaced 3y agoThe AAP, until recently, recommended no screentime before age 2. They dropped that recommendations due to lack of strong evidence. That said, if your child has a speech delay, their SLP's first question will be about screentime.
- usgroup 3y agoI feel it’s obvious in some respect that if “screen time” means TikTok or YouTube binging then there’s probably something more developmentally useful you could be doing. That screen time might lead to a maladaptive brain as evidence by MRI, strikes me as an extreme effect. I’d be curious to know what else this experimental design had been applied to in the past and whether it’s at all commensurate with this purpose.
- hutzlibu 3y agoYeah, screen time != screen time. I noticed a very different result, when I consciously watched some selected videos together with my boy vs. setting him loose with a smartphone in his hand.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoEven within the realm of (say) YouTube, I'd expect a difference between "Khan Academy math lesson" and "Funniest Kicks In the Gonads Compilation". I agree with others here (and elsewhere) that "screen time" is way too coarse-grained to be useful. It's as if people back in the '60s were doing research on "paper time", lumping looking at porn magazines or pop star fan magazines together with reading physics textbooks.
- onemoresoop 3y agoDubious at best. If one has children they notice quite visibly that screen time makes their children more agitated during the days they have screen time. And screen time is as addictive to children as it is to adults, and we should consider the effects they have on their developing brains.
- evilduck 3y agoI have children and do not notice this. What you want to be true isn’t necessarily universal.
- SirMaster 3y agoNobody is saying it applies to every child. But if it affects enough of them then it's a problem worth looking into.
- vidarh 3y agoGP did make a blanket statement
- evilduck 3y agoIsn’t looking into it exactly what they did with the 12,000 kids in the study linked? OP’s kid could have major depression for all we know, their anecdotes about their kids being extrapolated to all kids is absurd.
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoWe shouldn't confuse observation with cause. If the OP genuinely observed such changes in behavior, then that's different than ascribing a direct cause to screen time. Perhaps some children respond differently. Perhaps other factors play out by means of screen time. Perhaps what their kids are doing on their phones is different (we shouldn't forget the affect of the content on the screen). Who knows, and from a parenting point of view, it may not matter all that much when deciding what to do. If reducing screen time improves symptoms, then that's a good start, at least.
- forgingahead 3y agoNo peer-reviewed paper that parachutes help make sky-diving safer either. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC300808/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC300808/
- whimsicalism 3y agoThis is obviously completely different than that.
- dumpsterlid 3y ago“screen time” is such a nonsense phrase. Sure make sure your kid gets physical exercise but to primarily define and rate the value of an experience a child is having primarily based on whether it is on a screen or not is hilariously myopic especially among people that supposedly claim to have a progressive view of technology. The question is WHAT is the child doing on that screen? Are they blobbing out or are they playing a video game that stimulates and challenges their brain (a strategy game, even action games) or socializing with friends in a video game learning how to conflict manage and operate as an effective social group? (minecraft is full of this). I mean we ruined the world for kids, I can’t blame them for looking to virtual worlds to transcend the hellhole we left them even a little bit. Sure, the kids should just “go outside” and play in the… development full of huge pickups that aren’t even designed to able to see children (they kind of look custom designed to run over children actually), with no public spaces to explore and play in, no sidewalks leading from the development to anywhere else and endless strip malls, parking lots and cars as far as the eye can see… Their brain is going to be healthier engaging with good video games than that landscape.
- rickdeckard 3y agoDoes this factor in the impact of constant instant-gratification of whatever is done on that screen? Because (subjectively) I can see how children with lots of screen-time have a harder time with activities which do not lead to immediate dopamine release, like reading, listening to a story, drawing, etc., while children with low/no screen-time can derive satisfaction already from the process of doing something. -- Edit: I'd say none of this impacts "brain function or well-being" directly, as both CAN do tasks without instant gratification, it's just that children with lots of screen-time perceive them vastly different from my personal observation.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoThis may be the major distinction that is missing. We don't talk about what someone is doing on the screen. Some activities are better than others. Me play Path of Exile -- not great. Reading HN -- potentially not a time sink. Watching a documentary on deadly snakes -- mild time waster. Reading Terry Pratchett for 20x time -- endless joy. edit: I guess my real point is that it is all in the eye of the beholder. I know my parents hated me playing games.
- usgroup 3y agoChildren and everyone else … I can’t watch a movie anymore without either reading something or playing chess at the same time just to up the frequency of those hits.
- rickdeckard 3y agoIndeed. I guess measurement of your "brain function or well-being" might not show any difference, but the way you perceive those activities might have changed completely. I have a similar observation regarding Movies. Funny how this can be improved by watching a movie in cinema, a purpose of cinema which silently grows while the original purpose of "better audio/video experience" is fading...
- red-iron-pine 3y agothere is James Cameron quote, something to the effect of "a movie ticket is a contract between you and the director that you're going to give this uninterrupted attention"
- kelseyfrog 3y agoCognitive development falls under the umbrella of psychology, a failed science. It's impossible to reliably and exhaustively measure development, and like real science, disproving an effect is orders of magnitude more difficult than finding an effect.
- hospitalJail 3y agoKid plays minecraft or runescape? Cool Kid watches people opening boxes for shock factor. No. Its time to stop pretending these are the same. The old guard cannot concede that Video Games might be different from TV Screen Time.
- milesward 3y agoworked for me
- ssijak 3y agoWell, screen time I imagine would also not induce diabetes or clogged arteries in children 9-12. but it will few decades down the line if they don't ingrain good habits because of that screen time. Same with this, if MRI does not detect brain "hardware" damage, that does not mean there are no software damage done to kids with excessive screen time at young age. I had a son 2 months ago. One of my biggest concerns is how to protect him from excessive screen time and social networks until he grows up enough (~14 years at least). I plan to do a lot of nature going (with some backyard astronomy and biology if that piques his interest) and sports, active travel.. We'll see how it goes
- usgroup 3y agoThere is a straightforward solution if you have enough time to commit. Your kids will likely prefer to play with you than sit on the screen every time. I think the bigger problem is that “we” just don’t “have the time” and fighting the default time sinks when kids are left to their on devises is an uphill battle.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoScreen time is pretty broad. A toddler watching 10 min of Ms. Rachel probably isn't the same as a teenager watching 10 min of TikTok. We've had some single digit aged children in our care that had been exposed to GTA, scary movies, etc. Those things absolutely DID have an effect on them.
- dfee 3y agoNot all screen time is equal. Though, all screen time may have negative consequences. My third grade son spends time daily on typing and Khan Academy (iMac). He spends an additional few minutes reading about sports (public school issued iPad). His video game exposure is quite limited. Though I have a PS5, he rarely plays it (once per week, perhaps – of course Madden and MLB The Show). He spends a lot of time either at school or playing organized club sports. Shorter and colder winter days will have a negative impact on outdoor activities, so looking at fields with lights or indoor sports. His cognitive functions are quite good. I'd say the iPad is definitely the lowest quality computer interaction he gets. The real setback for his cohort was Covid. Those who spent time on iPhones and iPads then (likley continuing on from their early childhood) appear to lag and continue to struggle. These kids are easy to pick out, and I sympathize with their struggle. I have another young child now (<2), and again: no iPhones or iPads for him. I'll wait for the research to catch up.
- usgroup 3y agoIt isn’t obvious to me why you think iPhones and iPads have retarded some of the cohort? Can you expand on the causality of it and what ages are you referring to ?
- dfee 3y agoI can’t tell you why. I just see a correlation. Age group up to nine. I’ll add: it’s especially notable in ability to focus and communicate. This is my take knowing and coaching many of these kids in youth sports.
- dudul 3y agoA few kids in my 8yo son's class don't use screens. No TVs, phones, games, etc. Others are already binge watching StarWars, Minecraft, etc. The differences between these 2 groups are enormous in terms of their play, their attention during lessons, their overall academic achievements. I will never believe a study telling me that spending 2 hours watching star wars is better for a kid than going to build a fort in the forest.
- vidarh 3y agoYou're assuming causality, and assuming less screen time would mean screen time would be replaced by activities you see as better. One possible reason why that logic might not hold might e.g. simply be that restrictions on screen time might correlate with more involved parents.
- dudul 3y agoNo there is causality when a group is hitting each other with sticks, pretending to be jedi knights, and the other is setting up a "fake" farm with some complex "economy" between the baker, the blacksmith, the tailor, etc. There is causality when all the kid can draw involves violence with vague shapes, while others can draw complex sceneries. Where I do agree is that at the end of the day, the screen is not really the issue, it's what you watch on it.
- vidarh 3y ago> There is causality when all the kid can draw involves violence with vague shapes, while others can draw complex sceneries. Without anything else all you have is correlation. There is no logically sound basis for your argument. It's staggering to me how many arguments in this thread are devoid of proper application of reasoning.
- it_citizen 3y agoNot sure why you are being downvoted. I can see a pretty strong correlation between the parents who have the will to not simplify their lives by putting kids in front of the TV and parents who will do more than the average parent for their kids to be well-educated.
- johnea 3y ago[flagged]
- SkyBelow 3y agoThe claim (per title, likely not from the scientists themselves): No evidence screen time is negative for child cognitive development. The study: Self reported screen time does not correlate to functional brain organization profiles related to maladaptive functioning as measured by MRI. There is a lot more in the study, but unless one is already well versed in this field, it will take a great deal of time to parse and understand the data and the limitations of the methodology they used. I think the press release is too strongly worded given what I've been able to understand of the study.
- pkphilip 3y agoThese are the sorts of "research" which severely undermines trust in research in general. Anyone who has children or who works with children knows that screen time adversely affects ability to focus, attention spans etc.
- Jensson 3y agoStarving your kids makes them appreciate food more, but that doesn't mean that starvation is good for them.
- jstarfish 3y agoResearch used to say cigarettes were healthy and having a cellphone glued to your head didn't have any adverse effects either. "No evidence screen time is negative for child cognitive development?" Really? > analysed the cognitive function of 9-12 year old children alongside their self-reported screen time use > no evidence was found to show that screen time impacted their brain function or well-being Oh, I'm sure screen-time lights up all sorts of areas of the brain. Stimulation is the point. The test passes because they redefined the problem itself. And if I'm reading the abstract correctly, the test only ran for 2 years. How'd they measure well-being? Because every other day there's articles published about how miserable all the kids are and how corrosive social media has been for their mental health.
- unknotted9017 3y agoHow many children miss out on face to face interaction or conversation when at reataurants, in the home, or in the car while using their screen?
- jasonpeacock 3y agoHere’s an actual study about the effects of screen time (TV) on childhood development: https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/thoughtful-animal/baby-tv-sesame-street-and-child-development/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/thoughtful-animal/baby-...
- walt74 3y ago1. Przybylski again. He continues to generalize from studies focussing on screentime that everything digital is harmless, including social media. I don't trust his work. 2. [Children's brains shaped by their time on tech devices, review shows](https://medicalxpress.com/news/2023-11-children-brains-tech-devices.html https://medicalxpress.com/news/2023-11-children-brains-tech-...) and [Does screen use really impact thinking skills? Recent analysis suggests it could](https://medicalxpress.com/news/2023-11-screen-impact-skills-analysis.html https://medicalxpress.com/news/2023-11-screen-impact-skills-...) > The evidence review, published today in Early Education and Development, is an analysis of 33 studies which use neuroimaging technology to measure the impact of digital technology on the brains of children under the age of 12. In total, more than 30,000 participants are included. > In particular, the research finds screen time leads to changes in the pre-frontal cortex of the brain, which is the base of executive functions such as working memory and the ability to plan or to respond flexibly to situations. It also finds impacts on the parietal lobe, which helps us to process touch, pressure, heat, cold, and pain; the temporal lobe, which is important for memory, hearing and language; and the occipital lobe, which helps us to interpret visual information. > "It should be recognized by both educators and caregivers that children's cognitive development may be influenced by their digital experiences," says the study's corresponding author, Chair Professor Hui Li, from the Faculty of Education and Human Development Faculty of Education and Human Development, at The Education University of Hong Kong.