5 ms·
The reality is much more complex than "batteries replace gas" - > Developers can no longer use financial modelling that assumes gas power plants are used const
by bell-cot 3y ago
The reality is much more complex than "batteries replace gas" -
> Developers can no longer use financial modelling that assumes gas power plants are used constantly throughout their 20-year-plus lifetime, analysts said.
> Instead, modellers need to predict how much gas generation is needed during times of peak demand and to compensate for the intermittency of renewable sources that are hard to anticipate.
> "It does become more complex," Nigel Scott, head of structured trade and commodity finance at Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation, said.
> Investors are putting increased scrutiny on the modelling, he added.
- so basically, maintaining a large-scale grid is an optimization problem. And batteries merely shift the answer to "how much of which each type of equipment should we have?" around some. Kinda like someone architecting a DC-scale system has to understand trade-offs between L1 cache / L2 cache / L3 cache / local-to-core RAM / more-distant RAM / SSD / HD / Tape - vs. what equipment is actually available - at what prices, lead times, configuration limitations, ...
- triplepoint217 3y agoI like that analogy. Batteries are kind of the RAM/cache in the system: - Big merchant batteries like Hornsdale are kind of like more distant ram RAM - Batteries co-located with renewables are kind of the local to core ram - UPS and similar are cache - Pumped hydro is probably Tape ;) It feels like we might still be lacking a good/widely deployed HD/SSD equivalent in this space, hopefully new/emerging technologies (maybe the sodium chemistries others are mentioning) will be able to fill that in.
- Maxion 3y agoI think in terms of the energy grid batteries are currently more like your L1 cache or similar. I.e. very expensive to have, and has specific requirements so you have little of it. Hydro would be more like your RAM.
- samus 3y agoIt is probably smart to keep around a certain capacity of nonrenewables to provide at least some base load. Long periods of low sunshine and slow winds could deplete batteries to a critical level. Also, the turbines of big powerplants act as grid frequency stabilizer. Do grid-scale batteries use alternators or might they run flywheels?
- marcosdumay 3y agoIt's quite likely that in the future electricity sellers will need to pay a tariff to cover the operation of flywheels.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoNot sure why the cost would be borne by sellers. More likely consumers will pay for it as part of the grid infrastructure in my opinion.
- marcosdumay 3y agoWell, currently the sellers are the ones directly paying for the grid infrastructure. It makes much more sense. They are the ones that can choose what part of the grid they plug on, and they are the ones choosing if they provide the service or not.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI dont think I agree. Typically electric companies pay for the grid infrastructure and operation currently. Electricity producers like solar plants out in the desert is not paying to maintain the poles to your house.
- marcosdumay 3y agoRetail electricity companies pay only for their own grid. They aren't paying for the link between your city and the plant out in the desert.
- s1artibartfast 3y agomaybe we have a difference in terminology. The interconnects between the grid and primary producers are often owned an managed by the retail company. Who pays for them is often a sticking point and can go both ways. What I think is indisputable is that it is the retail electric company who manages and maintains their grid, and manages it's demand and stability. >sellers are the ones directly paying for the grid infrastructure. This is absolutely not the case for the vast majority of that infrastructure. You just mentioned small connections. If you look at the grid, it is basically all retail companies[1] https://www.researchgate.net/figure/California-electric-grid-and-population-map_fig1_256704694 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/California-electric-grid...
- more_corn 3y agoYes, what type of equipment do you want. And do you want to favor fossil fuels or renewable. If the latter, deploy batteries.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoA major problem here is that intermittency isn't consistent. Okay, solar doesn't generate at night, so you would need to charge some batteries during the day and discharge them at night. Maybe that's fine. But solar also generates less in winter. If we want to transition heating from oil and gas to electric, we need a lot of generation in the winter. If we build some more solar to do that, now there's way more than enough in the summer, so anything that can make up the shortfall in winter is only going to be used in winter. Duty cycle for whatever that is just got cut in half or worse. Then sometimes it's cloudy for a week. Having enough battery capacity to make it through the night is very different than having enough to make it a whole week, or two. By the second or third day you need enough traditional generating capacity to run the whole grid at night -- but that capacity only gets used one week out of the year. Now you want to say that gas is too expensive if it can only amortize its costs in those limited circumstances. But what do you want to do instead? You need something that can run the whole grid the week that it's cloudy, none of the options for that are cheap, but the alternative is everybody loses power that week.
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoBut the capacity needed to top up that battery on a cloudy week is still less than having a gas plant having to meet peak demand. Kinda like the BMW i3 with Rex. You charge it at home (solar), but when it gets low the on-board generator (gasoline 2 cylinder) can trickle charge your battery until you get home (where you have solar again).
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThat works in a car because a car's energy demands are bursty. The power to accelerate the car from a stop comes from the battery and then the car's energy requirements drop by 95% and the tiny engine can eek out a little more than the 5% needed to maintain cruising speed and use the rest to slowly recharge the battery. The power grid doesn't work like that. The base load is around half of the peak load. It never drops to 5%. That doesn't mean the batteries can't be useful. If the average load is 150GW but that's because it's 100GW at night and 200GW during the day, the batteries let you get away with having only 150GW of average generating capacity instead of 200GW, because during the times when the generation exceeds the demand you can put the surplus in the batteries. But you still need to maintain an average of 150GW of generating capacity or the batteries will get empty and the power goes out.
- wortelefant 3y agoComplexoty causes high system costs at scale for energy grids with a large amount of intermittent renewables. Adding more stable adjustable sources like nuclear, hydro or geothermal will become more attractive than creating wildly intricate "smart grid" architecture. Just produce more power when needed instead of costly redistribution and storage.
- bokohut 3y agoSuperb analogy indeed as this is the same approach I use in my next pursuit in breaking through to those from a technology background. The cache sources can be anything providing energy to be stored in the rapid response system while the cache system itself is modular in design allowing ingress and egress simultaneously based on inputs and outputs of demand. The fun part is designing and writing the software to control all the "cache" hardware. I have no idea what I am talking about though but I did stay in a Holiday Inn last night... or was it a Motel 6. :) For those with their ear on the track when that sound resonates they will see the light, everyone else will be in the dark without energy storage. Costs are spiking everywhere and the U.S. government is having meetings near weekly exactly about this coming fun. Those meetings reflect frank direct statements about coming derailments and the grid has not changed since its inception and remains to be centralized to this very day. There are enough smart technologists here that can put together exactly what I infer, significant opportunity. For those further interested check out YT: "Environment Hearing: Clean Power Plan 2.0 Will Jeopardize Reliable and Affordable Energy". As with anything making significant revenues however those threatened with revenue loss will play the dirtiest games to preserve their position, this includes increasing the pollution output that is making that revenue. Stay Healthy!