6 ms·
As I posted elsewhere, I think this is a conflict between Dustin Moskovitz and Sam Altman. Ilya may have been brought into this without his knowledge (which mig
by alephnerd 3y ago
As I posted elsewhere, I think this is a conflict between Dustin Moskovitz and Sam Altman. Ilya may have been brought into this without his knowledge (which might explain why he retracted his position).
Dustin Moskovitz was an early employee at FB, and the founder of Asana. He also created (along with plenty of MSFT bigwigs) a non-profit called Open Philanthropy, which was a early proponent of a form of Effective Altruism and also gave OpenAI their $30M grant. He is also one of the early investors in Anthropic.
Most of the OpenAI board members are related to Dustin Moskovitz this way.
- Adam D'Angelo is on the board of Asana and is a good friend to both Moskovitz and Altman
- Helen Toner worked for Dustin Moskovitz at Open Philanthropy and managed their grant to OpenAI. She was also a member of the Centre for the Governance of AI when McCauley was a board member there. Shortly after Toner left, the Centre for the Governance of AI got a $1M grant from Open Philanthropy and McCauley joined the board of OpenAI
- Tasha McCauley represents the Centre for the Governance of AI, which Dustin Moskovitz gave a $1M grant to via Open Philanthropy and McCauley ended up joining the board of OpenAI
Over the past few months, Dustin Moskovitz has also been increasingly warning about AI Safety.
In essense, it looks like a split between Sam Altman and Dustin Moskovitz
- chucke1992 3y agoI mean, you can't vote to drop CEO without knowing...
- brandall10 3y agoWow, this is extremely useful information, it ties all the pieces together. Surprised it hasn't been reported elsewhere.
- teacpde 3y agoThis is the most logical explanation I have seen so far. Makes me wonder why Dustin Moskovitz himself wasn't on the board of OpenAI in the first place.
- htk 3y agoVery interesting take, and it sheds some light to the role of the two most discredited board members.
- htk 3y agoPlease repost this as a stand alone comment, I bet it would be voted to the top. Or maybe dang can extract this comment and orphan it.
- jansan 3y agoIt has come to the point that hearing the expression "Effective Altruism" sends shivers down my spline.
- jacquesm 3y agoIronically it is never effective nor is it ever altruism.
- golergka 3y ago[flagged]
- moffkalast 3y agoIt's one tier below weaponized autism.
- kylecordes 3y agoObviously we should all want our altruism to be effective. What is the other side of it? Wanting one's altruism to not really accomplish much? But with everything that has gone on, I cannot imagine wanting to be an Effective Altruist! The movement by that name seems to do and think some really weird stuff.
- upwardbound 3y agoThe "Think Globally, Act Locally" movement is the competing philosophy. It's deeply entrenched in our culture, and has absolutely dominated philanthropic giving for several decades. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_globally,_act_locally https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_globally,_act_locally "Think Globally, Act Locally" leads to charities in wealthy cities getting disproportionately huge amounts of money for semi-frivolous things like symphony orchestras, while people in the global south are dying of preventable diseases.
- zztop44 3y agoIt’s obnoxious because of that exact implication, that pre-existing altruism wasn’t concerned with efficacy. And that’s just not true. There has been a community of professional practice around measuring impact and directing funds accordingly for decades. Does it always generate perfect results? No, far from it!! Is there room to improve? Absolutely, lots and lots of room! But it’s hard not to notice that the people who call themselves Effective Altruists have no better a track record (actually, I would say far worse) than the so-called bloated NGOs and international organizations when it comes to efficacy.
- valine 3y agoIf he has safety concerns with OpenAI, he must be mortified with his old company Meta dropping 70B llamas on HF.
- g42gregory 3y agoGreat insights. very interesting!
- folli 3y agoOkay, I know this is a very naive question, but anyways: might Dustin /the board be onto something regarding AI safety which was not there before?
- jacquesm 3y agoIf there was there are 700 people motivated to leak it and none did. What could they be aware of that the rest of OpenAI would not be aware of? How did the learn about it?
- endtime 3y agoI agree it's probably not something new. But I will observe that OpenAI rank and file employees, presumably mostly working on making AI more effective, are very strongly selected against people who are sympathetic to safety/x-risk concerns.
- tatrajim 3y agoIntriguing, thanks. HN does provide gems of insight amidst the repetitive gossip.
- drawkbox 3y agoA "conflict" or false opposition can also be used in a theater like play. Maybe this was setup to get Microsoft to take on the costs/liability and more. Three board members left in 2023 that allowed this to happen. The idea of boards might even be an anti-pattern going forward, they can be played and used in essentially rug pull scenarios for full control of all the work of entire organizations. Maybe boards are past their time or too much of a potential timebomb/trojan horse now.
- coliveira 3y agoThis has been the case as long as companies existed. Even with all this, companies still have boards because they represent the interests of several people.
- alsodumb 3y agoIt's clear that Adam himself has a strong conflict of interest too. The GPT store announcement on DevDay pretty much killed his company Poe. And all this started brewing after DevDay announcement. Maybe Sam kept it under the wraps from Adam and the board.
- tedmiston 3y agoI've heard others take this stance, but a common response so far has been "Poe is so small as to be irrelevant", "I forgot it exists", etc in the grand scheme of things here.
- splatzone 3y agoWhen it's your company, it's never small.
- robg 3y agoAnd it quickly feels personal…
- alsodumb 3y agoPoe has a reasonably strong user base for two reasons: (i) they allowed customized agents and a store of these agents. (iI) they had access to GPT-32k context length very early, in fact one of the first to have it. Both of these kinda became pointless after DevDay. It definitely kills Poe, and I think that itself is a conflict of interest, right? Whether or not it's at a scale to compete is a secondary question.
- nilkn 3y agoWhat matters is how much personal work and money Adam put into Poe. It seems like he's been working on it full-time all year and has more or less pivoted to it away from Quora, which also faces an existential threat from OpenAI (and AI in general). Either way, Adam's conflict of interest is significant, and it's staggering he wasn't asked to resign from the board after launching a chatbot-based AI company.
- bertil 3y agoThat would explain why Sam wants the whole board gone and not one or two members, while he was very fast to welcome Ilya back.
- codethief 3y ago> while he was very fast to welcome Ilya back Was he? I must have missed that in all this chaos.
- Mandelmus 3y agohttps://twitter.com/sama/status/1726594398098780570 https://twitter.com/sama/status/1726594398098780570
- rngname22 3y agoCan anyone explain why when I go to https://twitter.com/sama https://twitter.com/sama I don't see the linked tweet, but if I navigate to https://twitter.com/sama/status/1726594398098780570 https://twitter.com/sama/status/1726594398098780570 I can? Is this a nuance of like tweets being privatable? Or deleted tweets remaining directly navigable? Sorry probably something basic about how twitter functions.
- chunky1994 3y agoCorrelation =/= causation. This is most likely coincidental. I highly doubt Dustin's differing views caused a (near) unanimous ousting of a completely different company's CEO that had nothing to do with Dustin's primary business.
- tempsy 3y agoAll 3 having some connection to effective altruism, which Dustin is at the center of, is not coincidental.
- bagels 3y agoWhy would Sam let the board get so far out of his control?
- ealexhudson 3y agoNo board is ever controlled by a CEO by virtue of the title/office. Boards are controlled by directors, who are typically nominated by shareholders. They may control the CEO, although again, in many startups the founder becomes the CEO and retains some significant stake (possibly controlling) in the overall shareholding. The top org was a 501(c)3 and the directors were all effectively independent. The CEO of such an organisation would never have any control over the board, by design. We've gotten very used to founders having controlling shareholdings and company boards basically being advisory rather than having a genuine fiduciary responsibility. Companies even go public with Potempkin boards. But this was never "normal" and does not represent good governance. Boards should represent the shareholders, who should be a broader group (especially post-IPO) than the founders.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThat isnt relevant to the question. Sam was on the board prior to all of these other directors, and responsible for selecting them. The post asks how/why Sam ended up with a board full of directors so far out of alignment with his vision. I think a big part of that is that the board was down several members, from 9 to 6. Perhaps the problem started with not replacing departing board members and this spiraled out of control as more board members left. Here is a timeline of the board: https://loeber.substack.com/p/a-timeline-of-the-openai-board https://loeber.substack.com/p/a-timeline-of-the-openai-board
- ealexhudson 3y agoActually, you're rephrasing the question - it was specifically about "control", not "alignment". Even if we substitute "alignment" the problem is that the suggestion is still that Sam would have been "better protected" in some way. A 501(c)3 is just not supposed to function like that, and good corporate governance absolutely demands that the board be independent of the CEO and be aligned to the company goals not the CEO's goals.
- SpaceManNabs 3y agoA thing a sad, understated ongoing is that so many people are throwing vitriol at Ilya right now. If the speculation here is true, then he just chased by a mob over pure nonsense (well, at least purer than the nonsense premise beforehand). Gotta love seeing effective altruists take another one on the chin this year though.
- tspike 3y agoDoes this whole thing remind anyone else of the tech community’s version of celebrity gossip?
- SpaceManNabs 3y agoAbsolutely. It is borderline salacious. Honestly didn't feel too good watching so many people opine on matters they had no real data on and insult people; also the employees of openai announcing matters on twitter or wtv in tabloid style. I hope people apologize to Ilya for jumping to conclusions.
- elaus 3y agoYes, it was especially weird to read this on HN to such a big extend. The comments were (and are) full of people with very strong opinions, based on vague tweets or speculation. Quite unusual and hopefully not the new norm...
- fuzztester 3y agoNo. It reminds me more of Muddle [1] Ages' intrigue, scheming, and backstabbing, like the Medicis, Cesare Borgia and clan, Machiavelli (and his book The Prince, see Cesare again), etc., to take just one example. (Italy not being singled out here.) And also reminds me of all the effing feuding clans, dynasties, kingdoms, and empires down the centuries or millenia, since we came down from the trees. I guess galaxies have to be next, and that too is coming up, yo Elon, Mars, etc., what you couldn't fix on earth ain't gonna be fixable on Mars or even Pluto, Dummkopf, but give it your best shot anyway. [1] Not a typo :)
- nostrademons 3y agoMore confusion - Emmett Shear is a close friend of Sam Altman. He was part of the original 2005 YCombinator class alongside Altman, part of the justin.tv mafia, and later a part-time partner at YCombinator. I don't think he has any such close ties to Dustin Moskovitz. Why would the Dustin-leaning OpenAI board install him as interim CEO? This whole thing still seems to have the air of a pageant to me, where they're making a big stink for drama but it might be manufactured by all of the original board, with Sam, Ilya, Adam, and potentially others all on the same side.
- alephnerd 3y agoHe's part of the EA community which Moskovitz funded. He was even named in Yudkowsky's warcrime of a Harry Potter fanfic [0][1] [0] - https://www.404media.co/new-openai-ceo-emmett-shear-was-minor-character-in-hpmor-harry-potter-ai-fanfic/?ref=upstract.com https://www.404media.co/new-openai-ceo-emmett-shear-was-mino... [1] - https://hpmor.com/chapter/104?ref=404media.co https://hpmor.com/chapter/104?ref=404media.co
- dymk 3y agoSilicon Valley lore is way too complex at this point; needs a reboot. I'd rather start One Piece from scratch.
- chucke1992 3y agoWe need a wiki indeed.
- Apocryphon 3y agoYou're posting on it.
- layer8 3y agohttps://silicon-valley.fandom.com/ https://silicon-valley.fandom.com/ is already taken, unfortunately.
- 3y ago
- thrwwy_dm231120 3y agoI heard directly from Dustin that he was surprised as anyone by the board’s actions. He is not some hidden mastermind behind the scenes, he has just been personally invested in AI and AI safety for a long time and therefore has many connections to other key players in the space.
- spiantino 3y agoThe EA community includes a lot of AI folks, as well as philanthropists like Dustin. That doesn't mean this is this kind of conspiracy
- JohnFen 3y agoBut it does cast a pretty dark shadow over the AI community.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AlwaysBCoding 3y agoAnother fun fact re: Dustin Moskovitz Dustin was an early investor in Alameda Research and was also one of the biggest donors to Mind the Gap -- Sam's mom's Super PAC. When SBF was about to go under Dustin was his first call to try to raise money (came out in the FTX trial).
- zone411 3y agoHe said this is false. https://www.threads.net/@moskov/post/Cz482XgJBN0?hl=en https://www.threads.net/@moskov/post/Cz482XgJBN0?hl=en
- jacquesm 3y agoVery interesting except for one little detail: Moskovitz denies it.