6 ms·
GM's big bet on driverless cars turns sour
- monero-xmr 3y agoThe economics of a ~$500k car supported by $2.5 million per year of personnel, all to undercut an immigrant working as a 1099 contractor for… a few bucks an hour saved? The math never worked and it still doesn’t work.
- RankingMember 3y agoIsn't the idea that the cost of the car would go down over time with economies of scale while providing a safer means of transport? Not saying that's the current reality, but that's the goal isn't it?
- ska 3y ago>Isn't the idea that ... Sure, in the sense that's the idea behind lots of things. But there is an awful lot of handwaving about how to concretely get there. The overall goal of using self-driving technology to reduce human deaths and injuries is clearly admirable. What's less clear is a) if it is technologically achievable and b) if any of the current efforts are scaled appropriately to get there over a decade or two. The early self-driving hype was pretty depressing to behold. It was obviously an Apollo sized or bigger effort, and people were actually getting traction with the laughable idea that we'd "get there" in 2-3 years with a few 10k of engineers (or less, I'm estimating conservatively).
- bdsa 3y agoHow many people were involved in engineering in the Apollo program?
- ska 3y ago400-500k total staff by some estimates, it's a little hard to know where to draw the lines, and a little hard to do apples-to-apples. Also about 5% total GDP applied which is crucial.
- FullyFunctional 3y agoExactly this. It is still unclear if this is even possible to do, which means betting the company (GM and Tesla) on it is irresponsible. Of the current efforts, the only that I have heard very positive things about is Waymo.
- dvt 3y ago> while providing a safer means of transport Cars are safer than they've ever been; looking at some statistics, we have halved the fatality rates since 1980. So I'm not exactly sure claiming "it's safer" is really much of a selling point. GP is correct that the money has never really made sense, other than in the context of logistics (automating semi trucks maybe?). Given that even the safest of transport modes (say, the metro in London or Paris) still needs to have a conductor (for potential emergencies), it's hard to see the fully driverless dream ever materializing.
- david-gpu 3y ago> Cars are safer than they've ever been Not if you are outside the car. Pedestrian and cyclist fatalities have increased steadily in the US over the past ten years [0] due to ever increasing car sizes and speeds [1]. [0] https://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/fatal/trends.html https://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/fatal/trends.html [1] https://www.cdc.gov/transportationsafety/pedestrian_safety/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/transportationsafety/pedestrian_safety/i...
- Tiktaalik 3y agoSafer for whom? Pedestrian fatality rates have exploded upward in recent years in the united states, at the highest rates in 41 years. up 77% since 2010. Cars are inherently unsafe but we refuse to disengage from this failed model despite the solutions (ie. public transit) being right there for decades and decades. Self driving public transport in contrast is a solved problem. Vancouver's driverless Skytrain has been serving customers since the early 1980s (as you say, requiring a driver only in the rare exception of some emergency or technical malfunction).
- Symbiote 3y agoAutonomous metro trains in some cities don't have a conductor. Copenhagen's metro doesn't, for example. London's system is particularly old and deep, and lacks space for emergency walkways.
- rented_mule 3y agoThe price will definitely come down. But not enough for taxi/ride-share companies. Many drivers for ride-share companies make less than nothing once you account for consumables, maintenance, and depreciation of their vehicles. That last one is often left out of the discussion. Many such drivers stop being drivers when their cars wear out because they don't make enough to pay off a car loan before the car wears out. In many cases, this means the companies are getting the cars at below cost with drivers thrown in for free. The premium for self driving hardware isn't likely to be negative anytime soon. Self-driving eliminates the drivers and therefore the people providing part of the cost of the cars. There are certainly exceptions, often well publicized by the companies, of drivers who figure out how to exploit the algorithms to make decent money. But when too many figure this out, the companies adjust the algorithms to contain costs, leading right back to the above.
- kube-system 3y agoA technology in the R&D phase is almost never profitable until later matured, that's why engaging in that type of business is called an investment. Once upon a time there was probably someone who said it was silly to spend a couple million dollars to do the job of a secretary making 50 cents per hour, but now here we are, typing these comments with computers.
- dmbche 3y agoPretty certain computers weren't created to replace secretaries - it's just one of the ways computers changed the world. Self driving is not even claiming it would have much of an effect of the world. A few points more efficient, cutting a bit of costs - not changing the human experience at it's core.
- mohaine 3y agoI'm pretty sure the families of the 38k people who died in car crashes last year (US alone) would disagree with this not changing the human experience at it's core.
- david-gpu 3y agoLet's not automatically assume that self-driving cars will be safer than the average driver in the foreseeable future. Right now the best way to reduce car fatalities is reducing the number of cars by eliminating single family zoning mandates, building safe cycling infrastructure, improving public transit frequency, allowing mixed-use buildings and walkable neighborhoods. Boring stuff, yes, but unlike self-driving cars, it is something we already know how to do.
- AlexandrB 3y agoWhat about actually making public transit usable? That doesn't require years of R&D and solving several "unknown unknowns". Instead we get companies doing R&D of unproven technologies on public roads because no one wants to build more rail. For some eye-popping numbers, check out the automotive deaths/100,000 people for the US (12.9) vs. Denmark (3.4)[1]. Denmark doesn't have some magical AI that makes all their cars safe, just better infrastructure. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-related_death_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-r...
- deelowe 3y agoThe market opportunity is many of orders of magnitude larger than taxi/rideshare programs.
- s08148692 3y agoIf Tesla succeeds in their FSD ambitions (vision only), and they are actually correct that HW3/4 (current tesla hardware) is capable of full self driving, the economics will make sense, and we're a software update away from having millions of self driving taxis already on the roads That's a lot of ifs, so I'm not at all saying its right around the corner, but it's within the set of possible outcomes. V12 is looking quite promising, but then again so was V11 and V10
- AlexandrB 3y agoThe problem with Elon Musk constantly over promising and under delivering on this is that it's impossible to tell how close Tesla actually are. A year? A decade? Who knows! The CEO's statements on the matter are best treated as random noise.
- kwhitefoot 3y ago> it's impossible to tell how close Tesla actually are. Isn't this true of all the other players as well.
- hnav 3y agoI think lidar is going to get cheaper much faster than tesla figures out vision-only FSD. Consider that solid state lidar capable of scanning a room is integrated in smartphones today.
- ra7 3y agoYou are inflating cost of the car by at least 2x. GM had a plan to bring down the cost by manufacturing Origin, but recent events have put a stop to that.
- xnx 3y agoSelf-driving is an immensely hard problem. Anyone who doesn't approach it with that mindset, will eventually be humbled. There is a huge a mount of "you don't know what you don't know". Expertise in making cars does not translate into expertise in making drivers.
- sschueller 3y agoThere is one particular very well know person that still hasn't grasp this and people are still believing his spiel.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoWell, he did get a bunch of patsys to invest their life savings into his company based on the "full self driving is (eternally) 6 months aways and backwards portable to existing cars" hype, till his company was worth more than all other car companies combines, so well done him I guess.
- rndmize 3y agoI'm growing somewhat tired of the endless shade thrown at Elon across the internet. People believe Elon when he promises something absurd because he's done it before. Twenty years ago there were no electric cars. Fifteen years ago the idea of a mass-market electric vehicle was considered a joke. Ten years ago people talked about the chicken-and-egg problem of cars and chargers and how you can't have one without the other, and no one was building chargers. Today, Tesla has some of the best selling vehicles worldwide, as an EV only company; other companies are adopting their standard on charging; the idea of them building a charger network, originally seen as completely ridiculous, has ended up as the premier way to charge your vehicle and is being opened to other companies' cars. I'd be tempted to guess that they've had a larger impact on reducing emissions than any other single company on the planet. Twenty years ago, private spaceflight was considered impossible; this was the domain of governments alone, and the various x-prizes and the like had done nothing to change this matter. Fifteen years ago, reusable rockets was considered impossible (NASA and their contractors can't even do it, how could anyone else?) Ten years ago, SpaceX cut the costs of delivering stuff to space by what, 10x? 20x? Now they're casually demolishing all players in the satellite-ISP space single-handedly, and are looking at reducing delivery costs another 5-10x; the EU's current rockets and space orgs are collapsing under the weight of their lack of competitiveness. I don't have to agree with the man's recent decisions around Twitter or politics to credit his past accomplishments, many of which were promised years before they became reality, and it boggles me to see all the people that are incapable of doing so.
- Fricken 3y agoOne can feign capability with scale and fool backers for x amount of time. Fake it til you make it or break it. Cruise isn't the first self driving company to fall to such a temptation.
- StillBored 3y agoThe cruise vehicle (and some of the tesla features) are clearly not ready for the open road. As a bystander to them, I have pictures of those cars making mistakes that my unlicensed 14-year-old would never make. And not only in exceptional circumstances but fairly normal ones. A recent tesla incident I witnessed made me wonder if my robot vacuum cleaner has better pathfinding than the Tesla. So, the regulators must build a more rigorous testing/scoring system before these systems are allowed on the open road without a human minder. The existing ones designed for humans have many assumptions about human behavior built into them that clearly makes it unsuitable for nonhuman drivers.
- paxys 3y agoCompletely agree. Living and driving around SF over the last couple of years it's very clear that Waymo is the only one that meets the bare minimum standard of being allowed to operate on public roads, and they are also the one with the least number of cars on the road and most limited routes. Regardless of how many years and billions of dollars that have been poured into the space, it is not anywhere close to ready for prime time.
- HankB99 3y ago> more rigorous testing/scoring system before these systems are allowed on the open road It never occurred to me that the AIs driving these vehicles should be tested, but that makes absolute sense. I wonder what tests these systems must pass before allowed on the road. I remind that it's important that the vehicles do better than human drivers and sadly that's a pretty low bar. I hope we aren't evaluating this primarily by counting deaths, injuries and property damage and comparing between the two.
- someonehere 3y agoI get why they want to test in tech friendly cities, but I honestly think they need a reverse approach to getting these cars on the road. These companies need to go in cities with bigger roads and less crowded streets. They also need to incentivize citizens to ride these cars for training. Here are places I can see this tech gaining a foothold and improving its data - Walt Disney World Resort. I hate waiting for busses or taking the transit options. Disney had (don’t know if it’s still there) a brief collab with Lyft having earmarked cars for ride share between the parks. Make the cars some sort of upgrade package for visitors. A Cruise/Disney partnership would definitely benefit testing those new Cruise cars they put on hold. - Las Vegas. Big open roads. Lots of people and construction. Plenty of room to move around. Lots of data to learn. Over time they can’t go towards more condensed roads and traffic. Ideally I could see Disney being a partner with Cruise to get those Cruise cars on the road for real world testing.
- mullingitover 3y agoSelf-driving cars seem like an existential threat to GM, I'm surprised they're seriously working on them instead of desperately trying to tank the concept. They seem like they have a huge conflict of interest as it's a massive threat to their business model. If we had truly capable self-driving cars, we could probably get rid of >50% of all cars on the road. Most cars spend upwards of 90% of their existence parked and doing nothing, waiting for their owners to need them. If cars could be operating full-time 24/7, ready to be dispatched anywhere as needed, it would mean the destruction of vast amounts of transportation demand.
- webdood90 3y ago> we could probably get rid of >50% of all cars on the road I've seen this argument before but it doesn't make sense to me. In some subset of situations, yes, this would be the case. But 8-9a or 5-6p there is a surge of demand in every major metro in America. Developing self driving cars is not a fruitful endeavor IMO. We need to push alternative modes of transportation (transit, e-bikes, etc) which are way, way more efficient and cost effective.
- dventimi 3y agoWhat do you mean "we"? Push for alternative modes of transportation to the complete exclusion of autonomous vehicles if you like. Personally, I like autonomous vehicle and will continue to advocate for them.
- mullingitover 3y ago> Developing self driving cars is not a fruitful endeavor IMO. We need to push alternative modes of transportation (transit, e-bikes, etc) which are way, way more efficient and cost effective. The US is incapable of building cost-effective heavy transit though. Just building a few miles of subway in the LA metro area, for example, costs on the order of double digit billions and takes a decade plus. In huge areas of the country where it's snowy in the winter, e-bikes are a non-starter. I'm not saying every self-driving vehicle needs to be a single occupancy car. We could have fleets of self-driving minivans that are somewhere between buses and cars that can move the dramatically more people than solo drivers. Even self-driving buses would be a win, a very big chunk of the operating expenses of public bus fleets is the payroll for drivers.
- Night_Thastus 3y agoTrue Level 5 driverless cars that are fully autonomous and work in arbitrary environments, even in just the US, is just not happening any time in the next 30+ years if you ask me. Smaller more gimicky stuff in limited environments already exists though. And the level 2 stuff out there is awesome and a major value-add. The technology that has been put out so far is amazing and the engineers behind it should be very proud of that work. But there are too many "but if..."s for driverless to be mainstream just yet. We need a system that can really think like a person can. Something that has very high-level abstractions and understands context, situational state and human behavior. It's not a problem that can be just solved by slapping more and higher-resolutions sensor packages onto the car, though that will absolutely be necessary. (And until that becomes MUCH cheaper, that's a major roadblock as well)
- thfuran 3y ago>is just not happening any time in the next 30+ years if you ask me How accurate do you think your tech predictions from the early '90s about today were?
- hackermeows 3y agomoney alone can't build good tech. It's about the passion and drive of the builders, not just deep pockets. You can't just throw cash at tech problems and expect magic to happen.
- gwbas1c 3y agoThe big problem with self-driving cars is that too many people are letting their imaginations run away. This actively hurts funding when promises fail! Who's going to want to invest in self-driving cars when their "full self driving" Tesla that they bought 5 years ago will never be "full self driving" while they own it? Who's going to believe the promise that self-driving-cars are safer when Cruise's and Uber's cars hit passengers? It's clear that their cars weren't refined as much as their leadership believed. Self-driving cars are a problem that might take another decade or two to perfect; so acting like they are going to come out in the next few years is counter-productive.
- taylodl 3y agoI can't imagine GM's legal department wanting to sell self-driving cars as they know that's going to open GM to all kinds of lawsuits. But, your honor, self-driving cars are better drivers isn't going to go over well with a jury hearing your case when your vehicle ran over and killed a 5 year old girl. Your company's name and reputation is going to be drug through the mud world-wide. Why are Tesla and GM pursuing this?
- nathants 3y agojust make driving chill. let that be enough.