3 ms·
Mm. Possibly, but not necessarily. I have a suspicion that art is to humans as fancy tails are to peacocks: the difficulty is the point. I believe this is why
by ben_w 3y ago
Mm. Possibly, but not necessarily.
I have a suspicion that art is to humans as fancy tails are to peacocks: the difficulty is the point.
I believe this is why we have art galleries proudly displaying oil paintings of fruit bowls, but don't do this for random food snapshots.
It's also why photographs as a category were initially dismissed (in an era that had come to praise extreme realism in paintings), but when photographers went on long trips to visit unusual places, people, and events, those photographs suddenly did count as art.
Bit of overlap between arts and knowledge shown by the wiktionary entry for the Latin "ars", so this can be extended to the way Socrates didn't like writing, and the desire for hand-made foods and durable goods over mass produced foods and products.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good
- amelius 3y ago> the difficulty is the point Ok, so what does the next level of "difficult" look like?
- dale_glass 3y agoIt's an interesting question, because AI breaks the intuitiveness of this dramatically. You can look at say, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wedding_at_Cana https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wedding_at_Cana and quickly get that yup, this took a whole lot of time and effort. But AI has nothing like that. Some things that look like an awful lot of work it spits out with ease, some things that sound simple can take a whole lot of fiddling. Like the other day I was playing with DALLE3, and for whatever reason it didn't want to place things on a table.
- Dioxide2119 3y agoIn the same way that using a limited medium like some oil paints, paintbrushes, and canvas to create images = the art of painting, there will become the art of hacking / abusing / advanced prompt engineering / pushing AI to do things that are close to or at its limits of capabilities. A: Oh so your LLM generated an image of a spaceship cockpit, so what? B: So what? This LLM was trained on nothing but tax records from 1929! A: :o amazing! So AI artists do not necessarily equal 'creatives who render images using AI tooling', they may instead be 'creatives who tease out novel outputs from AIs' or something like that. Then again, this is suspiciously close to a 'what is art' conversation, so i'll stop here.
- ben_w 3y ago> B: So what? This LLM was trained on nothing but tax records from 1929! I recon a sufficiently advanced AI could learn enough to do that from only that training data and some appropriate prompting.
- ben_w 3y agoRight now, I'd guess engineering and growing custom life forms, like The Thought Emporium is doing. Not sure how long that will last for.
- vonjuice 3y agoWe have art galleries displaying things like empty canvases or toilet bowls that make a statement, it's definitely not about difficulty. The fact is that the debate about what art is is part of what makes art art, it escapes definition because part of the spirit of art is rebelling against definition.
- AlecSchueler 3y ago> We have art galleries displaying things like empty canvases or toilet bowls that make a statement, it's definitely not about difficulty You're under selling the difficulty of using a toilet bowl to make a convincing statement.
- thatcat 3y agoIt's a water fountain
- AlecSchueler 3y agoThat one was done over a hundred years ago, sadly. The public wasn't original and topical statements for every new opening.
- ben_w 3y agoMm. I'm 50-50 split on thinking I regard that kind of art as a vehicle for tax evasion, vs. thinking the "difficulty" is the money wasted on it (which is still Veblen "look at me I'm rich I can waste money on something pointless").
- lancesells 3y ago> art galleries displaying things like empty canvases or toilet bowls This is so far from the norm and feels like a television lens version of artists and art galleries. Yes, Duchamp used a toilet bowl in 1917 as art which was over 100 year ago. This is known because no one had done it before and presented an everyday object as art. This is 106 years old but still referred to so you can guess it was a big deal. My suggestion is to visit a modern art museum in a larger city and you'll see this kind of "easy bullshit art as a statement" doesn't really exist. https://www.tate.org.uk https://www.tate.org.uk https://www.hauserwirth.com https://www.hauserwirth.com https://www.moma.org https://www.moma.org https://www.davidzwirner.com https://www.davidzwirner.com https://gagosian.com https://gagosian.com
- dale_glass 3y ago> I believe this is why we have art galleries proudly displaying oil paintings of fruit bowls, but don't do this for random food snapshots. We also have them for social/historical reasons. A museum usually isn't built around "best stuff humanity has to offer", but has some sort of more complicated angle. Eg, a reason why you may have a fruit bowl hanging on the wall is that this particular artist has been influential, and they just happened to paint a fruit bowl. Maybe thousands of artists of the era painted fruit bowls, and maybe a dozen of those are technically more impressive, but this is the guy that got talked about a lot, or started a movement, or such, so it's this guy's bowl we're going to go with. Museums can have many themes. They may showcase a particular artist, a particular movement, a particular theme, a particular period in time. You can build a museum of nothing but paintings of cats if you wanted to.
- OCASMv2 3y agoThat view of art ended over a century ago with the modernist (mediocrist) movements. Nowadays art is whatever one wants it to be (or not to be). It's just a word people use to enhance the social perception of whatever manmade creation they like.