4 ms·
True, but what if they start encoding the ads into the stream?
by amelius 3y ago
True, but what if they start encoding the ads into the stream?
- overtomanu 3y agosomething like below extension. Relies on crowd (end users submitting time ranges) to skip unwanted parts https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/sponsorblock-for-youtube/mnjggcdmjocbbbhaepdhchncahnbgone https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/sponsorblock-for-yo...
- mimimi31 3y agoThat wouldn't work for dynamically injected ads that could be at different timestamps and have different lengths for each user.
- meithecatte 3y agoSome sort of checksumming to detect segments differing between users would probably be doable.
- _ache_ 3y agoI think you under estimated the cost of your solution, the cost must not excess the profit from the ad. You need hard work on the encoder to do that (at least to segment video, because re-encoding dynamically is obviously not an option). Not profitable for Google.
- amelius 3y agoAren't there codecs that don't carry state across keyframes? Wouldn't it then be trivial to split a video at a keyframe and insert new content?
- 15155 3y agoShazam-style audio fingerprinting can help.
- creativenolo 3y agoThe same applies for regular ads on websites. If the ad is delivery alongside the content, it can’t be blocked. But the industry doesn’t want this. They want cheap delivery of extremely targeted and tracked pushing of micro optimised advertising. That’s a reason to ad block alone. If a digital newspaper had the same ad for everyone on their website, with no tracking, I would be ok not to ad block it. That isn’t the creepy ad business I am inclined to block.