5 ms·
Note that at this point in time it is economics, not yield-per-area that dominate any solar cell installation so a new cell doesn't necessarily have to be high
by jacquesm 3y ago
Note that at this point in time it is economics, not yield-per-area that dominate any solar cell installation so a new cell doesn't necessarily have to be high yield, it has to be better when you compute total power generated for a given $ invested over the lifetime of the cell. That's pretty much all that matters, everything is just a distraction unless you are severely space constrained a couple of percent more or less isn't going to make a huge difference, and cost savings on existing processes have now compounded to the point that people are more and more looking at the price of inverters and installation as important factors. That's also why you see the push for transformerless inverters (those are bulky and costly so they affect both inverter cost and installation/shipping).
I did a pretty big solar installation over the last two years and I decided to go for quality panels because the glass-glass sandwich panels have a much better economic picture than the glass-plastic ones even though they are more expensive up front.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- robmsmt 3y agocan you elaborate a bit more on your setup?
- jacquesm 3y ago6 strings of cells, hooked up to two inverters, one handling two banks on a very high roof, peak production there is 4KW, one inverter handling four strings on covered outdoors space and the garage. The last four are at very shallow angles, so less than ideal but total surface area really makes up for that. We draw about 300W on average and the peak production capacity for the whole setup is close to 15KW (or even slightly higher in full sun in March). Over the last 11 months the system produced 12 MWh on about 4 MHw consumption so net 8 MWh returned to the grid. 34 of the panels are brand new 370W glass-glass panels, the remaining 16 are much older (probably a decade old, maybe more) that still work pretty well rated at 265 W each (but probably closer to about 220 or so).
- chrisweekly 3y agoWhat's your geography, and what'd it cost up front?
- jacquesm 3y agoNetherlands. Panels cost about 210/each for the new ones and the old ones were pretty much free. Inverter: the one upstairs is a new one, 500 Euros ('second chance'), three phase 4KW, the one downstairs is a monster, it's 17KW with up to six strings and cost another 500. The panels on the high roof were installed, about 1000 to do the job and the rest I did myself, add another 500 or so in cables, tubing etc. The power bill went from 8500 / year to 3500 / year, and all of that is the remaining gas usage. We're looking into using any surplus in nov/dec/jan/feb to help heat the house to further offset the gas usage but the economics aren't really there yet as far as I can see. And even in November we are still offsetting about 75% of our electricity usage, which somewhat surprises me, I'd expected far worse.
- chrisweekly 3y agothanks!
- jacquesm 3y agoYou're welcome. I've done a bunch of these by now if you are ever in the market for a setup and want to bounce ideas of me then feel free to mail, email is in profile.
- icy_deadposts 3y ago> We draw about 300W on average Dude, teach me. Forget solar panels, if you can explain how you're living on ~1/10th the power of the typical home around here I'd power my house on a hamster wheel.
- jacquesm 3y agoLol. Ok: first, you get 25 hamsters... No, more seriously: we started off by pulling all the breakers and to go 'from scratch', then every time I re-connected a breaker I monitored the increase in power draw. This took a bit of time but after a while we figured out there were a number of really bad consumers: my PC (which had a very high end graphics card in it from a machine learning project a couple of years ago), the NAS (which had 12 bays), an older fridge (though I thought it was quite energy efficient, but this really wasn't the case), a water heater hidden under the kitchen cupboards (that one took forever to track down), some smaller loads but still considerable (a couple of studio monitors, game computer that was on standby when not in use, a large studio mixer, a massive pump for the infloor heat that worked just as well (or even better) with the lowest setting as the one that it was on) and then a large number of really small loads that were always on but rarely needed. Removing all of those saved us 2/3rds of our power draw, we went from 30 to 35 KWh to around 8 to 10 KWh / day. After that it was relatively easy to get to '0' using solar panels and another batch of them and we were suddenly offsetting our gas usage with surplus electricity (which the power company buys). No hamsters were harmed in the preparation of this message.
- marcosdumay 3y agoWell, installation prices correlate very well with efficiency. What was always a huge problem for perovskite cells, because they tend to be way less efficient. They also suffer from lack of raw-material abundance and shorter lifetimes. But it may be possible to fix both of those too. The factory for perovskite cells should require much less initial investment, what is a huge limitation for silicon cells, so it could be revolutionary.
- balderdash 3y agoWhy I’d installation prices correlate with efficiency?
- Retric 3y agoIf you want a 1 GW solar farm you need to pay people per hour which is essentially per panel to physically install them and pay for mounting equipment etc. At 20% efficiency you need 5% more of that labor and mounting equipment than at 21%.
- hinkley 3y agoNot just more panels but more wiring to take care of. And more square meters of panel to clean.
- jacquesm 3y agoAnd more ground to buy for a given yield.
- balderdash 3y agoAhh I’m with you, i mistook your comment to mean that they were positively correlated with installation prices as opposed to negatively correlated.
- fgonzag 3y agoAt least in my house in Mexico, solar panels were mounted on custom made structures that maximize your house's power generation. That can't be cheap in a high labor cost country. The panel might be cheap but mounting it is expensive.
- pornel 3y agoGrid-scale installations can probably use anything. However, more efficient cells will probably find new uses where space or weight is very limited.
- jwells89 3y agoThere are some possibilities that could be opened up at certain efficiency thresholds, though, due to considerations that aren’t purely economic. For instance, if small panels had high enough efficiency you’d probably see a lot of people who wouldn’t consider roof installations popping them up on their back decks and the like since it’s far less involved to do so. It’d also help work around rules like the one my HOA imposes, where roof mounted solar can’t be street visible.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, when you are severely space constrained it could well make sense. But 25% isn't a big enough difference to enable that. You'd have to do much better than that.
- rsynnott 3y ago> It’d also help work around rules like the one my HOA imposes, where roof mounted solar can’t be street visible. Bloody hell, some people just want to watch the world burn.
- theLiminator 3y agoWonder if they'd allow a rooftop similar to Tesla's solar rooftop. I totally think HOAs are pretty ridiculous in general.
- grecy 3y ago> It’d also help work around rules like the one my HOA imposes, where roof mounted solar can’t be street visible. I feel like if we cared about climate change at all there would be federal (global?) laws with severe penalties making rules like the one above highly illegal. What is disgrace
- Modified3019 3y agoDefinitely a good thing to put on the list of things to complain to legislators about. For those that don’t have such a list, I recommend you start, otherwise the only opinions they hear are from people paid to capture their attention.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sroussey 3y agoYou can be very space constrained… ironically… in space. Well, needs to fit in the rocket.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, but that's not even close to the best that can be done for space applications. For that there are multi junction cells, with 30% readily attainable (at a cost, but still, you can just order them if you need them). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multi-junction_solar_cell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multi-junction_solar_cell
- godelski 3y ago> Note that at this point in time it is economics ... That's pretty much all that matters, everything [else] is just a distraction What? This doesn't make any sense. How do we invent new things if economics is all that matters? There's a whole process. You prove a thing is possible (literally the thing happening, nothing else), then move onto making the thing reliably reproducible to demonstrate, THEN optimizing for being cheap. It can fail at any point here (and there are more between tbh). This is a really long process. An example might be NASA's TRL scale. I mean yeah, it is university press and they hype it up, but I'm pretty sure a big reason for that is because comments like this. Being shitty at something is the first step to being kinda sorta good at that thing. Context matters a lot and the context here is: done by researchers, university research, journal publication. This is not Apple coming out and saying they invented something that's going to be on the market in a few months. This is someone at Apple's research lab being like "Hey, that thing we've been researching? I reached a milestone, we shouldn't call it quits yet."
- jacquesm 3y ago'at this point in time'. This is now a mature market and mature markets are governed by economics unless you manage to make a massive step forwards. So if that x% improvement comes with an increase in total cost over installed life > x% it's a non-starter.
- godelski 3y agoSolar is a mature market, sure, but that doesn't mean every technology related to solar is mature
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's fair but it does mean that those new technologies - especially if they aim to replace other technologies - will be tested on that parameter. And the difference would have to be large enough for a party to take the risk to go to manufacturing and then for other parties to take the risk to buy the product.
- bawolff 3y agoI mean, you have to do something in an expensive fashion before you can do it cheaply. Has this solved every problem? Obviously not. Not even close. Its still an important research milestone.