4 ms·
Absolutely not. Users should set the zoom level of their operating system to whatever makes user interface elements the optimal size for them -- menus, dialog
by crazygringo 3y ago
Absolutely not.
Users should set the zoom level of their operating system to whatever makes user interface elements the optimal size for them -- menus, dialog boxes, filenames, toolbars, and so forth.
Then 12pt/16px will be perfectly readable as it was always designed to be.
I'm sick of websites where the body text is four times the size of the text in my menubar (by area). This trend has become increasingly common among tech bloggers and I'm constantly having to zoom out in my browser just to bring the text down to a reasonable size.
Stick with standards and let users modify zoom levels as they desire. If everybody follows the same standard, then users don't have to keep changing their zoom levels per site.
- amelius 3y agoAt some point we'll have AI that reformats pages to whatever size the user wants, and in whatever style the user prefers. This is what "web designers" are pushing us towards anyway.
- crazygringo 3y agoHonestly you don't need AI for that at all. Come to think of it, that's not a terrible idea for a browser extension -- figure out the median text size, figure out the visual apparent size of the font by drawing a few characters to a canvas and measuring them, and then set the page zoom to compensate. Voilá -- you never have to zoom again!
- amelius 3y agoUnfortunately, web designers will find ways around that as they have an inborn drive to show us things the way they want us to see things regardless of our preferences. Therefore, I think the only true solution is to work from rendered pixels, and from there transform into whatever the user wants (font size, style, no advertisements, etc.)
- dylan604 3y agoImagine a printed magazine you just bought from a newstand that allowed you to change the font, font size, colors, layout, and even the text in the body of the articles. Why is a website different? With a magazine, if you didn't like it, you just didn't buy it. With a website, you could just close it, or you can modify every single pixel and character on the site. So we went from take it or leave it to you can do whatever the hell you want with it. So just because you don't agree with someone else's style doesn't mean it's wrong. It's not like it is preventing you from reading it. You're just upset you might have to do a little bit of work on your end and it's not being served exactly like you want it to be. The entitlement in today's society is beyond belief at this point.
- mrob 3y agoIt's not entitlement to expect a "user agent" (formal name for a web browser) to serve the user.
- dylan604 3y agoWho said it's not able to do that? You can literally change everything about a website using your "user agent". You can change the CSS. You can remove elements from the DOM. You can change the text within so that it says something that wasn't actually there. There's nothing that you can't do with it. You just have to actually, you know, do it. That's the entitled part. Complaining about it even though you already have the ability to change it to the way you like it. I'm one step away from being at the "get over yourself" commenting. It's a small step though.
- amelius 3y agoChanging the CSS is not what I'm proposing here. If most users changed the CSS, then web designers would go out of their way to make it impossible. To solve this once and for all, you'd have to take the rendered page, and turn it into something the user wants. Advantages: 1. the user agent may apply the same general preferences to many different web sites (which all work in different ways and would require different CSS); 2. anything that's already rendered in images can still be transformed into a style preferred by the user. 3. it is technology independent so you could even use those style transformations in AR-goggles (e.g. to change the text on billboards) or on a TV.
- carlosjobim 3y agoThat's reader view and you can set your browser to enable it for all websites by default. It's great!
- cantSpellSober 3y ago> let users modify zoom levels as they desire A common reply, but that requires setting a zoom level on every site across all browsers on all devices. A better solution for users is setting a legible size, and respecting their choice of base font size in the browser. > the body text is four times the size of the text in my menubar This is the same symptom of type being too small: poor design. Communicate the importance of legibility with your designers to help mitigate.
- swatcoder 3y agoOr even just remembering the difference between a web application, a web art project, a document being hosted on the web. Applications are meant to be used and may need to be zoomed to maintain coherency among various widgets and controls. Likewise, art projects need to preserve their design intent. Documents, meanwhile, are meant to be read and the user is going to best know what makes things legible for them. Ideally, publishers hint some presentation ideas but allow and anticipate that the user have final control, like you suggest.
- cantSpellSober 3y agoFalse dichotomy. "Documents" are allowed to have design. They should not have bad design (bad in this case referring to legibility). Is HN a web application, an art project, or a document? IMO it's a mix of all of the above.
- meiraleal 3y agoit's definitely not an art project without a generous stretch.
- cantSpellSober 3y agoIs there no art to successfully accelerating startups?
- 3y ago
- MightyBuzzard 3y ago[dead]