3 ms·
> New York may ban noncompete employment agreements and Wall Street is not happy I though capitalism (Wall Street) was about competition. /s
by hulitu 3y ago
> New York may ban noncompete employment agreements and Wall Street is not happy
I though capitalism (Wall Street) was about competition. /s
- eru 3y agoIt's about voluntary contracts, too.
- neilwilson 3y agoIt can only be voluntary if everybody has an alternative job to go to. While firms only hire if there is a profit to be made, and people have to earn to eat the 'no deal' stand off isn't an option.
- eru 3y agoUnemployment is near record lows in the US.
- Paul-Craft 3y agoAgreements between parties of vastly unequal power and alternatives are not voluntary.
- cj 3y agoIf they aren't voluntarily, they wouldn't be enforceable in court. What you're trying to say is there's limited alternatives. (The most obvious alternative is to not take the job)
- Paul-Craft 3y agoNo. What I'm saying is "take a job with a non-compete or starve" is not a situation in which a worker can make a voluntary choice, "enforceable in court" be damned. Not to mention, such agreements are often not stated up front as part of the job description.
- cj 3y agoI hear what you’re saying, but it’s hyperbole. I think there’s zero percent of you starving over your unwillingness to sign a non-compete. Pretending like the situation is that extreme isn’t helping anyone.
- Paul-Craft 3y agoWhy should I believe you? You don't offer an argument. It is entirely plausible that one could be faced with a situation of losing one's home, health insurance, ability to exist in modern life, and, oh, one's actual life due to unemployment. I know this because it happens. Non-competes, by definition, make this problem worse by reducing the number of jobs available to a person. What's your justification?
- cj 3y agoI’m not going to debate or justify non-competes. I’m also not advocating for them. All I’m doing is calling you out that when you join a company, you’re voluntarily signing all of the contracts. It’s not some kind of involuntary act of slavery. A responsible adult is presented a contract and chooses to sign it. That’s the opposite of involuntary. Your argument is it’s involuntary. That’s what we were debating. I wasn’t debating the contents of the contract. I personally don’t see a major need for non-competes and is overkill in almost all cases. I’m simply tired of the “I’m a victim!” mindset of blaming others for their own actions. It’s your fault if you signed a shitty employment contract. Next time read the fine print, or don’t sign it.
- Paul-Craft 3y agoAbsolutely none of that is necessarily voluntary. You have missed the point entirely. A choice between "X or die" is not a choice. That is a very real scenario, which you have not even acknowledge. Instead, you're saying I should be an expert in contracts. I am not making the situation "extreme," either. If anything, the situation is even more extreme than I am making it out to be.
- eru 3y agoUnemployment is very low in eg the US at the moment. That suggests that workers have lots of alternatives, but employers don't. Are you arguing that employers don't voluntarily hire workers, but are somehow forced to?
- Thuggery 3y agoWhy would you need violent state enforcement of voluntary contracts?
- louwrentius 3y agoNot like that! They mean competition in the sense of how much wage theft is possible to get away with