143 ms·
Google's ChatGPT Competitor Will Have to Wait
- TechRemarker 3y agoGoogle was certainly completely caught of guard. Then they said there version was more powerful and released it and it was certainly not. Then they said they had a more powerful version coming out soon that would be much more powerful, and they released Bard which was far behind ChatGPT. Now they are saying Gemini is going to be as powerful but now until early 2024 and of course by then presumably will be behind what ChatGPT is so they are also now touting there is Claude coming someday that will be even more powerful, which seems as unlikely as their past attempts. ChatGPT was able to gather so much data without restrictions and now companies late to the party will have many more restrictions and their tools will be much more limited presumably. Any secret sauce Google can develop ChatGPT presumably will be able too. Apple’s may be the most limited as they may want to be the most cautious and privacy orientated but Siri can’t get any worse so excited for any improvements.
- ur-whale 3y ago> Google was certainly completely caught of guard. They weren't. Their AI research team is completely dysfunctional and unfocused. They're only interested in doing research and are entirely incapable of the engineering and product focus necessary to build something like ChatGPT. That isn't the same thing as being caught off guard.
- itchy_spider44 3y agoThe execs were. They've been paying millions for a top-tier AI devteam hoping for something like ChatGPT, just to find out that their devteam made and freely released the transformers research that ChatGPT is based on (derp) As always, Google has incredible ideas and promise but lacks business execution
- siva7 3y agoSo they were caught of guard, maybe not from a research pov but certainly from a product pov. They are behind and are just playing catch-up for over a year now that it's safe to say that they don't have any competitive advantage over microsoft/openai anymore
- dietr1ch 3y agoIt's not caught off guard. Google simply can't do products because of how career growth works. You don't get promoted for polishing things other than ad revenue. It's all about launching things built in a hasty way.
- hn8305823 3y agoThis article was posted just a few weeks before ChatGPT was released: https://www.inc.com/nick-hobson/googles-rest-vest-days-for-sr-employees-are-over-says-ceo-its-a-brilliant-idea.html https://www.inc.com/nick-hobson/googles-rest-vest-days-for-s... Too little too late?
- ur-whale 3y ago> Too little too late? Announcing things and actually executing on said announcements are two very different things. Sundar has never been able to tell the difference between the two.
- huytersd 3y agoWell atleast others are using all the research coming out of Google for all of this. DALLE and chatGPT are both the result of research papers directly from Google research.
- danans 3y ago> They weren't. Correct, but not for the reason you gave. > Their AI research team is completely dysfunctional and unfocused. The bigger problem was that they saw the major problems with trustworthiness of LLMs and felt there was still too much brand risk to Google. OpenAI had no such problem.
- resource0x 3y agoRemember this? “We should stop training radiologists now. It's just completely obvious that within five years, deep learning is going to do better than radiologists.” Geoffrey Hinton, 2016 (while working for Google). I speculate that they weren't caught off guard. More likely, they tried to find a real-life application for their AI, and failed. Improving the quality of search is not in their interests (in fact, it's the contrary)
- two_in_one 3y ago> ChatGPT was able to gather so much data without restrictions and now companies late to the party will have many more restrictions Not only that. OpenAI entered the second stage in AI development: acceleration. They are using their current models to build next generation models. Like they used 4v to build better DALE-3. No competitor is doing it, not at this scale. This and the fact that OpenAI rises the bar makes it very hard to compete even for behemoths like Google. Not even talking about Hugging Face. DALE-3 is incomparably better than Stable Diffusion. But it's artificially limited, like no nudes, no recognizable humans, etc. Making unrestricted competitor will be really hard to do. So, my prediction: OpenAI is far ahead and the gap will increase with the time. Unless there is a breakthrough somewhere else. Then history will repeat itself. Remember, Deep Mind was an indisputable leader not so long ago.
- vineyardmike 3y agoThis isn’t history as I remember it. It’s also not history as the product announcement for bard reads. Bard was explicitly a smaller (cheaper) version of their model. They always said they had a bigger and better one behind the curtain (now called Gemini I guess). I expected bard to be simpler than ChatGPT because they said it’d be small and simple. I guess that still means it’s disappointing 1:1 though. The notable feature of the model that Bard has over ChatGPT (at least at time of launch) was daily updates keeping it way better for current information and events. Of course, Google has a lot more internal APIs they can/are leverage (eg search, drive, etc) so today bard has a different focus than just talking to a big model.
- intellectronica 3y agoIn the future, when people will be comparing Google's (lack of) corporate governance and SBF's shenanigans, the former will be considered more outrageous by a lot.
- natch 3y agoI’m afraid the real problem is that Google engineering is just lame. Case in point, Google’s vaunted spam filter marks emails from Google as phishing attempts. As I understand it every engineer at Google has the access to fix this. None of them do it. Not even having 20% time is enough. Being a leet coder is one thing. Having an ounce of initiative and giving a shit is another.
- ur-whale 3y agoYou're thinking of the Google of 2008. In 2023 Google is an entirely different beast. 20% project is a forbidden sentence by now and certainly never mentioned by the current layer of middle management that has come to infest the engineering department of the company.
- gumballindie 3y agoGoogle prompt results yield far more results and links to sources. Furthermore content creators gain traffic which they can monetise. What benefits does a procedural text generator such as chat gpt bring to the table by comparison? A summary of people’s content without attribution and without monetisation?
- award_ 3y agoChatGPT4 regularly answers questions for me, summarizes web content, etc while providing linked sources. Saying it doesn't provide links to sources is not accurate. On the other hand, Bard usually (tho admittedly not always) directs me to use Google search for the latest information.
- seydor 3y ago> it’s also severely limited Is bard so bad? I asked it to help write text for a patent, and it did. ChatGPT refuses to do so and gives me another moralistic lecture (this has become so annoying that i stopped using it - i use bing/copilot instead). As a ChatGPT competitor it might even be better, i dont get the outright dismissal.
- TwentyPosts 3y agoBard is honestly fine, I think? It wasn't particularly impressive when they first rolled it out, that probably had a significant impact on peoples' perception.
- Semaphor 3y agoThe GPT API becomes less usable with every new version. For 3.5, March is mostly okay, June requires a heavy hand to only sometimes give a weird moral lecture, and the newest gpt4 version now also starts moralizing all the time. It's one or two updates before it becomes completely useless for anything but corporate usage.
- kulahan 3y agoThe lectures drive me insane. At the very least, Bard seems to let the guardrails bend a bit here and there. ChatGPT is insanely strict on it. If I run into a problem, I can get around it in Bard way more easily.
- chankstein38 3y agoYeah I'm getting pretty tired of ChatGPT lectures as well. I use it less because most of the time, when I think of some use for it, I'm like "Eh it probably would refuse to do that anyway." I don't feel like I'm even doing anything awful with it. It just takes issue with the simplest things. Once I had it running a Text Adventure Game for me and I tried to, in game, specify to someone that changing their name was a requirement of joining my company and ChatGPT lost the plot completely and started lecturing me about how unreasonable that requirement was. Like "Oh I'm sorry I didn't realize we needed the moral police in the fantasy realm."
- blahyawnblah 3y agoBard has been working really well for me. Creating contexts/hooks for react. Generating fake resumes for some tests. Questions about how the stock market works.
- ternaus 3y agoReproducing should be easier than creating from scratch. Waiting for someone will match GPT-4 and especially GPT4-V quality and latency. And this would be the start of the battle, which could be bad for combatants but great for the rest of us. Fingers crossed, it will happen soon. Not sure that early 2024 ill be that day, but let's hope.
- GrinningFool 3y agoIt's only great for the rest of us until someone emerges a clear winner. Then the cycle starts over again.
- googlethrwaway 3y agoGoogle was so busy milking its search lead it forgot it needed to be outstanding to win consistently in the long term. As far as I'm concerned, Google's key, meaningful homegrown products are Search, Maps, Gmail and Chrome. Those products (and everything else they have acquired, including Android) exist for one single purpose: selling ads. Funnily enough, those products have also degraded in quality over time as their ability to sell ads has increased. Unfortunately for Google, it is hard to imagine a GPT chatbot that is aligned with that One True Objective, so the organization can't help itself. Sure, it's a quote-unquote "tech company", but it's far from nimble. As it scrambles to come up with a response to ChatGPT, it looks more like GE or IBM than it looks like OpenAI. Changing course of such a massive ship is damn near impossible. I don't think the decisions made by Alphabet today are as engineering-driven as they were in the early days. I'm sure the talent is still there (or was there, pre-pandemic), but maybe it's just not calling the shots.
- Sakos 3y agoGoogle is no different from any other entrenched monopoly. It's hard for the organization to care about anything outside its core revenue enough to put significant weight behind it. How many technologies were passed on by Kodak, AT&T or Xerox in favor of their existing businesses that wound up being wildly financially successful. The problem isn't Google here. It's how all potential competitors or even just any interesting tech startup is gobbled up by the big 4 (?) and then extinguished. Imagine if companies like IBM had been able to or allowed to do any of what Facebook or Google does to reduce competition.
- ur-whale 3y ago> Google's key, meaningful homegrown products are Search, Maps, Gmail and Chrome. TBH Youtube and Photos aren't half bad. And their cloud-based office suite, while it could be way better, is kind of useful.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38300990 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38300990
- Dudester230602 3y agoWhy did not clever interview questions help? They need to grind LeetCode some more.
- Lamad1234 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wkat4242 3y agoI would really hope Google's monopoly is undermined a bit. The internet is too dependent on them and their business model is pretty consumer-hostile. But big ships turn slowly, but once they build up steam they're unstoppable. I think they will manage. I bet they would have chipped in to OpenAI if Microsoft hadn't beat them to it. As for OpenAI and Microsoft, not sure what I think of it, Microsoft has not exactly been an angel in the internet history books either.
- breadwinner 3y agoQuestion about training LLM models: Can OpenAI leverage their existing models when training new ones? Asking because data sources such as Reddit and Twitter are now blocking AI crawlers. So if new OpenAI models can't be trained on those sources then can we expect that future models will be dumber? Or will they be able to leverage the existing models, so future models can only get smarter?