17 ms·
De-crufted Windows 11 coming to Europe soon
- Mindless2112 3y ago> Microsoft's post notes that Windows uses the region picked during Windows install to offer the EEA-exclusive options. Only a PC reset can undo the options. Looks like I will be telling Windows that I live in the EEA next time I install.
- crunchyfrog 3y agoI too will only install Windows in Ireland from now on.
- extraduder_ire 3y agoUnless they changed something substantial, that is where you buy it from.
- josephcsible 3y agoI predict that Microsoft will soon create something equivalent to Apple's "countryd", with the sole purpose of preventing people outside of the EU from having access to this.
- mrweasel 3y agoIt's an interesting approach. I might be remembering incorrectly, but last time Microsoft created a "stripped down" version of Windows it was pretty much impossible to actually buy.
- benhurmarcel 3y agoIt already works to select "English (Europe)" as the region. The bloatware isn't defined for that region so it doesn't include it. https://www.windowslatest.com/2023/08/06/you-can-install-windows-11-without-the-third-party-bloatware-in-two-clicks/ https://www.windowslatest.com/2023/08/06/you-can-install-win...
- aetherspawn 3y agoSuppose you are buying a new laptop ... does anyone else feel sad that their operating system has effectively turned into some weird social media marketing tracking data harvesting hybrid of a thing? But in the name of progress and security, you can't stay on Windows 10. So for me it's this weird middle ground right now .. waiting for either Windows to U-turn, die out, or for more work apps to port to OS X.
- jhoechtl 3y agoYou didn't mention Linux by intention? Why?
- aetherspawn 3y agoNothing against Linux but none of our line of business apps officially support it or even recognise that they may support it in the future.
- tonymet 3y agoIn a few minutes you can make Windows 11 look pretty close to Windows 7 (or 10) by disabling personalization, content , widgets, new tab content. In edge disable all of the new tools and bing integration. You’re right about the hassle of doing it manually, and I wish there were a global “Windows 2k mode” that ran the OS as lean as possible.
- dannyw 3y agoPay for Enterprise and a lot of it is pre disabled. Others can be configured via group policy.
- t-writescode 3y agoHow do you get access to enterprise? Last I looked, I believe you had to create a company-relationship with Microsoft to be allowed to do that and there was probably a lot more cruft to do. Edit: and a quick scan of the Microsoft website says that you need to "Contact Sales" still.
- graphe 3y agoJust install LTSB or LTSC instead.
- mananaysiempre 3y agoFor 12- or 13-th generation Intel systems with non-homogeneous cores, the scheduler in Windows 11 is supposed to work much better than the one in Windows 10 (including the latest Windows LTSC release from 2021).
- sodality2 3y agoIn that case, use AME wizard and uninstall the cruft. https://ameliorated.io/ https://ameliorated.io/
- eur0pa 3y agoAs others have mentioned, the thread scheduler in Windows 10 isn't up to par with Intel >12th gen. Fear not though, Windows 11 LTSC is scheduled for release in 2024 and I'll be switching over my gaming rig.
- zacksiri 3y agoThis is one of the marks of good product managers. Cut the cruft from the product. It's refreshing that in this case regulators are cutting things from the product rather than enforcing things to be added like cookie banners.
- ocdtrekkie 3y agoRegulators didn't enforce cookie banners. Cookie banners are a form of malicious compliance. When you complain about them, you are doing the lobbying work of ad companies for free. The correct solution is to just not spy on people, and the problem is that the EU didn't go far enough and just ban the behavior altogether.
- 6510 3y agoFun thought experiment: How would you disable access to your website after someone refuses your cookies? iow, you should always click NO.
- scintill76 3y agoIf they don’t send a cookie, pop up the banner. If they click No, redirect them to another site. If they click yes, save the cookie.
- 6510 3y agoWhat if they visit the same site again? Can you just ask again and again?
- zamadatix 3y agoBy requiring a valid cookie be present and used when trying to actually use the functionality of the site. The law does not allow this kind of behaviour for any cookies that require consent though, so that's why you can get away with hitting no.
- watermelon0 3y ago
- mkoryak 3y agoFirst read that as Windows 3.11, the definition of decrufted.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoWell, Windows 3.1 wasn’t an operating system, so it isn’t really a comparison.
- mkoryak 3y agoWhy does it need to be compared?
- daft_pink 3y agoI can't wait to switch to the EEA version of Windows. Finally!
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] More here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38293303 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38293303
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- megaman821 3y agoI have to wonder if there is a play here. Cave on basically all of the EU's demands, it doesn't matter that much too their bottom line. If the EU uses this as the blueprint to apply to iOS and Android, there is much more for Microsoft to gain on those platforms than what they lost on their own.
- supriyo-biswas 3y agoLeaked memos from Google show that they stand to gain from antitrust regulation which would help them increase their traffic on iOS and potentially become dominant on that platform.
- magnio 3y agoMaybe I'm overthinking this, but how on earth did the EU pass a regulation[0] with such far-reaching implications? First Apple opening up to third-party app stores and RCS, now Microsoft giving users a bit more leeway. How come none of the big tech lobby against it in the EU? If it survives the waves of appeals, the DMA will probably change the entire technology landscape in the near future. Not that I'm complaining of course, but still, quite a surreal moment. [0]: https://www.engadget.com/eu-confirms-the-six-tech-giants-subject-to-its-strict-new-competition-laws-161917822.html https://www.engadget.com/eu-confirms-the-six-tech-giants-sub... The 6 companies are Google, Amazon, Apple, Meta, ByteDance, and Microsoft.
- waythenewsgoes 3y agoI would imagine they did lobby against this, likely fighting tooth and nail legally. However I do not think the EU is as easily swayed, especially as EU regulators are generally skeptical of the business practices of large US multinationals. IMO, and possibly objectively, the EU is generally more pro-competition and pro-privacy, it is also much harder to buy out politicians due to the parties being really fragmented and it would appear more difficult to unilaterally impose the will of these corps on their citizens.
- microtonal 3y agoespecially as EU regulators are generally skeptical of the business practices of large US multinationals The singling out of US multinationals is a bit of a myth, it's just more visible to us tech people and since the revenues are larger, the fines also tend to be larger. But they also fined Daimler, Scania, DAF, Philips, Volvo, Deutsche Bank, etc. http://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/editorcharts/EU-GOOGLE-ANTITRUST/0H0012Y9L1DV/index.html http://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/editorcharts/EU-GOOGLE-...
- dmitrygr 3y ago> and pro-privacy Are we talking about the same EU that is currently attempting to ban encryption?
- extraduder_ire 3y agoIs this going to apply to windows 10 too? They are still updating it, and pushing bing/edge a lot.
- wesapien 3y agoYou can reinstall windows without bloat. Select the "World" region during the installation process. https://www.techradar.com/computing/windows/secret-trick-installs-windows-11-without-the-bloatware-but-microsoft-is-looking-to-fix-it https://www.techradar.com/computing/windows/secret-trick-ins...
- qwertox 3y agoOh no! I hope the loss of key features reflects in heavily lowered pricing.
- aorth 3y agoFantastic! How do we get access to this "European" version of Windows 11? Asking for Europeans who don't live in Europe, and for non-Europeans everywhere who want less Bing, Edge, and upselling in their OS.
- harrygeez 3y agoWhen I still used Windows I remember there used to be a Windows "N" version. Some AIO ISOs will let you choose
- rekoil 3y agoIs the license the same between N and non-N versions?
- orthoxerox 3y agoNo, they require different keys.
- rekoil 3y agoThought so.
- WD40ForRust2 3y agoIrrelevant! See vlmcsd on github.
- robotnikman 3y agoSame here, I look forward to the workarounds that will come.
- microtonal 3y agoI know that this is hard. But the end solution is not installing European Windows versions, but fixing government, especially curtailing lobbying, campaign funding, etc. And break the narrative 'market is everything, government is the enemy' that is so common in the US. Some regulation is good, it makes the market fairer to everyone.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoThis reminded me of a similar event in 2004 when Windows Media Player was made verboten, and Windows "N" was born: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Media_Player#European_Commission_case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Media_Player#European_...
- pipeline_peak 3y agoTragic, we’ve finally reached a version of Windows that’s actually really good. Yet management has somehow decided it’s more important to push this crap as if it’s still the 2000’s and we dont have viable alternatives. News flash, outside of work and gaming, Windows isn’t needed. And even those are questionable in the future of cloud. What happens when we can run photoshop in the browser using remote resources? What happens when the Netflix of gaming emerges, what’s MS’s foothold then?
- InCityDreams 3y ago>News flash, outside of work and gaming, Windows isn’t needed. Sunken cost fallacy? I have some really expensive windows software that I'm not about to throw away, repurchase, as well as a new os/ machine. Windows fits my needs, though the constant telemetry fight etc is very annoying.
- pipeline_peak 3y agoIn the future won’t we just be able to run that software on a remote windows container?
- LelouBil 3y agoI mean there already exists software for Linux to run windows apps using a VM but make it as if they are native
- cookiengineer 3y agoPro Hint: due to licensing issues and EU regulations, "Windows Pro Education N" is pretty much the most bloatware free version, as it's also compliant with HIPAA. - No media codecs - No AI recording/transcription features due to missing media codecs - No cortana - No Teams upselling, no Office upselling, no Skype - No self installing games
- orthoxerox 3y agoI installed the N version once, and the lack of media codecs was infuriating. Most programs assume they are always present, so the error messages they give are cryptic and the average user won't guess the problem lies in their Windows having been N(eutered). What's worse, Microsoft website provides several guides that explain how to install the codecs, and they all contradict each other. I think https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/media-feature-pack-for-windows-10-11-n-february-2023-2aaf89b8-f9d3-4322-98d0-612c9bea9c01 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/media-feature-pa... is the correct link, but I might be mistaken. And of course Microsoft bundles a lot of additional programs like Groove Music and Skype with the codecs in a single pack.
- soco 3y agoOnly when I started programming lambdas I realized how life-saving resource tests and error messages really are. You could say it was straightforward, when you think about it, but I definitely wasn't following it properly before. It turned to be a very important lesson, which I carried with me in all other environments as well "for fun and profit".
- tambre 3y agoThe fact that made me switch away from the N edition was the fact that the separately installable media codecs weren't available for weeks after my computer auto-updated to a new major Windows release. This basically made my computer unusable for many regular tasks I did, since as you noted most programs assume they're available.
- mike_d 3y agoI thought I would be clever and install the N edition of Windows 11, took me nearly two weeks to figure out what extra bits needed to be installed to allow a webcam to work.
- roschdal 3y agoLinux is much better than Windows 11.
- gloosx 3y agoI remember the first time I used a Windows system last year after tens of years on Linux/OSX, and it was really a somewhat strange experience: the moment I connected the ethernet cable I was instantly looking at random flashy news articles from another part of the world. Not in the browser, not in some kind of "News" app, but right in my taskbar! The most amazing part is that I did not even have to click on it – the system carefully opened it for me to delight me with some low-quality not-even-local news. I was not astonished then to see it resisting the Chrome browser download - something I had seen and laughed at many years before. What also caught my eye so much is the amount of branding around – there are Spotify, TikTok, Amazon Prime, Instagram, and Facebook Messenger icons right in your menu bar before you ever need them or attempt to download and discover these apps for yourself. I mean that is too much. It feels like you don't really own this system but use it in some kind of public library.
- pavlov 3y ago> "the system carefully opened it for me to delight me with some low-quality not-even-local news" To be fair, Apple does this exact same thing on their operating system. On a freshly installed iPhone, swipe right at the home screen. It takes you to the widget screen which is loaded by default with Apple News showing random junk. Microsoft deserves the flak for turning Windows 11 into a billboard, but Apple isn't immune to this either.
- hurril 3y agoBut they don't do the exact same thing at all. One comes preloaded with apps you didn't choose and news or ads right on the task bar. Apple does none of that.
- pavlov 3y agoApple preloads the phone with commercial apps that I didn't ask for like Apple Music, and those apps will get automatically triggered for some content. They show news and other unsolicited content practically in the home screen (the widget screen is just a swipe away, every user will stumble there). What's the difference? I think people are a bit blind to Apple's defaults. They compare a fresh Windows 11 install to their own customized iOS install with a decade of history, and conclude that Microsoft is so much worse. But the out of the box experience for a new user isn't all that different, IMHO. (MacOS is still better than Windows in many respects, but it's been steadily moving closer to iOS and comes with an ever-growing pile of Apple default apps loaded in the Dock and set as defaults.)
- chris_wot 3y agoCan we not just implement this everywhere?!?
- Jean-Papoulos 3y agoThe EU just keeps winning on the big tech front, it seems. I'm honestly not sure how they keep doing it ; is the motivation to keep away influence from big tech ? Giving a bit of stick now so the carrot is more efficient later ?
- karmakurtisaani 3y agoThey just care about EU citizens more than American tech companies. If they were European mega corporations, I'm sure it would be different.
- lofaszvanitt 3y agoCan't you see what happened in the US, where these big tech monkeys are roaming around, free, doing whatever they want?
- fifteen1506 3y agoIdk about you, I like the bloatware. Makes me feel in a cozy setting, just like home. No-one will like the new versions and Microsoft will say to EC: see? You dumb dumb. Same with Meta's subscription for €9.99. Same with cookie regulations which gave us cookie banners. This malicious compliance, don't be mistaken.
- alok-g 3y ago>> Camera, Cortana, and Photos can now be uninstalled When a user would uninstall an app, would it actually be removed from the system, or just the icons and entries would be. Motivation for asking: Several built-in apps are listed in the Apps section of the settings as having just a few kB in size, which does not match how bloated in size apps typically are in the current times. I've seen mouse drivers occupy hundreds of MB. My guess is that the apps are much bigger than those kB values and the installed Apps settings section is set to let users believe otherwise.
- walteweiss 3y agoAs with my iPhone that has none of Voice Memos at the moment has data shown as 4 GB. I remove the app, nothing changes, it frees some kilobytes for the app (which I doubt, that the app is in kilobytes) and leaves the data, while it claims it keeps the data only when I unload the app to the cloud.
- hurryer 3y agoSome Windows binaries are hard linked to run directly from the installation disk image copied during Windows install . Those few kb are probably the size of the hard links to the image.
- alkonaut 3y agoI think for app uninstallation to be relevant it's not whether the app resides on disk that's important, it's whether it's interfering with how you use the system. E.g. for a browser it's just important that the browser isn't registered as the default browser everywhere, but you can install your own browser. Being able to "uninstall" an app in a relevant way means being able to make it appear as if you don't have it. Whether or not the files the app uses are still on disk is perhaps relevant for disk space, but from a legal standpoint that seems almost irrelevant.
- Shadowed_ 3y agoWhat you are talking about is not uninstalling. It's disabling. Uninstalling should remove application.
- shmde 3y agoWindows 11 LTSC version when ?
- lofaszvanitt 3y agoKick them back into the stone age. Mongrels of the software world.
- whostolemyhat 3y agoDMA already paying off
- axpvms 3y agoI don't see mention of removing news from the widgets bar. I could actually use the widgets bar for things, but it's pointless with more than half the bar dedicated to low-quality clickbait that I can't get rid of.
- dendrite9 3y agoOut of curiosity, why did the title here change sometime in the last couple hours? It was something like the "no Bing, No Edge, .." from the current Ars title. Did they change the article title after this was posted here? I know Ars does A-B titles for a period after publishing.
- octacat 3y agooh yea, can we also patch Apple? This "Your icloud storage is low" and "Buy space" warnings are annoying. And you cannot do anything about them. Oh, Apple products have such an amazing usability (they are not, apparently, in 2023, if they think advertising their cloud bundle is ok).
- SushiHippie 3y agoI can't count on one hand how many times I've pressed reject on the Apple Care advertisement in the System Settings on a MacBook Pro. It always had a message something along the lines of "You'll never be able to get this deal again..." a few days later it always popped up again.
- felixding 3y agoExactly. I disabled notifications completely because of this which makes the feature useless to me. I kinda miss the good old Growl days.
- BSDobelix 3y agoRunning Win10-IoT/Enterprise or even Win11-Enterprise is such a refreshing experience compared to the "consumer"-editions. Why is microsoft making it so hard to buy enterprise editions as a private person? I would happily pay 5$ a month...well no i dont, but IF i had to use windows i would. BTW, two nice apps to cleanup and shutup your windows (deinstall everything you want): -O&O ShutUp10++ -O&O AppBuster
- redder23 3y agoWindows will now "always use customers' configured app default settings for link and file types" This is really the most disgusting thing they did, they really tried soo hard to make people you Edge that they open links from the windows search I think, no matter what default browser you have set. Strangely search is not working for me, might be because of Explorer Patcher because they are so fucking stupid the removed the ability to have the task bar on top in win11. It was a hidden setting that you can enable with a reg tweak then they completely remove it. Like WHY WTF? I need my taskbar on top, it makes so much more sense. Window bars are top, closing windows is top, browser tabs are top ... Like how many mouse miles do you use more by going all the way to the button of your screen, I hate dumping things down, I do not mind the win11 task bar but I am forced to use a hacky windows 10 one just to move it top ... Did I say I hate M$ already?