13 ms·
It would be interesting to see a real census of the folks who want to keep ia64 support in Linux, with some breakdown of their motivations. Cases like "Control
by bell-cot 3y ago
It would be interesting to see a real census of the folks who want to keep ia64 support in Linux, with some breakdown of their motivations. Cases like "Control software for our factory's special $Millions-dollar machine only exists for ia64" seem far more sympathetic than "I love my basement collection of archaic computer hardware".
- anotherhue 3y agoSuch a factory wouldn't be chasing the latest version of anything, it would probably be air-gapped.
- jabl 3y agoMost likely such Itanium systems would be running VMS or HP-UX rather than Linux.
- mrweasel 3y agoI was wondering is Itanium was still supported by HP-UX... It's apparently the only architecture supported by HP-UX currently. That's kinda sad. Must also be a little weird being on the HP-UX team, pushing out updates to a dying platform.
- ghaff 3y agoIn the enterprise software space, a ton of work goes into maintaining old platforms and backporting security patches and the like to old versions of software. That a not small part of what you're paying those companies to do.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bell-cot 3y agoPoint...but 's/would/should/g' is far too often the reality.
- josefx 3y agoJust because some of the hardware and its control software may be stuck in ancient times doesn't mean that they wouldn't want to upgrade other software or add other hardware that requires a newer kernel to function.
- fisf 3y agoBut in practice, it is often not possible or allowed to simply add other software or hardware to those systems. Those are delivered and certified as-is and upgrades are a no-go.
- phkahler 3y agoYeah they could upgrade the processor. And since it apparently runs Linux already, most the software should be relatively portable. Now if they're using a 9-bit serial UART there may be a problem...
- not_the_fda 3y agoThey wouldn't, its too much of a risk. The update could break the control software and bring everything down. If its working don't touch it, otherwise you might bring down production and lose lots of money. A new kernel brings no value to a currently working system.
- sneela 3y agoYep. I'm very curious to know who actually use itanium cpus anymore. I've only seen it referenced in a couple of research papers that are from... 2015-2016? I even went out of my way to see if a local refurbished electronics seller had itaniums many months ago and they said, "Itanium, huh. Haven't heard that name in a long time".
- aeyes 3y agoIn 2017 Intel released a new Itanium CPU so someone must have been using them.
- gsnedders 3y agoAFAIK they were contractually obliged to produce a new generation. However: > [The 2017 CPU] has no microarchitecture improvements over [the 2012 CPU]; despite nominally having a different stepping, it is functionally identical with the 9500 series, even having exactly the same bugs, the only difference being the 133 MHz higher frequency of 9760 and 9750 over 9560 and 9550 respectively. So they practically _didn't_.
- jacquesm 3y agoI wonder how many got sold or if it was just a run to fulfill that contract and nothing else.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoWe got 4 from that last batch that Intel ran. Our cloud migration project is way behind schedule and we needed the insurance. Support for the VMS version we’re running on them goes until 2028 I think. We’re decommissioning a couple of first-gen Itanium servers in the next few months. I think that the assumption is that we’d have to pay for disposal, so if someone wants them for Linux kernel support and can pick them up in Chicago, reply from an account with contact info and I’d send an email if it’s possible to give them away for free (I can ask).
- jabl 3y ago> "I love my basement collection of archaic computer hardware" Nothing wrong with retro-computing enthusiasts, per se. From the Linux kernel perspective it's about the architecture having maintainers and not causing pain for the rest of the kernel. The Linux m68k port is probably a good example of this, hard to see it having any kind of commercial value these days, and the maintainers are hobbyists. But with the Itanium port not having anybody willing to maintain it, bye bye. Probably also helps that qemu has m68k support, so even if you love the idea of running Linux on your old Amiga, you can actually do the development on a mainstream platform.
- repelsteeltje 3y agoYour argument comes down to: put your money where your mouth is. I think that makes sense, both for hobbyists and commercial value. A census is one, but unless someone's willing to pick up the gauntlet...
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, but most retro computing enthusiasts are more than happy to run retro software as well, because that's where the fun is. Running a 2023 OS on 1993 hardware is going to be a frustrating experience anyway even if you get it to work because of the relative change in performance since then. Hardware is usually best matched with software from roughly the same era if you want anything close to acceptable performance. My oldest still-in-use hardware is now 15 years old and I'm amazed it does as well as it does but I'm also quite aware of the limitations and that stuff was absolutely top-of-the-line when it was bought. Parts are unobtanium and if it goes (which could happen every time it power cycles) we'll probably hold a small service but not cry too much.
- creshal 3y ago> The Linux m68k port is probably a good example of this, hard to see it having any kind of commercial value these days There's some 500 Eurofighters around with two dozen m68k each for their avionics (though not running Linux – and they're slooowly getting updated to less obsolete architectures), and I suspect they're not the only current use case. Industrial life cycles can be very, very long.
- iforgotpassword 3y agoThe only reasonable thing would be having exotic architectures around to ensure the kernel is as portable as possible and doesn't make any weird assumptions. I think that's OpenBSD's reasoning for some of the CPUs supported. No idea though if itanium brings anything interesting to the table in that regard. If it's just EFI woes, not much is gained really.
- cesarb 3y ago> The only reasonable thing would be having exotic architectures around to ensure the kernel is as portable as possible and doesn't make any weird assumptions. Some of these "weird assumptions" are necessary or useful for either performance or maintainability reasons. Having special cases for exotic architectures makes the kernel harder to change, and makes it harder to refactor it to user better code and data structures. That's, for instance, the reason support for the original Intel 386 was removed. Yes, this makes the kernel less portable, but that's a tradeoff.
- chasil 3y agoSPARC is big-endian, and is likely the greatest correction to coders who maintain "all the world's a VAX!" Much gdb has been spilt on these shores. Both the VAX and x86(-64) are little-endian. The Itanium could run either, but was little-endian by default (HP-UX would toggle to big-endian).
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoFascinatingly, ARM (aarch64) can also do either; while the only operating system I know about that uses this fact is NetBSD, I have actually run that in big endian mode on a Raspberry Pi (3b) and it does actually work.
- chasil 3y agoThat is a really interesting fact.
- CrLf 3y agoArchaic hardware should be running period-correct software anyway. It’s not that they can’t stay on a previous kernel. Itanium isn’t truly archaic, though. It was only discontinued 3 years ago.
- mhh__ 3y ago> basement I was looking for an itanium server for a while and literally couldn't find one that wasn't silly money
- dspillett 3y agoI expect there are people out there who were in the right place at the right time when the company they work for was decommissioning some IA64 kit, and got it for nothing or close to. So there will be at least some hobbyists who haven't paid silly money. Because of the niche it ended up in, and how small that niche was, you either get the kit for very little that way or a lot by buying it from someone who got it that way, there is not much in between.
- repelsteeltje 3y agoBack in the day, we reluctantly abandoned PowerPC, UltraSPARC, PA-RISC, Alpha AXP, MIPS... because the bright future was Intel Itanium. Bye, bye, SUN, Silicon Graphics, Acorn, DEC/Compaq, Hewlett Packard, Sony NEWS. That future never materialized.
- flyinghamster 3y agoAbout the only real "success" of Itanium was wiping out the competing architectures. ARM only survived because its low power consumption was perfect for mobile and embedded use. Once Acorn was gone, we didn't see a mainstream ARM-based personal computer again until the M1 Mac.
- jabl 3y ago> About the only real "success" of Itanium was wiping out the competing architectures. Arguably x86-64 would have wiped those out anyway, with or without Itanium.
- unregistereddev 3y agoMost likely, yes. But without Itanium, the competing architectures would have had several more years of development before x86-64 was released. While the end result would probably be similar, it is interesting to think about what improvements may have been made in competing architectures in those interim years.
- hannob 3y agoI'm not even sure that's so relevant. Ultimately, the question is: Is there a community of people willing to maintain it properly? And it appears to me that's Torvalds' position as well.
- ta1243 3y agoI'd say its the other way round. You want updates for your million-dollar business critical hardware, you can bloody well pay for it.
- ianai 3y agoExcept it would more likely be “no more software to run this? Such a shame <off goes the hardware>”
- imtringued 3y agoI have to disappoint you then. There is no such thing as a sufficiently good compiler for the Itanium architecture. The software that was worth turning on the hardware for never existed.