3 ms·
James Webb Space Telescope finds 2 of the most distant galaxies ever seen
- sounds 3y agoHere's a slightly more in-depth link, still written by Penn State U's PR people but it links to the paper: https://science.psu.edu/news/WangLeja11-2023 https://science.psu.edu/news/WangLeja11-2023
- dylan604 3y agoI have a feeling that this headline will keep repeating itself as more imagery comes in and keeps getting analyzed. The first thing found from Webb that was further than Hubble gets "most distant ever seen", then the next thing from Webb that was further will get "most distant ever seen". We need to just have "most distant ever seen, yet" edit to them all
- Civitello 3y agoEventually, there will be a telescope to be the last to set the record for the most distant galaxy observed, because cosmic expansion will make it impossible to observe things so distant. I sometimes like to imagine what it will be like in the far future when you can only observe things a billion ly away, or a few million.
- mihaitodor 3y agoI think it will take us a long time to map the entire “surface” of the visible sphere. Eventually, telescopes will be able to pick up some of the farthest galaxies, but there will always be one which might be a bit farther away, even if it won’t be orders of magnitude farther.
- Ilverin 3y agoThe expansion of the universe is accelerating. At some point, the number of galaxies in the visible universe will stop growing and the light received from distant galaxies will grow more and more redshifted. However, it's possible that the redshifting will accelerate faster than our technological ability to detect more and more redshifted light.
- chongli 3y agoI think we can fight back against this to some extent. The most distant galaxies are fading due to increasing redshift. If we build larger and larger radio telescopes then we should be able to continue seeing them at longer wavelengths. If in a billion years we manage to colonize a substantial chunk of our galaxy then maybe we could build a gigantic radio telescope out of many small collectors spread out over several light years.
- Ilverin 3y agoYou may be right, so I edited my comment.
- Larrikin 3y agoNothing in the universe can travel faster than the speed of light (we think), but the universe can expand faster than the speed of light. There are probably already objects we can't see and at some point in the far far future we will only be able to see objects in our own galaxy no matter how good our telescopes become.
- imoverclocked 3y agoThere may be other cool tricks that we haven't thought of too. No reason that we need to make things bigger and colonize the galaxy if we figure out something neat that is smaller instead! eg: Maybe we figure out that we can accelerate small telescopes to some significant fraction of the speed of light for an observation. Or perhaps we find some other neat physical phenomena to manipulate incoming light. The cool thing about scientific and engineering progress is that we can't know what we will discover and develop. 200 years ago, we started having electric lamps. In just 100 years time, we have gone from computers being fringe and folly to them being integrated into places they don't even need to be for sheer convenience. Assuming humanity makes it another 100 years and continues to advance technologically, things we only dream of today could easily be so common-place that people can't imagine living in the current dark-ages of technology. Also, 100 years is a cosmic blip! If we are thinking ahead to the point where we can't see things in the universe that we can see today, humanity itself will likely not be recognizable from our current vantage point... assuming it exists at all.
- echelon 3y agoThat we are the universe alive and experiencing itself is the most amazing thought in the world. By that same coin, the universe going dark is the most depressing and crushing. Let's hope our feeble understanding of the universe yields to a future full of more possibility than we can imagine today.
- irrational 3y agoThe reminds me of Asimov's short story "The Last Question" http://www.thelastquestion.net/ http://www.thelastquestion.net/
- bjorn2run 3y agoI hadn’t read this before, thanks for sharing it. Also this site is perfect, it reminds me of the feeling I got using StumbleUpon so long ago. Finding a super specific site someone passionate was hosting, the best!
- ahazred8ta 3y agoObligatory xkcd: https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/1448:_Question https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/1448:_Question
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoIt’s like when apple announces “our greatest iPhone yet” as if they’d ever announce one which was “almost as good as last year’s”.
- kevindamm 3y agoiPhone Air EDIT: or, a hybrid iPhone Lite that fits in a head-mounted frame and double as a Vision SE
- baal80spam 3y agoAs a layman it always amazes me when reading such news that what we see now actually _happened there_ n years ago (in this case: 3.5 billions years ago). Not that it matters, but it is mind boggling nevertheless.
- lanna 3y agoWe are always seeing the past. If you are talking to someone a foot away from you, you are seeing how they were a nanosecond ago.
- seanw444 3y agoYes, but that is beyond human perception. A nanosecond is pretty much now. Several billion years is a whole time machine.
- go_elmo 3y agoBut still - it unveils the "present" to just as well be an illusion of human categorical thinking, an abstract concept, not more. It is super useful to have none the less, just interesting to know its fragility.
- somenameforme 3y agoShould we ultimately be able to develop relativistic rockets, and it seems there is no inherent reason why we shouldn't, then everything is just going to be so unbelievably weird. Traveling on a rocket to friendly distant planet, except the planet you land on may be millions of years in the future from when it was first settled. Or imagine living on said planets and occasionally seeing relics thousands, millions, or even further back in history approaching for landing. Time, life, death, technology, and everything will be just so unimaginably alien. It will be basically impossible to have a normal linear view of time when it's violated constantly, even though your body itself will yet still almost certainly be insistent on linear time - and steadily marching towards its expiration date. Even evolution itself will be weird. Humans over millions of years will probably scarcely resemble ourselves today, yet you'll regularly have 'old' species humans regularly reintegrating with 'new' ones? Such a bizarre reality we live in, unless perhaps somehow the views we have today end up being as quaint as those of times past.
- just_boost_it 3y agoWhen I saw this I thought it was a "water is wet" type story, because this telescope is supposed to see further than all the other ones we've made. The gravitational lensing aspect of it makes it cool though.
- denton-scratch 3y agoSo we can see stuff at z=13. What I can't get my head around is that the Milky Way either formed around the same time, 13 billion years ago, or it formed from stuff produced by galaxies that did. But we can't see the primordial Milky Way by pointing our telescopes at z=13. These old, faraway galaxies must have been formed just faraway enough from where our galaxy formed, that the expansion of spacetime has prevented their light from reaching us until "just now". So I wonder what distances apart the places where the primoridal Milky Way, and these two distant galaxies, must have been for the light to take so long to reach us. Like, the Universe was a lot smaller then; galaxies were much closer together. Galaxies at z=13 must have formed shortly after the Dark Age ended, and the Universe became transparent - like a few tens of millions of years - less than the time since the dinosaurs were knocked out (I'm assuming galaxies can't form in a plasma Universe, but maybe I'm wrong).
- irrational 3y agoI've wondered the same thing. I'm hoping somebody knowledgeable replies.
- divbzero 3y agoYour question in other words is: How far was the primordial Milky Way from these two galaxies 13 billion years ago? I don’t have the answer on hand but it might be related to comoving vs. proper distances: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comoving_and_proper_distances https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comoving_and_proper_distances
- kbelder 3y ago>But we can't see the primordial Milky Way by pointing our telescopes at z=13. Isn't that the cosmic microwave background? The ultrahot primal universe dispersed and cooled by initial expansion?
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]