10 ms·
FBI Director: FISA Section 702 warrant requirement a 'de facto ban'
- sophacles 3y agoWow, law enforcement sure does whine a lot when someone suggests they do their jobs and present evidence slightly more substantial than "Because I'm a cop and I say so".
- i_am_jl 3y ago"A warrant requirement would amount to a de facto ban" Yeah Chris, that is the point.
- naasking 3y agoIt's almost like some people don't get that some tools should only be selectively applied only when absolutely needed.
- ethanbond 3y agoThe determination of probable cause has nothing to do with whether the invasion of privacy/warrant is "absolutely needed" or not. The FBI's position is that that should be a consideration.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThey have proven themselves unworthy of this power and legal exception process. > He did address the FBI's earlier abuses of Section 702 to spy on protesters, campaign donors, and even elected officials. > "To be sure, no one more deeply shares Members' concerns regarding past FBI compliance violations related to FISA, including the rules for querying Section 702 collection using US person identifiers, than I do," Wray said. > The FBI "responded rigorously" to these violations, he added, and that already "dramatically" reduced the 702 searches on US persons, he added. > "Moreover, as we publicly announced in June, the FBI is implementing further measures both to keep improving our compliance and to hold our personnel accountable for misuse of Section 702 and other FISA provisions, including through an escalating scheme for employee accountability, including discipline and culminating in possible dismissal." Anchorman Ron Burgundy I don't believe you meme here.
- ethanbond 3y agoI mean... there obviously shouldn't be an exception to the legal process. That's the whole point of the legal process. GP was suggesting that exception should still exist and they should just use it selectively, which of course is the entire debate.
- nullserver 3y agoBut think of the poor people that just want target to political opponents!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- newZWhoDis 3y agoLook, it’s either this or the whole FBI. Take it or leave it. Speaking of warrants, I’d like to start seeing judges held accountable for “bad warrants”, the rubber-stamp problem is real.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y ago> the rubber-stamp problem is real. If it's real then please provide supporting evidence for that claim.
- SteveNuts 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Foreign_Intelligence_Surveillance_Court https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Foreign_Intellig... > FISA warrant requests are rarely denied. During the 25 years from 1979 to 2004, 18,742 warrants were granted, while only four were rejected. Fewer than 200 requests had to be modified before being accepted, almost all of them in 2003 and 2004. The four rejected requests were all from 2003, and all four were partially granted after being submitted for reconsideration by the government. Of the requests that had to be modified, few were before the year 2000. During the next eight years, from 2004 to 2012, there were over 15,100 additional warrants granted, and another seven being rejected. Over the entire 33-year period, the FISA court granted 33,942 warrants, with only 12 denials – a rejection rate of 0.03 percent of the total requests.[4] This does not include the number of warrants that were modified by the FISA court
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoThat they're rarely denied doesn't mean they're a rubber stamp.
- function_seven 3y agoThat's the literal definition of a "rubber stamp" process! That you won't be denied, that the granting of your request is essentially automatic.
- koolba 3y agoHere's the full quote: > "A warrant requirement would amount to a de facto ban, because query applications either would not meet the legal standard to win court approval; or because, when the standard could be met, it would be so only after the expenditure of scarce resources, the submission and review of a lengthy legal filing, and the passage of significant time — which, in the world of rapidly evolving threats, the government often does not have," Wray said. That's even worse than the abbreviated statement. Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice ... you can't get fooled again.
- ClarityJones 3y ago> would not meet the legal standard to win court approval; That is to say, they're targeting individuals who they have no substantial reason to believe actually did anything wrong.
- ethanbond 3y agoThat isn't true. It means it wouldn't reach probable cause. There are plenty of crimes and suspected crimes for which it's hard to gather enough evidence to reach probable cause. He said it correctly: it wouldn't meet the legal standard. That should mean, correctly, you cannot invade people's privacy, but again it's pretty unrelated to "are they investigating crimes or not." Edit: GP's comment was edited from "That is to say, they're not even investigating a crime." That claim is untrue.
- frumper 3y agoIf they don't have enough evidence it's hard to say that have substantial reasons. It sounds like they have a hunch.
- chatmasta 3y agoThey don't even need to have a hunch. They just need to say they do, and in the cases where it even goes in front of a judge, it gets rubberstamped with a 97%+ approval rate.
- yxwvut 3y agoWhen I worked at a certain three-letter-agency, much of the annual legal training amounted to "Here's our incredibly tortuous interpretation of every relevant term in the letter of the law. Don't like it? There's the door."
- ofslidingfeet 3y agoCool, so what kinds of people typically leave and what kinds of people typically stay?
- yxwvut 3y agoWell, I left for exactly that reason. I imagine those who stayed took an 'ends justify the means' stance that I couldn't abide. The organizations themselves are insatiable - there's no way that, left to their own devices, any three-letter-agency would ever say "Oh, this is beyond our scope, we shouldn't be allowed to access this.", and that combined with rubber stamp 'checks' allowed this surveillance creep.
- helpfulContrib 3y ago[dead]
- s1gnp0st 3y ago"Why did you create the panopticon hive-mind when you could've stopped at any point?" "Oh... I was going for promo."
- azalemeth 3y agoI think this comment deserves to be read more widely. It always seems all around the world that the three letter agencies are trying very hard to convince people to spy more and I have often wondered where the justification comes from internally and if they have any debate inside. Self selection would be one example. To be fair, when I once had a beer with someone who worked in that area before coming to academia she basically said you could work out how many intelligence officers a country had, and realise that given the amount of time effort and money it takes to properly surveil someone they were limited to a small multiple of that number of people to spy on "properly". I felt reassured by that. I can also see it being a justification for RoboCop.
- injeolmi_love 3y agoWhy is Biden opposing the warrant requirement? Shouldn’t he be careful regarding 2024? Or is the hope that the alternative is so bad people will still come out to vote for someone who supports warrantless searches? Maybe most people don’t care, but at least in my circle this is a big deal.
- bogantech 3y agoIt would stop them spying on his political enemies
- bequanna 3y agoI don't disagree with your assertion that the Executive branch has probably weaponized agencies against political rivals but what we really need is clear evidence of this happening so we can stop it. Regardless of who is doing it, it is wrong. Even if you think its great that <your party> had their political opponents audited by the IRS, investigated and harassed by the FBI, etc. remember that in a few years the party in control can change and those same dictator-like tactics are now available to them to use against <your party>.
- bradleyjg 3y agoShouldn’t he be careful regarding 2024? No. A decent, but my no means huge, number of people have opinions about this subject. But the number for whom it is a high enough priority issue that it would determine if they would vote or who they would vote for is infinitesimal.
- empyrrhicist 3y ago[flagged]
- sidewndr46 3y agoif you asked the voters in federal elections to describe what a warrant is, why they exist & the historical significance of them most would fail to articulate it any meaningful matter.
- ofslidingfeet 3y agoIt's a start.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoWhy should they need a warrant to surveil foreign targets? > Section 702 allows the Feds to warrantlessly spy on communications belonging to foreigners outside of the United States in the name of preventing crime and terrorists attacks.
- ofslidingfeet 3y agoBecause the FBI is supposed to be a domestic law enforcement agency.
- rtkwe 3y agoAlso if they can capture foreign correspondence without a warrant they can just bug the family of any US person and gather all their communications with them through that. That person's communications are supposed to be protected by a warrant under the 4th.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoI agree on the warrant point, but how could they bug the family of any US person unless that person or those family members are out of the country?
- rtkwe 3y agoThings like Room 641a [0] and requests to service providers. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A
- tssva 3y agoThe warrant would only be required to review data of US citizens which is captured while surveilling foreign targets.
- aaronmdjones 3y agoBecause they've been abusing it to warrantlessly snoop on the communications with or involving US persons.
- znpy 3y ago> However it also scoops up phone calls, texts, and emails of US persons — if the foreigner is communicating with or about these US persons So let me get this straight? basically if I (non us citizen) make some dumb joke in a private conversation (with another non-us citizen) about bombing some place in the US and also mention, say, Elon Musk or Hilary Clinton or Donald Trump or Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez (even though i clearly have no relation to any of them) then the FBI has "legal ground" to intercept and store their private communication?
- AlanYx 3y agoYou're misreading it, but the reality goes further than you're imagining. Section 702 allows data collection for non-US persons, regardless of what they're communicating about. Sometimes those collections also vacuum up names of US persons; basically incidental collections. There's apparently a process called "targeting and minimization" to strike the names of US persons gathered in this manner, unless a warrant is obtained. What may really blow your mind is that s.702 also authorizes collection of foreign data held by subsidiaries of US companies. Foreigners making decisions about data residency need to understand this, but many don't. It is not sufficient to avoid s.702 to just store data in a foreign datacentre, if that datacentre is owned by a subsidiary of a US company.
- redavni 3y ago> What may really blow your mind is that s.702 also authorizes collection of foreign data held by subsidiaries of US companies. The only thing that strikes me as possibly uncommon about this is that the US publicly encodes it as law. How is this mind blowing? There is no place on earth where the sitting government does not have access to the things on it's territory.
- AlanYx 3y agoThe effect I'm referring to is extraterritorial. It's sometimes a surprise to foreigners because there can be a mistaken belief that specifying a particular non-US datacentre for cloud services places the data stored therein under the domestic (local, non-US) legal system and outside of US jurisdiction with respect to s.702 monitoring. Section 702 requests are still used, even for countries like the UK and Australia who have signed their own executive agreements under the US CLOUD Act. (The new Trans-Atlantic Data Privacy Framework and its Data Protection Review Court is a different ball of wax.)
- MightyBuzzard 3y ago[dead]
- kstrauser 3y agoUh, OK. If you can’t do it within our legal framework that at least pays lip service to balancing freedom vs security, then don’t do it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MikeKusold 3y agoHere is the EFF Take Action page on FISA Section 702: https://act.eff.org/action/tell-congress-absent-major-changes-702-should-not-be-renewed https://act.eff.org/action/tell-congress-absent-major-change...
- giardini 3y agoThat URL fails to find valid addresses and is likely EFF "Hoovering up" addresses - SOS.
- boomboomsubban 3y agoI can't say why it's failing to find your address, but the URL both explains why it needs your address and presents an option to contact your representative without using their tool.
- kelnos 3y agoOof, the pre-filled email they send has a typo: > I implore you not to support any attempts to renew Section 702 of FISA without major reforms that project privacy I assume that should be "protect" privacy, not "project"...
- aftbit 3y agoThe rule of law, in complex times, Has proved itself deficient. We much prefer the rule of men! It's vastly more efficient.
- bcx 3y agoIf I recall the original FISA warrants were part of the US Patriot Act, which was one of the greatest increases in domestic surveillance in US history and brought about as an immediate response to 9/11. I haven't followed what it's been up to over the last 12 years, but it's nice there was actually some expiry in there. Certainly the US intelligence apparatus existed pre 9/11. Would FISA courts and secret warrants have prevented 9/11, who knows. Did all the agencies get a rubber stamp in everything they ever wanted in response to 9/11 under the guide of patriotism, during a period of intense groupthink -- likely.
- heroprotagonist 3y agoDo these kind of things ever actually expire though? All the 'temporary' powers granted with an expiration period have been renewed or expanded for the last 30 years. Often as little-noted riders on lesser bills of questionable relation, or bundled as side notes into major debacles like threats of government shutdown.
- newZWhoDis 3y agoFederal income tax was supposed to be temporary for WWII, we see how that worked out.
- rsync 3y agoFederal income tax, while extant in some ways prior, was broadly established in 1913 with the 16th amendment[1]. Other than very high war profiteering tax rates imposed during WWII - which were not only refundable but also removed over time - there is almost no connection at all between WWII and the broad concept of federal income tax. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixteenth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixteenth_Amendment_to_the_Uni...
- kelnos 3y agoI'm pretty sure most of the PATRIOT Act (including the FISA stuff) has come up for expiration many times since 9/11, and Congress more or less just rubber-stamps a renewal of all of it, with at best minor changes/reforms. I think this bill that the FBI is opposed to is the first real reform we're seeing that actually takes away some power from these agencies.
- Clubber 3y ago>In prepared remarks, he told Representatives that "loss of this vital provision, or its reauthorization in a narrowed form, would raise profound risks." Of course having an agency with arrest powers that "investigates itself," more power also raises profound risks.
- rtkwe 3y agoIt really does strike me that every publicized 'plot' from foreign 'terrorists'/their sympathizers has mostly read like they found someone with some grievances but not the inclination or means to act on them until the FBI gets involved.
- newZWhoDis 3y agoParents have caught FBI attempts to groom their autistic children to become terrorists.
- mjcohen 3y agoI wrote this in a story of mine in 2012: I knew that the organization most often responsible for terrorist plots on American soil was the FBI, and I decided to take advantage of this.
- ilovetux 3y agoFrom the Director of the FBI, I would expect better than this. > query applications either would not meet the legal standard to win court approval; or because, when the standard could be met, it would be so only after the expenditure of scarce resources That is exactly how it's supposed to work, right? If they don't qualify for a warrant, then the warrant will not be issued and it is the responsibility of the investigators to do the work and find probable cause to justify the warrant. > To be sure, no one more deeply shares Members' concerns regarding past FBI compliance violations related to FISA, including the rules for querying Section 702 collection using US person identifiers, than I do Based on the next quote, I do not think he shares any concern over abuse whatsoever. > hold our personnel accountable for misuse of Section 702 and other FISA provisions, including through an escalating scheme for employee accountability, including discipline and culminating in possible dismissal. If he did share the concerns about abuse, why not have the discipline process culminate in personal liability including fines, prison and more?
- beerandt 3y agoThe FBI lawyer who was convicted of lying on a FISA application barely had to go a year before getting their law license back. He has no concern about abuse.
- _8j50 3y agoYeah, resources are tax payer funded, not out of his pocket. He should show evidence of congress denying him a budget item to use that as an excuse.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> why not have the discipline process culminate in personal liability including fines, prison and more? I assume you mean "refer for potential criminal prosectution". Apropos of anything else, you'd have a hard time getting a federal employee contract to allow arbitrary fines to be issued against an employee, etc.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> From the Director of the FBI, I would expect better than this. Why? I mean, I know you mean this as lead-in for arguing for accountability. I do get that. But the wording - it is sticking with me. It sticks because US federal LEO & IC directors lie. Serially. Every administration. ~Every public remark. As in some directors do not tell one meaningful public truth throughout their term. Most directors lie at close to that rate. Generally they lie by omission and obfuscation but they will lie about plain facts, if necessary, to advance an agenda or defer accountability. Believing them by default is an absurd thing to do. The leadership directly below directors aren't well known to be better. When certain positions have a low-truth history that stretches for generations, maybe we should recognize that. We ought not accept their assertions as factual; any consideration should come with worthwhile vetting and analysis.
- thewanderer1983 3y agoGiven the constant abuse of surveillance and the lack of care from these agencies. How about more dialogue on how we can put Data Sovereignty, Self Sovereign Identities and surrounding technologies into practice. Isn't this something the IETF along side the EFF could champion? This falls within rfc7258 and could be done via the PEARG. That specific working group even references rfc7258. In the digital world, your data is your identity and we should be working to ensure proper rights and frameworks around it. https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc7258 https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc7258 and here is working group that related to it. https://datatracker.ietf.org/rg/pearg/about/ https://datatracker.ietf.org/rg/pearg/about/ https://standards.ieee.org/beyond-standards/data-sovereignty-and-trusted-online-identity/ https://standards.ieee.org/beyond-standards/data-sovereignty...
- karaterobot 3y ago> In other words: if law enforcement doesn't have sufficient time to complete warrant paperwork and get a judge to sign off on one in advance, it's business as usual. That's not even what the previous paragraph said. They don't need a warrant if there is imminent danger to life, not if they just don't have time to get one. The latter implies they could use it for anything they wanted as long as they made an argument that time was of the essence, which seems like a fairly low bar to clear.
- esotericimpl 3y ago[dead]
- DennisP 3y agoI used to be under the impression that the Fourth Amendment was a de facto ban on warrantless surveillance.
- kyboren 3y agoThe Government Surveillance Reform Act looks to be a great bill, and the stars finally seem to be aligning for real reform. I'm hopeful for the first time in over a decade. However, GSRA doesn't go far enough. GSRA still allows USGOV to wiretap communication links/facilities and save a copy of the communications without any individualized suspicion for those communications. Let's be clear: This is mass surveillance. This would be fine if it were strictly used for foreign intelligence purposes and completely firewalled off from domestic criminal law enforcement. But that's not what GSRA does. GSRA still allows the warrantless and suspicionless mass seizure of communications, it just says that the government needs to apply for a warrant to search through them retrospectively. Don't get me wrong, that's a whole lot better than the current situation where FBI/NSA/CIA do not even need a warrant, but it's still mass surveillance and it's still incompatible with the Constitution.
- olliej 3y ago“Requiring the constitutionally mandated probable cause to spy on people would ban spying on them when we don’t have probable cause” is certainly a take