6 ms·
The antitrust case against Google Search doesn't seem to add up
- johnea 3y agoAt this point, that's not an issue...
- anon115 3y agolmao its not.
- barbazoo 3y agoLet's cross that bridge should we get to it :)
- bjord 3y agoI suspect that this will be an unpopular opinion on HN, but I think this raises a really good question. I am a ($10/month) paying user of Kagi and I constantly find myself using !g to search with Google. As far as actual search results, Kagi seems fine (as do DDG and others, honestly), but I think I've come to expect far more than search results when I type a query into my address bar. Kagi offers a lot of great options that I really appreciate (paying instead of selling my data, search rank tweaking, etc.), but I think I've become really dependent on Google's wide variety of different widgets and tools in what we tend to call "search results". I hate the thought of having to go back to Google full time, but it's really looking that way. Has anyone else experienced something similar?
- willk 3y agoI stopped used Google search two years ago. I switched to DDG and I have never felt the need to switch back. I just want search, I don't need my search engine to anticipate me. I want to type in a query and get results, maybe modify my query and try again. I really feel that Google search has lost its way and it is sad to see, but I guess money talks and search doesn't make them money.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoYeah, some years ago I still needed to use Google quite often since DDG didn't provide a way to restrict search to specific times, but a few years ago they added that functionality...
- weldedtogether 3y agoWhat kind of widgets are you using so frequently? I'm another paying using of Kagi and I've found the result quality has more than justified the price beyond the added benefits of not having my results in the hands of advertisers and the like, so I'm curious to know what it is you're getting out of google search.
- ethanbond 3y agoOnly thing I've noticed lacking in Kagi is quick math and conversions (units, currencies, timezones).
- weldedtogether 3y agoActually, searching with Kagi conversions like "4 inches to cm" brings up a box at the top of the search results with the conversion already done.
- ethanbond 3y agoHuh... wonder if that's new or I was trying some more complex/weirder example... I don't think I've ever seen this box though! Thanks for pointing that out.
- hug 3y agoThe thing I find lacking in Kagi -- and the only Google service I find myself unable to find my way towards not using in general -- is maps. The funny thing about Google Maps is I actually hate their map (and their navigation), and vastly prefer using Apple Maps to actually look at a map or to get to a place, but Google Maps is so far and away better than any competitors in its value-add information about businesses. The difference between looking for a restaurant on Google's or on Apple's maps products is pretty stark.
- CPLX 3y agoMe too. If it wasn’t for Maps and Google local I wouldn’t really need it any more Kagi is pretty much better for everything else.
- claytonjy 3y agoI used DDG for years and often reached for "!g", yet a year or so into using Kagi and I don't think I've ever needed to fall back to Google. Any particular patterns to the searches you prefer Google for?
- bjord 3y agoCopying another one of my responses here: Off the top of my head, detailed map results and conversions. I know Kagi supposedly supports both(?) of these, but in my experience, I end up needing to re-search things with !g well over half the time. To get even more specific to my use cases: Recently, I've been on the move, so in order to work, I rely on cafes and libraries. Thus, the fewer steps I need to do to see opening hours for a given location, the better. The most common conversion that I need is timezone, as I work with people in a huge number of different timezones. It's very useful for me to be able to type in something like "almaty time nyc 9pm" without screwing around on one of those time conversion sites. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38270198 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38270198
- dotnet00 3y agoThat's how I felt with all other search engines I tried before Kagi. I found myself needing to check google anyway very often, so I'd end up switching back because in most searches I was really just wasting time using the alternate search engine. Kagi has been the only engine where, since setting as default, the only times I've used google search has been on machines I don't control. I have found it to have most of the widgets I tend to like (unit conversions, calculators etc).
- meatmanek 3y agoYep. I "used" DDG for years before switching to Kagi. By "used" I mean I would habitually prefix all of my web searches with !g because I just came to expect that DDG's results would be bad. I was pretty much just using it as a bang-syntax engine. Maybe I should've broken that habit to give DDG a fairer shake before switching away to Kagi, but when I switched, I added a custom search engine to my browser with the keyword "!g" that strips out the !g and searches on Kagi. My experience is that it gives me the results I'm looking for 95% of the time, and for most of the 5% where I don't get good results, Google also fails to give me good results. In the past year or so, there have been several times where one of my coworkers lamented how bad Google search was, and in almost every example, Kagi performed better.
- padjo 3y agoYeah I find myself using g! a fair bit on DDG, particularly for things I’m going to spend money on. I search Google maps all the time too. (Restaurants, personal services, tradespeople etc)
- ttt3ts 3y agoI just run searxng. There is no reason to waste time checking multiple places. I did find I used Google's widgets a lot and it took some time to break the habit but for most flows I don't have a first step of opening a browser anymore so actually ended up faster.
- beej71 3y agoI think I've been with Kagi for about 3 months and have used !g zero times. For me, Google was delivering results stuffed with SEO crap and one day it pushed me over the edge. I signed up for Kagi's $5 limited search. Then they offered unlimited for $10, so I got that. (I used the money I saved from canceling YT Premium. :) ) Never looked back. But that's me. If it's not working for you, it's not working.
- ape4 3y agoIt doesn't do verbatim any more.
- cowsup 3y agoIANAL but this paragraph is completely wrong: > As we’ve noted, a key part of the ongoing case was just how much Google was paying for these defaults (over $26.3 billion in 2021). But that seems to actually argue against an abuse of a monopoly position argument. Because if Google were such a monopoly, then it wouldn’t need to pay as much to get those deals. There just wouldn’t be other offerings to compete. This is a fundamental misunderstanding of what constitutes a monopoly. It is not just "Google is the only usable search engine, therefore it's a monopoly, therefore it must be fined." A monopoly is typically someone who is already a leader in an industry, using their vast resources to make it incredibly difficult or even nearly impossible for competition. A judge may very well find that what Google is doing with Apple constitutes monopolistic practices.
- sweeter 3y agoExactly, I had the same issue with this. If Google isn't some form of a monopoly with Chrome, their search engine and advertising... then literally nothing qualifies at that point.
- akoboldfrying 3y agoIs Chrome the default browser on any major desktop platform (Mac, PC or major Linux distros)? If it's still not: Users must actively take the step of downloading and installing it. Is this step less difficult than changing the default search engine in Firefox or Safari?
- elashri 3y agoIt is the default on android which is the most used OS in the world. And part of the reason why people install chrome is the heavy advertisement and annoyances that Google put on using it services on something other than chrome. That's the textbook case of monopolistic actions. And Google guide people to how to install chrome and majority of people can download some exe and run it with next next while keeping the defaults. And many of them will not change any of the settings. And chrome will take every chance to let you revert back to google search if you happen to change it.
- kodzoman 3y agoI started using DDG a week ago instead of Google, and honestly I don't see that much of a difference. If I don't get a good result I go back to Google only to find it doesn't give me anything better than DDG. Might it be that people are just used to Google and not that it really produces better results?
- vasdae 3y ago[flagged]
- bachmeier 3y agoI've been using DDG for years. Always hear about how it's so bad compared to Google, but that's definitely not been the case for the searches I do. I suspect it's heavily contingent on the types of searches you're doing.
- filterfiber 3y ago> Might it be that people are just used to Google and not that it really produces better results? Maybe, but for me it struggles to recommend relevant reddit articles, copy+pasted error messages were hit/miss. It just feels like it sometimes misses obvious things, even word for word things, and I type it into google and it's right there. I apologize I dont have any good examples off hand
- rPlayer6554 3y agoI've been trying to use DDG for years and I really want to like it. At first it seems as good, but at some point it just doesn't cut it. Yes for most clear cut searches it's fine, but I still have to !g (use Google) enough that I haven't bothered changing for any other device. Especially not my work laptop where I have to do actual work. DDG/Bing is just not as good with programming questions.
- stvltvs 3y agoWith !g being right there when you need Google, it doesn't need to be all-or-nothing. I started out resorting to it every day. Now it's only maybe every couple or weeks.
- chung8123 3y agoThat is not the issue. Just being a better search engine does not mean that they are not a monopoly abusing their position in the search engine market.
- postalrat 3y agoBut What Do We Do If postalrat Is Legitimately Better?
- butterknife 3y agoI question such Legitimacy!
- spunker540 3y agoI agree with this take. If anything the lawsuit should be against Apple for selling off its default search engine placement, arguably abusing Apple’s monopoly power to charge exorbitant rates that limit competition. If the default search engine market needs to be made more competitive, then Apple can’t just be free to sell its default to the highest bidder and should be required by law to make every user choose a search engine. And even then I expect 90% of users to choose Google. The lawsuit makes no sense!
- r00fus 3y agoApple does not have a monopoly on mobile, so I don't see how your argument is valid. Google, however, does have a monopoly on ad networks/pricing.
- spunker540 3y agoFair pushback on the definition of monopoly. But my main point stands— the lawsuit is against google. If Google is not allowed to pay Apple because of their monopoly status, does that mean MSFT still could pay Apple? Is the goal of this lawsuit just to give Bing a better rate? It just seems weird to focus on Google here when Apple seems to be the more actionable company to sue, since Apple actually controls the market of “default search engine on iOS”.
- r00fus 3y agoIn the 1990s, Microsoft had arguably the best desktop operating system. They were executing on all cylinders and clearly doing things competitors couldn’t deliver at the same scale. That doesn’t mean that they weren’t guilty of being a coercive monopolist. It’s quite possible this means that the Apple/Google deal is not allowed but only if Google is deemed to be abusing their market position.
- bad_user 3y agoYour argument isn't as strong as you'd like. Microsoft having a Windows monopoly wasn't illegal, what brought their antitrust case was distributing IExplorer with Windows, taking market share from Netscape. But in 2023, are there any operating systems that don't ship with a built-in browser? Is there any reality in which the browser isn't an integral part of the operating system? And then there's also the fact, which people forget, that IExplorer was a technically superior browser to Netscape's Navigator. It took a revamping of the organization, and of the product, to come up with a Firefox that could compete.
- manishsharan 3y agoIs Google' business model going to survive the LLMs ? I used to use Google quite a bit for coding issues and now I mostly get my answers from ChatGPT premium. And the answers are getting better at least for my questions. Same for cooking recipes ; I hate going to recipe sites as they are poorly written and crawling with distractions; ChatGPT saves me from this ordeal.
- Jensson 3y agoCoding queries aren't very good for advertisement. When you are working you are unlikely to buy something, so Google losing those isn't a big deal for them.
- riku_iki 3y agothey can advertise you some product you were searching 2h ago.
- pphysch 3y agoGoogle's business model is data, and LLMs are downstream of that.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoNothing? The whole point is that should be decided by fair competition and not bribing your competitors. Antitrust is not about punishing winners, it's about forcing fair competition (in theory). If fair competition is taking place then we all win.
- sweeter 3y agobrother if Google isn't a candidate for an anti-trust lawsuit then literally no corporation on Earth is. Anti-trust suits are typically good things for consumers. Just look at the anti-trust lawsuit around Microsoft, it allowed for Apple to come up in the market alongside HP and others. Without that Microsoft would have maintained their dominance even more so than they have now and we'd have no alternatives. Google search is absolutely trash, they can only provide such a lackluster service by having a stranglehold over advertising and the browser market as a whole. Which they undoubtedly dominate.
- daft_pink 3y agoThe article really misses the point that the agreements are anti-competitive behavior. We can allow Google to naturally dominate search if it truly can, while still restricting anti-competitive behavior and if that doesn't work you can simply break Google into parts so one company isn't dominating so many search (Google)/video (Youtube)/phones(Android)/browser(Chrome). It's what they did with the phone companies before. I'm not saying that this is what should happen. I'm just saying the article really misses the issues and what suggested remedies there could be.
- tantalor 3y ago> the agreements are anti-competitive Can you elaborate? The article shows that Yahoo outbid Google for the default in Firefox. So the evidence shows companies are competing for these agreements.
- daft_pink 3y agoExclusivity agreements are a form of anti-competitive behavior, because they are paying to deny their competitors access. Your turning the whole thing on it's head by saying they are competing for the exclusive contract. The competition is for one search engine to be better than another search engine and the user chooses the best. It's not for vendors to compete to limit other vendors access to the market.
- Ukv 3y agoFor reverse image search, Google was massively behind competitors (especially Yandex) for a long time - though the gap has narrowed with Google Lens. For regular search results, I often find myself frustrated that Google seems to prefers ad-heavy sites where any actual content is copied from elsewhere then unnecessarily padded. As an ad company it's probably not in their interest to include it as a factor to rank such sites lower, even when though it legitimately degrades user experience. I've noticed a lot of "[game] wiki" searches on Google give an unmaintained and incomplete Fandom pages, whereas other search engines are better at surfacing the one actively used by the community. A true blind comparison between results would be interesting. Not just users reacting to the change in site as with the article's example, and also ideally not a marketing campaign like Microsoft's "Bing It On" that dubiously claimed a 2:1 preference towards Bing.
- hbn 3y agoGoogle's reverse image search was actually great until several years ago when they nerfed it. I heard they were forced to at the pressure of stock photo companies who were upset that people could find unwatermarked versions of photos with it. There are currently no versions of reverse image search existing today that are as good as what Google was offering several years ago.
- Ukv 3y ago> There are currently no versions of reverse image search existing today that are as good as what Google was offering several years ago. Which have you tried? Finding unwatermarked versions of stock image photos is a pretty low bar that most should be capable of. Some are at the level of finding videos a person appears in based on a blurry photograph of their face, or determining a street/location based on a photograph of a building.
- hbn 3y agoI've tried Google, Bing, Yandex, Tineye... can't think of any others off the top of my head. I know I used to be able to upload pretty much any image to Google and get hits of other places the image was used, and now I'll upload an image I found online and get no hits. All the reverse image searches are now trying to do cute AI tricks, like detect a handbag in the photo and show where you can buy it, or the breed of dog. All I want is other places hosting that exact image.
- nathants 3y agoit’s not. kagi is fine.
- hbn 3y agoBeing the best search engine barely means anything at this point. Unless you're looking for something very specific that you know exists like documentation, or are looking for an opinion on reddit that hopefully isn't astroturfed, you're probably going to find garbage. The issue is the internet just has too much garbage now. The SEO arms race has generated an insane amount of bot-generated garbage, mobile devices have made the internet is so accessible that it's filled with people generating garbage. It's garbage all the way down. Have you ever watched a 0 view YouTube or TikTok video? I end up with them in my feed every once in a while and check them out and it's always garbage. And this is MOST of the content on these platforms! Back in the mid-aughts, YouTube was new and it was still somewhat novel to plug a camcorder into your computer and upload a video file to the site. Now every 8-year-old is walking around with an iPad wirelessly connected to the internet, and a YouTube app with a giant, idiot-proof button to start recording a video and upload it right from the app. It blows my mind how much server space and bandwidth is being dedicated to host and transmit all this garbage around the world.